Quotes · Quote card

Quotation from Helvering v. Davis by Supreme Court of the United States

“Whether wisdom or unwisdom resides in the scheme of benefits set forth in Title II, it is not for us to say.”

Supreme Court of the United States

Helvering v. Davis, Opinion of the Court (Justice Cardozo) (U.S. Reports text (Wikisource))

Portrait of Supreme Court of the United States

Justice Cardozo separates the Court's question of power from the policy question of the plan's merits.

Citation: "Whether wisdom or unwisdom resides in the scheme of benefits set forth in Title II, it is not for us to say." — Supreme Court of the United States, Helvering v. Davis, Opinion of the Court (Justice Cardozo) (U.S. Reports text (Wikisource)). (id helvering-v-davis-q6)

Portrait: Benjamin Cardozo, Harris & Ewing, Inc., Public domain.

Download card (PNG)

Quote card: Whether wisdom or unwisdom resides in the scheme of benefits set forth in Title