Five-minute digest

Murder at the Margin

Summary

Murder at the Margin, published in 1978, is a short mystery novel by Marshall Jevons, the pen name of the economists William Breit and Kenneth G. Elzinga. It is the first of the Henry Spearman mysteries, in which a Harvard economist on holiday uses the tools of his trade—incentives, opportunity cost, revealed preference and the idea that people respond to prices and constraints—to see what a crime scene looks like to someone who thinks first about choice. The setting is a Caribbean resort at Cinnamon Bay, on St. John in the Virgin Islands. Spearman and his wife are there to rest; a guest is killed, the local investigation stalls, and Spearman begins to reason his way from the beaches and lawns of the resort to the old port of Charlotte Amalie and into the island's forest trails. The book is frankly didactic. Its pleasure is the same pleasure as a good classroom example: a puzzle is stated, an economic idea is tried as a lamp, and a hidden action becomes visible. It is not a great novel, and it does not pretend to be. It is a companion to serious work in the library—Smith, Hayek, Sowell, Friedman, Hazlitt—and a way for students who like stories to watch a principle do work outside a textbook chapter. Later volumes in the series include The Fatal Equilibrium and A Deadly Indifference; Elzinga, writing alone as Marshall Jevons after Breit's death, continued with The Mystery of the Invisible Hand. The novel is under copyright, and this library stores no text and no quotations. Princeton University Press has kept it in print as a paperback, and it is still used in some introductory economics courses as a change of pace from graphs and problems. Parents and teachers should know that it is a murder mystery: there is a crime, an investigation and a solution, but the book is not written as a tale of gore. Because the value of a mystery is partly in the puzzle, this guide describes the method and the setting rather than the identity of the killer. Readers should meet that discovery in the book itself.

Top Lessons

  • Incentives make hidden things visible

    The book's claim is that people act for reasons, and that those reasons can be read from what they choose when something is scarce or costly. A class can take that claim seriously without pretending that economics explains every human act, or that a murderer is only a rational calculator.

  • Merit, integrity and the detective's temptation

    A detective who has a theory can be tempted to force the facts. Spearman's virtue, when the book is at its best, is the economist's ordinary discipline: check the story against the cost. Integrity here means not twisting a principle to get a clever close.

  • A parable for the economics shelf

    The novel is a doorway, not a substitute, for Smith, Hayek, Sowell, Friedman and Hazlitt. Used well, it lets a student watch a tool at work and then go read the tool stated without a plot. Used poorly, it becomes a gimmick that flatters the already convinced.

Verified Quotes