Five-minute digest

The Price of Everything

Summary

The Price of Everything: A Parable of Possibility and Prosperity, published in 2008 by Princeton University Press, is a short novel by the economist Russell Roberts. It is written to teach, through a story, how prices work, why a rich society is rich, and how an order of trade and invention can arise without a single mind in charge. The hero is Ramon Fernandez, a Stanford student and Cuban-American tennis player, who is outraged when a large store raises its prices on the night of an earthquake. He plans a campus protest against what he sees as price gouging. The store is also a major donor to the university. Ruth Lieber, a provost and professor of economics, begins a series of conversations with him about prices, prosperity, innovation and the hidden coordination of ordinary life. The book is a parable in the same family as Roberts's earlier classroom novels, including The Choice and The Invisible Heart. Ruth's case is the classical one students will also meet in Smith, Hayek, Sowell and Friedman: a price is not only a moral verdict on a seller, but a signal and an incentive. After a disaster, a higher price can call in supplies, discourage waste and direct scarce goods to uses people value most, even when the seller's motive is unlovely. Ramon has to test that claim against his sense of fairness, against the anger of a public moment, and against the university's entanglement with its donor. The novel follows him as events larger than the campus pull him into a national argument, and as he is forced to reconsider what he thought he knew about why some societies are able to build, invent and choose. The work is under copyright, and this library stores no text and no quotations. It is still in print in a Princeton paperback and is used in some high-school and college courses as a readable companion to a first treatment of markets. It is gentle in subject compared with Zola or Norris: a campus debate and a parable, not a study of vice. Teachers should still mark its point of view clearly. It is a defense of the price system and of an order that no one plans in full, and it should be read beside, not instead of, harder questions about fraud, monopoly and the duties of the strong.

Top Lessons

  • What a price is for

    Ruth's lesson is that a price carries information and an incentive, not only a judgment on a seller's heart. After a shock, a higher price can call in supplies and restrain waste. Students should be able to state that claim fairly, and also to state the fairness objection that makes Ramon angry in the first place.

  • Order without a single master

    The parable's larger claim is Hayek's as well as Roberts's: much of the daily order of a prosperous society is made by people who do not know one another, coordinated by prices rather than by a plan. That is a reason for humility in officials and in reformers. It is not a reason to ignore fraud, monopoly or the duties of those who have much.

  • Merit, gratitude and the source of plenty

    Ramon has to think about where a high standard of living comes from: not only from fairness at the cash register, but from invention, saving and a rule of law that lets people try things. A Christian classroom can add what the parable may only imply: gratitude, the danger of pride, and the command to care for the poor without smashing the tools that feed them.

Verified Quotes