Five-minute digest

Three Dialogues between Hylas and Philonous

Summary

George Berkeley published Three Dialogues between Hylas and Philonous in 1713, three years after A Treatise Concerning the Principles of Human Knowledge. The later book is not a new doctrine so much as a clearer, more conversational statement of the same immaterialism. Two speakers carry the argument. Hylas, whose name recalls matter, begins as a defender of material substance. Philonous, 'lover of mind,' speaks for Berkeley. In three successive days of talk, Philonous drives Hylas from the claim that sensible things exist outside the mind, first by examining the secondary qualities, then the primary, then the very idea of an unthinking material support. The official subtitle says the dialogues are written in opposition to sceptics and atheists. Berkeley's surprising claim is that denying matter, as philosophers use that word, is the way to restore common sense and to honor God. Sensible things, Philonous argues, are those only which are immediately perceived by sense. To exist, for such things, is to be perceived. That does not leave the world a private dream. Created things may exist in other created minds, and they have a steady existence in the mind of God, who perceives always. Philonous refuses, as he says, to change things into ideas; he would rather change ideas into things, taking the immediate objects of perception to be the real things themselves. The hosted text is Project Gutenberg #4724, the same public-domain English series as the library's Principles (#4723). The two works should be read together and linked both ways. The Principles state the case in treatise form; the Dialogues test it in conversation, answer the charge of scepticism, and end by turning the reader back, as the last page says, to common sense. Students in grades 11–12 can follow the talk with guidance, especially if they have already met Locke's essay on human understanding, which is the book Berkeley is most steadily answering.

Top Lessons

  • Two books, one argument

    The Dialogues recast the Principles in conversation. Students should ask what the dialogue form makes easier, and what a treatise still does better.

  • Esse and perception

    The distinction Hylas draws between existing and being perceived is the nerve of the book. Philonous answers it only for sensible things, and then rebuilds a public world in God and in other minds.

  • Scepticism and piety

    Berkeley presents immaterialism as a defense of common sense and of religion. A class should test that presentation, not merely repeat it.

Verified Quotes

“Good morrow, Hylas: I did not expect to find you abroad so early. HYLAS. It is indeed something unusual; but my thoughts were so taken up with a subject I was discoursing of last night, that finding I could not sleep, I resolved to rise and take a turn in the garden.”
— George Berkeley, Three Dialogues between Hylas and Philonous, The First Dialogue, opening (Project Gutenberg #4724).Quote card
“To EXIST is one thing, and to be PERCEIVED is another. PHIL. I speak with regard to sensible things only.”
— George Berkeley, Three Dialogues between Hylas and Philonous, The First Dialogue (Project Gutenberg #4724).Quote card
“That there is no such thing as what PHILOSOPHERS CALL MATERIAL SUBSTANCE, I am seriously persuaded: but, if I were made to see anything absurd or sceptical in this, I should then have the same reason to renounce this that I imagine I have now to reject the contrary opinion.”
— George Berkeley, Three Dialogues between Hylas and Philonous, The First Dialogue (Project Gutenberg #4724).Quote card
“This point then is agreed between us--That SENSIBLE THINGS ARE THOSE ONLY WHICH ARE IMMEDIATELY PERCEIVED BY SENSE. You will farther inform me, whether we immediately perceive by sight anything beside light, and colours, and figures; or by hearing, anything but sounds; by the palate, anything beside tastes; by the smell, beside odours; or by the touch, more than tangible qualities.”
— George Berkeley, Three Dialogues between Hylas and Philonous, The First Dialogue (Project Gutenberg #4724).Quote card
“I am not for changing things into ideas, but rather ideas into things; since those immediate objects of perception, which, according to you, are only appearances of things, I take to be the real things themselves.”
— George Berkeley, Three Dialogues between Hylas and Philonous, The Third Dialogue (Project Gutenberg #4724).Quote card
“In answer to that, I say, first, created beings might begin to exist in the mind of other created intelligences, beside men. You will not therefore be able to prove any contradiction between Moses and my notions, unless you first shew there was no other order of finite created spirits in being, before man.”
— George Berkeley, Three Dialogues between Hylas and Philonous, The Third Dialogue (Project Gutenberg #4724).Quote card
“just so, the same Principles which, at first view, lead to Scepticism, pursued to a certain point, bring men back to Common Sense.”
— George Berkeley, Three Dialogues between Hylas and Philonous, Close of the Third Dialogue (Project Gutenberg #4724).Quote card
“And I give it you on my word; since this revolt from metaphysical notions to the plain dictates of nature and common sense, I find my understanding strangely enlightened, so that I can now easily comprehend a great many things which before were all mystery and riddle.”
— George Berkeley, Three Dialogues between Hylas and Philonous, The Third Dialogue (Project Gutenberg #4724).Quote card