Work record

Veto Message on the Bank of the United States

Also known as: Jackson Bank Veto · Veto of the Second Bank of the United States

1832 · 19th Century · Oratory · English

Read this when a national bank is treated as a privileged power, and a veto defends popular government.

Abstract

Written
Dated 10 July 1832
Setting
The Bank War, in the campaign year 1832; Washington, D.C., sent to the Senate as a veto message
Country
United States
Language
English
Genre
Presidential veto message
Form
Long official written message, later circulated as a campaign paper
Recommended
Grades 10–12 (A long official veto; best taught in excerpts with the famous closing paragraphs.)

Occasion. Congress sent Jackson a bill to renew the Second Bank's charter well before it expired. He returned the bill unsigned on 10 July 1832 and attached this official explanation, which his supporters then used in the fall canvass.

Constitution. A large part of the message is a lawyer's brief. Jackson reviews the Bank's history, the terms of the new bill, and the 1819 decision upholding a national bank, then insists that a President's oath does not require him to treat that decision as the last word on this statute.

Privilege. He pictures the Bank as a privileged corporation, partly owned abroad, that holds public deposits and private power together. The closing pages turn from legal detail to a republican charge: law should not add exclusive favors to the differences already found among citizens.

Afterward. The veto was not overridden. Jackson won another term, and the federal Bank was wound down after a further fight over the deposits. Later panics kept the argument alive, so the message is both a victory document and a starting point for debate. Students should read the closing pages slowly, then set the constitutional claims beside the later history, without letting either erase the other. The message is long; it can be taught in excerpts if the closing pages are not cut off from the legal argument that precedes them.

Key figures

  • Andrew Jackson: Seventh President, who vetoed the recharter
  • Nicholas Biddle: President of the Second Bank of the United States
  • Henry Clay: Senator and candidate who backed the early recharter
  • John Marshall: Chief Justice whose Court had upheld a national bank in 1819

Summary

On 10 July 1832 Andrew Jackson returned to Congress, unsigned, the bill to recharter the Second Bank of the United States four years before the Bank's existing charter would expire. Henry Clay and Nicholas Biddle had pressed the recharter early, hoping to force Jackson to sign or to hand them a campaign issue. He chose the veto, and the message became the chief document of the Bank War. Jackson grants that a bank of some kind may be useful, but he denies that this corporation, with its private stockholders, its branches in the states, and its hold on the government's deposits, is necessary or constitutional in the form the bill proposed. He reviews the Supreme Court's opinion in McCulloch v. Maryland (1819), which had upheld a national bank, and answers that Congress, the Executive, and the Court must each judge the Constitution for itself. An officer who swears to support the Constitution, he writes, swears to support it as he understands it. The close is the part students remember. Jackson says it is to be regretted that the rich and powerful too often bend the acts of government to their selfish purposes. Distinctions of talent, education, or wealth will always exist, but when the laws add exclusive privilege to those natural advantages, the humble members of society—farmers, mechanics, and laborers—have a right to complain. There are no necessary evils in government, he writes; its evils exist only in its abuses. If government would confine itself to equal protection, and, as Heaven does its rains, shower its favors alike on high and low, it would be an unqualified blessing. Many rich men, he charges, have not been content with equal protection but have asked to be made richer by act of Congress. The country can at least stand against new grants of monopoly and against any prostitution of government to the advancement of the few at the expense of the many. Congress did not override the veto. Jackson was reelected in 1832, and after a further struggle over the government's deposits the Bank's federal charter ended. The message is a primary text of Jacksonian democracy and of the debate over banks, privilege, and constitutional authority. It should be read alongside the later Panic of 1837, which his critics tied to the Bank War and which his defenders blamed on speculation and paper money.

Virtues in this work

  • Justice: Jackson states the rule of equal protection and attacks exclusive legal privileges granted to a few.
  • Prudence: He grants that a bank may be useful, and he aims the veto at this charter and this corporation, not at all banking.
  • Fortitude: He accepted a fight with Clay, Webster, and Biddle rather than sign a bill he thought wrong.

Plot or Argument

  • The early recharter

    Jackson explains that the Bank's friends have asked for a new charter years before the old one expires, and he states his reasons for refusing.

  • Constitutional judgment

    He denies that the Supreme Court's earlier decision binds the President or Congress to this particular bill, and he claims an independent oath to the Constitution.

  • A private monopoly

    He argues that the Bank concentrates money and political power in a corporation not fully answerable to the people or to the states.

  • Equal protection

    The close contrasts equal laws with exclusive privileges granted to the rich and powerful.

  • The political choice

    The veto leaves the Bank question to the voters in the election of 1832.

    Lessons

    • An oath and a court

      Jackson's claim that each branch judges the Constitution for itself is one of the strongest presidential statements of that view. Students should set it beside McCulloch v. Maryland and ask what is left of judicial review if the President may set a holding aside in a veto.

      • Does Jackson reject all judicial authority, or only the idea that one decision settles this bill?
      • How does he treat McCulloch v. Maryland, and what does he say each branch may still do?
      • Is this a constitutional argument, a political one, or both at once?
    • Privilege and equality

      The famous last pages are not a call to level property. They distinguish natural differences of talent and wealth from legal privileges created by Congress.

      • What, according to Jackson, may the poor justly complain of, and what must they accept?
      • How does he distinguish natural differences of talent and wealth from legal privileges?
      • Does the close of the veto defend equality, or mainly attack a particular corporation?
    • The Bank War in history

      The veto won the election and killed the federal Bank, but it did not end the argument over money and panics. A class should follow the story into the removal of the deposits and the Panic of 1837 without treating later events as already decided in 1832.

      • How should a student judge a policy by its stated principle and by its later fruits?
      • What happened after the veto to the Bank, the deposits, and the country's money?
      • Can a student honor the stated principle and still judge the later panic honestly?

    Context

    The Second Bank of the United States, chartered in 1816 after the War of 1812, held the federal deposits and issued a national paper currency. By 1832 it was both a useful fiscal agent and a political target. Clay, Daniel Webster, and Biddle sought an early recharter to box Jackson in before the election. Jackson, already hostile to the Bank, used the veto to appeal over Congress to the voters.

    Composition

    The message was dated Washington, 10 July 1832, and sent to the Senate with the unsigned bill. It is an official veto message, not a spoken inaugural, though parts were widely reprinted as a campaign paper. The hosted text follows Richardson's compilation as given in Project Gutenberg #10858.

    Reception

    Friends of the Bank called the message demagogy and an attack on property and the Court. Jackson's supporters treated it as a charter of equal laws against monopoly. The veto held; Jackson won reelection; the Bank's federal role ended in the mid-1830s. Historians still divide over whether the war was a blow for republican equality or a source of later financial disorder.

    Comparisons

    • First Inaugural Address

      In 1829 Jackson spoke of economy, limited power, and reform of officeholding; the 1832 veto shows how he applied those claims to a great corporation.

    • First Inaugural Address (Jefferson)

      Jefferson in 1801 praised a frugal government and equal rights; Jackson's close on equal protection and exclusive privilege is a later, harsher statement of a similar republican language.

    • Farewell Address and Selected Letters

      Washington warned against factions and encouraged public credit; Jackson treats a national bank as a faction with legal privileges.

    Quotes

    “It is to be regretted that the rich and powerful too often bend the acts of government to their selfish purposes.”
    — Andrew Jackson, Veto Message on the Bank of the United States, Near the close of the veto (Richardson / Gutenberg #10858).Quote card
    “There are no necessary evils in government. Its evils exist only in its abuses.”
    — Andrew Jackson, Veto Message on the Bank of the United States, Near the close of the veto (Richardson / Gutenberg #10858).Quote card
    “If it would confine itself to equal protection, and, as Heaven does its rains, shower its favors alike on the high and the low, the rich and the poor, it would be an unqualified blessing.”
    — Andrew Jackson, Veto Message on the Bank of the United States, Near the close of the veto (Richardson / Gutenberg #10858).Quote card
    “The Congress, the Executive, and the Court must each for itself be guided by its own opinion of the Constitution.”
    — Andrew Jackson, Veto Message on the Bank of the United States, On constitutional authority (Richardson / Gutenberg #10858).Quote card
    “Each public officer who takes an oath to support the Constitution swears that he will support it as he understands it, and not as it is understood by others.”
    — Andrew Jackson, Veto Message on the Bank of the United States, On constitutional authority (Richardson / Gutenberg #10858).Quote card
    “Many of our rich men have not been content with equal protection and equal benefits, but have besought us to make them richer by act of Congress.”
    — Andrew Jackson, Veto Message on the Bank of the United States, Near the close of the veto (Richardson / Gutenberg #10858).Quote card
    “If we can not at once, in justice to interests vested under improvident legislation, make our Government what it ought to be, we can at least take a stand against all new grants of monopolies and exclusive privileges, against any prostitution of our Government to the advancement of the few at the expense of the many,”
    — Andrew Jackson, Veto Message on the Bank of the United States, The close of the veto (Richardson / Gutenberg #10858).Quote card
    “The many millions which this act proposes to bestow on the stockholders of the existing bank must come directly or indirectly out of the earnings of the American people.”
    — Andrew Jackson, Veto Message on the Bank of the United States, On the Bank's profits (Richardson / Gutenberg #10858).Quote card

    For Students

    A reading companion for classical Christian high school students. See the student guide.

    Reading Guide

    Watch for

    • The claim that each branch judges the Constitution for itself.
    • How Jackson describes the Bank's stockholders and foreign owners.
    • The distinction between natural inequalities and legal privileges.
    • The rain image and the phrase 'no necessary evils in government.'

    Key terms and names

    Second Bank of the United States
    The federally chartered bank, renewed in 1816, whose early recharter Jackson vetoed in 1832.
    Bank War
    The political struggle between Jackson and the Bank's friends over recharter, deposits, and the Bank's power.
    McCulloch v. Maryland
    The 1819 Supreme Court decision that upheld a national bank and denied a state the power to tax it.
    Veto message
    A President's official written reasons for refusing to sign a bill; this one was also used as a campaign paper.
    Equal protection
    Jackson's name for laws that do not add exclusive legal privileges to the natural differences among citizens.

    Seminar Questions

    1. Comprehension Why does Jackson object to rechartering the Bank four years early?
    2. Comprehension What does he say each public officer swears when he takes the constitutional oath?
    3. Interpretation How does Jackson distinguish natural differences of wealth from privileges created by law?
    4. Interpretation Why does he mention foreign stockholders, and what fear is he trying to raise?
    5. Big Question Should a President refuse to follow a Supreme Court doctrine he thinks is wrong?
    6. Big Question When, if ever, may a popular leader treat a corporation as the people's enemy?

    Faith Connections

    • Deuteronomy 16:19 (Scripture)

      The warning not to wrest judgment or respect persons is a useful check on exclusive legal privileges, which is Jackson's closing charge.

    • Proverbs 22:2 (Scripture)

      'The rich and poor meet together: the Lord is the maker of them all' sits beside Jackson's claim that law should not add artificial favors to differences already present.

    • Romans 13:1-4 (Scripture)

      Paul's account of the ruler as a minister for good raises the question whether Jackson is defending that office or stretching it against the Court and the Bank.

    Logic and Rhetoric

    Central argument: Because this Bank is an unnecessary and unconstitutional grant of exclusive privilege to the wealthy, the President must veto the recharter and leave the question to the people.

    Rhetorical device: antithesis. Jackson sets equal protection against exclusive privilege, and the humble farmers and mechanics against the rich and powerful who seek to be made richer by act of Congress.

    Debate: Resolved: that Jackson's 1832 Bank veto was a just defense of equal laws rather than an attack on lawful property and the judiciary.

    Memory Work

    There are no necessary evils in government. Its evils exist only in its abuses.

    Near the close of the veto. A short, often quoted statement of limited government: there are no necessary evils in government; its evils exist only in its abuses.

    Writing Prompts

    Essay: Explain Jackson's constitutional argument in the Bank veto, then judge it against McCulloch v. Maryland and against the later end of the Bank.

    Comparison with First Inaugural Address: Compare the 1829 inaugural's promises about limited power and reform with the 1832 veto: where does Jackson keep his earlier language, and where does he go further?

    Medical Lens

    This presidential text concerns constitutional politics and public office; it has no medical content for this library's lens.

      Creative Prompts

      • Classroom

        Mark every constitutional argument in the veto, then write a one-page reply in the voice of a defender of McCulloch v. Maryland.

      • Dialogue

        Write a conversation in July 1832 between a western farmer who cheers the veto and a Philadelphia merchant who holds Bank stock.

      • Essay

        Jackson says there are no necessary evils in government. Using the veto and one event after 1832, argue whether he kept that standard.

      Further Reading

      • A Compilation of the Messages and Papers of the Presidents, James D. Richardson

        Official nineteenth-century compilation; the source of the hosted Gutenberg texts.

      • Inaugural Addresses of the Presidents of the United States, Avalon Project / GPO

        Parallel official texts for classroom comparison.

      • The Rhetorical Presidency, Jeffrey K. Tulis

        A study of how inaugural and other presidential speech reshaped the office.

      Verification notes

      Quotes were matched as substrings against the Richardson / Gutenberg #10858 text stored with this work. Historical framing is standard reference knowledge.

      No verification flags recorded.