Five-minute digest
Struggling Upward
Summary
Struggling Upward; or, Luke Larkin's Luck, published in 1890, is one of Horatio Alger's later and better-made novels. Luke Larkin is the son of a carpenter's widow in the village of Groveton, a train ride from New York. He sweeps the schoolhouse as janitor, does odd jobs for farmers, and is the most popular boy in town. His rival is Randolph Duncan, the snobbish son of Prince Duncan, president of the Groveton Bank. The story opens with a skating race for a Waterbury watch, which Luke is about to win when another boy crashes into him; Randolph takes the prize, and the teacher tells Luke he must be satisfied with deserving it. That night a stranger on the road asks Luke to keep a tin box for him. Soon afterwards the bank's box of bonds is found missing. A prying neighbour, Miss Melinda Sprague, reports the tin box, and Squire Duncan has Luke arrested for robbery. At the hearing the stranger, Roland Reed, walks in and shows that the box is his own. Reed becomes Luke's friend, places his little daughter Rosa in Mrs. Larkin's care, and gives Luke paid copying work. Duncan has already cost Luke his janitor's place to win votes, and Randolph is running up a debt at Tony Denton's billiard saloon. The real victim of the theft is John Armstrong, a New York merchant whose bonds were kept in the Groveton vault. Armstrong comes to trust Luke and sends him west to find a former bookkeeper, James Harding, who has the numbers of the stolen bonds. In Chicago a smooth salesman, J. Madison Coleman, tries to rob him. On the way to the Black Hills his stagecoach is held up by masked men, and near Deadwood Luke finds Harding and gets the list. Back in New York the numbers trap the thief. Tony Denton, who has been blackmailing Duncan, pledges one of the bonds with his brokers and confesses that he had it from the bank president himself. Armstrong confronts Duncan, who must repay what he took, resign, and leave for the West, where Randolph becomes an office boy. Roland Reed turns out to be a long-lost cousin of the Larkins, settles money on Luke, and Armstrong takes him into his office. Alger's closing sentence admits there has been some luck in Luke's rise but credits most of it to his good qualities. For classical Christian readers the book is a lively study of honesty under false accusation, patience, industry, gratitude, trust in God and the folly of pride, and a good place to ask how much of any person's success comes from effort and how much from providence and the help of others.
Top Lessons
Honesty under false accusation
Luke is arrested for a crime he did not commit, on the word of the man who did it. He refuses to run, stays courteous, and says he relies on God to stand by him. The book teaches that a good character is a defence even when appearances are against us, and that patience is part of honesty.
Pride goes before a fall
Randolph and his father look down on everyone they think beneath them. The father's pride covers a theft, and the son's pride leads him into debt at a saloon. By the end both have lost everything they were proud of. Alger mocks pride with a light touch, but the lesson is old and serious.
Industry, thrift and trustworthiness
Luke does whatever honest work he can find, from sweeping the schoolhouse to copying documents, and he answers to his employer for every expense of his journey. Mr. Armstrong trusts him with a difficult task because he has already proved faithful in small ones.
Luck, patrons and providence
Alger's last sentence admits that Luke has had some luck, but says he owes most of his fortune to his own good qualities. The plot also depends on a rich stranger who turns out to be a relative. Christian readers can test the 'luck and pluck' formula: character matters, but success also depends on God's providence and on the kindness of others, and good people are not always rewarded in this life.
Verified Quotes
“Luke worked where he could, helping the farmers in hay-time, and ready to do odd jobs for any one in the village who desired his services.”
“You will have to be satisfied with deserving it.”
“Time is likely to be of as much importance to a poor boy as to a rich boy.”
“We both know that I am innocent, and I rely on God to stand by me.”
“It kept me from squandering money on foolish pleasures, for I had none to spend; it made me industrious and self-reliant, and when I obtained employment it made me anxious to please my employer.”
“It is difficult to play the part of an aristocrat in a country village, but that is the role which Prince Duncan assumed.”
“It ought to, surely, and I am grateful to Providence for all the blessings which it has showered upon me and mine.”
“There has been some luck about it, I admit, but after all he is indebted for most of his good fortune to his own good qualities.”
Medical Lens
A boys' adventure story, not a medical one. Randolph drinks and gambles at a billiard saloon, a travelling salesman drinks whisky, and Luke refuses drink; worry over his guilt makes Prince Duncan look haggard and ill. These reflect nineteenth-century temperance attitudes rather than medical description.