Work record

Struggling Upward

Also known as: Struggling Upward; or, Luke Larkin's Luck · Luke Larkin's Luck

1890 · 19th Century · Novel · English

Read this when a poor boy's honesty is tested, and luck is less important than a clean conscience.

Public domainlow medical relevanceRead full textDownload EPUBFive-minute digest

Abstract

Written
Published as a book 1890
Setting
About 1880; The village of Groveton near New York, New York City, Chicago and the Black Hills mining camp of Deadwood
Country
United States
Language
English
Genre
Juvenile novel; mystery and adventure
Form
Novel in forty chapters
Recommended
Grades 5–8 (A false arrest, a saloon, a stagecoach holdup; fine read aloud from grade 4.)

Background. Written late in Alger's long career, this is one of the tightest of his many village tales. It keeps his usual cast, from the honest poor boy and his pious mother to the vain rich boy and the grasping squire, and adds a bank mystery and a trip west.

Plot. A janitor's son is cheated of a prize, then wrongly charged with a bank theft after a stranger asks him to hold a box. Cleared in court, he is given work by the stranger and trusted by the robbed merchant, who sends him across the country for proof. He escapes a swindler and a holdup and returns with the evidence that exposes the real thief.

Ideas. The novel praises patience under insult, honest work and faithfulness in small things, and it mocks pride and the worship of money. Its final sentence admits that fortune helped its hero, which invites readers to weigh effort, providence and the kindness of others.

Text. The library hosts the 1890 book text from Project Gutenberg. Readers will meet a saloon, a stagecoach robbery, and a few dated ethnic labels worth discussing. It is often printed together with Ragged Dick, and the two make a natural pair for a class.

Main characters

  • Luke Larkin: A poor widow's son and school janitor, honest and steady
  • Randolph Duncan: His snobbish rival, son of the bank president
  • Prince Duncan: The proud squire and banker who robbed his own vault
  • Roland Reed: A mysterious stranger who becomes Luke's friend and patron
  • John Armstrong: The New York merchant whose bonds were stolen
  • Linton Tomkins: Luke's loyal younger friend

Summary

Struggling Upward; or, Luke Larkin's Luck, published in 1890, is one of Horatio Alger's later and better-made novels. Luke Larkin is the son of a carpenter's widow in the village of Groveton, a train ride from New York. He sweeps the schoolhouse as janitor, does odd jobs for farmers, and is the most popular boy in town. His rival is Randolph Duncan, the snobbish son of Prince Duncan, president of the Groveton Bank. The story opens with a skating race for a Waterbury watch, which Luke is about to win when another boy crashes into him; Randolph takes the prize, and the teacher tells Luke he must be satisfied with deserving it. That night a stranger on the road asks Luke to keep a tin box for him. Soon afterwards the bank's box of bonds is found missing. A prying neighbour, Miss Melinda Sprague, reports the tin box, and Squire Duncan has Luke arrested for robbery. At the hearing the stranger, Roland Reed, walks in and shows that the box is his own. Reed becomes Luke's friend, places his little daughter Rosa in Mrs. Larkin's care, and gives Luke paid copying work. Duncan has already cost Luke his janitor's place to win votes, and Randolph is running up a debt at Tony Denton's billiard saloon. The real victim of the theft is John Armstrong, a New York merchant whose bonds were kept in the Groveton vault. Armstrong comes to trust Luke and sends him west to find a former bookkeeper, James Harding, who has the numbers of the stolen bonds. In Chicago a smooth salesman, J. Madison Coleman, tries to rob him. On the way to the Black Hills his stagecoach is held up by masked men, and near Deadwood Luke finds Harding and gets the list. Back in New York the numbers trap the thief. Tony Denton, who has been blackmailing Duncan, pledges one of the bonds with his brokers and confesses that he had it from the bank president himself. Armstrong confronts Duncan, who must repay what he took, resign, and leave for the West, where Randolph becomes an office boy. Roland Reed turns out to be a long-lost cousin of the Larkins, settles money on Luke, and Armstrong takes him into his office. Alger's closing sentence admits there has been some luck in Luke's rise but credits most of it to his good qualities. For classical Christian readers the book is a lively study of honesty under false accusation, patience, industry, gratitude, trust in God and the folly of pride, and a good place to ask how much of any person's success comes from effort and how much from providence and the help of others.

Virtues in this work

  • Honor: Luke keeps the stranger's box safe, refuses to run while under arrest, and answers honestly for his employer's money.
  • Industry: He sweeps the school, works for farmers, copies documents for pay and carries out a long errand for Mr. Armstrong.
  • Fortitude: He bears a false arrest calmly and travels alone through Chicago and the Black Hills on a difficult commission.
  • Humility: Luke answers Randolph's sneers without boasting, while the proud Duncans are brought low.
  • Justice: The real thief is exposed and made to restore what he took, and the innocent boy is cleared.

Plot or Argument

  • Chapters I–VII: The skating race and the tin box

    Luke loses the Waterbury watch to Randolph Duncan through an accident. On the way home a stranger leaves a tin box in his keeping. At Florence Grant's party Randolph sneers at Luke's clothes, but the other young people welcome him.

  • Chapters VIII–XV: Suspicion, arrest and rescue

    Melinda Sprague discovers the tin box; the Groveton bank's bonds are missing; Squire Duncan has Luke arrested and takes away his janitor's post. At the hearing Roland Reed appears, claims his box, and clears Luke.

  • Chapters XVI–XXIV: New friends and a commission

    Reed takes Luke to New York, sends his daughter Rosa home with him to live with Mrs. Larkin, and gives him copying to do. Duncan secretly borrows on the stolen bonds; John Armstrong, their owner, comes to trust Luke and sends him west to find his old bookkeeper.

  • Chapters XXV–XXXIV: Chicago and the Black Hills

    Luke outwits the swindler J. Madison Coleman in Chicago, survives a stagecoach holdup on the way to Deadwood, and finds James Harding at a mining claim near Deadwood with the list of the bonds' numbers.

  • Chapters XXXV–XL: The thief is found

    Tony Denton tries to pledge a bond he extorted from Duncan and confesses where he got it. Armstrong confronts Duncan, who must make restitution, resign and leave Groveton. Reed proves to be a relative and provides for Luke, who joins Armstrong's office.

Characters

  • Luke Larkin, protagonist

    A carpenter's widow's son and the school janitor, cheerful, hard-working and honest, who keeps his temper under insult and false accusation.

  • Mrs. Larkin, mother

    Luke's patient, pious mother, who lives on narrow means and thanks Providence for every turn of good fortune.

  • Randolph Duncan, rival

    The bank president's vain, snobbish son, who despises Luke as a poor boy and runs up debts at a saloon.

  • Prince Duncan, villain

    Squire, magistrate and bank president of Groveton, proud and grasping, who has secretly robbed his own bank.

  • Roland Reed, patron

    The mysterious stranger who leaves the tin box with Luke, clears him in court and is revealed as a lost cousin.

  • John Armstrong, mentor

    A shrewd old New York merchant, once a barefoot poor boy, whose bonds were stolen and who sends Luke west.

  • Linton Tomkins, friend

    A younger boy from a well-off family who stays Luke's loyal friend and has nothing snobbish about him.

  • Tony Denton, saloon-keeper

    The owner of the billiard saloon, who lends to Randolph and blackmails his father.

  • J. Madison Coleman, swindler

    A smooth travelling salesman who befriends Luke in Chicago and tries to steal his employer's money.

  • Melinda Sprague, busybody

    A prying village dressmaker whose gossip leads to Luke's arrest.

Lessons

  • Honesty under false accusation

    Luke is arrested for a crime he did not commit, on the word of the man who did it. He refuses to run, stays courteous, and says he relies on God to stand by him. The book teaches that a good character is a defence even when appearances are against us, and that patience is part of honesty.

    • Why does Luke refuse to run away while he is in the constable's custody?
    • Who stands up for Luke, and why do they believe him?
    • How should a Christian respond when falsely accused?
  • Pride goes before a fall

    Randolph and his father look down on everyone they think beneath them. The father's pride covers a theft, and the son's pride leads him into debt at a saloon. By the end both have lost everything they were proud of. Alger mocks pride with a light touch, but the lesson is old and serious.

    • What does Randolph think makes a person important?
    • How does Prince Duncan's pride help him hide his crime, and how does it help undo him?
    • Is Randolph's ending fair? Is it merciful?
  • Industry, thrift and trustworthiness

    Luke does whatever honest work he can find, from sweeping the schoolhouse to copying documents, and he answers to his employer for every expense of his journey. Mr. Armstrong trusts him with a difficult task because he has already proved faithful in small ones.

    • What jobs does Luke do in the story, and how does he do them?
    • Why does Mr. Armstrong trust a boy with such an important errand?
    • What does Luke refuse to do in Chicago, and why does it matter?
  • Luck, patrons and providence

    Alger's last sentence admits that Luke has had some luck, but says he owes most of his fortune to his own good qualities. The plot also depends on a rich stranger who turns out to be a relative. Christian readers can test the 'luck and pluck' formula: character matters, but success also depends on God's providence and on the kindness of others, and good people are not always rewarded in this life.

    • List the pieces of good luck in the story. Could Luke have succeeded without them?
    • Mrs. Larkin thanks Providence; the narrator speaks of luck. Who is right?
    • What would you say to a boy as good as Luke whose story did not end happily?

Context

The story is set around 1880 in a small town within easy rail distance of New York, at a time when village banks held bonds for wealthy depositors and the railroad had opened the West. The Black Hills gold rush of the late 1870s had made Deadwood a rough mining camp, and travel there was by rail and stagecoach. Coupon bonds that carried no owner's name could be sold by anyone who held them, which is why the bond numbers matter to the plot.

Composition

Struggling Upward was published in book form by Porter & Coates of Philadelphia in 1890, late in Alger's career, when his popularity was declining and he was writing many books a year. It reuses his familiar figures (the poor widow's son, the snobbish rich boy, the grasping squire and the generous stranger) but has a tighter mystery plot than most of his later work. The text hosted here is Project Gutenberg eBook #5417.

Reception

The book was reprinted many times after Alger's death, when his work sold in the millions, and it has often been paired with Ragged Dick in modern editions as one of his two most representative stories. Critics have used it to show how much his heroes' rise depends on lucky patrons as well as on effort.

Comparisons

  • Ragged Dick

    Alger's first great success, set in the city streets rather than a village; Dick's rise is slower and more his own, while Luke's depends on a mystery and a rich relative.

  • Great Expectations

    Pip also owes his rise to a hidden benefactor, but Dickens makes the secret patron a moral test and shows the snobbery that money can breed, the very fault Alger gives to Randolph.

  • The Adventures of Tom Sawyer

    Twain's village boys, a trial and a box of treasure make a useful contrast: Twain mocks the 'model boy' that Alger celebrates.

  • Autobiography of Andrew Carnegie

    Carnegie, a poor immigrant boy who became a telegraph messenger and then an industrialist, is the real-life rags-to-riches story most often set beside Alger's fiction.

  • Autobiography and Poor Richard's Almanack

    Mr. Armstrong's speech on poverty that made him industrious and self-reliant echoes Franklin's account of his own youth and Poor Richard's sayings.

  • David Copperfield

    David's hard boyhood, loyal friends and slow rise by industry give a fuller picture of the same journey, with Uriah Heep as a darker version of Alger's false and grasping men.

Quotes

“Luke worked where he could, helping the farmers in hay-time, and ready to do odd jobs for any one in the village who desired his services.”
— Horatio Alger Jr., Struggling Upward, Chapter I (Project Gutenberg #5417 (Porter & Coates, 1890)).Quote card
“You will have to be satisfied with deserving it.”
— Horatio Alger Jr., Struggling Upward, Chapter IV (Project Gutenberg #5417 (Porter & Coates, 1890)).Quote card
“Time is likely to be of as much importance to a poor boy as to a rich boy.”
— Horatio Alger Jr., Struggling Upward, Chapter V (Project Gutenberg #5417 (Porter & Coates, 1890)).Quote card
“We both know that I am innocent, and I rely on God to stand by me.”
— Horatio Alger Jr., Struggling Upward, Chapter XIII (Project Gutenberg #5417 (Porter & Coates, 1890)).Quote card
“It kept me from squandering money on foolish pleasures, for I had none to spend; it made me industrious and self-reliant, and when I obtained employment it made me anxious to please my employer.”
— Horatio Alger Jr., Struggling Upward, Chapter XX (Project Gutenberg #5417 (Porter & Coates, 1890)).Quote card
“It is difficult to play the part of an aristocrat in a country village, but that is the role which Prince Duncan assumed.”
— Horatio Alger Jr., Struggling Upward, Chapter XXXI (Project Gutenberg #5417 (Porter & Coates, 1890)).Quote card
“It ought to, surely, and I am grateful to Providence for all the blessings which it has showered upon me and mine.”
— Horatio Alger Jr., Struggling Upward, Chapter XL (Project Gutenberg #5417 (Porter & Coates, 1890)).Quote card
“There has been some luck about it, I admit, but after all he is indebted for most of his good fortune to his own good qualities.”
— Horatio Alger Jr., Struggling Upward, Chapter XL (Project Gutenberg #5417 (Porter & Coates, 1890)).Quote card

For Students

A reading companion for classical Christian high school students. See the student guide.

Reading Guide

Watch for

  • How Luke answers insults from Randolph. Does he ever lose his temper?
  • Every time Luke is trusted with something that is not his: the tin box, Rosa, Mr. Armstrong's money. What does he do with each?
  • The pieces of luck in the plot, especially Roland Reed. Keep a list and decide at the end how much they matter.
  • Dated language: a politician who wants 'the Irish vote' and the phrase 'negro newsboy.' Talk about how the book labels people.
  • Mrs. Larkin's prayers and thanks to Providence, set beside the narrator's talk of luck.

Key terms and names

Janitor
The person who sweeps and heats a building; Luke does this at his own school for pay.
Bonds
Certificates of a loan that pay interest; coupon bonds with no owner's name could be sold by whoever held them.
Squire
In an American village, a leading citizen who often served as justice of the peace or magistrate.
Restitution
Paying back or restoring what was wrongly taken; Duncan must repay the bonds he used.
Drummer
A nineteenth-century word for a travelling salesman, like J. Madison Coleman.
Black Hills
A gold-mining region of Dakota Territory; Deadwood was its rough boom town.

Seminar Questions

  1. Comprehension Why does Luke lose the skating race, and what does the teacher say to him afterwards?
  2. Comprehension How does the tin box get Luke into trouble, and how is he cleared?
  3. Comprehension Why does Mr. Armstrong send Luke west, and what does Luke bring back?
  4. Interpretation Why does Prince Duncan want to blame Luke for the robbery?
  5. Interpretation What does Randolph believe makes a person important, and how does the story answer him?
  6. Interpretation Why does Alger make Luke's best friend, Linton, a boy from a well-off family?
  7. Big Question How much of a person's success comes from character, and how much from luck, providence and the help of others?
  8. Big Question Is Mr. Armstrong right to let Prince Duncan go free for the sake of his family? What does justice require, and what does mercy allow?

Faith Connections

  • Proverbs 16:18 (Scripture)

    'Pride goeth before destruction, and an haughty spirit before a fall.' Prince Duncan and Randolph are a village-sized picture of the proverb.

  • Psalm 37:1–7 (Scripture)

    'Fret not thyself because of evildoers... Rest in the LORD, and wait patiently for him.' Luke's calm under false accusation is close to the psalm's counsel, and the plot brings forth his righteousness 'as the light.'

  • James 2:1–4 (Scripture)

    James warns against honouring the man in fine clothing and despising the poor man in vile raiment, which is exactly what Randolph does at Florence Grant's party.

  • Proverbs 16:9 and the doctrine of providence (Great Conversation)

    'A man's heart deviseth his way: but the LORD directeth his steps.' Mrs. Larkin thanks Providence where the narrator speaks of luck; the verse gives students a way to hold effort and providence together.

Logic and Rhetoric

Central argument: Honesty, industry and courtesy will in the end be vindicated, and pride and dishonesty exposed. The plot supports this with a mystery that Luke helps solve, but its reliance on a wealthy stranger and a lucky family tie shows the limits of the claim.

Rhetorical device: foil. Randolph Duncan, rich, vain and idle, is set against Luke at every turn, from the skating race and the party to their final fortunes, so that each boy's character shows more clearly by contrast.

Debate: Resolved: That Luke Larkin owes his success more to good luck than to good character.

Memory Work

We both know that I am innocent, and I rely on God to stand by me.

Chapter XIII. Luke's short sentence in the courtroom joins a clear conscience with trust in God and is easy to learn by heart.

Writing Prompts

Essay: Compare Luke Larkin and Randolph Duncan. Using three scenes, show how each boy's character shapes his fortune.

Comparison with Ragged Dick: Compare Luke Larkin and Ragged Dick. Which boy rises more by his own efforts, and which depends more on luck and patrons?

Medical Lens

A boys' adventure story, not a medical one. Randolph drinks and gambles at a billiard saloon, a travelling salesman drinks whisky, and Luke refuses drink; worry over his guilt makes Prince Duncan look haggard and ill. These reflect nineteenth-century temperance attitudes rather than medical description.

    Creative Prompts

    • Fiction

      Write a letter from Luke to Linton from Deadwood, describing the stagecoach holdup and the mining camp.

    • Essay

      Alger says Luke owes 'most of his good fortune to his own good qualities.' Agree or disagree, using at least three events from the book.

    • Dialogue

      Write a conversation between Randolph and Luke ten years after the book ends, when Randolph is an office boy in the West.

    • Classroom

      Trace Luke's journey from Groveton to New York, Chicago and Deadwood on a map, noting how long each leg would have taken by rail and stagecoach in 1880.

    Further Reading

    • Ragged Dick, Horatio Alger Jr.

      His first great success (1868), hosted in this library.

    • Phil the Fiddler, Horatio Alger Jr.

      An 1872 reform novel about an Italian boy street musician held by a padrone.

    • The Lost Life of Horatio Alger, Jr., Gary Scharnhorst and Jack Bales

      The standard modern biography (1985).

    • Tom Sawyer, Mark Twain

      A comic picture of a village boyhood that pokes fun at the 'model boy' of Sunday-school fiction.

    Verification notes

    Full text from Project Gutenberg #5417 (digitized by Cardinalis Etext Press, prepared for Gutenberg by Andrew Sly), the 1890 book text first issued by Porter & Coates, Philadelphia; public domain in the United States. Publication year and publisher follow standard bibliographies of Alger's works. All eight quotations were matched against the stored file as whitespace-normalized exact substrings. Dated material, noted in the guide: a politician courting 'the Irish vote' by appointing an Irish janitor, and the label 'negro newsboy' in a New York street scene.

    • Whether Struggling Upward appeared as a magazine serial (for example in Golden Argosy) before the 1890 book; not confirmed for this record.