Work record

First Inaugural Address

Also known as: McKinley First Inaugural

1897 · 19th Century · Oratory · English

Read this when a new president speaks of tariff, currency, and peace, after a hard depression.

Abstract

Written
Delivered 4 March 1897
Setting
After the 1896 tariff and currency campaign, and after years of industrial depression; Washington, D.C.
Country
United States
Language
English
Genre
Presidential inaugural address
Form
Formal inaugural of moderate length
Recommended
Grades 9–12 (A clear inaugural on revenue, currency, and peace; read it with the 1901 address after the war.)

Occasion. McKinley took the oath on 4 March 1897 after a hard campaign on the tariff and the currency, and after a long industrial depression. He treats restored confidence and sufficient revenue as first duties, and he calls Congress into extra session to revise the tariff rather than delaying the subject until the regular meeting.

Money and the tariff. Revenue, he says, must meet the government's needs and protect the public credit; a deficit is not a policy. A sound currency is affirmed in language shaped by the 1896 gold-and-silver fight, but the inaugural is not simply a repetition of the canvass.

Peace as the declared preference. He praises arbitration and insists that fighting should wait until every peaceful means has been tried and has failed. In almost every contingency, he prefers peace. The sentence should be taught at full weight, because the war with Spain would follow in 1898.

What this address is not. This is not a war message, and it is not yet a speech about Cuba, the Philippines, or island government. Those subjects belong to the second inaugural and to the history that came between the two ceremonies. A just reading keeps the 1897 caution and the later war in view together. The hosted text is cut at the close of the inaugural, before later messages in the volume.

Key figures

  • William McKinley: Twenty-fifth President, inaugurated 4 March 1897

Summary

William McKinley delivered his first inaugural address on 4 March 1897, after a campaign fought largely over the tariff and the currency and after years of industrial depression. He treats the restoration of confidence and of business as a first duty, and he asks Congress to meet in extra session to revise the tariff. Revenue, he says, must be sufficient for the public credit and for the government's needs; a deficit is not a policy. He affirms a sound currency and the obligation to protect it, in language shaped by the gold-and-silver fight of 1896, without turning the inaugural into a second stump speech. The extra session is itself a sign of his method: he will not postpone the revenue question to the regular meeting of Congress, because he treats a short treasury as a present danger to credit and to confidence. On foreign relations he speaks with caution. He honors arbitration as a method of settling disputes, and he says that wars should never be entered upon until every agency of peace has failed. Peace, he claims, is preferable to war in almost every contingency. The Cuban struggle is already a fact in American politics in 1897, but this inaugural is not a war message; the war with Spain would come in 1898. A class should not read later victories back into this day's language, nor treat the caution as mere hypocrisy before a planned war. The hosted text follows Richardson, Project Gutenberg #14446, and is cut at the close of the inaugural, before the later messages collected in the same volume. McKinley would be inaugurated again in 1901 after the Spanish-American War had given the United States new island possessions. This first address is the program of a president who still speaks as if peace and a restored tariff are the main business of the term. Students should hold the 1897 caution and the 1898 war together, without collapsing either into the other. The second inaugural will have to speak of Cuba, the Philippines, and the government of those islands; this one still does not.

Virtues in this work

  • Prudence: He prefers peace to war in almost every contingency and honors arbitration before force.
  • Justice: He treats sufficient revenue and a sound currency as duties owed to the public credit, not as optional conveniences.
  • Industry: The restoration of business and confidence is presented as work the administration must take up at once, beginning with an extra session.

Plot or Argument

  • After depression and a hard canvass

    McKinley treats the restoration of confidence and of business as a first duty of the new administration.

  • An extra session

    He asks Congress to meet at once to revise the tariff, rather than postponing revenue to the regular session.

  • Sufficient revenue

    The government, he says, must have income enough for its needs and for the public credit; a deficit is not a policy.

  • A sound currency

    He affirms the duty to protect a sound currency, in the shadow of the 1896 monetary fight.

  • War as a last resort

    Arbitration is honored, and war is not to be entered upon until every agency of peace has failed.

    Lessons

    • Revenue as a duty

      McKinley treats adequate revenue and public credit as moral as well as fiscal duties. Students can compare that claim with Cleveland's revenue-tariff language, which is not the same program.

      • What, for McKinley, is a tariff for, besides filling the Treasury?
      • Why does he want Congress to meet in extra session, and what does that tell you about his method?
      • How does his account of the tariff differ from Cleveland's revenue-tariff language?
    • The sentence about war

      The pledge that wars should wait until every agency of peace has failed is easy to praise in 1897 and hard to forget in 1898. A class should neither dismiss it as decoration nor use it as a simple verdict on the later war.

      • What would count, in McKinley's own terms, as the failure of every agency of peace?
      • What role does arbitration play in the peace sentences?
      • Should a class treat the 1897 caution as a real limit, or only as a preface, once the war of 1898 is known?
    • Two inaugurals, one career

      The first address still speaks as if peace and the tariff are the main business of the term. The second will speak of a war already fought and of new possessions. Students should read both.

      • What, if anything, in 1897 prepares the listener for 1898—and what does not?
      • What large foreign subject of the next year is not yet the business of this inaugural?
      • How do you hold the 1897 caution and the 1898 war together without letting either erase the other?

    Context

    McKinley, a former congressman and governor of Ohio, defeated William Jennings Bryan in 1896 in a campaign dominated by the gold standard and the protective tariff. The country was emerging from the depression that had followed the Panic of 1893. He was inaugurated on 4 March 1897. The war with Spain would begin the following year.

    Composition

    The address was delivered 4 March 1897. The hosted text is Richardson, Gutenberg #14446, cut at the close of the inaugural before the later messages in the volume.

    Reception

    Friends heard a promise of restored business and careful peace. The 1898 war and the second inaugural of 1901 quickly became the frame in which the 1897 caution was remembered, praised, or charged with irony.

    Comparisons

    • Second Inaugural Address

      Cleveland in 1893 treated the tariff as revenue and warned against paternalism on the eve of a panic; McKinley in 1897, after those years, calls an extra session for a protective revision and speaks as a party victor with a different fiscal creed.

    • Second Inaugural Address

      The 1901 inaugural is the speech of a president who has already fought the war with Spain and must now speak of Cuba, the Philippines, and island government; this 1897 address is still a peace-and-revenue paper.

    • First Inaugural Address

      Washington also treated the first inaugural as a cautious opening and deferred much of his program to Congress; McKinley's extra-session call is more specific, but the solemnity of a first taking of the oath is shared.

    Quotes

    “War should never be entered upon until every agency of peace has failed; peace is preferable to war in almost every contingency.”
    — William McKinley, First Inaugural Address, On war and peace (Richardson / Gutenberg #14446).Quote card
    “The preservation of public order, the right of discussion, the integrity of courts, and the orderly administration of justice must continue forever the rock of safety upon which our Government securely rests.”
    — William McKinley, First Inaugural Address, On arbitration (Richardson / Gutenberg #14446).Quote card
    “Economy is demanded in every branch of the Government at all times, but especially in periods, like the present, of depression in business and distress among the people.”
    — William McKinley, First Inaugural Address, On the extra session (Richardson / Gutenberg #14446).Quote card
    “It has been the policy of the United States since the foundation of the Government to cultivate relations of peace and amity with all the nations of the world, and this accords with my conception of our duty now.”
    — William McKinley, First Inaugural Address, On revenue (Richardson / Gutenberg #14446).Quote card
    “It will be our aim to pursue a firm and dignified foreign policy, which shall be just, impartial, ever watchful of our national honor, and always insisting upon the enforcement of the lawful rights of American citizens everywhere.”
    — William McKinley, First Inaugural Address, On confidence (Richardson / Gutenberg #14446).Quote card
    “The triumph of the people, whose verdict is carried into effect to-day, is not the triumph of one section, nor wholly of one party, but of all sections and all the people.”
    — William McKinley, First Inaugural Address, On a sound currency (Richardson / Gutenberg #14446).Quote card
    “Loans are imperative in great emergencies to preserve the Government or its credit, but a failure to supply needed revenue in time of peace for the maintenance of either has no justification.”
    — William McKinley, First Inaugural Address, On the canvass (Richardson / Gutenberg #14446).Quote card
    “One of the lessons taught by the late election, which all can rejoice in, is that the citizens of the United States are both law-respecting and law-abiding people, not easily swerved from the path of patriotism and honor.”
    — William McKinley, First Inaugural Address, On public credit (Richardson / Gutenberg #14446).Quote card

    For Students

    A reading companion for classical Christian high school students. See the student guide.

    Reading Guide

    Watch for

    • The call for an extra session on the tariff.
    • The language of sufficient revenue and public credit.
    • The sound-currency affirmation after 1896.
    • The sentences on arbitration and war as a last resort.
    • What the speech does not yet say about Cuba or Spain.

    Key terms and names

    Extra session
    A meeting of Congress called before the regular session; McKinley asks for one at once to revise the tariff.
    Protective tariff
    A system of customs duties meant not only to raise revenue but to shelter domestic industry; a central issue of the 1896 campaign.
    Sound currency
    Money kept honest and stable, in the terms of the gold-and-silver argument that dominated 1896.
    Arbitration
    The settlement of international disputes by a tribunal or agreed process rather than by war, which McKinley here honors.
    Public credit
    The government's reputation for meeting its obligations, which he says requires sufficient revenue.

    Seminar Questions

    1. Comprehension Why does McKinley want Congress to meet in extra session?
    2. Comprehension What does he say about revenue, deficits, and the public credit?
    3. Interpretation What is his declared preference between peace and war, and what role does he give to arbitration?
    4. Interpretation What large foreign subject of the next year is not yet the business of this inaugural?
    5. Big Question Is the sentence about war as a last resort a real limit, or only a pious preface?
    6. Big Question How should a class hold this 1897 caution together with the war of 1898 without letting either erase the other?

    Faith Connections

    • Matthew 5:9 (Scripture)

      The blessing on peacemakers sits close to McKinley's honor of arbitration and his preference for peace, and it makes the later war harder, not easier, to treat lightly.

    • Romans 13:7 (Scripture)

      Render to all their dues, tribute to whom tribute is due: a standard for his claim that revenue and public credit are duties.

    • Proverbs 16:32 (Scripture)

      He that is slow to anger is better than the mighty: a measure for 'every agency of peace' before war.

    Logic and Rhetoric

    Central argument: Because the country needs restored confidence and a government that can pay its way, Congress must revise the tariff at once, the currency must be kept sound, and war must wait until every agency of peace has failed.

    Rhetorical device: program of first duties. The extra-session call and the peace sentence do the plain work of the speech: one names the first legislative task, the other names a limit on force.

    Debate: Resolved: that McKinley's 1897 declaration that wars should wait until every agency of peace has failed ought to govern any just reading of the war with Spain that followed.

    Memory Work

    War should never be entered upon until every agency of peace has failed; peace is preferable to war in almost every contingency.

    On war and peace. The compact statement that wars should wait until every agency of peace has failed.

    Writing Prompts

    Essay: Explain McKinley's 1897 program of revenue, currency, and peace, then judge the peace sentences in the light of the coming of the war of 1898, without reading that war back into the inaugural as if it were already present.

    Comparison with Second Inaugural Address: What has changed, between the 1897 and 1901 inaugurals, in McKinley's account of peace, war, and American duty overseas? What, if anything, has stayed the same?

    Medical Lens

    This presidential text concerns constitutional politics and public office; it has no medical content for this library's lens.

      Creative Prompts

      • Classroom

        Mark every sentence about peace, arbitration, or war, then write a short note on how each sentence sounds if read in March 1897 and if reread in April 1898.

      • Dialogue

        Write a conversation on inauguration day between a protectionist Republican and a gold-standard Democrat who has just heard McKinley.

      • Essay

        McKinley says wars should wait until every agency of peace has failed. Using this inaugural and a clear account of the coming of the war with Spain, judge the sentence fairly.

      Further Reading

      • A Compilation of the Messages and Papers of the Presidents, James D. Richardson

        Official nineteenth-century compilation; the source of the hosted Gutenberg texts.

      • Inaugural Addresses of the Presidents of the United States, Avalon Project / GPO

        Parallel official texts for classroom comparison.

      • The Rhetorical Presidency, Jeffrey K. Tulis

        A study of how inaugural and other presidential speech reshaped the office.

      Verification notes

      Quotes were matched as substrings against the Richardson / Gutenberg #14446 text stored with this work, cut at the close of the inaugural before later messages in the volume.

      No verification flags recorded.