Work record
Second Inaugural Address
Grover ClevelandCleveland Second InauguralSecond Inaugural Address by Grover Cleveland (1893)Grover Cleveland delivered his second inaugural address on 4 March 1893, returning to the presidency after four years out of office and becoming both the twenty-second and the twenty-fourth President.Also known as: Cleveland Second Inaugural
1893 · 19th Century · Oratory · English
Read this when a president returns after a defeat, and tariff and money are treated as public trust.
Abstract
A second, nonconsecutive term. Cleveland took the oath again on 4 March 1893, after four years as a private citizen. The unique return is treated not as a personal triumph only, but as another chance to enforce limits on the General Government and to warn against official patronage and extravagance.
Paternalism again. He repeats, in substance, the seed-bill lesson: the people support the government, and the government's functions do not include the support of the people. An expectation of official care, he says, weakens the sturdiness of the national character. The second inaugural is thus a public restatement of a veto already famous.
Currency, tariff, and equality. Much of the address concerns a sound and stable currency, the public credit, and a tariff meant for revenue rather than for favors. Equality before the law, in his view, forbids special privileges, whether sought by capital or by other organized interests.
What followed. The Panic of 1893 arrived within months and tested every word about credit and confidence. The withdrawal of the Hawaiian treaty came later in the year. Those events are not in the speech, but they belong to any honest reading of the program with which the second term began. Students should keep those later facts as aftermath, not as hidden sentences in the March address.
Key figures
- Grover Cleveland: Twenty-fourth President, inaugurated again after a term out of office
Summary
Grover Cleveland delivered his second inaugural address on 4 March 1893, returning to the presidency after four years out of office and becoming both the twenty-second and the twenty-fourth President. The occasion is unique in the American record, and he treats it with a renewed warning against patronage, extravagance, and what he calls the lessons of paternalism. The functions of the General Government, he says, do not include the support of the people; the people support the Government. He returns, almost in the language of the 1887 seed-bill veto, to the claim that a government of limited powers must not be asked to do for citizens what they should do for themselves, and that an expectation of official care weakens the sturdiness of the people. Money and the tariff occupy much of the address. He insists on a sound and stable currency, honest coin, and a careful regard for the public credit. He treats tariff taxation as a means of revenue for the government, not as a system of favors, and he warns against the temptation to make the custom-house a partner in private gain. Equality before the law, in his account, forbids special privileges whether they are sought by capital or by organized interests. He also speaks of fraternal peace among the people and of the duty of the executive to execute the laws without fear or favor. The hosted text follows Richardson, Project Gutenberg #14137, and is cut at the close of the inaugural, before the special messages that follow in the volume. Within months the Panic of 1893 would test every claim in this paper about credit, currency, and confidence. Later in the same year Cleveland withdrew the Hawaiian annexation treaty left by the Harrison administration. Those later acts are aftermath, not parts of the inaugural, but a class should read the 1893 address as the program with which he began a second term already shadowed by financial panic.
Virtues in this work
- Temperance: He warns against extravagance and against asking the government to do what citizens should do for themselves.
- Justice: He ties a revenue tariff and a sound currency to equality before the law and to honest coin.
- Prudence: He treats public credit and limited functions as conditions of a durable republic, not as optional austerity.
Plot or Argument
- A unique return
Cleveland takes the oath again after four years out of office and treats the occasion as a renewed charge, not a personal trophy.
- Against paternalism
He restates that the people support the government and that official care must not replace self-support.
- Sound money
He insists on a stable currency, honest coin, and the public credit.
- The tariff as revenue
Customs duties, in his account, are for the government's needs, not for private favor.
- Equality before the law
Special privileges, whether for capital or for other interests, are refused in the name of equal law.
Lessons
The same lesson, a second term
The seed-bill principle is now spoken from the inaugural platform. Students should ask whether a second term is a chance to keep a promise, or a temptation to enlarge power.
- Where in this address does Cleveland sound most like the 1887 veto, and where does he go further?
- What does a second, nonconsecutive term allow him to claim that a first inaugural could not?
- Is restating the seed-bill lesson from the inaugural platform a strengthening of the principle, or a hardening of it?
Money as a moral subject
Currency and credit are treated as questions of honesty, not only of policy. A class can test that claim against the Panic that followed.
- What, in Cleveland's terms, would count as a dishonest currency?
- How does he connect honest coin to the public credit?
- How should a class use the Panic of 1893 without pretending the speaker already saw it?
Privilege and equality
He links a revenue tariff and equal law against special favors. Students should ask who, in 1893, was seeking those favors, and whether 'equality before the law' is used fairly.
- Does 'equality before the law' here protect the weak, or mainly restrain the government's gifts?
- Who, in his account, is seeking special favors from the tariff?
- Can 'equality before the law' be a true protection and still be used mainly to refuse gifts?
Context
Cleveland lost the Electoral College in 1888 while winning the popular vote, then defeated Benjamin Harrison in 1892. He was inaugurated again on 4 March 1893, unique in having served two nonconsecutive terms. The country was already moving toward the financial panic that would begin that year.
Composition
The address was delivered 4 March 1893. The hosted text is Richardson, Gutenberg #14137, ending at the close of the inaugural before the special messages in the volume.
Reception
Friends heard a consistent limited-government program. Critics heard rigidity on the eve of a depression. The Panic of 1893, the fight over silver, and the later Hawaiian decision quickly became the context in which the speech was remembered.
Comparisons
- First Inaugural Address
The 1885 inaugural opened the career with reform and economy; the 1893 address returns after a term out of office and hardens the warning against paternalism.
- Veto of the Texas Seed Bill
The second inaugural restates, almost as a public creed, the 1887 lesson that the people support the government and the government should not support the people.
- First Inaugural Address
McKinley's 1897 inaugural, after the Panic years and a new party victory, treats tariff and currency under different assumptions; the contrast is useful and should not be flattened.
Quotes
“The lessons of paternalism ought to be unlearned and the better lesson taught that while the people should patriotically and cheerfully support their Government its functions do not include the support of the people.”
“This is the bane of republican institutions and the constant peril of our government by the people.”
“It undermines the self-reliance of our people and substitutes in its place dependence upon governmental favoritism.”
“Loyalty to the principles upon which our Government rests positively demands that the equality before the law which it guarantees to every citizen should be justly and in good faith conceded in all parts of the land.”
“Under our scheme of government the waste of public money is a crime against the citizen, and the contempt of our people for economy and frugality in their personal affairs deplorably saps the strength and sturdiness of our national character.”
“Manifestly nothing is more vital to our supremacy as a nation and to the beneficent purposes of our Government than a sound and stable currency.”
“If in lifting burdens from the daily life of our people we reduce inordinate and unequal advantages too long enjoyed, this is but a necessary incident of our return to right and justice.”
“Humanity and consistency require us to treat them with forbearance and in our dealings with them to honestly and considerately regard their rights and interests.”
For Students
A reading companion for classical Christian high school students. See the student guide.
Reading Guide
Watch for
- The unique nonconsecutive return.
- The restatement of the seed-bill lesson.
- The currency and public-credit passages.
- The tariff as revenue, not favor.
- The claim of equality before the law.
Key terms and names
- Paternalism
- Cleveland's name for the habit of expecting the General Government to care for the people as a parent would.
- Sound currency
- Honest, stable money and a careful regard for the public credit, as opposed to a depreciated or experimental coinage.
- Revenue tariff
- A system of customs duties meant to fund the government, not to confer private advantages.
- Equality before the law
- The refusal of special legal privileges, whether sought by capital or by other organized interests.
- Nonconsecutive terms
- Cleveland's unique service as both the twenty-second and the twenty-fourth President, separated by Harrison's term.
Seminar Questions
- Comprehension What is unusual about the occasion of this inaugural, and how does Cleveland treat that fact?
- Comprehension How does he restate the relation between the people and the government?
- Interpretation What does he demand of the currency and of the public credit?
- Interpretation How does he describe the proper use of the tariff?
- Big Question Is 'paternalism' a just name for federal relief, or a way of closing the argument before it starts?
- Big Question How should a class read this program in the light of the Panic of 1893, which the speech itself cannot yet see?
Faith Connections
- Proverbs 11:1 (Scripture)
A false balance is an abomination: a standard for Cleveland's insistence on honest coin and public credit.
- Exodus 23:3, 6 (Scripture)
The law forbids partiality either to the poor or to the great; useful beside his claim of equality before the law.
- 1 Timothy 6:10 (Scripture)
The love of money as a root of evils bears on his warning against making the custom-house a partner in private gain.
Logic and Rhetoric
Central argument: Because the people support the government and its functions do not include their support, the second term must resist paternalism, keep a sound currency and public credit, and use the tariff for revenue rather than for privilege.
Rhetorical device: restated principle. He lifts the seed-bill lesson onto the inaugural platform and applies it to currency, tariff, and official care together.
Debate: Resolved: that Cleveland's second inaugural was a consistent and just restatement of limited government, rather than a rigid creed on the eve of a panic he did not yet face.
Memory Work
The lessons of paternalism ought to be unlearned and the better lesson taught that while the people should patriotically and cheerfully support their Government its functions do not include the support of the people.
Writing Prompts
Essay: Trace the idea that the people support the government from the 1887 veto into the 1893 inaugural, and judge whether the second address adds anything essential.
Comparison with Veto of the Texas Seed Bill: Compare the 1887 veto and the 1893 inaugural on paternalism and the Treasury. What is constant, and what has the later speech added or hardened?
Medical Lens
This presidential text concerns constitutional politics and public office; it has no medical content for this library's lens.
Creative Prompts
- Classroom
Make a two-column table: Cleveland's 1893 promises on currency, tariff, and paternalism, and the events of the Panic year that tested each one.
- Dialogue
Write a conversation in March 1893 between a silver Democrat and a gold-standard supporter, both of whom have just heard the inaugural.
- Essay
How does the second inaugural restated the seed-bill veto, and what, if anything, is new in 1893?
Further Reading
- A Compilation of the Messages and Papers of the Presidents, James D. Richardson
Official nineteenth-century compilation; the source of the hosted Gutenberg texts.
- Inaugural Addresses of the Presidents of the United States, Avalon Project / GPO
Parallel official texts for classroom comparison.
- The Rhetorical Presidency, Jeffrey K. Tulis
A study of how inaugural and other presidential speech reshaped the office.
Verification notes
Quotes were matched as substrings against the Richardson / Gutenberg #14137 text stored with this work, cut at the close of the inaugural before the special messages.
No verification flags recorded.