Work record

Second Inaugural Address

Also known as: McKinley Second Inaugural

1901 · 19th Century · Oratory · English

Read this when a war has made a new American power, and a second term faces distant rule.

Abstract

Written
Delivered 4 March 1901
Setting
After the war with Spain and a decisive reelection, with new island possessions to be governed; Washington, D.C.
Country
United States
Language
English
Genre
Presidential inaugural address
Form
Formal inaugural of substantial length
Recommended
Grades 10–12 (A substantial inaugural on a concluded war and new island possessions; pair with 1897.)

Occasion. McKinley took the oath a second time on 4 March 1901, after the war with Spain and a decisive reelection. The first inaugural had spoken of peace and a restored tariff. This one must speak of a war already fought and of islands the United States now had to govern.

Cuba and the islands. He treats the conflict as reluctantly begun and successfully ended, and he presents the new holdings as a charge rather than as loot. Cuba is to be helped toward her own government. Puerto Rico and the Philippine Islands are named as a continuing duty of order and honest rule. Later readers have heard in that language both conscientious stewardship and the rhetoric of empire; both hearings should be tested against what followed, including the war already under way in the Philippines.

Restored prosperity. He claims that good times and the public credit have returned, and that the country has shown itself able to take up duties it had not expected. The claim should be read as the administration's account of the four years just ended, not as a verdict a class must simply accept.

Aftermath, not in the speech. McKinley was shot at Buffalo on 6 September 1901 and died on the 14th. Roosevelt inherited the office and the island questions. Those facts cannot be found in the March address, but they belong to any honest teaching of this last beginning of a second term, and they make the 1897 peace sentences harder, not easier, to forget.

Key figures

  • William McKinley: Twenty-fifth President, inaugurated for a second term on 4 March 1901

Summary

William McKinley delivered his second inaugural address on 4 March 1901, after a war with Spain, a decisive reelection, and the acquisition of island possessions that the United States had not governed before. The first inaugural of 1897 had spoken of peace as preferable to war and of a restored tariff as the first business of the term. This second address must speak of a war already fought and of the government of Cuba, Puerto Rico, and the Philippines. McKinley treats the conflict as a war entered reluctantly and concluded in victory, and he presents the new possessions as a trust rather than as a mere prize. Cuba, he says, is to be assisted toward a government of her own, in keeping with the declared purpose of the war. The Philippines and the other islands are described as a duty of instruction, order, and just government, in language that later readers have heard both as conscientious stewardship and as the rhetoric of empire. A class should hear both possibilities and test them against what followed, including the Philippine-American War, which was already under way. He also claims that prosperity has been restored, that the public credit is strong, and that the American people have shown a capacity to meet unexpected duties. The hosted text follows Richardson, Project Gutenberg #14446. McKinley would be shot at Buffalo on 6 September 1901 and would die on the 14th; Theodore Roosevelt would take the oath and inherit both the office and these island questions. Those facts are aftermath, not parts of the inaugural, but they belong to any honest teaching of the last speech he delivered as a man beginning a second term. Students should read the 1901 address beside the 1897 peace sentences, neither erasing the earlier caution nor treating the later paper as a simple betrayal of it.

Virtues in this work

  • Prudence: He presents the new possessions as a duty to be governed justly, rather than as a mere prize, whatever later history has made of that claim.
  • Justice: Assistance toward a Cuban government of her own is offered as a standard consistent with the purpose of the war.
  • Fortitude: The second term is treated as a charge to finish unexpected work, not as a rest after victory.

Plot or Argument

  • A second term after war

    McKinley takes the oath again after the war with Spain and treats the new term as a charge to govern unexpected possessions.

  • Cuba as a declared purpose

    He presents assistance toward a Cuban government of her own as consistent with the purpose for which the war was fought.

  • The other islands

    Puerto Rico and the Philippines are described as a duty of order, instruction, and just government.

  • A trust, not a mere prize

    The possessions are framed as a responsibility laid on the American people, in language that later readers have judged in more than one way.

  • Restored prosperity

    He claims that credit and prosperity have been restored and that the people have met unexpected duties.

    Lessons

    • The first inaugural and the second

      In 1897 McKinley said that wars should wait until every agency of peace had failed. In 1901 he speaks of a war concluded and of islands to be governed. Students should hold the two papers together.

      • What, if anything, does the second inaugural say about how the standard of 1897 was met?
      • How does he describe the war with Spain, and what does he not say about how it began?
      • Does the second inaugural answer, or only leave behind, the 1897 standard about war as a last resort?
    • Trust and empire

      The language of duty, instruction, and just government can be conscientious, and it can also cover conquest. A class should test the words against the Philippine-American War and against the later record in Cuba and Puerto Rico, without flattening the speech into a slogan.

      • Where in this address is the people of an island allowed a will of their own, and where is that will assumed?
      • What does he say the United States owes to Cuba, and what to the Philippines?
      • How would a critic of empire, in 1901, have heard the language of trust and just government?
    • A last beginning

      This is the opening of a term McKinley would not finish. The assassination is not in the speech, but it belongs to the teaching of the paper as the last program he announced.

      • How does the knowledge of September 1901 change the way a class hears a second beginning?
      • What is the force of teaching this paper as a last beginning, rather than as an ordinary second term?
      • How should the assassination of September 1901 be present in the lesson without being read into the speech?

    Context

    The United States went to war with Spain in 1898. The peace that followed left Cuba under American occupation, pending a government of her own, and placed Puerto Rico, Guam, and the Philippines under American authority. A bitter war against Filipino republicans was already under way when McKinley, having defeated Bryan again in 1900, was inaugurated on 4 March 1901.

    Composition

    The address was delivered 4 March 1901. The hosted text is Richardson, Gutenberg #14446. McKinley was shot on 6 September 1901 at the Pan-American Exposition in Buffalo and died on the 14th.

    Reception

    Admirers heard a sober account of duty after a necessary war. Critics then and later heard the language of empire and asked whether the 1897 peace sentences had been honored. The assassination soon fixed the speech as a last beginning.

    Comparisons

    • First Inaugural Address

      The 1897 inaugural is a peace-and-revenue paper that treats war as a last resort; the 1901 address must justify a war already fought and a new island government.

    • Second Inaugural Address

      Lincoln's second inaugural, after a far more terrible war, is a penitential meditation on judgment and charity; McKinley's second is an account of duty, prosperity, and possessions. The contrast is instructive and should not be forced into a simple ranking.

    • Second Inaugural Address

      Cleveland's 1893 return warned against paternalism at home; McKinley's 1901 return announces unexpected duties abroad. The two second inaugurals belong to different crises.

    Quotes

    “May it end without further bloodshed, and there be ushered in the reign of peace to be made permanent by a government of liberty under law!”
    — William McKinley, Second Inaugural Address, On the war (Richardson / Gutenberg #14446).Quote card
    “I did all that in honor could be done to avert the war, but without avail.”
    — William McKinley, Second Inaugural Address, On Cuba (Richardson / Gutenberg #14446).Quote card
    “The peace which we are pledged to leave to the Cuban people must carry with it the guaranties of permanence.”
    — William McKinley, Second Inaugural Address, On the Philippines (Richardson / Gutenberg #14446).Quote card
    “The declaration of the purposes of this Government in the resolution of April 20, 1898, must be made good.”
    — William McKinley, Second Inaugural Address, On a trust (Richardson / Gutenberg #14446).Quote card
    “We are not waging war against the inhabitants of the Philippine Islands.”
    — William McKinley, Second Inaugural Address, On unexpected duties (Richardson / Gutenberg #14446).Quote card
    “Division on public questions can no longer be traced by the war maps of 1861.”
    — William McKinley, Second Inaugural Address, On prosperity (Richardson / Gutenberg #14446).Quote card
    “Honesty, capacity, and industry are nowhere more indispensable than in public employment.”
    — William McKinley, Second Inaugural Address, On the new term (Richardson / Gutenberg #14446).Quote card
    “Four years ago we stood on the brink of war without the people knowing it and without any preparation or effort at preparation for the impending peril.”
    — William McKinley, Second Inaugural Address, On just government (Richardson / Gutenberg #14446).Quote card

    For Students

    A reading companion for classical Christian high school students. See the student guide.

    Reading Guide

    Watch for

    • How the second inaugural speaks of the war with Spain.
    • The language about Cuba and a government of her own.
    • The language about the Philippines and the other islands.
    • The claim of restored prosperity.
    • What a class knows, and the speech cannot yet say, about September 1901.

    Key terms and names

    Spanish-American War
    The 1898 war with Spain, already concluded when this inaugural was delivered, which left the United States responsible for Cuba, Puerto Rico, Guam, and the Philippines.
    Trust
    McKinley's word, in substance, for the claim that the new possessions are a responsibility of just government, not a mere prize.
    Cuba
    The island whose independence had been a declared purpose of the war, and which in 1901 was still under American occupation pending a government of her own.
    Philippines
    The archipelago ceded by Spain and already the scene of a war against Filipino republicans when McKinley spoke in 1901.
    Public credit
    The government's reputation for meeting its obligations, which he says has been restored along with prosperity.

    Seminar Questions

    1. Comprehension How does McKinley describe the war with Spain in this second inaugural?
    2. Comprehension What does he say the United States owes to Cuba?
    3. Interpretation How does he describe the duty of the United States in the Philippines and the other islands?
    4. Interpretation What claim does he make about prosperity and the public credit?
    5. Big Question Is the language of trust and just government a real limit on power, or a way of naming empire kindly?
    6. Big Question How should a class read this last beginning of a second term in the light of the 1897 peace sentences and of the assassination that followed in September?

    Faith Connections

    • Luke 12:48 (Scripture)

      To whom much is given, much will be required: a standard for the language of trust and unexpected duty, and a warning against using 'duty' as a soft word for domination.

    • Micah 6:8 (Scripture)

      To do justly, love mercy, and walk humbly: a measure for 'just government' in islands whose people did not elect this president.

    • Matthew 5:9 (Scripture)

      The blessing on peacemakers, already close to the 1897 inaugural, remains the hardest scriptural test of a second address spoken after war.

    Logic and Rhetoric

    Central argument: Because the war with Spain has ended in unexpected possessions, the second term must treat those islands as a trust of just government, assist Cuba toward a government of her own, and go on in the restored prosperity the first term claims to have won.

    Rhetorical device: duty after victory. The Cuba passage and the island-government passage do the central work: one names a promised end of occupation, the other names a continuing charge.

    Debate: Resolved: that McKinley's 1901 language of trust and just government in the islands should be read as a real standard the United States was bound to meet, not as a decoration of conquest.

    Memory Work

    The declaration of the purposes of this Government in the resolution of April 20, 1898, must be made good.

    On a trust. The compact statement of the islands as a duty of instruction, order, and just government, which a class must both hear and test.

    Writing Prompts

    Essay: Compare the 1897 and 1901 inaugurals on peace, war, and American duty. What has changed, what has stayed, and how should a class judge the language of trust in the light of Cuba and the Philippines?

    Comparison with First Inaugural Address: Place the 1897 sentences about war as a last resort beside the 1901 account of a concluded war and new possessions. What, if anything, does the later speech say about how the earlier standard was kept?

    Medical Lens

    This presidential text concerns constitutional politics and public office; it has no medical content for this library's lens.

      Creative Prompts

      • Classroom

        Place the 1897 peace sentences beside the 1901 passages on Cuba and the Philippines, and write a short judgment that honors both papers.

      • Dialogue

        Write a conversation in March 1901 between an American anti-imperialist and a supporter of McKinley's island policy, both of whom have just heard the inaugural.

      • Essay

        Does the second inaugural treat the new possessions as a trust, as an empire, or as both? Answer from the text, then test the claim against one fact of the years that followed.

      Further Reading

      • A Compilation of the Messages and Papers of the Presidents, James D. Richardson

        Official nineteenth-century compilation; the source of the hosted Gutenberg texts.

      • Inaugural Addresses of the Presidents of the United States, Avalon Project / GPO

        Parallel official texts for classroom comparison.

      • The Rhetorical Presidency, Jeffrey K. Tulis

        A study of how inaugural and other presidential speech reshaped the office.

      Verification notes

      Quotes were matched as substrings against the Richardson / Gutenberg #14446 text stored with this work. The Philippine-American War and the assassination are taught as context and aftermath, not as passages in the address.

      No verification flags recorded.