Work record

Address upon Assuming the Presidency

Also known as: Arthur Inaugural Address · Arthur Address upon Assuming the Presidency

1881 · 19th Century · Oratory · English

Read this when an unexpected succession follows a shooting, and a new president must steady the office.

Abstract

Written
Issued 22 September 1881
Setting
The days after President Garfield's death; Washington, D.C., after the oath taken in New York on 20 September
Country
United States
Language
English
Genre
Presidential accession address
Form
Very short written address, later printed by Richardson as an inaugural
Recommended
Grades 9–12 (A very short accession address; pair it with Tyler's 1841 paper and with the later Pendleton Act.)

Occasion. Garfield died on 19 September 1881, after a lingering wound. Arthur had taken the oath in New York on the 20th and issued this short address on the 22nd as he assumed the duties in Washington. It is an accession paper after assassination, not a ceremonial inaugural, though Richardson later headed it as one. The hosted text is the complete short accession; the later mourning proclamation is a separate paper and is not included here.

Continuity. Arthur's theme is that the government does not die with a man. For the fourth time a president has been removed by death, and for the fourth time the constitutional officer has been called to the chair. Men may die, he says, but the fabrics of the free institutions remain unshaken.

Repose. He promises no unusual session and no sudden legislative program. Foreign affairs are quiet; the country, in his account, needs rest after months of anxiety more than it needs a new crusade of party measures.

The term that followed. The speech itself is a reassurance. The later Pendleton Act, signed in 1883, is the surprising fact of Arthur's presidency and should be taught with the life, without being read back into these few hundred words as if he had already announced it.

Key figures

  • Chester A. Arthur: Vice President who assumed the presidency
  • James A. Garfield: Twentieth President, shot on 2 July and dead on 19 September 1881

Summary

Chester A. Arthur issued this short address on 22 September 1881, after the death of James A. Garfield. Garfield had been shot on 2 July and died on 19 September. Arthur took the presidential oath in New York on 20 September and, two days later, addressed the country as he assumed the office in Washington. Like Tyler's paper of 1841, this is an accession address after a death, not a ceremonial inaugural after an election, though Richardson later printed it under the heading of an inaugural. The mourning proclamation that follows in the same volume is not part of this text. The address is brief, only a few hundred words. Arthur notes that for the fourth time in the history of the Republic a chief magistrate has been removed by death, and that for the fourth time the officer elected to fill such a vacancy is called to the executive chair. The wisdom of the fathers, he says, made sure that the government should never be imperiled by the uncertainty of human life. Men may die, but the fabrics of the free institutions remain unshaken. He offers reassurance rather than a long program. No threatening issue mars foreign intercourse; the people may be trusted to continue a career of peace, tranquillity, and welfare. No demand for speedy legislation has been heard, and he sees no occasion for an unusual session of Congress. The gloom and anxiety that have enshrouded the country must make repose especially welcome now. Summoned to these duties and conscious of their gravity, he assumes the trust imposed by the Constitution, relying on divine guidance and on the virtue, patriotism, and intelligence of the American people. The hosted text follows Richardson, Project Gutenberg #12754. Arthur had been a lieutenant of the Conkling machine and collector of the Port of New York until Hayes removed him; many therefore expected a spoils presidency. In 1883 he instead signed the Pendleton Civil Service Act. That later reform is the fruit of the term, not a promise spelled out in this first short paper, but it belongs beside the accession when the life is taught. He was not nominated for a full term in 1884 and died in 1886.

Virtues in this work

  • Prudence: He refuses a special session and treats quiet, after a long public anxiety, as a duty rather than as weakness.
  • Humility: He confesses the gravity of the trust and looks to divine guidance and to the people's character, not to his own past in party organization.
  • Hope: The unshaken fabrics of the institutions are offered as a reason not to despair after a murder.

Plot or Argument

  • A fourth death in office

    Arthur states that a chief magistrate has again been removed by death, and that the constitutional successor has again been called.

  • Institutions unshaken

    He attributes to the framers a design that the government not be imperiled by the uncertainty of human life.

  • No emergency session

    He sees no threatening foreign issue and no need for an unusual session of Congress.

  • A welcome repose

    After months of gloom, he thinks the country needs rest.

  • The trust

    He assumes the office, relying on divine guidance and on the people's virtue, patriotism, and intelligence.

    Lessons

    • The fourth succession

      Arthur places himself in a line that already includes Tyler. The lesson is continuity after assassination, and the same accurate title: an accession address, not a formal inaugural.

      • How does Arthur use the count—'the fourth time'—to calm the country?
      • What earlier accessions does he silently rely on when he speaks of the fourth time?
      • Does naming a line of predecessors make the claim to the full office stronger, or only more familiar?
    • A short paper and a later act

      The address promises repose, not a reform program. In 1883 Arthur signed the Pendleton Civil Service Act, a surprise given his machine past. Teach the speech first, then the term.

      • Is it fair to praise this paper for a reform it does not announce?
      • What, if anything, in the address would prepare a listener for the Pendleton Act two years later?
      • Should a short accession be judged only by what it says, or also by the term that followed?
    • Repose as a policy

      After a summer of national anxiety, Arthur treats quiet as a public good. Students may ask when a new president should refuse a special session, and when silence would be a fault.

      • When is 'no unusual session' prudence, and when is it a vacancy of leadership?
      • Why might a country exhausted by a summer of anxiety want 'repose' more than a program?
      • Who, in Arthur's audience, would have wanted a special session, and why?

    Context

    Garfield was shot on 2 July 1881 and died on 19 September. Arthur, his Vice President and a former collector of the Port of New York associated with Senator Roscoe Conkling's organization, took the oath on 20 September in New York and issued this address on the 22nd. It was the fourth presidential death in office, after Harrison, Taylor, and Lincoln.

    Composition

    The hosted text is Richardson, Gutenberg #12754. Richardson prints it as an 'INAUGURAL ADDRESS.' The following mourning proclamation in the volume is not included. The library titles the work as an address upon assuming the presidency.

    Reception

    The paper was received as a reassurance. Arthur's later signing of the Pendleton Act in 1883 changed his reputation, and that later fact should be taught with the life. He was not nominated in 1884 and died in 1886.

    Comparisons

    • Address upon Assuming the Presidency

      Tyler in 1841 first claimed the full office after a president's death; Arthur in 1881, after an assassination, is a later short accession address in the same line.

    • Inaugural Address

      Hayes in 1877 had already called for civil-service reform; Arthur, whom Hayes had once removed from the New York collectorship, later signed the Pendleton Act.

    • Second Inaugural Address

      Lincoln's second inaugural is a long moral reckoning after civil war; Arthur's accession is a brief reassurance after a single murder, and the two should not be forced into the same register.

    Quotes

    “For the fourth time in the history of the Republic its Chief Magistrate has been removed by death.”
    — Chester A. Arthur, Address upon Assuming the Presidency, On the vacancy (Richardson / Gutenberg #12754).Quote card
    “The wisdom of our fathers, foreseeing even the most dire possibilities, made sure that the Government should never be imperiled because of the uncertainty of human life.”
    — Chester A. Arthur, Address upon Assuming the Presidency, On the framers (Richardson / Gutenberg #12754).Quote card
    “Men may die, but the fabrics of our free institutions remain unshaken.”
    — Chester A. Arthur, Address upon Assuming the Presidency, On the institutions (Richardson / Gutenberg #12754).Quote card
    “For the fourth time the officer elected by the people and ordained by the Constitution to fill a vacancy so created is called to assume the Executive chair.”
    — Chester A. Arthur, Address upon Assuming the Presidency, On succession (Richardson / Gutenberg #12754).Quote card
    “The gloom and anxiety which have enshrouded the country must make repose especially welcome now.”
    — Chester A. Arthur, Address upon Assuming the Presidency, On the public mood (Richardson / Gutenberg #12754).Quote card
    “No threatening issue mars our foreign intercourse, and the wisdom, integrity, and thrift of our people may be trusted to continue undisturbed the present assured career of peace, tranquillity, and welfare.”
    — Chester A. Arthur, Address upon Assuming the Presidency, On foreign and domestic quiet (Richardson / Gutenberg #12754).Quote card
    “No demand for speedy legislation has been heard; no adequate occasion is apparent for an unusual session of Congress.”
    — Chester A. Arthur, Address upon Assuming the Presidency, On Congress (Richardson / Gutenberg #12754).Quote card
    “Summoned to these high duties and responsibilities and profoundly conscious of their magnitude and gravity, I assume the trust imposed by the Constitution, relying for aid on divine guidance and the virtue, patriotism, and intelligence of the American people.”
    — Chester A. Arthur, Address upon Assuming the Presidency, The close (Richardson / Gutenberg #12754).Quote card

    For Students

    A reading companion for classical Christian high school students. See the student guide.

    Reading Guide

    Watch for

    • The count of 'the fourth time' and what it is meant to calm.
    • The sentence about men dying and institutions remaining.
    • The refusal of an unusual session.
    • The later Pendleton Act, which this paper does not announce.

    Key terms and names

    Accession address
    A short official paper issued when a Vice President assumes the presidency after a death, as distinct from a ceremonial inaugural.
    Pendleton Civil Service Act
    The 1883 statute Arthur signed, creating a classified, examination-based service; taught with the term, not as a promise in this address.
    Roscoe Conkling
    The New York senator whose organization Arthur had served; useful background for the surprise of his later reform.
    Mourning proclamation
    A separate official paper in Richardson after this address; it is not part of the hosted text.
    Fourth succession
    Arthur's count of presidential deaths in office before him: Harrison, Taylor, Lincoln, and now Garfield.

    Seminar Questions

    1. Comprehension What does Arthur say has now happened for the fourth time?
    2. Comprehension Why does he think there is no need for an unusual session of Congress?
    3. Interpretation How does he use the framers to argue that the government survives a president's death?
    4. Interpretation What later act of Arthur's presidency should be taught with this life but not read into this first paper?
    5. Big Question When is a new president right to offer repose rather than a program?
    6. Big Question How should a class use Arthur's machine past when hearing a speech that never mentions it?

    Faith Connections

    • Psalm 146:3-4 (Scripture)

      'Put not your trust in princes... his breath goeth forth, he returneth to his earth' is the biblical form of Arthur's claim that men die and must not be the last stay of the government.

    • Isaiah 6:1 (Scripture)

      In the year that a king died, the prophet still saw the Lord on the throne: a useful text beside a speech that points past a dead president to unshaken institutions.

    • Proverbs 21:1 (Scripture)

      The king's heart in the hand of the Lord is a check on both despair after an assassination and on over-trust in the successor's personal past.

    Logic and Rhetoric

    Central argument: Because the Constitution already provides for this vacancy, the government is not imperiled by Garfield's death; Arthur will assume the trust, seek no unusual session, and rely on divine guidance and on the people's character.

    Rhetorical device: reassurance by count. The repeated 'fourth time' turns a shocking assassination into one more test the institutions have already been built to survive.

    Debate: Resolved: that Arthur's 1881 decision to offer repose, rather than a special session and a new program, was the right first word after Garfield's death.

    Memory Work

    Men may die, but the fabrics of our free institutions remain unshaken.

    On the institutions. The shortest and most memorable sentence in the paper: men may die, but the fabrics of the free institutions remain unshaken.

    Writing Prompts

    Essay: Explain how this accession address claims continuity after assassination, then judge it beside Tyler's 1841 paper and beside the Pendleton Act Arthur later signed.

    Comparison with Address upon Assuming the Presidency: Compare Tyler's 1841 and Arthur's 1881 accession addresses: what does each man claim about the office, and how does the fact of assassination change the tone of the later paper?

    Medical Lens

    This accession address concerns a presidential death and constitutional succession; it has no medical content for this library's lens beyond the public fact of Garfield's wound and death.

      Creative Prompts

      • Classroom

        Set Arthur's sentences about unshaken institutions beside a timeline of 2 July–22 September 1881, and write a page on what 'repose' meant after those months.

      • Dialogue

        Write a conversation on 22 September 1881 between a Conkling ally who expects patronage and a reformer who fears the new president's machine past.

      • Essay

        Compare Arthur's accession with Tyler's: what does each man think will actually keep the government alive after a president's death?

      Further Reading

      • A Compilation of the Messages and Papers of the Presidents, James D. Richardson

        Official nineteenth-century compilation; the source of the hosted Gutenberg texts.

      • Inaugural Addresses of the Presidents of the United States, Avalon Project / GPO

        Parallel official texts for classroom comparison.

      • The Rhetorical Presidency, Jeffrey K. Tulis

        A study of how inaugural and other presidential speech reshaped the office.

      Verification notes

      Quotes were matched as substrings against the Richardson / Gutenberg #12754 text stored with this work. The following mourning proclamation was excluded from the hosted text on purpose.

      No verification flags recorded.