Work record

Inaugural Address

Also known as: Hayes Inaugural Address

1877 · 19th Century · Oratory · English

Read this when a disputed election is over, and a new president speaks of reform and reunion.

Abstract

Written
Delivered 5 March 1877
Setting
The start of a presidency settled after the disputed election of 1876; Washington, D.C.
Country
United States
Language
English
Genre
Presidential inaugural address
Form
Formal inaugural after a contested election, delivered on Monday, 5 March
Recommended
Grades 9–12 (A clear inaugural; the Reconstruction context must be taught with the text.)

Occasion. Hayes was inaugurated on 5 March 1877, after the disputed election of 1876 and the settlement that withdrew remaining federal support from Reconstruction governments in the South. The speech has to be heard as the first word of a president whose title had just been contested.

The South and the color line. He promises to regard white and Black Southerners equally and to work for a policy that will end the color line in political affairs and heal the division of North and South. Those sentences must be read beside the actual withdrawal of remaining protection for Black citizens, which was part of the bargain that seated him.

Reform and money. He calls for a thorough reform of the civil service and for a paper currency resting on coin. He also says that a president, though chosen by a party, serves that party best when he serves the country best.

How to teach it. The inaugural is a document of reunion language at the end of Reconstruction. A class should let Hayes speak, then set the record of 1877 beside the promises, without treating either the promises or the settlement as if the other were not there. His later refusal to seek a second term is part of the same short presidency. Keep both the promises and the bargain in view.

Key figures

  • Rutherford B. Hayes: Nineteenth President, seated after the disputed 1876 election
  • Samuel J. Tilden: The 1876 Democratic candidate, who had led the popular vote

Summary

Rutherford B. Hayes delivered his inaugural address on 5 March 1877, a Monday, because the 4th fell on a Sunday. He entered office after the disputed election of 1876. Samuel J. Tilden had led the popular vote, twenty electoral votes were contested, and an Electoral Commission, with the political settlement often called the Compromise of 1877, placed Hayes in the presidency. Federal support for the remaining Reconstruction governments in the South was withdrawn. The inaugural is therefore not a victory speech of an ordinary canvass; it is the first official word of a president whose title itself had been in question. Hayes speaks at once to the Southern States. He says it is his earnest desire to regard and promote the truest interests of white and colored people both and equally, and to put forth his best efforts for a civil policy that will wipe out, in political affairs, the color line and the distinction between North and South, so that the country may have not merely a united North or a united South, but a united country. A class must set that promise beside the withdrawal of remaining federal protection for Black citizens in the South, which was the price of the settlement that seated him. The words and the policy belong together in the lesson. He also urges civil-service reform, a thorough change in official patronage, and a return to the principles of the founders, who, he says, neither expected nor desired partisan service from public officers. On the currency he repeats a statement from his letter of acceptance: the uncertainty of an irredeemable paper currency is a great obstacle to prosperous times, and the only safe paper is one that rests on a coin basis and is promptly convertible into coin. He adds that a president, though elected by a party, should remember that he serves his party best who serves the country best. The hosted text follows Richardson, Project Gutenberg #13021. Hayes declined to seek a second term. The address is a primary document of the end of Reconstruction and of the civil-service and hard-money arguments of the late 1870s, and it should be taught with the disputed election clearly in view.

Virtues in this work

  • Justice: He says the interests of white and colored people must be regarded equally; the later record of 1877 must be used to test the claim.
  • Prudence: He urges a coin-based currency and a thorough reform of patronage rather than a new crusade of party revenge.
  • Temperance: He presents himself as a one-term president of reunion, not as a man grasping for a longer hold on office.

Plot or Argument

  • A contested beginning

    The address opens a presidency that had been settled only after a disputed count and a political bargain.

  • A united country

    Hayes promises a policy that will regard white and Black Southerners equally and will end the color line in political affairs.

  • Civil service

    He asks for a thorough, radical, and complete reform of official patronage.

  • Hard money

    He repeats his view that irredeemable paper is a barrier to prosperity and that a safe currency rests on coin.

  • Party and country

    A president, though elected by a party, should serve the country first.

    Lessons

    • Promises and a bargain

      The most quoted sentences are about a united country and the color line. They have to be taught with the Compromise of 1877 and the withdrawal of remaining federal support for Reconstruction.

      • What, exactly, does Hayes promise the South, and what did the settlement actually do?
      • How does the speech sound if you know the Compromise of 1877, and how if you try, for a moment, not to?
      • What does he say about the color line, and what does the later record do with that promise?
    • Party and office

      The line that a man serves his party best who serves the country best is easy to admire. Students should ask how it sounds from a president seated by a party bargain.

      • Is the sentence a check on party, or a covering of one?
      • How does a president seated after a disputed count ask the country to trust his impartiality?
      • Can a man 'serve his party best' by serving the country, or is that a pleasant contradiction?
    • Money and patronage

      Civil-service reform and a coin-based currency are the practical program. They connect this inaugural to later reform fights, including Arthur's term after 1881.

      • Which of Hayes's reforms can be judged inside the speech, and which need the later record?
      • What does he propose about civil-service reform and about the currency?
      • Which later events—Arthur's term, the Pendleton Act—belong beside this program, and which would overgrow it?

    Context

    The election of 1876 was disputed. Tilden led the popular vote; twenty electoral votes were contested; an Electoral Commission and the Compromise of 1877 placed Hayes in office. Remaining Reconstruction governments in the South lost federal support. Hayes was inaugurated on 5 March 1877, the 4th having fallen on a Sunday.

    Composition

    The hosted text is Richardson's compilation, Gutenberg #13021. It is a formal inaugural, delivered after the settlement, not a campaign speech about the count itself.

    Reception

    Admirers heard a program of reunion, hard money, and civil-service reform from an honest man who would not seek a second term. Critics then and later heard the end of Reconstruction protection for Black Southerners, covered by generous language. Both the language and the settlement belong in the lesson.

    Comparisons

    • Second Inaugural Address

      Lincoln in 1865 speaks of malice toward none at the end of a war; Hayes in 1877 speaks of a united country at the end of Reconstruction, after a disputed election.

    • First Inaugural Address

      Grant's 1869 inaugural still belongs to Reconstruction government; Hayes's 1877 address marks the political close of that period.

    • Address upon Assuming the Presidency

      Hayes calls for civil-service reform; Arthur, four years later, would sign the Pendleton Act after Garfield's death.

    Quotes

    “a civil policy which will forever wipe out in our political affairs the color line and the distinction between North and South, to the end that we may have not merely a united North or a united South, but a united country.”
    — Rutherford B. Hayes, Inaugural Address, On the South (Richardson / Gutenberg #13021).Quote card
    “in my judgment the feeling of uncertainty inseparable from an irredeemable paper currency, with its fluctuation of values, is one of the greatest obstacles to a return to prosperous times.”
    — Rutherford B. Hayes, Inaugural Address, On the currency (Richardson / Gutenberg #13021).Quote card
    “The only safe paper currency is one which rests upon a coin basis and is at all times and promptly convertible into coin.”
    — Rutherford B. Hayes, Inaugural Address, On the currency (Richardson / Gutenberg #13021).Quote card
    “he should strive to be always mindful of the fact that he serves his party best who serves the country best.”
    — Rutherford B. Hayes, Inaugural Address, On party (Richardson / Gutenberg #13021).Quote card
    “The President of the United States of necessity owes his election to office to the suffrage and zealous labors of a political party, the members of which cherish with ardor and regard as of essential importance the principles of their party organization;”
    — Rutherford B. Hayes, Inaugural Address, On party (Richardson / Gutenberg #13021).Quote card
    “we ought not to be, in a partisan sense, either Republicans or Democrats, but fellow-citizens and fellow-men, to whom the interests of a common country and a common humanity are dear.”
    — Rutherford B. Hayes, Inaugural Address, On public spirit (Richardson / Gutenberg #13021).Quote card
    “I ask the attention of the public to the paramount necessity of reform in our civil service--a reform not merely as to certain abuses and practices of so-called official patronage which have come to have the sanction of usage in the several Departments of our Government, but a change in the system of appointment itself; a reform that shall be thorough, radical, and complete;”
    — Rutherford B. Hayes, Inaugural Address, On the civil service (Richardson / Gutenberg #13021).Quote card
    “the question of government or no government; of social order and all the peaceful industries and the happiness that belong to it, or a return to barbarism.”
    — Rutherford B. Hayes, Inaugural Address, On the Southern question (Richardson / Gutenberg #13021).Quote card

    For Students

    A reading companion for classical Christian high school students. See the student guide.

    Reading Guide

    Watch for

    • The promise to the Southern States about white and Black citizens and the color line.
    • What the Compromise of 1877 actually did.
    • The civil-service and currency program.
    • The sentence about serving party by serving the country.

    Key terms and names

    Compromise of 1877
    The political settlement that resolved the disputed 1876 election in Hayes's favor and ended remaining federal support for Reconstruction governments in the South.
    Electoral Commission
    The body that awarded the contested electoral votes after the 1876 canvass.
    Civil-service reform
    The effort, urged here, to replace partisan patronage with a more professional and less partisan official service.
    Irredeemable paper
    Currency not convertible into coin; Hayes treats its fluctuating value as a barrier to prosperity.
    Color line
    Hayes's phrase for the racial distinction in political affairs that he says a civil policy should wipe out.

    Seminar Questions

    1. Comprehension What does Hayes say he wants for the white and colored people of the Southern States?
    2. Comprehension What is his program for the civil service and for the currency?
    3. Interpretation How does the disputed election of 1876 change the way this inaugural should be heard?
    4. Interpretation What does he mean by saying that a man serves his party best who serves the country best?
    5. Big Question Can reunion language be just if it accompanies the end of remaining federal protection for Black citizens?
    6. Big Question How should a class judge a promise by the words of the speech and by the bargain that made the speech possible?

    Faith Connections

    • Micah 6:8 (Scripture)

      To do justly, love mercy, and walk humbly is a standard for reunion talk after Reconstruction, especially when Black citizens were about to lose remaining federal protection.

    • Proverbs 14:34 (Scripture)

      Righteousness exalts a nation; sin is a reproach to any people: a check on treating sectional peace as the only measure of a just settlement.

    • Amos 5:21-24 (Scripture)

      The warning against feast days without justice is relevant when a ceremonial inaugural is set beside the cost of the bargain that produced it.

    Logic and Rhetoric

    Central argument: Having entered office after a disputed election, Hayes offers a program of a united country, equal regard for white and Black Southerners, civil-service reform, and a coin-based currency, and he asks to be judged as a servant of the country rather than of a party; the settlement of 1877 must be read with that offer.

    Rhetorical device: ethical appeal. He addresses 'my countrymen of the Southern States' and rests his claim on equal regard and on a united country, rather than on the legal mechanics of the Electoral Commission.

    Debate: Resolved: that Hayes's 1877 promises of equal regard and a united country cannot be judged apart from the Compromise of 1877 that ended remaining Reconstruction protection in the South.

    Memory Work

    he should strive to be always mindful of the fact that he serves his party best who serves the country best.

    On party. A short, often quoted rule about party and country, which this inaugural makes a test of the office itself.

    Writing Prompts

    Essay: Set Hayes's language about the color line beside the facts of the Compromise of 1877. What does the inaugural still teach, and what must be contradicted or completed from the record?

    Comparison with Second Inaugural Address: Compare Lincoln's 1865 and Hayes's 1877 inaugurals on reunion and on the place of Black Americans in the restored country: where does Hayes follow Lincoln's charity, and where has the political situation changed the meaning of similar words?

    Medical Lens

    This presidential text concerns constitutional politics and public office; it has no medical content for this library's lens.

      Creative Prompts

      • Classroom

        Print Hayes's sentences on the color line beside a short factual paragraph on the Compromise of 1877, and write a page on how a teacher should hold the two together.

      • Dialogue

        Write a conversation in March 1877 between a Black officeholder in South Carolina and a Northern supporter of Hayes, each reading the inaugural aloud.

      • Essay

        Hayes says he serves his party best who serves the country best. How does that claim sound after the disputed election that seated him?

      Further Reading

      • A Compilation of the Messages and Papers of the Presidents, James D. Richardson

        Official nineteenth-century compilation; the source of the hosted Gutenberg texts.

      • Inaugural Addresses of the Presidents of the United States, Avalon Project / GPO

        Parallel official texts for classroom comparison.

      • The Rhetorical Presidency, Jeffrey K. Tulis

        A study of how inaugural and other presidential speech reshaped the office.

      Verification notes

      Quotes were matched as substrings against the Richardson / Gutenberg #13021 text stored with this work. The account of the 1876 election and the Compromise of 1877 is standard reference history, taught beside Hayes's own words.

      No verification flags recorded.