Five-minute digest

In Defense of Marcus Caelius

Summary

In 56 BC the young Roman Marcus Caelius Rufus was brought to trial on a charge of public violence. Caelius had been a pupil of Cicero in his youth. The charge had several parts, among them that he had borrowed gold from a woman named Clodia and had then tried to poison her. Clodia was a widow from the great Claudian family and sister of Cicero's enemy Clodius. She had been Caelius's friend for a time, and the trial grew from a quarrel after that friendship ended. Cicero spoke last for the defense, after Caelius himself and another advocate had already addressed the court. His speech is among his most brilliant and playful. He opens by saying that a stranger ignorant of Roman customs might wonder what great crime was being tried on a festival day, in the middle of the public games, when all other business was suspended. He then deals with the charges against Caelius's character, saying that young men may be forgiven youthful pleasures and that Caelius had been sensible enough to turn from them to public service. The heart of the speech is the attack on Clodia. Cicero does not question her directly in the manner of a cross-examination, but he stages a scene in which her own famous ancestor, Appius Claudius the Blind, rises from the dead to scold her for her way of life. Cicero then turns to the charge of poison itself and shows how weak and contradictory the story of the gold and the plot is. He suggests that the charge arises from a woman's anger and not from any real crime. Caelius was acquitted. Cicero's speech was published soon afterward and has been read ever since for its wit, its sympathy for the young and its picture of Roman society. It is also a reminder that a defense can slander the accuser, which is a fair question for students of rhetoric. Teachers should read it first, as the tone of the attack on Clodia is rough and the case turns on matters of private scandal and a poison charge.

Top Lessons

  • A defense that attacks

    Cicero defends Caelius by discrediting the chief witness. Students can ask when attacking an accuser is fair, and when it is simply a way of avoiding the question.

  • Youth and forgiveness

    Cicero argues that a young man's follies should be forgiven. The speech asks how a city should treat the mistakes of the young.

  • Rhetoric and truth

    The speech is full of wit and imagination. It invites students to ask where a clever argument ends and the truth begins.

Verified Quotes