Work record

In Defense of Marcus Caelius

Also known as: Pro Caelio · Pro Marco Caelio · For Marcus Caelius

56 BC · Ancient · Oratory · Latin

Read this when you want Cicero defending a young man amid a society scandal.

Abstract

Written
56 BC
Setting
The Roman Republic in 56 BC; Rome, in a criminal court
Author
Cicero; trans. C. D. Yonge
Country
Roman Republic (Italy)
Language
Latin
Genre
Oratory
Form
Court speech for the defense
Recommended
Grades 11–12 (A society trial and a poisoning charge; read first. Grades 11-12.)

The case. Marcus Caelius Rufus, a young Roman and a former pupil of Cicero, stands trial on a charge of public violence. The accusations include borrowing gold from the widow Clodia and then trying to poison her.

The defense. Cicero speaks last. He treats the youthful pleasures of Caelius with humor and sympathy, saying that a young man may be forgiven his follies and that Caelius has turned to public service. He then turns to the charge of poison and shows that it is weak and contradictory.

The attack on Clodia. Cicero attacks the accuser's world, depicting Clodia's way of life and imagining her famous ancestor Appius Claudius the Blind coming back to scold her. He suggests that the charge arises from anger, not from fact.

Why it matters. Caelius was acquitted. The speech is prized for its wit, its portraits and its picture of Roman society. It also raises a question about whether a defense should discredit a witness. Teachers should read it first, as its attack on Clodia is hard and the case turns on a private scandal. Students should notice how far the speech is a piece of theater, with characters, voices and jokes, as well as an argument.

Key figures

  • Cicero: The advocate for the defense, speaking last.
  • Marcus Caelius Rufus: A young Roman accused of public violence and attempted poisoning.
  • Clodia: A widow of the Claudian family whose quarrel with Caelius lies behind the charges.
  • Appius Claudius the Blind: A famous ancestor whom Cicero calls up to scold Clodia.
  • The judges: The Roman jury who decide the case.

Summary

In 56 BC the young Roman Marcus Caelius Rufus was brought to trial on a charge of public violence. Caelius had been a pupil of Cicero in his youth. The charge had several parts, among them that he had borrowed gold from a woman named Clodia and had then tried to poison her. Clodia was a widow from the great Claudian family and sister of Cicero's enemy Clodius. She had been Caelius's friend for a time, and the trial grew from a quarrel after that friendship ended. Cicero spoke last for the defense, after Caelius himself and another advocate had already addressed the court. His speech is among his most brilliant and playful. He opens by saying that a stranger ignorant of Roman customs might wonder what great crime was being tried on a festival day, in the middle of the public games, when all other business was suspended. He then deals with the charges against Caelius's character, saying that young men may be forgiven youthful pleasures and that Caelius had been sensible enough to turn from them to public service. The heart of the speech is the attack on Clodia. Cicero does not question her directly in the manner of a cross-examination, but he stages a scene in which her own famous ancestor, Appius Claudius the Blind, rises from the dead to scold her for her way of life. Cicero then turns to the charge of poison itself and shows how weak and contradictory the story of the gold and the plot is. He suggests that the charge arises from a woman's anger and not from any real crime. Caelius was acquitted. Cicero's speech was published soon afterward and has been read ever since for its wit, its sympathy for the young and its picture of Roman society. It is also a reminder that a defense can slander the accuser, which is a fair question for students of rhetoric. Teachers should read it first, as the tone of the attack on Clodia is rough and the case turns on matters of private scandal and a poison charge.

Virtues in this work

  • Prudence: The opening asks the judges to keep proportion: not every charge deserves a great public terror.
  • Justice: A defense of a young man must still tell the truth; students should ask whether this one always does.

Plot or Argument

  • The charge

    Cicero opens playfully, answers the charges of ambition and violence, and argues that a young man's follies are not crimes.

  • The turn against Clodia

    He takes up the heart of the accusation, the story of the gold and the poison, and turns the attention to Clodia's character and motives.

  • The verdict

    He urges the judges to see in Caelius a young man who has turned from folly to public service, and the court acquits him.

Characters

  • Marcus Caelius Rufus, Defendant

    A gifted young advocate, once Cicero’s pupil.

  • Clodia, The woman behind the charge, in Cicero’s telling

    Sister of Clodius; the speech attacks her character at length.

  • Cicero, Advocate

    Defending a younger man by a dangerous kind of wit.

Lessons

  • A defense that attacks

    Cicero defends Caelius by discrediting the chief witness. Students can ask when attacking an accuser is fair, and when it is simply a way of avoiding the question.

    • How does Cicero use Clodia's reputation in the defense?
    • Does the attack on Clodia answer the charge of poison?
  • Youth and forgiveness

    Cicero argues that a young man's follies should be forgiven. The speech asks how a city should treat the mistakes of the young.

    • What does Cicero say about the pleasures of youth?
    • What would a wise judge do with that argument?
  • Rhetoric and truth

    The speech is full of wit and imagination. It invites students to ask where a clever argument ends and the truth begins.

    • Which parts of the speech are jokes and which are arguments?
    • How does Cicero keep the court's attention?

Context

The trial took place in April 56 BC, during a period of competing factions at Rome. It was held while public games were under way.

Composition

Caelius was prosecuted under a law on public violence. Cicero spoke last for the defense. The speech was published, as many of his were.

Reception

The speech has been read since antiquity as a model of wit and character drawing. Its picture of Clodia has been much debated, since it is the work of an advocate who was her enemy's friend.

Comparisons

Quotes

For Students

A reading companion for classical Christian high school students. See the student guide.

Reading Guide

Watch for

  • The playful opening, and how Cicero builds sympathy for a young defendant.
  • The way Cicero summons Clodia's ancestor to speak.
  • The treatment of the poison charge, and how weak Cicero shows it to be.

Key terms and names

vis
Violence, a crime tried under Roman law and the charge against Caelius.
prosopopoeia
A figure of speech in which a person, often dead, is made to speak; here Appius Claudius speaks.
invective
Sharp verbal attack on an opponent's character.
patronus
The advocate who defends a client at Rome; Cicero was Caelius's patron.

Seminar Questions

  1. Comprehension What is Caelius charged with, and what part does Clodia play?
  2. Comprehension Whom does Cicero call up to speak to Clodia, and why?
  3. Interpretation Why does Cicero spend so much of his speech on Clodia and not on the charges?
  4. Interpretation How does Cicero use humor to win the jury?
  5. Big Question Is it fair for a defense to attack the character of the accuser?
  6. Big Question How should a community treat the follies of the young?

Faith Connections

  • Matthew 5:22, 27–28 (Scripture)

    The speech is a reminder that words about a man or a woman in public can be a kind of assault; students should judge Cicero’s method, not only his success.

  • Proverbs 11:13 (Scripture)

    A talebearer revealeth secrets; the case is full of gossip used as a weapon.

Logic and Rhetoric

Central argument: Cicero argues that the charges against Caelius are weak, that the accuser's motive is private anger, and that a young man's follies deserve forgiveness.

Rhetorical device: Prosopopoeia. Cicero lets Clodia's dead ancestor speak, so that the criticism of her way of life comes from a voice the court respects.

Debate: Resolved: that an advocate may fairly weigh the character of the chief witness against the accused.

Memory Work

If any one, O judges, were now present by any chance, ignorant of our laws, and of our judicial proceedings, and of our customs, he would in truth wonder what great atrocity there is in this particular cause

Opening, trans. C. D. Yonge. The opening passage, which shows Cicero's play with the court's expectations.

Writing Prompts

Essay: Assess whether Cicero's speech for Caelius answers the charge or avoids it by attacking Clodia. Use examples from the text.

Comparison with The Mother-in-Law (Hecyra): Compare how Pro Caelio and The Mother-in-Law treat a young man's past and the reputation of a woman.

Creative Prompts

  • Essay

    Does Cicero's attack on Clodia answer the charge against Caelius? Argue from specific passages.

  • Dialogue

    Write a conversation between Cicero and Caelius the night before the verdict.

  • Classroom

    Have students list the charges against Caelius and Cicero's answer to each, then identify which are met with evidence and which with ridicule.

Further Reading

  • Cicero: Defence Speeches, Cicero, trans. D. H. Berry

    Oxford World's Classics; includes Pro Caelio.

  • Cicero: The Life and Times of Rome's Greatest Politician, Anthony Everitt

    A readable life, with the Caelius trial in place.

  • SPQR: A History of Ancient Rome, Mary Beard

    A general history of Rome with attention to its social world.

Verification notes

The translation is Yonge’s 1856 prose as given by Perseus. Section or chapter numbers follow that text.

  • Minor legal and chronological points in Yonge’s arguments should be checked against a modern commentary if used for examination work.