Five-minute digest
In Defense of Titus Annius Milo
Summary
In January 52 BC two armed bands met by chance on the Appian Way near Bovillae, outside Rome. One was led by Titus Annius Milo, a politician and candidate for the consulship, who was traveling with his wife and a large retinue of slaves and gladiators. The other was led by Publius Clodius Pulcher, a violent popular leader and an old enemy of both Milo and Cicero. A scuffle broke out, Clodius was wounded, and his men carried him to an inn. Milo's men then dragged him out and killed him. The death of Clodius was followed by riots in Rome. The mob carried the body into the Senate House and burned it, and the building itself caught fire. To restore order, the Senate appointed Pompey as sole consul and sent troops into the city. Milo was charged with the murder, and the trial was held under heavy guard. Cicero, who had once been driven out of Rome with Clodius's help, spoke for Milo. Cicero's speech is built on a clear line of argument. He begins by saying that the court is ringed with soldiers and he is nervous, then lays down a principle: self-defense is natural, and when armed men attack, laws are silent. He argues that it was Clodius who ambushed Milo and that Milo, a man traveling with his wife, had no reason to start a fight, while Clodius had every reason to wish him dead. He retells the story of the fight on the road, and he also argues that, even if Milo had killed Clodius on purpose, he would have been a benefactor of the state. He ends with a plea for mercy for Milo. According to ancient writers, Cicero was so shaken by the soldiers and the shouts of Clodius's supporters that he spoke poorly in court. The speech he later published is a polished and much admired version. Milo was convicted and went into exile at Massilia. The published speech survives as a model of rhetoric and as a source for the street politics of the late Republic.
Top Lessons
Laws and arms
The speech's famous principle is that laws are silent when arms are raised. Students can discuss whether it is a statement of natural right or an excuse for violence.
Rhetoric under pressure
Cicero speaks before soldiers in a hostile crowd. The speech shows how fear can shape an advocate's words.
Political violence
The death of Clodius was followed by riots and fire. The speech shows how street violence can threaten the life of a republic.
Verified Quotes
Frequently cited
“For laws are silent when arms are raised, and do not expect themselves to be waited for, when he who waits will have to suffer an undeserved penalty before he can exact a merited punishment.”