Work record
In Defense of Titus Annius Milo
Marcus Tullius CiceroPro Milone; For Milo; In Defense of MiloIn Defense of Titus Annius Milo by Marcus Tullius Cicero (52 BC)In January 52 BC two armed bands met by chance on the Appian Way near Bovillae, outside Rome.Also known as: Pro Milone · For Milo · In Defense of Milo
52 BC · Ancient · Oratory · Latin
Read this when you want Cicero's speech for a man who killed his rival.
Abstract
The case. In 52 BC Milo's armed party met that of Clodius on the Appian Way, and Clodius was killed. His followers burned the Senate House in grief and rage. Pompey was made sole consul, and Milo was tried for murder before a court ringed with soldiers.
The argument. Cicero speaks for Milo. He says that self-defense is natural and that laws fall silent when arms are raised, tells the story of the fight on the road, and argues that Clodius, not Milo, had the motive to lay an ambush.
The appeal. He ends by urging the judges to treat Milo as a benefactor, and he asks for mercy on Milo's behalf, saying that the republic would not be served by a verdict that disowned a defender.
Why it matters. Ancient writers say that Cicero spoke badly in court, frightened by the soldiers. The speech he published is a model of polished argument. The jury condemned Milo, who left for Massilia. The speech remains a source for the street politics that undermined the Republic. It rewards close reading for the way Cicero fits a law of nature, a story and an appeal to the judges' own safety into one speech.
Key figures
- Cicero: The advocate who speaks for Milo.
- Titus Annius Milo: A politician and candidate for consul, charged with killing Clodius.
- Publius Clodius Pulcher: A popular leader and old enemy of Milo and of Cicero, killed on the Appian Way.
- Pompey: The sole consul appointed to restore order.
- The judges: The Roman jury, who sit under armed guard.
Summary
In January 52 BC two armed bands met by chance on the Appian Way near Bovillae, outside Rome. One was led by Titus Annius Milo, a politician and candidate for the consulship, who was traveling with his wife and a large retinue of slaves and gladiators. The other was led by Publius Clodius Pulcher, a violent popular leader and an old enemy of both Milo and Cicero. A scuffle broke out, Clodius was wounded, and his men carried him to an inn. Milo's men then dragged him out and killed him. The death of Clodius was followed by riots in Rome. The mob carried the body into the Senate House and burned it, and the building itself caught fire. To restore order, the Senate appointed Pompey as sole consul and sent troops into the city. Milo was charged with the murder, and the trial was held under heavy guard. Cicero, who had once been driven out of Rome with Clodius's help, spoke for Milo. Cicero's speech is built on a clear line of argument. He begins by saying that the court is ringed with soldiers and he is nervous, then lays down a principle: self-defense is natural, and when armed men attack, laws are silent. He argues that it was Clodius who ambushed Milo and that Milo, a man traveling with his wife, had no reason to start a fight, while Clodius had every reason to wish him dead. He retells the story of the fight on the road, and he also argues that, even if Milo had killed Clodius on purpose, he would have been a benefactor of the state. He ends with a plea for mercy for Milo. According to ancient writers, Cicero was so shaken by the soldiers and the shouts of Clodius's supporters that he spoke poorly in court. The speech he later published is a polished and much admired version. Milo was convicted and went into exile at Massilia. The published speech survives as a model of rhetoric and as a source for the street politics of the late Republic.
Virtues in this work
Plot or Argument
- The scene
Cicero opens in a court surrounded by soldiers and explains why he is nervous, then sets the case in the political tension of the time.
- The principle
He argues that self-defense is natural and that laws are silent when arms are raised, so that killing an attacker may be lawful.
- The fight on the road
He tells the story of the encounter on the Appian Way, claims that Clodius laid the ambush, and argues that Milo had no motive to start a fight.
- The appeal
He urges the judges to see Milo as a friend of the state and asks for mercy.
Characters
- Titus Annius Milo, Defendant
A turbulent politician, charged with killing Clodius.
- Publius Clodius Pulcher, The dead man
Cicero’s old enemy, killed on the Appian Way.
- Cicero, Advocate
Defending a man in a city already used to street war.
Lessons
Laws and arms
The speech's famous principle is that laws are silent when arms are raised. Students can discuss whether it is a statement of natural right or an excuse for violence.
- What does Cicero mean by 'laws are silent when arms are raised'?
- When might this principle be true, and when false?
Rhetoric under pressure
Cicero speaks before soldiers in a hostile crowd. The speech shows how fear can shape an advocate's words.
- How does the setting affect Cicero's argument?
- What does the published speech gain by being revised?
Political violence
The death of Clodius was followed by riots and fire. The speech shows how street violence can threaten the life of a republic.
- Who benefits from such violence, and who suffers?
- How did Rome try to restore order?
Context
The killing took place on 18 January 52 BC. Rome was in turmoil, and the elections for the year had been delayed by gang violence. Pompey was made sole consul to restore order, and the trial was held under his guard.
Composition
The speech was delivered in April of 52 BC. Ancient commentators say that Cicero faltered in court. The version that survives was written afterward and is more polished than what he said.
Reception
Milo was condemned and went into exile. The speech was admired by later teachers of rhetoric, and the principle that laws are silent in the face of arms has been cited in debates on self-defense.
Comparisons
- The Fourteen Philippics
A later Cicero still arguing that the republic’s arms and laws can be made to serve justice, as the crisis deepens.
- First Oration Against Catiline
Another speech in which Cicero treats public violence as a test of the state’s nerve.
Quotes
Frequently cited
“For laws are silent when arms are raised, and do not expect themselves to be waited for, when he who waits will have to suffer an undeserved penalty before he can exact a merited punishment.”
For Students
A reading companion for classical Christian high school students. See the student guide.
Reading Guide
Watch for
- How Cicero speaks about the soldiers and the tension in the court.
- The statement that laws are silent when arms are raised.
- The account of the fight on the Appian Way and who is said to have laid the ambush.
Key terms and names
- silent leges
- The Latin tag 'silent enim leges inter arma', meaning that laws fall silent among arms.
- sole consul
- Pompey's office in 52 BC, an unusual power given to restore order.
- self-defense
- The right to resist an attack by force, which Cicero says is natural.
- exile
- A common penalty for a Roman citizen, which Milo accepted at Massilia.
Seminar Questions
- Comprehension What happened on the Appian Way, according to Cicero?
- Comprehension Why was the court ringed with soldiers?
- Interpretation What does Cicero mean by saying that laws are silent when arms are raised?
- Interpretation Why does Cicero argue that Clodius had more reason than Milo to start a fight?
- Big Question When, if ever, may a citizen use force in self-defense?
- Big Question How should a city treat the killing of a violent man?
Faith Connections
- Exodus 22:2–3 (Scripture)
The law of Moses itself distinguishes a killing in the night in defense of a house from other bloodshed. Cicero’s principle is not Christian, but it is a serious attempt to say when force may be used to save a life.
- Romans 13:3–4 (Scripture)
Paul treats the magistrate, not the private man, as the bearer of the sword; the speech is a good place to ask how far a private defense may go when the city itself is armed.
Logic and Rhetoric
Central argument: Cicero argues that Milo acted in lawful self-defense, that Clodius laid the ambush, and that the republic gained from Clodius's death.
Rhetorical device: Appeal to natural law. He says that it is a law of nature, not of paper, that a man may repel violence with violence.
Debate: Resolved: that a man who kills an attacker in the street acts lawfully.
Memory Work
For laws are silent when arms are raised, and do not expect themselves to be waited for, when he who waits will have to suffer an undeserved penalty before he can exact a merited punishment.
Writing Prompts
Essay: Assess Cicero's principle that laws are silent when arms are raised and say whether the speech proves Milo acted in self-defense.
Comparison with The Fourteen Philippics: Compare how the Pro Milone and the Philippics treat the use of armed force in the life of the Republic.
Creative Prompts
- Essay
Evaluate Cicero's argument that laws are silent when arms are raised. Does it justify Milo's action?
- Dialogue
Write a conversation between Cicero and a friend the night after the trial, in which they discuss what went wrong.
- Classroom
Divide the class into prosecution and defense, giving each the facts of the encounter on the Appian Way, and have each side argue before a student jury.
Further Reading
- Cicero: Defence Speeches, Cicero, trans. D. H. Berry
Oxford World's Classics; includes Pro Milone.
- Rubicon: The Last Years of the Roman Republic, Tom Holland
A popular account of the violent years of the late Republic.
- The Roman Revolution, Ronald Syme
A classic study of Roman politics after the fall of the Republic.
Verification notes
The translation is Yonge’s 1856 prose as given by Perseus. Section or chapter numbers follow that text.
- Minor legal and chronological points in Yonge’s arguments should be checked against a modern commentary if used for examination work.