Five-minute digest

In Defense of Sextus Roscius of Ameria

Summary

In 80 BC, in the aftermath of Sulla's civil war, a farmer of Ameria named Sextus Roscius was put on trial in Rome for murdering his own father. The father, also named Sextus Roscius, had been a wealthy landowner who was killed one night as he returned from dinner in the city. Almost at once, two relatives and a powerful man at Sulla's court began taking over his estate. They had the dead man's name added to the proscription lists, which let them buy his property for a tiny sum, and they drove his son away from the farm. To keep the son from complaining, they then accused him of the murder. The accuser was a young man named Erucius, and behind him stood Chrysogonus, a freedman of Sulla who had grown rich on confiscated land. No established advocate would take the case, because opposing Chrysogonus meant opposing Sulla. Cicero, then twenty-six, spoke for the defense. It was his first major criminal case, and he took it at some personal risk. He begins by explaining why he speaks, since older advocates had stayed silent. He then argues that the charge makes no sense. Roscius had always lived quietly in the country, with no motive to kill a father who had loved him, and he had no cruel nature. Cicero turns the question around and asks who gained from the father's death. The answer is the men who seized the property, and he names them. He describes how Chrysogonus bought a great estate for a few thousand sesterces and he points to Roscius's own relatives as the likely killers, who now seek to blame the son. Cicero is careful not to attack Sulla himself, treating the dictator as ignorant of the abuse and the freedman as the true source of corruption. He ends by calling the judges to defend the innocent and to resist the audacity of men who think their friends in power make them safe. The jury acquitted Roscius. The speech is the earliest of Cicero's surviving court orations. It shows his skill at telling a story and at asking the question of motive, and it is a standard text for study of Roman oratory and of how the law can be turned to private gain.

Top Lessons

  • Who gains?

    Cicero's central move is to ask who profited from the crime. The speech teaches students to test a charge by motive and by what the accusers stand to gain.

  • Courage in the courts

    A young advocate takes a case that older men refused. The speech shows what courage looks like in public speech, and what it costs.

  • Law turned to private gain

    The proscription lists were meant for the state's enemies but were used for plunder. The speech shows how a lawful form can serve a private greed.

Verified Quotes

“He is the defendant, to whom the death of his father has brought not only grief, but also poverty.”
— Marcus Tullius Cicero, In Defense of Sextus Roscius of Ameria, The speech, trans. C. D. Yonge.Quote card
“In the second place, I beg you, O judges, to resist the wickedness of audacious men; to relieve the calamities of the innocent, and in the cause of Sextus Roscius to repel the danger which is being aimed at every one.”
— Marcus Tullius Cicero, In Defense of Sextus Roscius of Ameria, The speech, trans. C. D. Yonge.Quote card