Work record

In Defense of Sextus Roscius of Ameria

Also known as: Pro Roscio Amerino · Pro Sexto Roscio · For Sextus Roscius of Ameria

80 BC · Ancient · Oratory · Latin

Read this when you want Cicero's first great speech against a powerful favorite.

Abstract

Written
80 BC
Setting
The Roman Republic under Sulla's dictatorship, 80 BC; Rome, in a criminal court
Author
Cicero; trans. C. D. Yonge
Country
Roman Republic (Italy)
Language
Latin
Genre
Oratory
Form
Court speech for the defense
Recommended
Grades 10–12 (Early Cicero: a young lawyer defends a man falsely accused of killing his father.)

The case. Sextus Roscius of Ameria is accused of killing his father. After the murder, relatives and a freedman of Sulla seized the dead man's estate through the proscription lists. The accusation is meant to keep the son quiet.

The argument. Cicero, aged twenty-six, takes a case that others avoided. He argues that the charge has no motive on the son's side, and he asks who gained from the death. The answer lies with those who bought the property for a tiny sum and who now stand as accusers.

Careful courage. He does not attack Sulla, whom he treats as unaware, but he speaks plainly of Chrysogonus and his helpers. He urges the judges to resist audacity and to defend an innocent man against men who rely on powerful friends.

Why it matters. This is the oldest of the court orations of Cicero that we still possess, and a standard model of the form: a story, a test of motive, a bold appeal. It shows how law can be bent to greed, and how one advocate can still answer it in public. Students can use it to practice the oldest test of any accusation: ask who gains, then ask who is speaking.

Key figures

  • Cicero: A young advocate, then about twenty-six, who defends Roscius.
  • Sextus Roscius: A farmer of Ameria accused of killing his father.
  • Chrysogonus: Sulla's freedman who profited from the seizure of the estate.
  • Erucius: The young accuser who speaks for the prosecution.
  • Sulla: The dictator of Rome, whom Cicero treats carefully.

Summary

In 80 BC, in the aftermath of Sulla's civil war, a farmer of Ameria named Sextus Roscius was put on trial in Rome for murdering his own father. The father, also named Sextus Roscius, had been a wealthy landowner who was killed one night as he returned from dinner in the city. Almost at once, two relatives and a powerful man at Sulla's court began taking over his estate. They had the dead man's name added to the proscription lists, which let them buy his property for a tiny sum, and they drove his son away from the farm. To keep the son from complaining, they then accused him of the murder. The accuser was a young man named Erucius, and behind him stood Chrysogonus, a freedman of Sulla who had grown rich on confiscated land. No established advocate would take the case, because opposing Chrysogonus meant opposing Sulla. Cicero, then twenty-six, spoke for the defense. It was his first major criminal case, and he took it at some personal risk. He begins by explaining why he speaks, since older advocates had stayed silent. He then argues that the charge makes no sense. Roscius had always lived quietly in the country, with no motive to kill a father who had loved him, and he had no cruel nature. Cicero turns the question around and asks who gained from the father's death. The answer is the men who seized the property, and he names them. He describes how Chrysogonus bought a great estate for a few thousand sesterces and he points to Roscius's own relatives as the likely killers, who now seek to blame the son. Cicero is careful not to attack Sulla himself, treating the dictator as ignorant of the abuse and the freedman as the true source of corruption. He ends by calling the judges to defend the innocent and to resist the audacity of men who think their friends in power make them safe. The jury acquitted Roscius. The speech is the earliest of Cicero's surviving court orations. It shows his skill at telling a story and at asking the question of motive, and it is a standard text for study of Roman oratory and of how the law can be turned to private gain.

Virtues in this work

  • Justice: The speech asks the judges to relieve the innocent and to resist men who have used a public terror for private gain.
  • Fortitude: A young advocate speaks when older men stay seated, against a favorite of Sulla.

Plot or Argument

  • The charge and the profit

    Cicero explains why he speaks, describes the murder and the seizure of the estate, and shows that the accusers, not the accused, gained from the father's death.

  • The turn

    He turns on Chrysogonus and the men who used the proscription lists for private gain, while carefully sparing Sulla himself.

  • The appeal

    He calls on the judges to resist audacity and relieve an innocent man, and the jury acquits Roscius.

Characters

  • Sextus Roscius, Defendant

    A country son, left poor and accused of parricide.

  • Cicero, Advocate

    A young man speaking when older orators sit silent.

  • Chrysogonus, Sulla’s freedman, purchaser of the estate

    The powerful figure behind the accusation.

Lessons

  • Who gains?

    Cicero's central move is to ask who profited from the crime. The speech teaches students to test a charge by motive and by what the accusers stand to gain.

    • Why is the question of motive so powerful in this speech?
    • What would the accusers have lost if Roscius had been acquitted?
  • Courage in the courts

    A young advocate takes a case that older men refused. The speech shows what courage looks like in public speech, and what it costs.

    • Why were older advocates unwilling to take the case?
    • How does Cicero speak boldly while staying careful about Sulla?
  • Law turned to private gain

    The proscription lists were meant for the state's enemies but were used for plunder. The speech shows how a lawful form can serve a private greed.

    • How did Chrysogonus use the lists?
    • What safeguards would stop such abuse in a just city?

Context

The speech was delivered in 80 BC, shortly after Sulla's victory in the civil war and during his dictatorship. Rome was still living with the proscriptions, lists of men outlawed whose property could be seized and sold.

Composition

Cicero, born in 106 BC, was about twenty-six. The speech was published later and is the oldest of his surviving court speeches. It was his first major criminal case.

Reception

Ancient writers treated the speech as the beginning of Cicero's public fame. Later teachers have used it as a model for the structure of a Roman court speech, from the statement of facts to the appeal.

Comparisons

Quotes

“He is the defendant, to whom the death of his father has brought not only grief, but also poverty.”
— Marcus Tullius Cicero, In Defense of Sextus Roscius of Ameria, The speech, trans. C. D. Yonge.Quote card
“In the second place, I beg you, O judges, to resist the wickedness of audacious men; to relieve the calamities of the innocent, and in the cause of Sextus Roscius to repel the danger which is being aimed at every one.”
— Marcus Tullius Cicero, In Defense of Sextus Roscius of Ameria, The speech, trans. C. D. Yonge.Quote card

For Students

A reading companion for classical Christian high school students. See the student guide.

Reading Guide

Watch for

  • How Cicero explains why he speaks when older advocates stayed silent.
  • The question of motive, and how it points away from the accused.
  • The way Cicero attacks Chrysogonus while sparing Sulla.

Key terms and names

proscription
A list of men declared outlaws, whose property could be seized and sold; Sulla used it in 82 and 81 BC.
freedman
A former slave who had been set free; Chrysogonus was a freedman of Sulla.
parricide
The crime of killing one's father, regarded at Rome as the worst of crimes.
exordium
The opening of a Roman speech, which seeks the hearers' goodwill.

Seminar Questions

  1. Comprehension What is Sextus Roscius accused of, and who accuses him?
  2. Comprehension How did Chrysogonus profit from the death of the elder Roscius?
  3. Interpretation Why does Cicero ask who gained, and not only who could have done the deed?
  4. Interpretation Why does Cicero speak carefully about Sulla?
  5. Big Question What does it cost an advocate to defend an unpopular client?
  6. Big Question How can a city protect itself from powerful men who use the law for private gain?

Faith Connections

  • Isaiah 1:17; Proverbs 31:8-9 (Scripture)

    Learn to do good, seek justice, defend the fatherless and plead for the widow: the Scriptures give the same charge that Cicero takes up when he defends a man whom the powerful have wronged.

  • Augustine, City of God IV and XIX (Great Conversation)

    Augustine asks what a commonwealth is without justice, a question that Cicero's courtroom answers by showing what happens when law is bent to greed.

Logic and Rhetoric

Central argument: Cicero argues that the accused had no motive and that the true profit lay with the accusers, so the charge is both unlikely and suspect.

Rhetorical device: Cui bono (who profits?). He asks who gained from the father's death and answers by naming the men who took the estate.

Debate: Resolved: that a charge should be judged first by who profits from it.

Memory Work

They are the accusers, to whom it was an advantage that the father of Sextus Roscius should be put to death.

The speech, trans. C. D. Yonge. A line that states the question of who gained, central to the speech.

In the second place, I beg you, O judges, to resist the wickedness of audacious men; to relieve the calamities of the innocent, and in the cause of Sextus Roscius to repel the danger which is being aimed at every one.

The speech, trans. C. D. Yonge. A call to the judges to resist audacity, short enough to learn by heart.

Writing Prompts

Essay: Explain how Cicero uses the question of motive to defend Roscius. Include a discussion of how he handles Sulla.

Comparison with In Defense of Titus Annius Milo: Compare how the Pro Roscio and the Pro Milone use the courtroom to speak about the power of an armed faction.

Creative Prompts

  • Essay

    How does Cicero turn the question of motive against the accusers? Use at least two passages.

  • Dialogue

    Write a conversation between Sextus Roscius and Cicero on the night before the trial.

  • Classroom

    Have students sort the facts of the case into those that favor the accused and those that favor the accusers, then discuss what remains uncertain.

Further Reading

  • Cicero: Defence Speeches, Cicero, trans. D. H. Berry

    Oxford World's Classics; includes the speech for Roscius.

  • Cicero: The Life and Times of Rome's Greatest Politician, Anthony Everitt

    A readable life, with the trial in its place.

  • The Roman Revolution, Ronald Syme

    On Roman politics in the late Republic and after.

Verification notes

The translation is Yonge’s 1856 prose as given by Perseus. Section or chapter numbers follow that text.

  • Minor legal and chronological points in Yonge’s arguments should be checked against a modern commentary if used for examination work.