Work record

Veto of the Texas Seed Bill

Also known as: Texas Seed Bill veto · Cleveland seed bill veto

1887 · 19th Century · Oratory · English

Read this when a drought bill is vetoed on principle, and public charity is distinguished from public duty.

Abstract

Written
Dated 16 February 1887
Setting
A drought in parts of Texas, during Cleveland's first term; Executive Mansion, Washington, D.C.
Country
United States
Language
English
Genre
Presidential veto message
Form
Short official written veto of a special appropriation
Recommended
Grades 9–12 (A short veto; the famous sentence needs the constitutional argument around it.)

Occasion. In February 1887 Congress sent Cleveland a modest bill to distribute seeds in Texas counties stricken by drought. He returned it unsigned on the 16th. The message does not mock the sufferers; it denies that this kind of relief is a constitutional duty of the General Government.

The constitutional line. He finds no warrant for using public money to indulge a charitable sentiment, and he refuses to extend federal power to individual suffering unrelated to the public service. The appropriation is small; the principle, in his view, is not. A class can honor the scruple and still ask what a republic owes neighbors in a genuine emergency.

Charity and character. Federal aid, he warns, breeds an expectation of paternal care and weakens national sturdiness, while it crowds out the private kindness that binds a people together. Countrymen, he says, can be relied on to relieve one another in misfortune.

The famous sentence. The lesson he wants kept in view is a sharp one: citizens fund the Treasury; the Treasury is not there to fund the citizens. The line has had a long life in later argument about federal relief. A class should read it in its 1887 setting, beside the drought and beside the first inaugural's economy, without pretending that later welfare states were already in view.

Key figures

  • Grover Cleveland: Twenty-second President, who returned the bill unsigned

Summary

On 16 February 1887 Grover Cleveland vetoed a House bill that would have allowed a special distribution of seeds in drought-stricken counties of Texas and made a small appropriation for that purpose. The bill, numbered 10203, came to him at the Executive Mansion as a charitable measure for farmers who had lost their crops after a long drought. Cleveland does not deny the distress. He says it is represented that the drought has caused failure of crops and consequent destitution, and he notes that individual aid has already been extended to some of the sufferers, and that the failure of an extra ten thousand dollars need not mean continued distress if the emergency is fully made known to the people of the country. He withholds his approval nonetheless. He can find no warrant in the Constitution, he writes, for an appropriation of public funds to indulge a benevolent and charitable sentiment, and he does not believe that the power and duty of the General Government ought to be extended to the relief of individual suffering which is in no manner properly related to the public service or benefit. Federal aid in such cases, he argues, encourages the expectation of paternal care and weakens the sturdiness of the national character, while it prevents the private charity that would otherwise strengthen the bonds of a common brotherhood. The friendliness and charity of our countrymen, he says, can always be relied upon to relieve fellow-citizens in misfortune. The lesson that should be constantly enforced is that though the people support the Government, the Government should not support the people. The hosted text follows Richardson, Project Gutenberg #15863, and is cut at the signature before the next message in the volume. The veto is short, only a few hundred words, and it became one of the most quoted statements of limited federal government in American political debate. It should be taught with the first inaugural's praise of republican economy, and with a clear account of the drought it refused to relieve from the Treasury. Students may honor the constitutional scruple and still ask what a republic owes to neighbors in a genuine emergency, and whether private charity is always as ready as Cleveland claims.

Virtues in this work

  • Prudence: He refuses to move a constitutional line for a small and sympathetic bill.
  • Temperance: He will not use the Treasury to indulge even a benevolent sentiment if the power has not been granted.
  • Justice: He treats public money as held under a limited grant, not as a fund for every good cause.

Plot or Argument

  • A drought and a small bill

    Cleveland states the facts as they have been represented: a long drought, failed crops, and a request for a special distribution of seeds.

  • No constitutional warrant

    He withholds approval because he finds no authority to spend public money for this kind of private relief.

  • Paternal care

    Federal aid, he argues, teaches the people to expect a parent's care from the government and weakens their sturdiness.

  • Private charity

    He trusts the friendliness of countrymen, and he notes that some aid has already been given.

  • The lesson

    The people support the Government; the Government should not support the people.

    Lessons

    • A small sum and a large principle

      The appropriation is minor. Cleveland treats the principle as major: once the Treasury relieves private distress, the constitutional line has moved.

      • Why does he think a small seed bill is worth a veto?
      • Does he deny the drought, or only the federal duty to relieve it?
      • What would change in his argument if the appropriation were much larger?
    • Charity and the state

      He prefers private charity to public relief and claims that federal aid weakens both character and kindness. Students should test that claim, not only applaud or dismiss it.

      • What evidence does he offer that countrymen will in fact relieve this drought?
      • What role does private charity play in the moral case for the veto?
      • Is his trust in countrymen a reasoned hope, or an untested assurance?
    • The sentence after 1887

      The line about the people supporting the government has been quoted far beyond Texas seeds. A class should first hear it in 1887, then ask how later uses honor or distort it.

      • When is a later quotation of this veto fair, and when is it an anachronism?
      • What is 'the people support the Government' meant to teach in 1887, before later welfare debates?
      • How can a later speaker quote this veto without turning Texas seeds into a verdict on every later relief program?

    Context

    In the mid-1880s parts of Texas suffered a severe drought. Congress passed a special bill, House bill 10203, for a distribution of seeds and a small appropriation. Cleveland, already known for a hard use of the veto and for a limited view of federal power, returned the bill on 16 February 1887.

    Composition

    The hosted text is Richardson's compilation, Gutenberg #15863, beginning at the Executive Mansion heading of February 16, 1887, and ending at the signature before the next message in the volume.

    Reception

    Admirers took the veto as a model of constitutional scruple and republican character. Critics then and later called it a hard heart toward a real emergency and a cramped reading of the General Government's duty. The sentence about the people and the government has had a long life in American debate about relief.

    Comparisons

    • First Inaugural Address

      The 1885 inaugural praised republican economy and a government of all the people; this veto applies those claims to a concrete, sympathetic appropriation.

    • Second Inaugural Address

      In 1893 Cleveland returns to the lesson that the people should support the government and that the government's functions do not include the support of the people.

    • Veto Message on the Bank of the United States

      Jackson's 1832 veto attacks exclusive privilege for the rich; Cleveland's 1887 veto refuses a charitable grant to the distressed. The two limited-government documents are not the same case.

    Quotes

    “though the people support the Government the Government should not support the people.”
    — Grover Cleveland, Veto of the Texas Seed Bill, The central lesson (Richardson / Gutenberg #15863).Quote card
    “The friendliness and charity of our countrymen can always be relied upon to relieve their fellow-citizens in misfortune.”
    — Grover Cleveland, Veto of the Texas Seed Bill, On private charity (Richardson / Gutenberg #15863).Quote card
    “Federal aid in such cases encourages the expectation of paternal care on the part of the Government and weakens the sturdiness of our national character, while it prevents the indulgence among our people of that kindly sentiment and conduct which strengthens the bonds of a common brotherhood.”
    — Grover Cleveland, Veto of the Texas Seed Bill, On paternal care (Richardson / Gutenberg #15863).Quote card
    “I can find no warrant for such an appropriation in the Constitution, and I do not believe that the power and duty of the General Government ought to be extended to the relief of individual suffering which is in no manner properly related to the public service or benefit.”
    — Grover Cleveland, Veto of the Texas Seed Bill, On the Constitution (Richardson / Gutenberg #15863).Quote card
    “It is represented that a long-continued and extensive drought has existed in certain portions of the State of Texas, resulting in a failure of crops and consequent distress and destitution.”
    — Grover Cleveland, Veto of the Texas Seed Bill, On the drought (Richardson / Gutenberg #15863).Quote card
    “And yet I feel obliged to withhold my approval of the plan, as proposed by this bill, to indulge a benevolent and charitable sentiment through the appropriation of public funds for that purpose.”
    — Grover Cleveland, Veto of the Texas Seed Bill, On withholding approval (Richardson / Gutenberg #15863).Quote card
    “It is within my personal knowledge that individual aid has to some extent already been extended to the sufferers mentioned in this bill.”
    — Grover Cleveland, Veto of the Texas Seed Bill, On aid already given (Richardson / Gutenberg #15863).Quote card
    “The failure of the proposed appropriation of $10,000 additional to meet their remaining wants will not necessarily result in continued distress if the emergency is fully made known to the people of the country.”
    — Grover Cleveland, Veto of the Texas Seed Bill, On making the need known (Richardson / Gutenberg #15863).Quote card

    For Students

    A reading companion for classical Christian high school students. See the student guide.

    Reading Guide

    Watch for

    • Whether Cleveland denies the drought or only the federal duty.
    • The constitutional 'no warrant' claim.
    • The argument about paternal care and private charity.
    • The famous sentence about the people and the government.

    Key terms and names

    Texas Seed Bill
    House bill 10203, a special 1887 appropriation to distribute seeds in drought-stricken Texas counties, which Cleveland vetoed.
    Paternal care
    Cleveland's name for the expectation that the General Government will relieve private distress as a parent would.
    Warrant
    His word for constitutional authority; he says he can find none for this appropriation.
    Private charity
    Voluntary relief by countrymen, which he says can be relied on and which federal aid may weaken or crowd out.
    General Government
    The federal government, as distinct from the states and from private associations.

    Seminar Questions

    1. Comprehension What facts about the Texas drought does Cleveland accept, and what does he refuse to do?
    2. Comprehension What constitutional reason does he give for the veto?
    3. Interpretation How, in his argument, would federal aid change the character of the people and of private charity?
    4. Interpretation What is the lesson of the sentence about the people supporting the government?
    5. Big Question May a republic ever use the Treasury to relieve a genuine local emergency, or is Cleveland's line the only just one?
    6. Big Question How should later speakers quote this veto without turning 1887 Texas seeds into a verdict on every later relief program?

    Faith Connections

    • James 2:15-16 (Scripture)

      The warning against telling the naked and hungry to depart in peace, without giving what they need, is the hardest scriptural test of this veto, and should be heard beside it, not used to erase Cleveland's constitutional claim.

    • 2 Thessalonians 3:10 (Scripture)

      The rule that if any will not work, neither should he eat, is sometimes quoted in this debate; it does not, by itself, settle the case of a drought that has destroyed a harvest.

    • Proverbs 22:9 (Scripture)

      A blessing on those who give of their bread to the poor sits close to Cleveland's trust in private charity, and raises the question whether that charity was in fact enough.

    Logic and Rhetoric

    Central argument: Because the Constitution does not grant the General Government the power to relieve this private distress, and because federal charity would weaken character and crowd out private kindness, the President must veto even a small and sympathetic seed bill.

    Rhetorical device: principle over sympathy. He grants the drought and the good intention, then refuses the bill on a constitutional and moral line rather than on the size of the sum.

    Debate: Resolved: that Cleveland's veto of the Texas seed bill was a just defense of constitutional limits and of private charity, rather than a failure of mercy toward a real emergency.

    Memory Work

    though the people support the Government the Government should not support the people.

    The central lesson. The most famous sentence in the veto, short enough to memorize and grave enough to debate.

    Writing Prompts

    Essay: Explain Cleveland's constitutional and moral arguments in the seed-bill veto, then judge them against the facts of the drought and against the first inaugural's praise of republican economy.

    Comparison with First Inaugural Address: How does the 1887 veto apply, or harden, the economy and limited-government language of the 1885 inaugural? Where, if at all, does the later paper go beyond the earlier one?

    Medical Lens

    This presidential text concerns constitutional politics and public office; it has no medical content for this library's lens.

      Creative Prompts

      • Classroom

        Write a one-page brief for a member of Congress who favored the seed bill, answering Cleveland's constitutional and moral points one by one.

      • Dialogue

        Write a conversation in a drought county of Texas in March 1887, after the veto has been read aloud from a newspaper.

      • Essay

        Cleveland says the government should not support the people. Using this veto and the first inaugural, explain what he means, then judge the claim.

      Further Reading

      • A Compilation of the Messages and Papers of the Presidents, James D. Richardson

        Official nineteenth-century compilation; the source of the hosted Gutenberg texts.

      • Inaugural Addresses of the Presidents of the United States, Avalon Project / GPO

        Parallel official texts for classroom comparison.

      • The Rhetorical Presidency, Jeffrey K. Tulis

        A study of how inaugural and other presidential speech reshaped the office.

      Verification notes

      Quotes were matched as substrings against the Richardson / Gutenberg #15863 text stored with this work. The cut ends at Cleveland's signature, before the next message in the volume.

      No verification flags recorded.