Five-minute digest
Michael Kohlhaas
Summary
Michael Kohlhaas is Kleist's masterpiece, a novella about a good man who is driven by a wrong to become a robber and a murderer. Its first sentence describes Kohlhaas as 'one of the most upright and, at the same time, one of the most terrible men of his day'. He is a horse-dealer in sixteenth-century Brandenburg, a model citizen until the age of thirty, with a farm, a wife, Lisbeth, and children. On a trip to Saxony, he is stopped at the castle of the Junker Wenzel von Tronka and told that he needs a pass, which does not exist. To be allowed to go on, he leaves two fine black horses as security. On his return he finds them starved, overworked at harvest, and his groom beaten and driven off. Kohlhaas takes his case to the Saxon courts, but the Junker's powerful relatives block every step. His wife tries to petition the Elector of Brandenburg on his behalf and is struck by a guard so brutally that she dies. After her funeral Kohlhaas takes up arms. With a few servants he storms Tronka Castle, kills those he finds and burns it, but the Junker escapes. He gathers a growing band of outlaws and pursues his enemy from town to town, burning Wittenberg and threatening Leipzig, until Martin Luther posts a placard rebuking him and then meets him in person. Luther, who has an eye for the good in Kohlhaas, tells him that he is no champion of justice but a rebel who has broken the order that protects the weak. Kohlhaas accepts the rebuke on every point but one: he cannot forgive the Junker. Luther refuses him the sacrament at first. In the end Kohlhaas accepts an amnesty, but the courts, while restoring his horses, sentence him to death for breaking the peace. A mysterious paper that a gypsy woman gave him decides his last satisfaction, and he is beheaded at Berlin, convinced that his claim has been met. Kleist's story asks what happens when a passion for justice becomes a passion for revenge. Kohlhaas is right in his first demand and wrong in his methods, and Kleist keeps both facts in view. The novella is an extraordinary study of how a righteous cause can destroy the person who holds it, and of the need for forgiveness. Teachers should note scenes of arson, killing, and public execution.
Top Lessons
A just cause does not justify any means
Kohlhaas's first demand is just, but he pursues it by arson and murder. Kleist makes him sympathetic and terrible together, and Luther's rebuke states the lesson.
Forgiveness is hard and necessary
Lisbeth's verse and Luther's refusal of the sacrament make forgiveness the test of Kohlhaas's faith. The story shows what it costs to refuse it.
Corrupt justice breeds disorder
The Saxon courts fail Kohlhaas because of favour and connection. Kleist suggests that a state which denies justice to a citizen invites his rebellion.
Verified Quotes
Frequently cited
“one of the most upright and, at the same time, one of the most terrible men of his day.”
“Forgive your enemies; do good to them that hate you.”
Frequently cited
“But the Lord, whose body you desire, forgave his enemy.”
Frequently cited
“Even the Lord did not forgive all his enemies.”
Medical Lens
Kohlhaas's pursuit of vengeance after his wife's death is a study of obsession and unresolved grief.
- The death of Lisbeth and the revenge
After his wife dies, Kohlhaas gives himself wholly to vengeance.