Work record

Murder on the Orient Express

Name: Murder on the Orient Express
Author: Agatha Christie

Agatha Christie

Also known as: Murder in the Calais Coach

1934 · Early 20th Century · Novel · English

CopyrightedFive-minute digest

Abstract

Written: Written 1933; published 1934
Setting: Winter, early 1930s; The Simplon-Orient Express, halted in snow in Yugoslavia
Author: Agatha Christie
Country: United Kingdom
Language: English
Genre: Detective novel
Form: Three parts: the facts, the evidence and the solution
Recommended: Grades 8–12 (Murder mystery; a child's kidnapping and death in the backstory.)

Background. Christie set this case aboard the luxury train she rode on her journeys to the Middle East, and borrowed its back-story from the notorious Lindbergh kidnapping. Serialized first in an American magazine, it reached British readers as a book on New Year's Day.

Plot. Snowbound in the Balkans, a crowded sleeping car becomes a crime scene when a sinister American is discovered dead from a dozen knife wounds. The little Belgian sleuth aboard learns that the victim had escaped punishment for the abduction and killing of a child in the United States. Questioning a mixed company of travelers, he untangles a web of planted clues and false alibis and finally proposes two very different explanations.

Ideas. The tale sets the rule of law against a private reckoning for an unpunished wrong, and leaves readers to judge the detective's final choice. The investigation relies on interviews, timetables and small physical traces, and the answer depends on noticing how neatly the testimony fits together. Readers are asked whether mercy or strict legality better serves justice in such a case.

Reception. Admired for its daring solution and attacked by some critics as improbable, it is among the most famous whodunits and has been filmed repeatedly. Sidney Lumet's 1974 film and Kenneth Branagh's 2017 version brought it to new audiences.

Main characters

Hercule Poirot: Belgian detective
M. Bouc: Railway director
Ratchett: Murdered American passenger
Mrs. Hubbard: American passenger

Portrait of Agatha Christie. Source · CC0

Summary

Murder on the Orient Express is a detective novel by Agatha Christie, published in Britain by Collins Crime Club on 1 January 1934 and in the United States the same year as Murder in the Calais Coach. It is one of the best-known cases of her Belgian detective, Hercule Poirot. Poirot, returning from a case in Syria, secures a berth on the Simplon-Orient Express from Istanbul thanks to his friend M. Bouc, a director of the railway company. The winter coach is unusually full. An American passenger, Ratchett, asks Poirot to protect him from threats, and Poirot refuses because he dislikes the man. That night, after leaving Belgrade, the train is stopped by a snowdrift in Yugoslavia, and in the morning Ratchett is found dead in his locked compartment, stabbed twelve times. With Bouc and a Greek doctor, Constantine, Poirot investigates while the train waits for rescue. A scrap of burned paper reveals that Ratchett was really Cassetti, the kidnapper who had murdered the small daughter of the wealthy Armstrong family in America and escaped conviction; the crime had led to the deaths of Daisy Armstrong's mother, her father and a nursemaid wrongly suspected. Poirot interviews the passengers, a varied group including an English governess, a colonel from India, a Russian princess, a Hungarian count and countess, an American widow, a valet and a secretary. The clues contradict one another: a conductor's uniform, a scarlet kimono, a pipe cleaner and a handkerchief marked with an initial. In the final chapter Poirot assembles the passengers and offers two explanations. In the first, an unknown intruder boarded at the last station, killed Ratchett and escaped. In the second, the passengers, each connected to the Armstrong household, acted together, each striking a blow. When Poirot's reasoning is confirmed, he leaves the choice to Bouc, who prefers the first solution for the Yugoslav police, and Poirot withdraws from the case. The novel drew on the 1932 kidnapping of Charles Lindbergh's son and on Christie's own journeys on the Orient Express, including a delay caused by floods. Its ending raises questions about justice outside the law that readers continue to debate, and it has been adapted for film, television, radio and the stage.

Plot or Argument

Part One: The facts
Poirot boards the Orient Express, refuses Ratchett's request for help, and the train is halted by snow; Ratchett is found stabbed.
Part Two: The evidence
Poirot interviews the conductor and each passenger and examines the luggage and the physical clues.
Part Three: Poirot sits back and thinks
Poirot reconsiders the evidence, confronts several passengers with their true identities and sets out two possible solutions.

Characters

Hercule Poirot, protagonist
Belgian private detective, traveling home from the Middle East.
M. Bouc, major
Belgian director of the Compagnie Internationale des Wagons-Lits and Poirot's friend.
Dr. Constantine, minor
Greek physician who examines the body.
Ratchett, major
American passenger murdered in his compartment; really the criminal Cassetti.
Mrs. Hubbard, major
Talkative American widow who reports a man in her compartment.
Mary Debenham, major
Composed English governess.
Colonel Arbuthnot, major
British officer traveling from India.
Princess Dragomiroff, minor
Elderly Russian aristocrat.

Lessons

Justice and the law
The novel asks whether a killing can be just when the law has failed. Readers can examine Poirot's decision without the book telling them what to conclude.
- Why does Poirot offer two solutions?
- Was Poirot right to let Bouc choose?
Related across the library
- Laws, Lesson: Rulers are servants of the law
  Rulers are servants of the law. The Athenian calls magistrates ministers or servants of the law and says that a state where law is above the rulers receives every blessing, while one where the law has no authority is on the road to ruin. Book III makes the same point historically about Persia and Athens.
- The Black Tulip, Lesson: The mob and justice
  The mob and justice. The opening murder shows a crowd acting without law, while the ending shows a ruler judging fairly.
- The Hunchback of Notre-Dame (Notre-Dame de Paris), Lesson: Learning without self-command
  Learning without self-command. Claude Frollo has mastered law, medicine, theology and languages and lives in strict austerity, yet he cannot govern his desire for Esmeralda, and it drives him to spying, stabbing, false witness and cruelty. Hugo presents a learned man whose knowledge gives him no rule over his passions, and who blames fate rather than himself.
- The Twelve Tables, Lesson: Learning the law by heart
  Learning the law by heart. Roman boys memorized the Tables. Memory work can root a people's laws and values in each generation.
- The World as Will and Representation, Source
  of intuition or perception but on the other hand it gains the certainty and preciseness of abstract knowledge The differential calculus does not really extend our knowledge of the curve it contains nothing that was not already in the mere pure perception of the curve but it alters the kind of knowledge it changes the intuitive into an abstract knowledge which is so valuable for application But here we must refer to another peculiarity of our faculty of knowledge which could not be observed until the distinction...
The logic of detection
Poirot reasons from inconsistencies in testimony and evidence. Students can follow how he tests each clue.
- Which clue first makes Poirot doubt the obvious explanation?
- How does Poirot use psychology as well as physical evidence?
Related across the library
- The Belmont Report: Ethical Principles and Guidelines for the Protection of Human Subjects of Research, Lesson: Protecting the vulnerable
  Protecting the vulnerable. Respect for persons includes protecting those with diminished autonomy, such as children and prisoners. The report recognizes that consent alone is not always enough.
- The Brothers Karamazov, Lesson: Brothers Karamazov: formed attention
  Brothers Karamazov: formed attention. The Brothers Karamazov teaches students to slow down before judgment. twelfth-grade readers can treat the novel as a summit of literary theology, psychology, and moral philosophy before graduation
- Thoughts on Government and Selected Letters, Preface
  a new office expressly for him Mr Sewall had a soft smooth insinuating eloquence which gliding imperceptibly into the minds of a jury gave him as much power over that tribunal as any lawyer ought ever to pos- sess He was also capable of discussing before the court any intricate question of law which gave him at least as much influ- ence there as was consistent with an impartial administration of justice He was a gentleman and a scholar had a fund of wit humor and satire which he used with great discretion at the...
- A History of Philosophy, Vol. IX: Maine de Biran to Sartre, Lesson: Clock time and lived time
  Clock time and lived time. Bergson distinguished measured time from the duration we live, and argued that free acts express the whole person rather than the outcome of a calculation. Copleston expounds the argument and asks whether it secures freedom or only describes it.
- The Belmont Report: Ethical Principles and Guidelines for the Protection of Human Subjects of Research, Lesson: For the Christian reader
  For the Christian reader. The report's principles echo older moral teaching: respect for persons reflects the dignity of each human being, beneficence the command to love one's neighbour, and justice the biblical concern for the poor and the stranger. Christians can find common ground here while asking deeper questions about why persons deserve such respect.
A closed world
The snowbound train isolates suspects and detective alike. The setting shapes the mystery's structure.
- How does the snowdrift affect the investigation?
- Why are trains and other closed settings popular in detective fiction?
Related across the library
- Heart of Darkness, I Ii Iii I
  without me The up-river stations had to be relieved There had been so many delays already that he did not know who was dead and who was alive and how they got on and so on and so on He paid no attention to my explanations and playing with a stick of sealing-wax repeated several times that the situation was very grave very grave There were rumours that a very important station was in jeopardy and its chief Mr Kurtz was ill Hoped it was not true Mr Kurtz was I felt weary and irritable Hang Kurtz I thought I interr...
- The Warden, The Warden'S Decision
  horse and he turned his head and winked funnily at his brothers Papa has heard such good news about the old hospital to-day We know you'll be glad to hear it because you're such a friend of grandpapa Harding and so much in love with Aunt Nelly How d'ye do lads said Bold dismounting I want to see your father if he's at home Lads said Henry turning on his heel and addressing himself to his brother but loud enough to be heard by Bold lads indeed if we're lads what does he call himself Charles James condescended to...
- As You Like It, Summary
  As You Like It begins with two households divided by envy. Orlando, youngest son of the late Sir Rowland de Boys, complains to the old servant Adam that his elder brother Oliver keeps him like a peasant and denies him the education his father willed him. Oliver, who hates Orlando without knowing why, encourages the court wrestler Charles to break his neck. At the court of Duke Frederick, who has usurped the dukedom and banished his elder brother, Duke Senior, to the Forest of Arden, Orlando throws Charles in fro...
- His Last Bow, Lesson: Dangerous experiments
  Dangerous experiments. Holmes tests the Devil's Foot on himself and nearly dies. Curiosity needs prudence.
- The Case-Book of Sherlock Holmes, THE ADVENTURE OF THE ILLUSTRIOUS CLIENT
  with a courteous bow His collaboration may be very necessary for we are dealing on this occasion Mr Holmes with a man to whom violence is familiar and who will literally stick at nothing I should say that there is no more dangerous man in Europe I have had several opponents to whom that flattering term has been applied said Holmes with a smile Don't you smoke Then you will excuse me if I light my pipe If your man is more dangerous than the late Professor Moriarty or than the living Colonel Sebastian Moran then h...

Context

Between the wars the Simplon-Orient Express carried wealthy travelers between Western Europe and Istanbul. The 1932 kidnapping and murder of the infant son of the aviator Charles Lindbergh had shocked the world.

Composition

Christie wrote much of the novel at the Pera Palace Hotel in Istanbul, according to the hotel's tradition, and drew on her own travels to Iraq by train, including a journey in 1931 delayed by floods. It was serialized in the Saturday Evening Post in 1933 as 'Murder in the Calais Coach' before book publication.

Reception

Reviewers praised the ingenuity of the solution, though some critics, including Raymond Chandler, objected that it was implausible. The novel remains one of Christie's most popular and has been filmed several times, notably in 1974 and 2017.

Crime / Punishment Justice Law Revenge Travel Journey Virtue Ethics

Comparisons

The Mysterious Affair at Styles
Poirot's first case, set in an English country house, shows the method he applies on the train.
The Murder on the Links
Poirot's second novel also turns on a past crime that resurfaces under a new identity.
The Moonstone
Collins's novel of detection likewise assembles the testimony of many witnesses.
The Hound of the Baskervilles
Conan Doyle's Holmes, the model for the brilliant private detective, solves a case in an isolated setting.
The Innocence of Father Brown
Chesterton's priest-detective also weighs justice and mercy in solving crimes.
Crime and Punishment
Dostoevsky's novel examines from the inside the question the ending poses: whether a person may kill for a supposed higher justice.

Quotes

For Students

A reading companion for classical Christian high school students. See the student guide.

Reading Guide

Watch for

Each passenger's alibi and how it connects to another's.
The scarlet kimono, the conductor's uniform and the handkerchief.
Poirot's interest in nationality and character.
Poirot's two solutions and Bouc's choice.

Key terms and names

Alibi: Evidence that a suspect was elsewhere when a crime occurred.
Red herring: A misleading clue that distracts from the truth.
Wagon-Lit: A European railway sleeping car.
Closed-circle mystery: A detective story with a limited group of suspects in an isolated place.
Vigilante justice: Punishment carried out by private persons rather than the law.

Seminar Questions

Comprehension Why does Poirot refuse to work for Ratchett?
Comprehension Who was Ratchett really?
Interpretation Why does Christie give Poirot two solutions?
Interpretation How does the setting help the mystery work?
Big Question Is it ever right to take justice into one's own hands?
Big Question What should happen when the law fails?

Faith Connections

Romans 12:19 (Scripture)
'Vengeance is mine; I will repay, saith the Lord': Paul's teaching bears directly on the novel's question of private punishment.
Fyodor Dostoevsky, Crime and Punishment (Great Conversation)
Raskolnikov's theory that some may kill for a higher good offers a serious counterpart to the novel's ending.

Logic and Rhetoric

Central argument: By presenting a crime that answers an unpunished wrong, the novel invites readers to weigh legal justice against moral justice while showing the power of methodical reasoning.

Rhetorical device: the summation scene. Poirot gathers the suspects and sets out his reasoning step by step, a convention Christie uses to deliver the solution.

Debate: Resolved: Poirot should have given the second solution to the police.

Writing Prompts

Essay: Explain how Christie uses the closed setting of the train to structure the mystery.

Comparison with The Mysterious Affair at Styles: Compare Poirot's methods and his sense of justice in Styles and on the Orient Express.

Creative Prompts

Fiction
Write the scene in which M. Bouc explains the first solution to the Yugoslav police.
Essay
Argue whether Poirot's decision at the end is just. Consider the arguments on both sides.
Classroom
Make a timeline of the night of the murder from the passengers' testimony, and identify the contradictions Poirot notices.