Five-minute digest

Don Carlos, Infante of Spain

Summary

Don Carlos is Schiller's tragedy of the Spanish court under Philip II, written when the poet was in his twenties and still the author of The Robbers. The Infante Carlos, the king's heir, is sick with a hopeless love for his stepmother, Elizabeth of Valois, who was once promised to him and is now his father's queen. His father despises him and favours the Duke of Alva, and the court is full of spies, among them the confessor Domingo. Carlos is rescued from despair by the return of his boyhood friend, the Marquis of Posa, a Knight of Malta who has just seen the suffering of Flanders under Spanish rule and who is persuaded that a prince like Carlos might free the Netherlands and change the world. Posa arranges a meeting between Carlos and the queen. She tells him to love his country and not herself. Meanwhile Princess Eboli, who loves Carlos and mistakes his signs for her, discovers that his heart belongs to the queen and takes revenge by joining Alva and Domingo against him. Posa, seeing that Carlos will be destroyed, goes to Philip himself. In the most famous scene of the play he tells the king to give his subjects freedom of thought and to become 'a king of men' and not of slaves. Philip, astonished and lonely, treats Posa as the first honest man he has met and makes him his confidant. Posa then does a hard thing. To save Carlos from the king's suspicion and to keep the cause of Flanders alive, he lets the king find letters that make Posa himself appear the queen's secret lover. He is shot in his prison, and as he dies he sends Carlos a message to remember the dreams of his youth. Philip learns too late that Posa was loyal to him in his own way. Carlos, roused to action, tries to escape to Flanders after one last meeting with the queen, but the king and the Grand Inquisitor appear, and the Inquisitor claims the prince. The play asks whether a man may use deceit for a noble end, and what happens to friendship when one friend becomes an instrument of a cause. Schiller is hard on the Inquisition and on the tyranny of Philip, and sympathetic, though not uncritical, towards the idealism of Posa. Teachers should note themes of illicit love, state violence, and a bitter picture of the Inquisition.

Top Lessons

  • Freedom of conscience is a theme of the play

    Posa asks Philip for liberty of thought and refuses to give up his ideal. Schiller lets him argue that a king rules best when the subject is free, and the Grand Inquisitor's scene shows what happens when the Church is made a tool of the state.

  • Friendship can take the form of sacrifice

    Posa gives up his life for Carlos. Schiller leaves it open whether his method of deceit was right.

  • Tyranny isolates the tyrant

    Philip has a throne and a kingdom but no friend, and he admits as much to Posa. The play makes the king a figure of pity as well as of fear.

Verified Quotes

“The world is yet Unripe for my ideal; and I live A citizen of ages yet to come.”
— Friedrich Schiller, Don Carlos, Infante of Spain, Act III, trans. R. D. Boylan (nineteenth century).Quote card
“Lord Cardinal! I've done my part. Go now, and do your own.”
— Friedrich Schiller, Don Carlos, Infante of Spain, Act V, trans. R. D. Boylan (nineteenth century).Quote card