Five-minute digest
Mary Stuart
Summary
Mary Stuart is Schiller's tragedy of the last three days of Mary, Queen of Scots, and of the Queen of England who sent her to the block. Mary has been a prisoner at Fotheringay Castle for nearly nineteen years. She has been tried by a commission of English peers and condemned for plotting against Elizabeth, and the play opens with the sentence awaiting only the queen's signature. Her gaoler, Sir Amias Paulet, is a stern Puritan; her nurse Hannah Kennedy and her steward Melvil are loyal; and a young convert to Catholicism, Mortimer, has come in secret to tell her that he will free her by force. The drama then pivots on a scene that Schiller invented and that never happened: the two queens meet in a park. Leicester, who is Elizabeth's favourite but secretly Mary's friend, has arranged it. Mary begins by kneeling and pleading, but Elizabeth's cold contempt breaks her, and she turns on her rival, calling her a bastard and a usurper. The meeting makes her death certain. An attempt on Elizabeth's life by a fanatic, and a plot of Mortimer's to storm the castle, supply the pretext. Mortimer, found out, kills himself. Leicester betrays Mortimer and Mary alike to save his own place. Elizabeth, who has spent the play weighing law, public opinion and her own safety, signs the warrant and hands it to her secretary Davison with an order so vague that it can be disowned. Burleigh takes it and carries out the sentence at once; Elizabeth then blames Davison and sends him to the Tower. Mary, meanwhile, has used her final hours to make a confession, to receive communion from Melvil, who has secretly become a priest, and to forgive her enemies. She goes to the scaffold calm, while Elizabeth, victorious, is left alone with the loss of her best counsellor Shrewsbury and of Leicester, who has fled to France. The play invites comparison of two kinds of power: the queen who is free by the law but a prisoner of opinion and fear, and the prisoner who is bound by the law but made free by repentance. Teachers should note a scene of Catholic confession and Eucharist and an offstage execution; the play is sympathetic to Mary but does not hide her faults.
Top Lessons
Repentance can free a prisoner from within
Mary begins as a proud queen who will not admit any fault. Schiller lets her recognise her old sins, accept a punishment she does not strictly deserve for the crime charged, and forgive her enemy before she dies.
Policy without conscience leaves a ruler alone
Elizabeth is the winner of the contest, and Schiller leaves her with no friend and no clean conscience. She disowns her order, blames Davison and loses Shrewsbury and Leicester.
Anger can destroy a good cause
Mary's insult in the park costs her whatever hope she had. Schiller shows the cost of pride even where the grievance is real.
Verified Quotes
“I am a queen, like you: yet you have held me Confined in prison.”
Frequently cited
“My heart was filled with thoughts of envious hate, And vengeance took possession of my bosom. I hope forgiveness of my sins from God, Yet could I not forgive my enemy.”
“God suffers me in mercy to atone, By undeserved death, my youth's transgressions.”
Frequently cited
“I pardon her my death; most humbly, too, I crave her to forgive me for the passion With which I spoke to her.”
“'Tis little I have done: I could not save Your nobler part. Live--govern happily! Your rival's dead! Henceforth you've nothing more To fear--henceforth to nothing pay regard.”