Five-minute digest

Dialogue on Oratory

Summary

The Dialogue on Oratory is a short work attributed to Tacitus, written in the form of a conversation. It opens with a letter to a friend, Fabius Justus, who has asked why the great age of Roman oratory seems to have passed. Tacitus replies that he cannot answer in his own voice, but he can report a discussion he heard as a young man in the sixth year of the emperor Vespasian, about AD 75, among the leading speakers of the day. The scene is the house of Curiatius Maternus, a successful advocate who has turned to writing tragedies. He has just read aloud a play on Cato, which has caused offense among powerful men. Two visitors, Marcus Aper and Julius Secundus, find him with his friends and tease him for neglecting the courts. Aper is a self-made man from Gaul and a hard-driving advocate. He argues that oratory is the most useful and rewarding of professions, giving power, wealth, fame and freedom. He claims that the speakers of his own day are in many respects better than the old orators, because they are more polished and fit the taste of their time. Maternus replies that he prefers poetry, which allows a quiet life far from the court, and he praises the peace of the woods and the muses. Then a third speaker, Vipstanus Messalla, comes in and the talk turns to the causes of the decline. Messalla says that the old orators were better because they were better educated. He blames modern parents who leave their children to slaves, modern schools that teach only show, and a general loss of seriousness. He recalls how the young orator once trained under the guidance of a great speaker. Maternus gives the last speech. He argues that great oratory belongs to a time of disorder, when the people were swayed by demagogues and the state was at risk, and that under the settled rule of the emperor there is less need for great speeches. The ending is abrupt, and the dialogue closes with the friends laughing and parting. The Dialogue is a work of literary criticism and of political reflection. It asks whether eloquence depends on freedom and conflict, and whether peace and order are worth the loss of high rhetoric. Of the works of Tacitus, it is the one that most closely imitates Cicero.

Top Lessons

  • Why does great speech decline?

    The speakers offer several explanations: poorer education, softer manners, the loss of political freedom. Students can weigh each.

  • Education and character

    Messalla argues that the old speakers were better because of the way they were raised and taught. The dialogue invites students to ask what a good education is for.

  • Freedom and peace

    Maternus suggests that great oratory belongs to turbulent times and fades under settled rule. The dialogue asks what a society gains and loses from order.

Verified Quotes