Work record
Dialogue on Oratory
TacitusDialogus de Oratoribus; A Dialogue on Oratory; Dialogue of the OratorsDialogue on Oratory by Tacitus (c. AD 100)The Dialogue on Oratory is a short work attributed to Tacitus, written in the form of a conversation.Also known as: Dialogus de Oratoribus · A Dialogue on Oratory · Dialogue of the Orators
c. AD 100 · Ancient · Oratory · Latin
Read this when you want to ask why great public speaking declined at Rome.
Abstract
The question. A friend of Tacitus asks why the great age of Roman oratory has passed. Tacitus answers by reporting a conversation he heard as a young man in about AD 75, among the leading speakers of the time.
The speakers. At the house of Maternus, an advocate who has turned to poetry, Aper defends modern oratory as the best road to fame, while Maternus praises the quiet of poetry. Messalla blames the decline on poor education, weak parenting and showy schools.
The last word. Maternus argues that great oratory flourished in a time of disorder and loses its fuel when a single ruler keeps the peace. The dialogue ends abruptly, with the friends laughing and parting.
Why it matters. The dialogue joins literary criticism to political thought, asking if eloquence needs liberty and strife in order to thrive, and if peace justifies what it costs. It also shows how a Roman writer could use dialogue to let several views be heard. Students will find it useful for comparing Roman and modern ideas of what makes a speech persuasive. It is also the best ancient discussion of how education shapes a speaker, and it repays a slow reading with attention to who speaks, in what order, and with what motive.
Key figures
- Tacitus: The narrator who recalls the conversation.
- Marcus Aper: A self-made advocate who defends modern oratory.
- Julius Secundus: A friend who takes the part of a peacemaker.
- Curiatius Maternus: An advocate turned poet, host of the conversation.
- Vipstanus Messalla: A speaker who blames the decline on education.
- Fabius Justus: The friend to whom the work is addressed.
Summary
The Dialogue on Oratory is a short work attributed to Tacitus, written in the form of a conversation. It opens with a letter to a friend, Fabius Justus, who has asked why the great age of Roman oratory seems to have passed. Tacitus replies that he cannot answer in his own voice, but he can report a discussion he heard as a young man in the sixth year of the emperor Vespasian, about AD 75, among the leading speakers of the day. The scene is the house of Curiatius Maternus, a successful advocate who has turned to writing tragedies. He has just read aloud a play on Cato, which has caused offense among powerful men. Two visitors, Marcus Aper and Julius Secundus, find him with his friends and tease him for neglecting the courts. Aper is a self-made man from Gaul and a hard-driving advocate. He argues that oratory is the most useful and rewarding of professions, giving power, wealth, fame and freedom. He claims that the speakers of his own day are in many respects better than the old orators, because they are more polished and fit the taste of their time. Maternus replies that he prefers poetry, which allows a quiet life far from the court, and he praises the peace of the woods and the muses. Then a third speaker, Vipstanus Messalla, comes in and the talk turns to the causes of the decline. Messalla says that the old orators were better because they were better educated. He blames modern parents who leave their children to slaves, modern schools that teach only show, and a general loss of seriousness. He recalls how the young orator once trained under the guidance of a great speaker. Maternus gives the last speech. He argues that great oratory belongs to a time of disorder, when the people were swayed by demagogues and the state was at risk, and that under the settled rule of the emperor there is less need for great speeches. The ending is abrupt, and the dialogue closes with the friends laughing and parting. The Dialogue is a work of literary criticism and of political reflection. It asks whether eloquence depends on freedom and conflict, and whether peace and order are worth the loss of high rhetoric. Of the works of Tacitus, it is the one that most closely imitates Cicero.
Virtues in this work
Plot or Argument
- The question
Tacitus answers a friend's question about the decline of oratory by reporting a conversation he heard as a young man at the house of the poet and advocate Maternus.
- The defense of modern oratory
Aper argues for the profit, power and fame that oratory brings, while Maternus answers that he prefers the quiet of poetry.
- The causes of decline
Messalla blames poor education and weak morals, and Maternus gives the last word, a political explanation tied to the settled rule of one man.
Characters
- Tacitus (as narrator), Writer, reporting a conversation
He addresses Justus Fabius and then lets the speakers talk.
- The speakers of the dialogue, Advocates of different explanations
Men of letters and of the courts, arguing about education and liberty.
Lessons
Why does great speech decline?
The speakers offer several explanations: poorer education, softer manners, the loss of political freedom. Students can weigh each.
- Which explanation of the decline do you find most convincing?
- What does each speaker's background tell you about his view?
Education and character
Messalla argues that the old speakers were better because of the way they were raised and taught. The dialogue invites students to ask what a good education is for.
- What does Messalla say is wrong with modern education?
- Is he right to blame the household as well as the school?
Freedom and peace
Maternus suggests that great oratory belongs to turbulent times and fades under settled rule. The dialogue asks what a society gains and loses from order.
- Is Maternus right that peace weakens eloquence?
- What would a Christian add to this account?
Context
The dialogue is set in about AD 75, in the reign of Vespasian, though it was probably written about AD 100. Tacitus was a young man at the time of the conversation and a senator by the time of writing.
Composition
It was composed as a letter to Fabius Justus and is in the manner of Cicero's dialogues on oratory. The English in the library is the Church and Brodribb translation of 1876, from Wikisource.
Reception
The Dialogue was long separated from Tacitus's other works, which are historical, because of its style. It is now the standard text for the ancient debate about the decline of Roman eloquence.
Comparisons
- First Oration Against Catiline
The Catilinarian is the kind of republican oratory the Dialogue looks back to.
- The Fourteen Philippics
The Philippics are the last great burst of that oratory; this dialogue asks why it did not return.
- The Annals of Imperial Rome
The Annals are Tacitus’s long history of the empire whose quiet this dialogue tries to explain.
- The Agricola and the Germania
Agricola, like this dialogue, thinks about virtue and fame under an emperor.
Quotes
Frequently cited
“You often ask me, Justus Fabius, how it is that while the genius and the fame of so many distinguished orators have shed a lustre on the past, our age is so forlorn and so destitute of the glory of eloquence that it scarce retains the very name of orator.”
For Students
A reading companion for classical Christian high school students. See the student guide.
Reading Guide
Watch for
- How Tacitus places himself as a young listener and what he says of the scene.
- The way Aper and Maternus differ about the value of poetry and the courts.
- Messalla's account of old and new education and Maternus's political reply.
Key terms and names
- dialogus
- A conversation in prose with named speakers, a form used by Plato and Cicero.
- orator
- A public speaker trained in the arts of persuasion, especially in the Roman courts and Senate.
- eloquence
- Skill and beauty in speaking.
- principate
- The rule of an emperor, as the Roman government after Augustus was called.
Seminar Questions
- Comprehension What question does Fabius Justus ask Tacitus?
- Comprehension What does Aper say about the benefits of oratory?
- Interpretation Why does Maternus prefer poetry to the courts?
- Interpretation What does Messalla say is wrong with the way children are raised and taught?
- Big Question Does great speech need freedom and conflict to flourish?
- Big Question Is an orderly state worth the loss of great rhetoric?
Faith Connections
- Proverbs 25:11; 15:23 (Scripture)
A word fitly spoken is a serious good in Scripture too; this dialogue asks what kind of city still trains such speech.
- Augustine, On Christian Teaching (De Doctrina Christiana) IV (Church Fathers)
Augustine, who knew this tradition of Roman eloquence, asks how rhetoric may serve the gospel rather than a career.
Logic and Rhetoric
Central argument: The dialogue offers several explanations of the decline of eloquence and leaves the reader to weigh them, with Maternus's political argument given the last word.
Rhetorical device: Dialogue form. By letting four speakers argue in turn, Tacitus shows each view in its strongest light.
Debate: Resolved: that great oratory depends on political freedom and cannot flourish under the settled rule of one man.
Writing Prompts
Essay: Weigh the speakers' explanations for the decline of oratory and say which one you think is strongest.
Comparison with The Fourteen Philippics: Compare the high eloquence of Cicero's Philippics with the account of eloquence's decline in the Dialogue.
Creative Prompts
- Essay
Assess the explanations that Aper, Messalla and Maternus give for the decline of oratory and say which is most persuasive.
- Dialogue
Write a conversation between Messalla and a modern parent about the education of the young.
- Classroom
Have students sort the speakers' arguments into those about education, those about politics and those about taste.
Further Reading
- Agricola, Germany, Dialogue on Orators, Tacitus, trans. Herbert W. Benario
Hackett; a modern translation of the Dialogue.
- Tacitus: Dialogus, ed. Roland Mayer
Cambridge Greek and Latin Classics; with commentary.
- Institutes of Oratory, Quintilian
A full ancient course on speaking, from the same period.
Verification notes
Complete 42-chapter text, Church and Brodribb 1876. Dates of composition are approximate (c. AD 100).
- Speaker attributions within the dialogue follow the standard division of the 1876 version.