Five-minute digest
The Brothers (Adelphoe)
Summary
Two brothers, Micio and Demea, have settled their family in opposite ways. Micio is a bachelor who lives easily in the city. He has adopted Aeschinus, the elder of Demea's two sons, and brings him up with indulgence and trust, giving him money and freedom and hoping to be loved rather than feared. Demea farms in the country and keeps his younger son Ctesipho under a strict hand, sure that hard work and fear are the only safe teachers. The play opens as Micio waits anxiously for Aeschinus, who has been out all night, and Demea storms in to report that the young man has broken down a door and carried off a music-girl. Demea blames Micio's softness. Micio answers that a father should rule by shame and kindness, not by dread. The truth is more tangled. Aeschinus did seize the girl, but he did it for his brother, who is in love with her and has hidden the fact from Demea. Aeschinus has taken the blame upon himself rather than expose Ctesipho. He has also wronged another young woman, Pamphila, a poor neighbor whose mother is now in labor, and he has promised to marry her. When rumors reach Pamphila's household that Aeschinus is courting someone else, the family is crushed, and the slave Syrus keeps the comedy moving with one scheme after another to hide Ctesipho from his father. In the last acts Demea sees that his own method has produced a son who lies and a household that fears him, while Micio's son has at least acted nobly. Stung, Demea decides to try kindness. He begins to be generous with everyone, urges Micio to make several unlikely gifts and favors, and so shows his brother how easy it is to be loved by giving things away. He then explains that his earlier reproach was not a conversion but a lesson: easy giving is not wisdom, and a father must care enough to correct. The play ends with marriages arranged and both brothers a little humbled. The Brothers was first staged in 160 BC at the funeral games for Lucius Aemilius Paullus, and it is the nearest thing in Terence to an essay on fatherhood. It does not simply choose a side. Severity without trust breeds concealment, and kindness without a rule leaves a young man unprepared for life. The Roman audience, which was itself arguing over the new Greek ease and the old Roman discipline, could see both fathers on the stage and judge them for itself.
Top Lessons
Two ways of raising a son
The play does not simply take Micio's side. Kindness without a rule can spoil a house, and severity without trust can drive a son to hide. Demea's last speech asks whether easy popularity is the same as virtue.
Honest blame and loyal brothers
Aeschinus takes a blame that is not wholly his in order to shield his brother. The play shows loyalty between brothers as a real moral good, though it is bought with a lie.
Authority that serves
Each father holds authority over a son, and each uses it differently. The play invites students to ask what authority is for, and whether it can be exercised without both firmness and trust.
Verified Quotes
“Never is there any thing more unreasonable than a man who wants experience, who thinks nothing right except what he himself has done.”
Frequently cited
“You are his father by nature, I by my anxiety.”
“Ah me! Learn to be a father from those who are really so.”
“The life of man is just like playing with dice: if that which you most want to throw does not turn up, what turns up by chance you must correct by art.”