Five-minute digest
The Cossacks
Summary
The Cossacks is Tolstoy's first major work of fiction after his army years, and it draws on his own life in the Caucasus in the early 1850s. Dmitri Olenin, a rich and idle young Moscow nobleman, tired of society, debts and a string of failed affairs, joins the army as a cadet and goes to the Caucasus, determined to start a fresh and simple life. He is billeted in a Cossack settlement on the Terek, where the Russians have long lived under arms among Chechen raiders. There he meets the old hunter Uncle Eroshka, who drinks, boasts and tells him that God made everything for man's pleasure; the young Cossack Lukashka, bold and reckless, who kills a Chechen abrek on the river bank; and Marianka, the handsome daughter of his landlord, who is promised to Lukashka. Olenin falls in love with Marianka and with the Cossack life she belongs to. He is drawn by the beauty of the mountains and of the land, by the strength of the men and women who live by hunting, vine-growing and war, and above all by what he takes to be their natural happiness. In a famous scene in the forest he thinks that happiness lies in love and self-sacrifice, and that he should live for others. But his goodness is mostly in his head. He lends money, gives gifts, drinks and talks with Eroshka, and offers himself to the girl as one who thinks that he can leap out of his class by affection. When the Cossack community prepares for Lukashka's wedding, and Lukashka is wounded in a skirmish, Marianka turns from Olenin, and he finds that she does not need him and that he is a stranger to her people. He leaves the settlement, and neither the old man nor the girl looks at him as he goes. The story is a young writer's first, clear statement of a theme Tolstoy never gave up: that the educated man's self-regard and reflection cut him off from the simple life that he envies and that the people he idealizes are no more innocent than he is. Eroshka's easy paganism and the Cossacks' readiness to kill are described without flattery, and Olenin's longing is shown to be partly a vanity. Christian readers will find the book a sharp account of how a sentimental love of nature and simplicity can be a refuge from duty, and a reminder that self-giving is not the same as self-deception. The Maude translation hosted here preserves the Russian names with their stress marks.
Top Lessons
Self-sacrifice must be done and not only felt
Olenin discovers in the forest that happiness lies in love and self-sacrifice, and runs off to find someone to sacrifice himself for. The comedy and the pathos of the scene are the same: he has seen the truth and has not yet learned to practice it. The point for the student is the gap between insight and action.
The idealised simple life is not innocent
Tolstoy loves the Cossacks and their landscape, but he does not hide their drinking, hunting of men and cruelty. Eroshka's philosophy that there is no sin in any of it is the book's real temptation, since it is attractive and wrong.
Love that takes without belonging is a kind of theft
Olenin's love for Marianka is genuine, but he asks to be made one of a community without sharing its burdens. She sees this sooner than he does. A reader may ask what a love that is willing to give up its own world would have to look like.
Verified Quotes
“No, to be beloved is a misfortune. It is a misfortune to feel guilty because you do not give something you cannot give.”
Frequently cited
“God has made everything for the joy of man. There is no sin in any of it.”
“Why injure a beast? You fool, you fool!”
Frequently cited
“What are they? Love, self-sacrifice.” He was so glad and excited when he had discovered this, as it seemed to him, new truth, that he jumped up and began impatiently seeking some one to sacrifice himself for, to do good to and to love. “Since one wants nothing for oneself,” he kept thinking, “why not live for others?”
“Why, I love you, and how I pity you! You are so forlorn, always alone, always alone.”
Frequently cited
“Daddy Eróshka was talking to Maryánka, evidently about his own affairs, and neither the old man nor the girl looked at Olénin.”
Medical Lens
The Cossack settlement drinks freely, with the old man Eroshka as a cheerful example, and fever hangs over the marshes of the Terek. Lukashka's wound and the abrek's death give small pictures of frontier medicine.
- Chapters XX–XXIII, Eroshka's talk
The old hunter's drinking and his praise of wine as a medicine and a joy show the permissive attitude of the settlement.
- Chapter XL, Lukashka's wound
A young Cossack is wounded in a skirmish and treated by his own people.