Five-minute digest
The Last Day of a Condemned Man (Le Dernier Jour d'un condamné)
Summary
The Last Day of a Condemned Man is a short novel in the form of a journal, written by a man under sentence of death in the Paris of the 1820s. It begins five weeks after his sentence. He never says what his crime was, and Hugo leaves that out on purpose, so that the reader looks at the punishment and not at the offence. The man writes in the prison at Bicêtre, in the Conciergerie and at last in the Hôtel de Ville, where the condemned wait for the cart. He remembers the trial, the chain of convicts who set out for the galleys, the slang of the prison, and the visits of the priest and the officials. Two fixed ideas hold him. One is the thought of the guillotine, which comes back in every chapter. The other is his three-year-old daughter Marie, who is brought to see him in the last hours and does not know him, for she has been told that her father is dead. In the closing chapters the clock runs down to four in the afternoon, the hour set for the execution on the Place de Grève. Hugo added a preface in 1832 in which he said plainly that the book was a plea against capital punishment, answering critics who had asked who the prisoner was and what the point of the tale might be. He also wrote a short comedy, printed in this edition, in which fashionable guests in a drawing-room discuss the book and show how little they have understood it. The preface goes through the arguments commonly made for the death penalty, such as deterrence and the removal of the dangerous, and replies to each of them from history and reason. It ends with a hope that the gentle law of Christ would enter the criminal law and that the cross would take the place of the gallows. For a classical Christian course the book is useful on the question of mercy and the magistrate's authority. Students can set Hugo's appeal beside Paul's teaching in Romans 13 that the ruler bears the sword, and beside the church's long reflection on mercy and on the sanctity of life, and they can ask whether his argument is sound. The text is Arabella Ward's 1896 English translation. It contains scenes of imprisonment, grief and a public execution, so it is best suited to the oldest students.
Top Lessons
Mercy and the magistrate
Hugo asks whether a society may take a life as a lesson to others. Students should state his case fairly, then weigh it against the Christian teaching that the ruler bears the sword (Romans 13) and against the church's long habit of speaking for mercy, so that they see a grave question argued on both sides and do not take either side on feeling.
The sanctity of human life
The book keeps the reader with one man through his last hours, and the effect is to make the weight of a single life felt. A Christian student can see in this the teaching that every person is made in the image of God, while asking whether that teaching settles what the law should do.
Use of the last hours
The prisoner counts the time that is left and cannot use it. The book can start a talk on how time should be used by one who knows that his days are numbered, which Psalm 90 puts as a prayer for wisdom of heart.
A reader's caution on how Hugo argues
Hugo wrote as a poet and a political writer, and the book works through feeling as much as through reasons. Teachers should ask students to separate the argument of the preface from the effect of the story, since each can be right or wrong apart from the other.
Verified Quotes
Frequently cited
“For five weeks this thought has dwelt within me, and this alone, congealing my blood, bearing me down beneath its weight!”
Frequently cited
“To avenge belongs to the individual; punishment, to God.”
“The gentle law of Christ will penetrate our laws after a while, and will shine through them.”
“The cross will take the place of the gallows.”
“Oh, if the jury had only seen my little Marie, they would have understood that they must not kill the father of a baby three years old!”
“Only three steps remain for me, — Bicêtre, the Conciergerie, La Grève.”
“Marie, I am your papa.”
“Pity me, O my God!”
Medical Lens
The journal is a study of the mind of a man who expects to die on a fixed day. It shows a single idea that fills the thoughts, sleeplessness, nightmares, and sudden changes from calm to panic, and Hugo treats the fixed idea as a kind of illness. In the preface he says that crime ought to be regarded as a malady with physicians instead of judges and hospitals instead of prisons, which is a statement of a penal theory and not of modern medicine. The book is a useful literary source on the psychology of the condemned and on 19th-century views of crime as a disease.
- Chapter I
The prisoner describes a single thought that dominates his mind and his body since the sentence.
- Chapters XXXVIII and XLII
A violent pain in the head and a feverish dread at the quarter-hour, then a nightmare of an old woman in his own house.
- Preface
Hugo proposes that crime be treated as a disease and that hospitals take the place of prisons.