Five-minute digest

The Secret of the Old Clock

Summary

The Secret of the Old Clock is the first of the Nancy Drew books, and this library hosts the original 1930 wording, not the later rewrite of 1959. Nancy Drew, a pretty girl of sixteen, lives with her father, the lawyer Carson Drew, and with Hannah Gruen, who keeps the house. She is already quick, kind and determined, and she takes it as a wrong that Josiah Crowley’s fortune should go to the snobbish Tophams rather than to poorer relations who loved him, including the girls Allie and Grace. A chance meeting, a storm, and a trail of talk about an old clock start her on a search for a later will. She visits the Tophams, follows a clue, is shut up and left in danger at a closed bungalow, and meets Jeff Tucker, the caretaker, in wording that a teacher should pause over. Robbers, a police chase, and a last examination of the old clock bring the hidden paper to light, and the deserving girls are remembered as Crowley had wished. Nancy keeps the clock as a trophy of her first case. The book is a swift mystery for middle-grade readers, written in the plain style of early series fiction, and it honors courage, perseverance and a sense of justice that is also a sense of kindness. It is of its time in manners and in some of its language, and this library keeps the 1930 wording so that students read what first readers saw, not a silent later polish. A parent may wish to read the caretaker passages and the sharper action with a younger child. Taken as a first case, it shows a girl who uses her wits, who will take a risk for a just cause, and who still comes home to a father who trusts her.

Top Lessons

  • Justice is also kindness

    Nancy’s case is not only a puzzle; she wants a fortune to go to people who loved the dead man, not only to people who can claim him. Justice here has a face.

  • Nerve and prudence together

    Nancy takes risks, including a night of real danger, but she also thinks, asks, and goes to her father and to the police when the time comes. Courage in this book is not rashness alone.

  • Read the 1930 wording with care

    The original text speaks of Jeff Tucker in the language of its day, and it is franker in action than the later rewrite. A good reading keeps the original and names what is dated, without losing Nancy’s real virtues.

Verified Quotes

“I was saying I think it's mean if those snobbish Tophams fall heir to all of Josiah Crowley's fortune. Can't something be done about it?”
— Carolyn Keene, The Secret of the Old Clock, Chapter I: The Lost Will (Grosset & Dunlap, 1930 original (Project Gutenberg #77924)).Quote card
“There's a negro caretaker who looks after it—they call him Jeff Tucker.”
— Carolyn Keene, The Secret of the Old Clock, Chapter XVII: Jeff Tucker’s Story (Grosset & Dunlap, 1930 original (Project Gutenberg #77924)).Quote card
“I'll always prize this clock as a trophy of my first venture as a detective,”
— Carolyn Keene, The Secret of the Old Clock, Chapter XXV: A Reward (Grosset & Dunlap, 1930 original (Project Gutenberg #77924)).Quote card

Medical Lens

Nancy is shut up and left in danger at a closed bungalow, a chapter of fear and want rather than of medical interest.

  • Chapter XVI: Left to Starve

    Nancy is locked in and left without help, a test of nerve in the original wording.