Five-minute digest
What Men Live By and Other Tales
Summary
What Men Live By and Other Tales gathers four of the short stories Tolstoy wrote in the 1880s for ordinary readers, after his spiritual crisis, in a plain folk manner meant to be read aloud in a peasant hut or a classroom. The first, What Men Live By, is the best known. A poor shoemaker named Simon, who owns one sheepskin coat with his wife, finds a naked stranger shivering by a roadside chapel and, after a hard struggle with his own misgiving and his wife's anger, takes him home. The stranger, Michael, works as his apprentice, smiles three times, and turns out to be an angel who has been sent to earth to learn three truths: what dwells in man, what is not given to man, and what men live by. The answer, given at the close, is that they live not by care for themselves but by love. The second tale, Three Questions, is a short parable about a king who wishes to know the right time for every act, the right people to heed, and the most important thing to do. A hermit, digging his garden, answers by letting the king help him and then by letting him save the life of a wounded stranger, who proves to be an enemy who meant to kill him. The most important time is now, the most important man is the one in front of you, and the most important work is to do him good. The third, The Coffee-House of Surat, is a fable in which travellers of every faith quarrel over whose God is true, until a Chinese student of Confucius answers that all temples are copies of the one God has built in the world. It is the one tale in the collection that Christian readers should discuss with care, since it argues for a general benevolence among religions and not for the exclusive claims of the Gospel. The last, How Much Land Does a Man Need?, tells of Pahom, a peasant who says that if he had enough land he would not fear the devil himself, and who is led by the devil from one purchase to the next. In the end the Bashkirs offer him as much as he can walk around in a day for a thousand roubles; he walks too far, runs back at sunset, and falls dead at the goal. His servant digs him a grave six feet long. The tales share a simple method: a clear moral question, a plain style, and an ending that does not need to be explained. Their weakness is their sureness that doctrine can be reduced to ethics; their strength is that they put the commandment to love before the child and the peasant as well as the philosopher.
Top Lessons
Love is the answer to what men live by
The first tale puts the whole of Tolstoy's later teaching in a shoemaker's hut: God gives life, men do not know what they need, and in practice they live by love. The angel is punished for refusing a mother's plea and saved by seeing a stranger's love for orphans. A reader should see that the teaching rests on the Epistle of John, which the book prints as its opening text.
Now is the important time
The king in Three Questions wants a method for acting well and is shown that there is none apart from loving the person in front of him. The hermit's answer is plain, and it may be tested on any ordinary school day: attend to the person you are with, and do him good.
Greed has a measure, and it is six feet
Pahom's wish for just a little more land is the oldest of the stories. The devil does not need to tempt him with evil; he only has to let him choose. The final sentence of the tale is one of the best-known in Russian literature.
Verified Quotes
“We know that we have passed out of death into life, because we love the brethren. He that loveth not abideth in death.”
Frequently cited
“I have learnt that all men live not by care for themselves but by love.”
“Nor is it given to any man to know whether, when evening comes, he will need boots for his body or slippers for his corpse.”
Frequently cited
“He who has love, is in God, and God is in him, for God is love.”
Frequently cited
“Remember then: there is only one time that is important--Now! It is the most important time because it is the only time when we have any power. The most necessary man is he with whom you are, for no man knows whether he will ever have dealings with any one else: and the most important affair is, to do him good, because for that purpose alone was man sent into this life!”
“Therefore, let him who sees the sun's whole light filling the world, refrain from blaming or despising the superstitious man, who in his own idol sees one ray of that same light. Let him not despise even the unbeliever who is blind and cannot see the sun at all.”
Frequently cited
“Six feet from his head to his heels was all he needed.”
Medical Lens
These are moral tales with no clinical interest apart from the exhausted death at the end of the last one, which describes Pahom's running, his bleeding mouth and his collapse in the language of a man who has overrun his own strength.