Work record
A Musical Instrument
Elizabeth Barrett BrowningA Musical Instrument by Elizabeth Barrett Browning (1860)A Musical Instrument is a poem of seven short stanzas about the god Pan and the making of a reed pipe.1860 · 19th Century · Poetry · English
Read this when art seems costly, and you wonder what must be cut down for music.
Abstract
Background. Elizabeth Barrett Browning wrote this poem near the end of her life, when she lived in Italy, and published it in the Cornhill Magazine in 1860. It retells the old myth of the god Pan making the first reed pipes.
Content. Pan wades into the river, tears a reed from its bed and leaves the water muddy and the lilies broken. He sits on the bank, hacks off the leaf, draws out the pith and notches holes in the reed. When he blows into it the music is so sweet that the sun forgets to set and the lilies revive. The last stanza says the half-beast god makes a poet out of a man, and the true gods sigh for the reed that will never again be a reed.
Form. Seven stanzas of six short lines, with a refrain on the river at the end of each. The rhythm is light and swift, with a dancing movement that imitates the god at his work and the sound of his pipe.
Themes. The poem's themes are creativity and its cost, the relation of art to nature, myth as a way of thinking about the poet, and the mixture of delight and sorrow in music.
Significance. The poem is a lively classic of the Victorian lyric and a fine short study of vocation. It invites students to consider what any art or calling takes from the one who practices it.
Summary
A Musical Instrument is a poem of seven short stanzas about the god Pan and the making of a reed pipe. Elizabeth Barrett Browning published it in the Cornhill Magazine in 1860, and it later appeared in Last Poems. It is a retelling of the old story, found in Ovid, of how Pan fashioned the first pipes from river reeds. The opening stanza asks what the great god Pan was doing down in the reeds by the river: spreading ruin and scattering ban, splashing and paddling with hoofs of a goat, and breaking the golden lilies afloat with the dragon-fly on the river. The second tells how he tore out a reed from the deep cool bed of the river, so that the limpid water ran turbid and the broken lilies lay dying. In the third and fourth he sits on the bank and hacks and hews at the patient reed with his hard bleak steel until there is no sign of the leaf, then draws out the pith like the heart of a man, steadily from the outside ring, and notches the poor dry empty thing in holes. In the fifth stanza he tries it, blowing in power by the river. The sixth is the music itself: sweet, sweet, sweet, O Pan, piercing sweet, blinding sweet. The sun on the hill forgot to die, and the lilies revived, and the dragon-fly came back to dream on the river. The final stanza gives the poem's reflection. Yet half a beast is the great god Pan, to laugh as he sits by the river, making a poet out of a man; the true gods sigh for the cost and pain, for the reed which grows nevermore again as a reed with the reeds of the river. The poem is playful, lively and a little dark. Its rhythm is light and its refrain returns to the river at the end of every stanza. Under the play lies a serious claim about art: music and poetry cost something, and what is made into a pipe can never be a reed again. Christian readers can read it as a poem about vocation and sacrifice, and can also notice its pagan setting and its remark that a half-beast god makes the poet.
Virtues in this work
Plot or Argument
- Stanzas 1-2: Pan at the river
The god wades in the reeds, ruins the lilies and tears a reed from the river bed, leaving the water muddy and the flowers dying.
- Stanzas 3-4: cutting and hollowing
He sits on the shore and hacks the reed, draws out the pith like the heart of a man, and notches it into a pipe.
- Stanza 5: the first note
He drops his mouth to a hole in the reed and blows in power by the river.
- Stanza 6: the music
The sound is sweet beyond bearing: the sun forgets to set, the lilies revive and the dragon-fly returns.
- Stanza 7: the cost
The half-beast god makes a poet out of a man, and the true gods sigh for the cost and pain of a reed that never grows again.
Characters
- Pan, The god of the wild
A goat-footed god who shapes the reed into a pipe and makes music, half beast and half god.
- The reed, The instrument
The living plant that is cut, hollowed and notched until it becomes a pipe, and so is a figure of the poet.
- The speaker, Narrator
A playful voice that tells the story and then sets its moral about art and its cost.
Lessons
Art asks sacrifice
The pipe is made by cutting down a living reed. The poem hints that a poet is made by a similar loss, and that the beauty of music is bought at a cost to whatever is cut and hollowed.
- What does Pan destroy in order to make the pipe?
- What does the poet seem to say that a poet loses by becoming a poet?
Playfulness and seriousness can live together
The poem's tune is bouncy and its images are comic, yet its last stanza reaches for pain. A good poem can delight and teach at the same time.
- Which images in the poem are playful, and which are serious?
- How does the rhythm help the poem to move from delight to sorrow?
Old myths can carry real questions
Ovid's story of Pan and the reeds was already ancient. Barrett Browning uses it to ask what it costs to make art and what part of the maker is lost in the making.
- What do you know about Pan from other stories, and how does this poem use him?
- Why might a Christian poet still use a pagan myth for such a question?
Context
The story behind the poem is the classical myth of Pan, the Arcadian god of shepherds and wild places, and the nymph Syrinx, whom he pursued; in Ovid's telling she was changed into reeds, from which he made the first pipes. Barrett Browning's version drops the pursuit and keeps the image of the reed cut down to become an instrument.
Composition
The poem was written in her last years in Italy and published in Cornhill Magazine in 1860. It was among the poems collected in Last Poems, which appeared in 1862 after her death.
Reception
It became a popular anthology piece, admired for its music and its closing twist, and was included in Quiller-Couch's Oxford Book of English Verse in 1900.
Comparisons
- Ode on a Grecian Urn
Both poems ask what art is, and both use a classical scene; Keats finds that art preserves, while Barrett Browning finds that art is made at a cost.
- Kubla Khan
Coleridge's poem treats poetic inspiration as a vision beyond the maker's control; Barrett Browning's treats it as something carved painfully from living nature.
- The Odyssey
The Odyssey remembers old gods and nymphs of the wild with respect; this poem takes one such god and shows him as maker and half-beast.
Quotes
Frequently cited
“What was he doing, the great god Pan, Down in the reeds by the river?”
Frequently cited
“Sweet, sweet, sweet, O Pan! Piercing sweet by the river! Blinding sweet, O great god Pan!”
Frequently cited
“Yet half a beast is the great god Pan, To laugh as he sits by the river, Making a poet out of a man:”
Frequently cited
“The true gods sigh for the cost and pain-- For the reed which grows nevermore again As a reed with the reeds of the river.”
For Students
A reading companion for classical Christian high school students. See the student guide.
Reading Guide
Watch for
- The refrain at the end of each stanza, which brings the reader back to the river.
- How the poem moves from physical action to music and then to reflection.
- The phrase half a beast and what it says about the making of a poet.
Key terms and names
- Pan
- The Greek god of shepherds, flocks and wild places, shown with the legs and horns of a goat.
- Reed pipe
- A simple wind instrument made from a hollow reed with holes, associated with Pan.
- Refrain
- A line or phrase repeated at the end of each stanza, here the river.
- Ban
- An old word meaning curse or ruin, as in the phrase scattering ban.
Seminar Questions
- Comprehension What does Pan do to the reed and the river before he makes the pipe?
- Comprehension What happens to the lilies and the dragon-fly when Pan begins to play?
- Interpretation Why does the poet call Pan half a beast, and what does this say about the source of art?
- Interpretation What do the true gods sigh for in the last stanza?
- Big Question Does great art always cost something, and who pays?
- Big Question Can a Christian read a poem about a pagan god with profit, and what should the reader keep in mind?
Faith Connections
- John 12:24 (Scripture)
Jesus says a grain of wheat must fall into the ground and die to bear much fruit. The poem's idea that something must be cut down to make music is a distant echo of the principle that fruitfulness comes through loss.
- Psalm 137:1-4 (Scripture)
The exiles hang their harps and cannot sing in a strange land, and the psalm shows how music comes out of suffering and cannot be commanded; the poem's pipe is made from pain in a similar way.
Logic and Rhetoric
Central argument: The poem argues that music and poetry are made by cutting something living into an instrument, and that the gods themselves lament the cost of that making.
Rhetorical device: Refrain. The river returns at the end of nearly every stanza, tying the playful narrative to the closing sorrow.
Debate: Resolved: Beautiful art is worth the cost it demands of those who make it.
Memory Work
What was he doing, the great god Pan, Down in the reeds by the river?
Yet half a beast is the great god Pan, To laugh as he sits by the river, Making a poet out of a man:
Writing Prompts
Essay: Write an essay on what A Musical Instrument says about the cost of making art, using at least three lines from the poem.
Comparison with Ode on a Grecian Urn: Compare how Barrett Browning and Keats think about what art preserves and what it costs.
Medical Lens
The poem does not address medical matters.
Creative Prompts
- Essay
Write an essay on how the last stanza changes what we think the poem has been about, and whether the cost it names is worth paying for art.
- Poetry
Write a short poem of six or seven lines in which something is changed or destroyed so that something beautiful can be made.
- Classroom
Read the poem aloud and mark the places where the music of the poem imitates the playing of the pipe.
- Fiction
Retell the story of Pan and the reed from the point of view of the reed.
Further Reading
- Metamorphoses, Book I (Pan and Syrinx), Ovid
The classical source for the myth of Pan and the reeds.
- Last Poems, Elizabeth Barrett Browning
The 1862 collection that includes this poem.
- Aurora Leigh, Elizabeth Barrett Browning
Her verse novel on the making of a woman poet.
Verification notes
The text follows the Oxford Book of English Verse (1900, no. 687) in Gutenberg #66619, and the first-printing details (Cornhill Magazine, 1860; Last Poems, 1862) come from standard bibliographies of the poet; they were not checked against page images. Quotes were checked against the hosted text.
No verification flags recorded.