Work record

The Constitution of Liberty

Also known as: Constitution of Liberty · Hayek's Constitution of Liberty · Why I Am Not a Conservative

1960 · Postwar Contemporary · Political Theory · English

Read this when law must bind the lawmaker, and Hayek asks what a constitution of liberty actually requires.

CopyrightedFive-minute digest

Abstract

Written
Written in the 1950s; completed May 1959; published February 1960
Setting
The postwar decades of the managed economy and the expanding welfare state; Chiefly Britain and the United States, with historical chapters on Athens, Rome, England, America and Germany
Country
United States (author born in Austria-Hungary; a British subject)
Language
English
Genre
Political and legal philosophy
Form
Treatise in an introduction, three parts of twenty-four chapters, and a postscript
Recommended
Grades 11–12 (Companion guide only; a long, demanding treatise for strong seniors. No text stored.)

Background. Readers of Hayek's 1944 polemic had asked for something more than alarm: a principled account of what a liberal state may and may not do. Working in Chicago through the 1950s, he supplied one, at length and with extensive notes, addressed less to specialists than to the educated citizen who must decide what government is for.

Thesis. Because each of us knows so little of what others know, a society progresses by letting people act on their own knowledge. That requires a protected private sphere, and the protection holds only where officials, legislators included, are restrained by general rules announced beforehand and applied without favor.

Development. Part I weighs reason against tradition and separates market value from moral desert. Part II offers a history of lawful government, from the Greek city through the common law and the American framers to German administrative law, and an account of its erosion. Part III tests unions, pensions, taxes, currency, housing, farming and schooling against the principle.

Use. No text or quotations are stored here. Strong seniors can read selected chapters beside The Road to Serfdom and Capitalism and Freedom. Teachers should press the question Hayek leaves open: whether evolved custom can carry the weight of morality without a law above it.

Key figures

  • F. A. Hayek: Austrian-born economist and philosopher at the University of Chicago
  • John Stuart Mill: Victorian liberal whom Hayek studied closely and partly answers
  • Edmund Burke: Whig statesman in whose tradition Hayek places himself
  • The American Founders: Framers of written constitutional limits on every branch of government

Summary

The Constitution of Liberty, published by the University of Chicago Press in February 1960, is F. A. Hayek's fullest positive statement of the free society. The Road to Serfdom (1944) had been a warning: comprehensive economic planning, however well meant, tends to concentrate power and to replace known rules with official discretion. Critics answered that a warning is not a program. Where, they asked, should a liberal draw the line between good and bad government action? This long book is Hayek's answer. The argument begins with knowledge. No person, and no government, can know more than a small share of what millions of people know about their own circumstances, skills and opportunities. Freedom matters chiefly because it lets that scattered knowledge be used, and because it leaves room for the unforeseen discoveries on which progress depends. Hayek defines liberty as the condition in which a person is not subject to coercion by the arbitrary will of another, and he holds that coercion can be reduced, though never abolished, only when the state itself is bound by general, abstract rules that are known in advance and apply equally to all. The book has three parts. The first, on the value of freedom, treats reason and tradition, responsibility, equality, merit and majority rule; it insists that equality before the law is a different thing from equality of condition, and that markets reward the value of a service to others rather than moral merit. The second traces the rule of law from ancient Athens and Rome through English common law, American constitutionalism and the German idea of the Rechtsstaat, and describes its decline in the twentieth century. The third applies the principle to labor unions, social security, taxation, money, housing, agriculture and education, asking in each case whether the state is acting by general rule or by particular command. A postscript, Why I Am Not a Conservative, separates Hayek's liberalism from a conservatism that resists change without offering principles of its own. For a classical Christian school the book is worth the effort. It is serious, learned and fair to opponents, and it gives students a vocabulary—rule of law, coercion, general rules, spontaneous order—for questions they will face as citizens. It also invites a disagreement worth having. Hayek grounds moral rules chiefly in tradition that has proved itself over time, not in a law given by God and knowable by reason. Read beside Lewis's The Abolition of Man or the natural-law tradition, his humility about human reason can be honored while his account of where moral rules come from is examined. The work is under copyright; this library stores no text and no quotations.

Virtues in this work

  • Justice: Hayek's central demand is that coercive law apply equally to all, the ruler as well as the ruled, without favor to persons.
  • Humility: The case for freedom begins with an admission of how little any person or government can know about the lives of millions.
  • Prudence: Each policy in Part III is weighed case by case against a principle, rather than accepted or rejected wholesale.

Plot or Argument

  • Introduction: from warning to program

    Hayek sets out to restate, for a generation that had largely abandoned them, the ideals of a free society: what liberty is, why it matters, and what institutions protect it. The book is meant as a positive program, not only a critique of planning.

  • Part I: The Value of Freedom

    Eight chapters define liberty as freedom from arbitrary coercion, argue that freedom matters because of our unavoidable ignorance, defend the role of evolved traditions, tie freedom to personal responsibility, and distinguish equality before the law from equality of material condition and market value from moral merit.

  • Part II: Freedom and the Law

    Hayek contrasts general laws with specific commands, traces the ideal of the rule of law through Greek, Roman, English and American history and the German Rechtsstaat, describes safeguards such as generality, equality and the separation of powers, and argues that the ideal declined in the twentieth century.

  • Part III: Freedom in the Welfare State

    The final chapters take up labor unions, social security, taxation and redistribution, the monetary framework, housing and town planning, agriculture and natural resources, and education and research. Hayek accepts some public services and a floor of provision while objecting to coercive, discretionary or redistributive schemes.

  • Postscript: Why I Am Not a Conservative

    Hayek explains why he will not call himself a conservative. He describes conservatism as distrustful of change and lacking principles of its own, and places himself with the older liberal tradition he associates with the English Whigs.

    Lessons

    • Law that binds the lawmaker

      Hayek's central claim is that liberty depends less on who rules than on how rule is exercised: by general, known rules that bind the government as well as the governed. Students can test this against Scripture's demand for impartial judgment and against the American Constitution.

      • What is the difference between a general rule and a particular command?
      • Can a law passed by a majority still violate the rule of law?
      • Where in American history has a court or constitution restrained a popular majority?
    • Humility about what we know

      Hayek's case for freedom begins with ignorance: no planner can gather the knowledge scattered among millions of people. This is a lesson in intellectual humility, though students should ask whether humility about policy also requires humility about moral truth.

      • Why does Hayek think our ignorance is an argument for freedom rather than for control?
      • Is there a difference between humility about economics and doubt about morality?
      • How does Lewis's The Abolition of Man answer the question of where moral rules come from?
    • Value, merit and justice

      Hayek insists that a market rewards the value of a service to others, not the moral worth of the person who provides it. A Christian reader can accept the distinction and still ask what charity, honor and justice require of those whom the market rewards.

      • Why does Hayek want to keep market reward and moral merit apart?
      • Is it unfair that a hard-working person may earn less than a lucky one?
      • What obligations does wealth carry that no law could enforce?
    • Liberal, conservative and Christian

      The postscript separates Hayek's principled liberalism from a conservatism of habit. Students can weigh his critique against Burke and ask where a Christian's loyalty to permanent things fits between the two.

      • What does Hayek think conservatism lacks?
      • Would Burke accept Hayek's description of conservatism?
      • Can a person be both a defender of tradition and a defender of free change?

    Context

    The book appeared at the height of postwar confidence in the managed economy and the welfare state, in Britain, Western Europe and the United States. Hayek, who had moved to the University of Chicago's Committee on Social Thought in 1950, wrote it partly to answer friendly and hostile critics of The Road to Serfdom who had asked what positive principles should guide government. It belongs with the founding texts of the postwar revival of classical liberalism, alongside the work of the Mont Pelerin Society that Hayek had founded in 1947.

    Composition

    Hayek worked on the book through the 1950s, a decade in which he also studied John Stuart Mill closely; he completed it in May 1959 and published it with the University of Chicago Press in February 1960. In 2011 the Press issued a definitive edition, edited by Ronald Hamowy, as volume 17 of The Collected Works of F. A. Hayek (paperback ISBN 9780226315393).

    Reception

    Reviewers took the book seriously and disagreed sharply. Sidney Hook criticized its preference for tradition over deliberate social reason; Lionel Robbins admired much of it while warning against uncritical respect for inherited institutions; Frank Knight faulted its treatment of democracy. It nonetheless became one of the standard statements of classical-liberal political philosophy and has remained in print.

    Comparisons

    • The Road to Serfdom

      The Road to Serfdom is Hayek's 1944 warning against comprehensive planning; The Constitution of Liberty is his later positive program, built around the rule of law that the earlier book's sixth chapter only sketched.

    • Capitalism and Freedom

      Friedman's 1962 book, written two years later in the same Chicago circle, turns many of Hayek's principles into specific policy proposals in shorter, plainer chapters.

    • On Liberty

      Hayek studied Mill closely while writing this book. Both defend a protected sphere of individual action, but Hayek grounds it in the rule of law and evolved tradition rather than in Mill's utilitarian case for individuality.

    • The Federalist Papers

      Hayek's chapter on the American contribution treats constitutionalism—written limits on all powers, including the legislature—as a major advance; the Federalist is the classic defense of that design.

    • Democracy in America

      Tocqueville's fear that democratic majorities and a benevolent central power can soften a people into dependence anticipates Hayek's chapters on majority rule and the welfare state.

    • Freedom and the Law

      Leoni, a colleague in the Mont Pelerin Society, pushes Hayek's contrast between general law and command further and prefers law found by judges to law made by legislatures.

    • The Burke-Paine Debate on the French Revolution

      Hayek's postscript rejects the conservative label while drawing on the Whig tradition Burke spoke for; the Burke-Paine exchange lets students weigh tradition against abstract rights before reading Hayek's middle path.

    • The Abolition of Man

      Lewis argues that moral rules are objective and not the product of conditioning or custom; set beside Hayek's account of evolved moral tradition, it frames the deepest question the book leaves open.

    Quotes

    For Students

    A reading companion for classical Christian high school students. See the student guide.

    Reading Guide

    Watch for

    • How Hayek defines liberty and coercion, and what he deliberately leaves out of the definition.
    • Every place where he contrasts a general rule with a particular command.
    • The difference he draws between equality before the law and equality of condition.
    • Where he accepts a role for government, and the test he uses to decide.
    • How the postscript changes the way you read the earlier praise of tradition.

    Key terms and names

    Rule of law
    The principle that government acts only by general rules, known in advance, that bind officials as well as citizens.
    Coercion
    For Hayek, control of a person's circumstances by another's will so that he must serve the other's ends rather than his own.
    Spontaneous order
    An order, such as a market or a language, that arises from many people following rules, not from one designing mind.
    Rechtsstaat
    The German ideal of a state bound by law, which Hayek treats as one stage in the history of the rule of law.
    Constitutionalism
    The limiting of all powers, including the legislature, by a higher written law.
    Welfare state
    A state that provides services and income security on a large scale; Hayek judges its parts by whether they use general rules or discretion.

    Seminar Questions

    1. Comprehension How does Hayek define liberty, and why does he link it to the absence of arbitrary coercion?
    2. Comprehension What are the three parts of the book, and what does each attempt?
    3. Interpretation Why does Hayek think our ignorance is the strongest argument for freedom?
    4. Interpretation Why does Hayek refuse to call himself a conservative, and is his description of conservatism fair?
    5. Interpretation How can a democratic majority violate the rule of law, according to Hayek?
    6. Big Question Do moral rules come from tradition that has proved itself, or from a law above all traditions?
    7. Big Question What does a free people owe one another that no government should compel?

    Faith Connections

    • Leviticus 19:15 (Scripture)

      The command to judge without favoring either the poor or the great is an ancient form of equality before the law, the principle Hayek places at the center of a free society.

    • 1 Kings 21 (Scripture)

      Ahab and Jezebel take Naboth's vineyard by fraud and power. The story shows why law must bind rulers as well as subjects, and why property can protect a family against the strong.

    • Proverbs 3:5-7 (Scripture)

      The warning not to lean on one's own understanding parallels Hayek's humility about human reason, while rooting that humility in trust in God rather than in tradition alone.

    • Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiae I-II, questions 90-97, on law (Great Conversation)

      Aquinas defines human law as an ordinance of reason for the common good, made by proper authority and grounded in natural and eternal law; students can compare this with Hayek's general rules and ask what grounds them.

    Logic and Rhetoric

    Central argument: Because no one can know enough to direct a society, freedom is the condition for using dispersed knowledge and for progress; freedom in turn requires that coercion be limited to the enforcement of general, known rules that bind the state itself. Each policy must be judged by that test.

    Rhetorical device: historical genealogy. Part II argues for the rule of law by tracing its development from Athens and Rome through England and America, presenting the ideal as an inheritance to be recovered rather than an invention.

    Debate: Resolved: That equality before the law is incompatible with government efforts to secure equality of condition.

    Writing Prompts

    Essay: Explain Hayek's distinction between general rules and particular commands, then apply it to one current law or proposal. Defend your judgment against the strongest objection.

    Comparison with The Road to Serfdom: Compare The Road to Serfdom with The Constitution of Liberty. What does the later book add to the earlier warning, and which is the more persuasive case for a free society?

    Creative Prompts

    • Classroom

      Give students five proposed laws from local or national news. In groups, decide whether each is a general rule applying equally to all or a particular command aimed at chosen people or outcomes, and defend the hard cases.

    • Dialogue

      Write a conversation between Hayek and Edmund Burke after Burke has read the postscript, Why I Am Not a Conservative. Let each man state the other's view fairly before answering it.

    • Essay

      Hayek separates the value of a service to others from the moral merit of the person who provides it. Explain the distinction and argue whether a just society should ever try to reward merit directly.

    Further Reading

    • The Road to Serfdom, F. A. Hayek

      The 1944 warning that this book turns into a positive program.

    • Law, Legislation and Liberty, F. A. Hayek

      Hayek's later three-volume work on law, social justice and the political order.

    • Capitalism and Freedom, Milton Friedman

    • The Abolition of Man, C. S. Lewis

    • Hayek's Challenge: An Intellectual Biography of F. A. Hayek, Bruce Caldwell

    Verification notes

    Copyrighted; no text and no quotations are stored. The three-part structure, the chapter subjects and the postscript title follow the published table of contents. Completion in May 1959, February 1960 publication by the University of Chicago Press, Hayek's 1950 move to the Committee on Social Thought, and the reviews by Sidney Hook, Lionel Robbins and Frank Knight follow standard accounts (University of Chicago Press, Caldwell's scholarship, and general reference summaries). The 2011 definitive edition, edited by Ronald Hamowy as Collected Works volume 17, and its paperback ISBN were confirmed from the publisher and BiblioVault. Descriptions of the argument are paraphrase, not quotation.

    • Chapter-by-chapter policy positions in Part III (for example, on progressive taxation and education finance) should be checked against a print copy before the plot outline is expanded.
    • The exact wording of Hayek's definition of coercion and of liberty, if a future revision wants to quote rather than paraphrase.