Work record

The Golden Bowl

Name: The Golden Bowl
Author: Henry James

Henry James

1904 · Early 20th Century · Novel · English

Public domainRead full text Download EPUB Five-minute digest

Abstract

Written: 1902-1904
Setting: About 1900; London and the country house of Fawns
Author: Henry James
Country: United States / England
Language: English
Genre: Psychological novel
Form: Novel in two books ('The Prince' and 'The Princess')
Recommended: Grades 11–12 (Very demanding late style; adult themes of adultery; upper high school.)

Situation. A wealthy American collector and his only child live in England. The daughter weds a charming Roman aristocrat with no fortune, and she then persuades her widowed father to marry her clever, poor school friend.

Secret. The friend and the aristocrat were lovers before either marriage. Left together while father and daughter stay inseparable, they renew their intimacy, while the father and daughter, absorbed in each other, notice nothing for a long time.

Symbol. Early on the former lovers find a gilded crystal vessel in a London antique shop; he refuses it because it is flawed. Years later the wife buys it, and the dealer's recognition reveals the affair.

Resolution. Rather than make a scene, the wife works by silence and tact to regain her husband and to send her father and stepmother to America, at great cost to everyone.

Reading. The last novel James finished, written in his most elaborate late style. It treats marriage, money and moral knowledge and suits only advanced readers. Students who persevere will find in it a searching portrait of how love, deceit and forgiveness work inside a family, and of how a quiet person can become strong.

Main characters

Maggie Verver: A rich American heiress who marries an Italian prince.
Prince Amerigo: An Italian nobleman of ancient family and little money.
Charlotte Stant: A beautiful American who becomes Maggie's stepmother.
Adam Verver: An American millionaire and collector.
Fanny Assingham: A friend who arranged the marriages and comments on them.

Summary

The Golden Bowl, published in 1904, is the last novel Henry James completed and the most intricate of his late works. Adam Verver, an immensely rich American widower and art collector, lives in England with his devoted daughter Maggie. Maggie marries Prince Amerigo, an impoverished Italian nobleman who is, in effect, another of her father's acquisitions. Before the wedding the Prince and Maggie's friend Charlotte Stant, a beautiful but penniless American who was once the Prince's lover, go shopping together for a present and find in a small shop a gilded crystal bowl. The Prince sees that it has a crack and will not buy it. To keep Maggie's father from loneliness after her marriage, Maggie encourages him to marry Charlotte, and so the four are bound together. Because father and daughter remain inseparable, the Prince and Charlotte are thrown into each other's company and resume their affair. The second half of the novel turns to Maggie's consciousness. Slowly she perceives the truth, and her suspicion is confirmed when she buys the very same golden bowl and the shopkeeper recognizes the photographs of the Prince and Charlotte. Her friend Fanny Assingham smashes the bowl on the floor, and Maggie resolves to save her marriage without open accusation, refusing to let her father learn what has happened. By silence, tact and quiet strength she wins back her husband, keeps her father's peace, and arranges for Adam and Charlotte to return to America, a separation that is painful for everyone. In the final scene the Prince tells Maggie that he sees nothing but her. The novel is a study of marriage, money, knowledge and moral power, of whether goodness can act shrewdly without becoming manipulative. It contains adultery as a central subject, though nothing is described explicitly, and its very long sentences make it suitable only for advanced high-school readers.

Virtues in this work

Fortitude: Maggie bears her knowledge without breaking the family apart.
Prudence: She acts with careful judgment to save her marriage.

Plot or Argument

Book First: the marriages
The Prince marries Maggie; Charlotte returns; the shopping trip finds the cracked bowl; Adam marries Charlotte.
The affair
Left together while father and daughter remain inseparable, the Prince and Charlotte resume their affair.
Book Second: The Princess
Maggie grows aware of the affair, buys the bowl, sees it broken, and quietly restores her marriage while Adam takes Charlotte to America.

Characters

Maggie Verver, protagonist
A rich American heiress who marries an Italian prince.
Prince Amerigo, Maggie's husband
An Italian nobleman of ancient family and little money.
Charlotte Stant, Maggie's friend
A beautiful American who becomes Maggie's stepmother.
Adam Verver, Maggie's father
An American millionaire and collector.
Fanny Assingham, confidante
A friend who arranged the marriages and comments on them.

Lessons

The flawed object
The cracked bowl is a symbol of the marriages: beautiful on the surface, flawed beneath. Students can follow the symbol through the book.
- What does the Prince notice about the bowl?
- Why does Fanny break it?
- What does the bowl stand for?
Related across the library
- San Antonio Independent School District v. Rodriguez, Full Text
  suspect classifications If as previous decisions have indicated strict scrutiny means that the State's system is not entitled to the usual presumption of validity that the State rather than the complainants must carry a heavy burden of justification that the State must demonstrate that its educational system has been structured with precision and is tailored narrowly to serve legitimate objectives and that it has selected the less drastic means for effectuating its objectives the Texas financing system and its c...
- The Varieties of Religious Experience, Source
  The Varieties of Religious Experience A Study in Human Nature Being the Gifford Lectures on Natural Religion Delivered at Edinburgh in By William James Longmans Green And Co New York London Bombay Calcutta and Madras CONTENTS Preface Lecture I Religion And Neurology Lecture II Circumscription of the Topic Lecture III The Reality Of The Unseen Lectures IV and V The Religion Of Healthy Mindedness Lectures VI And VII The Sick Soul Lecture VIII The Divided Self And The Process Of Its Unification Lecture IX Conversio...
- The Reformation, Lesson: Erasmus, Luther and the middle way
  Erasmus, Luther and the middle way. Durant clearly sympathizes with Erasmus, who mocked abuses and edited the Greek New Testament but would not break with Rome and debated Luther on free will. Their exchange of 1524-25 lets students compare two Christian humanists' understanding of grace, reform and peace, and ask whether moderation in that crisis was wisdom or evasion.
- The Consolation of Philosophy, Source
  superhuman dignity and beauty who by a succession of discourses convinces him of the vanity of regret for the lost gifts of fortune raises his mind once more to the contemplation of the true good and makes clear to him the mystery of the world's moral government INDEX OF VERSE INTERLUDES BOOK I THE SORROWS OF BOETHIUS SONG PAGE I BOETHIUS' COMPLAINT II HIS DESPONDENCY III THE MISTS DISPELLED IV NOTHING CAN SUBDUE VIRTUE V BOETHIUS' PRAYER VI ALL THINGS HAVE THEIR NEEDFUL ORDER VII THE PERTURBATIONS OF PASSION BO...
- Ethics, Postulates
  referred to pain is called compassion cf III xxii note when it is referred to desire it is called emulation which is nothing else but the desire of anything engendered in us by the fact that we conceive that others have the like desire Corollary I If we conceive that anyone whom we have hitherto regarded with no emotion pleasurably affects something similar to ourselves we shall be affected with love towards him If on the other hand we conceive that he painfully affects the same we shall be affected with hatred...
Knowledge and power
Maggie grows from innocence to knowledge and uses it to act. James asks whether her methods are wise or manipulative.
- How does Maggie learn the truth?
- Why doesn't she accuse anyone openly?
- Is her silence a virtue?
Related across the library
- On the American Indians (De Indis), Lesson: The law among nations
  The law among nations. Vitoria spoke of rights that all peoples share, such as travel and trade. This was a foundation of international law.
- The Law, Lesson: When law becomes a prize
  When law becomes a prize. Bastiat explains the passion of politics by the scope of law: if law can give benefits to whoever controls it, every class will fight for control. He uses this to explain the quarrel over the suffrage in France and the two dangerous questions in the United States.
- Laws, Lesson: Rulers are servants of the law
  Rulers are servants of the law. The Athenian calls magistrates ministers or servants of the law and says that a state where law is above the rulers receives every blessing, while one where the law has no authority is on the road to ruin. Book III makes the same point historically about Persia and Athens.
- The Institutes of Justinian, Lesson: Three kinds of law
  Three kinds of law. Title II distinguishes natural law, the law of nations and civil law. The text admits tension between them: slavery comes from the law of nations yet is said to be against nature. Students see an ancient legal system naming a principle above its own practice.
- Inaugural Address (Lyndon Baines Johnson), Lesson: Abundance and accountability
  Abundance and accountability. The justice section pairs each American abundance with a failure: wealth beside poverty, harvest beside hunger, "healing miracles" beside neighbors left unattended, learning beside illiteracy. The structure argues that plenty increases obligation, the same logic as the later warning about judgment on the favored.
People as possessions
Adam collects art and, in a sense, people. The novel questions what money can buy.
- In what ways is the Prince 'acquired'?
- How does Charlotte feel about being sent to America?
- Can love be bought?
Related across the library
- The Wealth of Nations, Lesson: Specialization multiplies what labour can produce
  Specialization multiplies what labour can produce. The pin factory shows that dividing a task among many hands multiplies output far beyond what the same people could make alone. Smith traces much of the difference between rich and poor nations to how far this division has gone, and how far markets allow it to go.
- Louise de la Vallière, Lesson: Grief and faithfulness
  Grief and faithfulness. Raoul's love does not change when he loses Louise. His sorrow raises questions about how to bear disappointment.
- The Cost of Discipleship, Lesson: Community as a visible alternative
  Community as a visible alternative. The last part insists that the church must take up physical space in the world, with its own order and discipline, rather than being an inward association. Finkenwalde was Bonhoeffer's experiment in that visibility.
- Thoughts on Government and Selected Letters, Late Adams-Jefferson correspondence
  Aging, grief, memory, and mortality shape the retrospective friendship.
- Dracula, To My Dear Friend Hommy-Beg
  forth as simple fact There is throughout no statement of past things wherein memory may err for all the records chosen are exactly contemporary given from the standpoints and within the range of knowledge of those who made them DRACULA CHAPTER I JONATHAN HARKER S JOURNAL Kept in shorthand May Bistritz Left Munich at P M on st May arriving at Vienna early next morning should have arrived at but train was an hour late Buda-Pesth seems a wonderful place from the glimpse which I got of it from the train and the litt...

Context

The novel completes the trio of James's late 'major phase', with The Wings of the Dove and The Ambassadors.

Composition

Published in New York in 1904 and in London in 1905; James revised it for the New York Edition in 1909.

Reception

Many readers found it impenetrable; critics later regarded it as one of the most ambitious psychological novels in English.

Marriage Money Wealth Love Desire Guilt Sin Innocence / Experience

Comparisons

The Ambassadors
Another late James novel told through a single searching consciousness.
The Portrait of a Lady
An earlier study of an American heiress and a marriage built on deception.

Quotes

“Why, it has a crack.”

— Henry James, The Golden Bowl, Book First, Part First, Chapter VI (Project Gutenberg #4264).Quote card

Elements, Books I-VI, Book III, Proposition XXXI
In a circle—(1). The angle in a semicircle is a right angle The first part of III.31, a result traditionally associated with Thales.
Opticks, Full Text
this put me upon observing the thickness of the Glass and considering whether the dimensions and proportions of the Rings may be truly derived from it by computation Obs I measured therefore the thickness of this concavo-convex Plate of Glass and found it every where of an Inch precisely Now by the sixth Observation of the first Part of this Book a thin Plate of Air transmits the brightest Light of the first Ring that is the bright yellow when its thickness is the th part of an Inch and by the tenth Observation...
The Prisoner of Chillon, Summary
The Prisoner of Chillon is a narrative poem in fourteen sections that Byron wrote in two days in June 1816 at Ouchy on Lake Geneva, after visiting the castle of Chillon with Percy Shelley. It is loosely based on François Bonivard, a Genevan patriot imprisoned in the castle's dungeon by the Duke of Savoy from 1530 to 1536, though Byron invents most of the story. The old prisoner tells his own tale. His hair is grey, but not with years: it turned grey in the dungeon. His father died at the stake for his faith, and...
The Gulag Archipelago, Summary
The Gulag Archipelago, 1918–1956: An Experiment in Literary Investigation is Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn's history of the Soviet system of prisons, labour camps and exile, which he likened to an archipelago of islands scattered across the country, visible only to those taken there. Written in secret between 1958 and 1968, it draws on Solzhenitsyn's own eight years as a prisoner and on the testimony of some two hundred and twenty-seven other former prisoners, together with published Soviet sources. It is not a novel b...
Autobiography and Poor Richard's Almanack, S. J. M. C. T. C. H
to disobey those instructions how that was brought about I shall show hereafter My acts in Morris's time military etc Marg note But I am got forward too fast with my story there are still some transactions to be mention'd that happened during the administration of Governor Morris War being in a manner commenced with France the government of Massachusetts Bay projected an attack upon Crown Point and sent Mr Quincy to Pennsylvania and Mr Pownall afterward Governor Pownall to New York to solicit assistance As I was...

“Everything’s terrible, cara, in the heart of man.”

— Henry James, The Golden Bowl, Book Second, Part Sixth, Chapter XLI (Project Gutenberg #4264).Quote card

The Hunchback of Notre-Dame (Notre-Dame de Paris), Book Fifth, Chapter II, This Will Kill That
The invention of printing is the greatest event in history. It is the mother of revolution. Hugo's argument that printing has replaced architecture as the principal expression of humanity.
Ecclesiastical History of the English People, Full Text
Bede s Ecclesiastical History of England A Revised Translation With Introduction Life and Notes By A M Sellar Late Vice-Principal of Lady Margaret Hall Oxford London George Bell and Sons CONTENTS Editor s Preface Introduction Life Of Bede Errata Preface Book I Chap I Of the Situation of Britain and Ireland and of their ancient inhabitants Chap II How Caius Julius Caesar was the first Roman that came into Britain Chap III How Claudius the second of the Romans who came into Britain brought the islands Orcades into...
The Life of Samuel Johnson, 1777 (Aetat. 68): at Ashbourne, September
when a man is tired of London, he is tired of life; for there is in London all that life can afford. Boswell wonders whether he might grow tired of London if he lived there; Johnson answers that no intellectual man is willing to leave it.
The Life of Samuel Johnson, 1755 (Aetat. 46)
Ignorance, madam, pure ignorance. His answer to a lady who asked why the Dictionary defined pastern as the knee of a horse.
The Sickness Unto Death, Part Two, B
Despair over one's sin and of forgiveness as intensifications of despair, relevant to religious guilt and scrupulosity in clinical settings.

For Students

A reading companion for classical Christian high school students. See the student guide.

Reading Guide

Watch for

The shopping trip and the bowl's crack.
Why Maggie urges her father to marry.
The moment Maggie buys the bowl.
Fanny Assingham's smashing of the bowl.
The parting of father and daughter.

Key terms and names

Late style: The long, qualified sentences of James's last novels.
Symbol: An object that stands for a larger idea.
Connoisseur: An expert collector of art.
Adultery: Unfaithfulness in marriage, the hidden subject of the novel.

Seminar Questions

Comprehension What happened between the Prince and Charlotte before the novel begins?
Comprehension Why does Adam marry Charlotte?
Comprehension How does Maggie confirm her suspicions?
Interpretation Why is the novel divided into 'The Prince' and 'The Princess'?
Interpretation Is Maggie's victory a happy one?
Big Question Can love that has been betrayed be restored?

Faith Connections

Hebrews 13:4 (Scripture)
Marriage is honourable in all; the novel examines a marriage broken and repaired.
Matthew 10:16 (Scripture)
Wise as serpents and harmless as doves; compare Maggie's methods.

Logic and Rhetoric

Central argument: A marriage built on appearances is like a gilded bowl with a hidden crack; only knowledge and quiet moral strength can repair it.

Rhetorical device: central symbol. The flawed bowl appears at the beginning, the middle and the crisis of the story.

Debate: Resolved: that Maggie was right not to confront her husband openly.

Memory Work

Why, it has a crack.
Book First, Part First, Chapter VI. The Prince's short sentence names the novel's central symbol.

Writing Prompts

Essay: Is Maggie Verver a heroine or a manipulator? Use specific scenes.

Comparison with The Ambassadors: Compare Maggie's growth in knowledge with Strether's in The Ambassadors.

Creative Prompts

Essay
Explain how the golden bowl works as a symbol in the novel.
Dialogue
Write the conversation Maggie never has with Charlotte.
Classroom
Chart what each of the four main characters knows at the end of Book First and at the end of Book Second.