Work record
On Anger
SenecaDe Ira; Of Anger; On Anger (De Ira); Seneca on Anger; Three Books on AngerOn Anger by Seneca (c. AD 41–49)On Anger is Seneca's long treatise against the passion he calls the most hideous and wild of all.Also known as: De Ira · Of Anger · On Anger (De Ira) · Seneca on Anger · Three Books on Anger
c. AD 41–49 · Ancient · Philosophy · Latin
Read this when a quick temper threatens to rule you and you want a Roman cure.
Abstract
Background. A Roman philosopher and statesman writes at the request of a friend, who wants to know how to soothe the temper, in a period when the rage of rulers and of great men could cost many lives and when self-command was counted the chief mark of a ruler.
Argument. Anger is held to be a short madness, contrary to the gentle nature of man and never needed by reason. The work answers its defenders, including Aristotle, separates the first shock from consent, and then sets out practical rules for prevention and cure, with stories of cruel kings and patient men to teach by example.
Ideas. Students are invited to ask where anger begins in the will, how a habit of gentleness is formed, what justice requires of those who correct, and whether any anger can be right. The Christian reader will compare this account of self-government with the teaching of Scripture on slowness to wrath.
Text. The text is Aubrey Stewart's 1889 English translation, and each quotation in the guide was matched to the hosted text. It is a pagan work whose remedy is reason, so teachers can pair it with Proverbs and James and with the library's study guide, seminar questions and memory work.
Key figures
- Seneca: Roman Stoic writer and the voice of the treatise
- Novatus: The friend, traditionally Seneca's brother, to whom the books are addressed
- Sextius: Philosopher whose nightly self-examination is held up as a model
- Gaius Caesar: The emperor called Caligula, whose cruelty serves as a warning in the third book
Summary
On Anger is Seneca's long treatise against the passion he calls the most hideous and wild of all. It is written in three books to Novatus, who had asked how anger might be soothed. The first book defines anger as a desire to repay a wrong with pain and argues that it is contrary to the gentle and social nature of man. Seneca meets the defenders of anger, who say that it is a spur to courage and a fit answer to wickedness, with a plain reply: reason needs no ally it cannot rule, a good man corrects out of judgment and not rage, and courage that has to be lashed up by temper is not strength. The second book separates the first involuntary shock of the body from the consent of the will that makes true anger, and then turns to prevention. It speaks of the training of children, the avoidance of weariness and hunger, the habit of not believing every report, and the need to see that most offences are small or are done in ignorance. Here also Seneca gives his best known counsel, that delay is the greatest remedy. The third book supplies the cure by practice. It describes the signs of the angry face, urges the reader to hide and resist his first impulses, and tells stories of cruel men whom anger drove to savage deeds, among them Persian kings, Alexander and Gaius Caesar (Caligula), and of patient men who bore insult without revenge, such as Philip of Macedon and Cato. It also commends Sextius's evening examination of conscience. Seneca ends by asking how little time men have to hurt one another and urging them to practise humanity while they live. The treatise is a pagan Stoic work, and its remedy is the discipline of reason, not grace. Christian readers will see in it a strong analogue of the biblical teaching on the slow temper and the soft answer, while noting that Scripture places the cure for anger in the fear of God, in forgiveness received and given, and in the work of the Spirit. The English version hosted here is Aubrey Stewart's 1889 translation, which keeps Seneca's own numbered sections. It has been cleaned from an old scan and is presented as a complete text. It repays slow reading in short passages, and it fits naturally beside the Letters and the Meditations as a school of self-government.
Virtues in this work
- Temperance: Seneca's whole programme is the government of the passions by reason, with practical rules for the habit of a gentle temper.
- Prudence: Delay, doubt of rumour and the nightly examination of conscience are acts of prudence in judging what has been done to us.
- Justice: He teaches that correction looks to the good of the offender and of others, not to the pleasure of revenge.
- Magnanimity: He argues that true greatness of mind is shown by an unmoved temper and by pardon, and that rage is only a false likeness of strength.
Plot or Argument
- Book I: what anger is and whether it may be defended
Seneca paints the hideous effects of anger, defines it, shows that it is against nature, and answers those who defend it as useful against enemies or as a spur to virtue.
- Book II: the first movements and the habit of anger
He separates the involuntary first shock from the consent of the will, argues that the wise man does not become angry, and answers the claim that anger helps the orator, the soldier and the ruler.
- Book II: prevention by education and habit
Seneca recommends the right bringing-up of children, avoidance of weariness, hunger and thirst, and the choice of gentle companions, since a hot temper is formed over time.
- Book II: patience with the faults of others
He counsels that we should not believe every report, should judge the offender fairly, remember our own faults, and give a delay before judgment.
- Book III: the reach of anger and how to avoid it (sections I–XIII)
The third book begins the cure by showing how widely anger spreads, how ruinous it is, and how a man may avoid the occasions of it. It advises him to choose quiet work, to hear and see less, and to fight himself.
- Book III: cruel kings and patient men (sections XIV–XXIX)
Seneca tells the stories of Cambyses, Harpagus, Cyrus, Alexander and Gaius Caesar as warnings, and of Philip, Cato and Diogenes as models of patience under insult.
- Book III: the causes of anger and its remedies (sections XXX–XXXVIII)
He lists the causes of quarrels, among them money, food and drink, and wounded pride, and recommends the evening examination of Sextius and the habit of turning an insult aside.
- Book III: against revenge, for humanity (sections XXXIX–XLIII)
The treatise ends with advice on soothing the anger of others and a closing appeal: life is short, so let us practise humanity and be a terror to no one.
Lessons
Anger is a vice to be ruled, not a servant to be employed
Seneca argues that reason needs no help from a passion it cannot control. For students of the classical tradition this is a lesson in self-government: the soul is governed by reason and the will, and the passions are trained to follow.
- Why does Seneca say reason should not call anger to its aid?
- Which of the defenders of anger do you find most persuasive, and how does Seneca reply?
The first shock is not yet anger
Seneca distinguishes the first involuntary movement of the body from the consent of the mind that makes anger. The distinction helps students see where the work of self-control begins: at the moment of assent.
- Where does Seneca say anger begins, and where does it become a choice?
- How might a student practise stopping between the first shock and the answer?
Delay and judgment
The treatise gives practical rules: wait, believe no rumour without proof, consider the offender's mind, and remember your own faults. These are the habits by which an angry person becomes a just one.
- Why does Seneca say delay is the greatest remedy?
- How can a student turn his own mistakes into a reason for patience with others?
Correction is not revenge
Seneca insists that punishment, when needed, aims at the improvement of the sinner and the safety of others, and not at the pleasure of the one who punishes. This is a useful start for discussions of justice, discipline and mercy.
- How does Seneca distinguish correction from revenge?
- When has discipline you received been just, and what made it so?
Mortality and gentleness
The closing appeal ties kindness to the shortness of life. Since we all die soon, quarrels waste the time we have.
- Why does Seneca end with death?
- How does the Christian hope of the resurrection give a different reason for gentleness?
Context
Seneca wrote in the Rome of Caligula, Claudius and Nero, where the anger of one man could end the lives of many. The Roman tradition prized self-command in the ruler, and Stoic teachers made the control of the passions a central part of moral education.
Composition
On Anger is usually dated between about 41 and AD 49, with the third book written after the death of Caligula, whose cruelty it describes. It is addressed to Novatus, traditionally identified as Seneca's elder brother, later known as Gallio; the identification and the dates are debated.
Reception
The treatise was widely read in the Middle Ages and the Renaissance, and its remedies were echoed in Christian writing on the vice of wrath. Aubrey Stewart's translation of 1889 appeared in Bohn's Classical Library with the other Minor Dialogues.
Comparisons
- Letters from a Stoic
The Letters return often to anger and to the nightly review of the day, and show Seneca applying the same discipline to his own temper in private counsel.
- Meditations
At the opening of Book II of the Meditations Marcus tells himself each morning that he will meet the idle, the thankless and the envious, and resolves not to be angry with them, which is the same preparation against offence that Seneca recommends.
- Discourses (selection) and Encheiridion
Epictetus teaches that we are disturbed by our opinions of events and not by events, which is the same root-cause analysis that Seneca uses for anger.
- On the Shortness of Life
The companion dialogue on the shortness of life uses the same appeal to mortality, and the two together form a short course in self-government.
- Summa Theologica
Aquinas treats anger as a passion that may be right in its object and measure, and as a vice when it is disordered, and so offers a Christian counter-argument to Seneca's rejection of all anger.
- The Nicomachean Ethics
Aristotle, whom Seneca criticises in the first book, holds that anger rightly measured is a virtue of the mean, and the debate is an early case of the question that Seneca takes up.
- On the Happy Life
The dialogue on the happy life gives Seneca's account of the good that anger and the other passions put at risk.
Quotes
Frequently cited
“Some of the wisest of men have in consequence of this called anger a short madness”
Frequently cited
“no wise man punishes any one because he has sinned, but that he may sin no more: for what is past cannot be recalled, but what is to come may be checked”
Frequently cited
“The greatest remedy for anger is delay; beg anger to grant you this at the first, not in order that it may pardon the offence, but that it may form a right judgment about it: if it delays, it will come to an end.”
Frequently cited
“Fight hard with yourself and if you cannot conquer anger, do not let it conquer you”
Frequently cited
“What bad habit of yours have you cured to-day? what vice have you checked? in what respect are you better?”
Frequently cited
“This breath that we hold so dear will soon leave us: in the meantime, while we draw it, while we live among human beings, let us practise humanity: let us not be a terror or a danger to any one.”
“So, too, anger is in itself hideous and by no means to be feared; yet it is feared by many, just as a hideous mask is feared by children.”
“I never saw any one at Plato's house act like that.”
“Let us believe nothing unless it forces itself upon our sight and is unmistakable, and let us reprove ourselves for being too ready to believe”
“Let us also reflect, how much credit the tale of our forgiveness will confer upon us, how many men may be made into valuable friends by forgiveness.”
For Students
A reading companion for classical Christian high school students. See the student guide.
Reading Guide
Watch for
- How Seneca defines anger in the first book, and the picture he draws of the angry man.
- Each argument made for anger by Aristotle, Theophrastus and others, and the reply that Seneca gives.
- The difference between the first shock and the consent of the mind that makes anger.
- The stories of cruel kings and patient men in the third book, and what each proves.
- The practical remedies he gives: delay, doubt about rumour, the evening examination.
Key terms and names
- Anger (ira)
- In Seneca's definition, the desire to repay a wrong with pain, which he treats as a passion and a vice of the soul.
- Passion (adfectus)
- A disorderly movement of the soul against reason, which the Stoics sought to remove and not merely to moderate.
- Irascibility
- A settled tendency to anger, which Seneca distinguishes from a single fit of it.
- Sextius
- A Roman philosopher whose habit of a nightly self-examination Seneca recommends.
- Novatus
- The friend, traditionally Seneca's brother, to whom the three books are addressed.
- Wise man
- The Stoic ideal of one who is free from the passions and governed wholly by reason.
Seminar Questions
- Comprehension How does Seneca define anger, and why does he call it the most hideous of the passions?
- Comprehension What is the difference between the first shock of anger and anger itself?
- Comprehension List the remedies for anger that Seneca gives in the second and third books.
- Interpretation Why does Seneca reject Aristotle's view that anger rightly measured is useful?
- Interpretation What do the stories of Cambyses and Harpagus add to the argument that anger is a disease?
- Interpretation How does the example of Sextius turn a theory of anger into a daily habit?
- Big Question Is there a righteous anger, as Scripture seems to allow, or must all anger be removed? Use both Seneca and the Bible in your answer.
- Big Question Can a person govern his temper by reason alone, or does he need help from beyond himself?
Faith Connections
- Proverbs 15:1 (Scripture)
A soft answer turneth away wrath, but grievous words stir up anger. Seneca's advice to delay and to speak gently is an instance of the same wisdom.
- James 1:19-20 (Scripture)
Let every man be swift to hear, slow to speak, slow to wrath, for the wrath of man worketh not the righteousness of God; this runs parallel to Seneca's rule of delay.
- Ephesians 4:26-27 (Scripture)
Be angry and sin not, let not the sun go down upon your wrath; Paul allows a place for anger that does not become sin, which Seneca denies, and the contrast is a rich ground for discussion.
- Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiae II-II, q. 158 (Great Conversation)
Aquinas treats anger as a passion that can be right or wrong according to its object and measure, and so gives a Christian reply to Seneca's rejection of all anger.
Logic and Rhetoric
Central argument: Anger is against the gentle and social nature of man, serves no good that reason cannot serve better, and can be avoided by early resistance, delay, doubt of rumour and a daily review of the soul, so a wise person should not employ it at all.
Rhetorical device: anticipation of objections (prolepsis). Throughout the first two books Seneca states what our adversary says in favour of anger, with the words says our adversary, and then answers the objection before moving on.
Debate: Resolved: That anger is never a fit servant of virtue.
Memory Work
The greatest remedy for anger is delay; beg anger to grant you this at the first, not in order that it may pardon the offence, but that it may form a right judgment about it: if it delays, it will come to an end.
Fight hard with yourself and if you cannot conquer anger, do not let it conquer you
Writing Prompts
Essay: Using Books II and III, explain Seneca's counsel on delay and judgment, and say what he thinks a person should do in the first moments after an insult.
Comparison with Summa Theologica: Compare Seneca's rejection of all anger with Aquinas's teaching that anger may be right or wrong according to its object and measure, and explain which account better fits the Bible's teaching.
Medical Lens
Seneca treats anger as a disease of the soul with a physical face, describes its bodily signs, relates the hot temperament to the elements of ancient physical theory, and prescribes a regimen of mind and body. It is an early record of philosophy as the therapy of the passions.
- Book I, section I
Seneca opens with a picture of the angry body, with its blazing eyes, deep red face, quivering lips, set teeth, bristling hair and hissing breath, and calls anger a short madness.
- Book II, section XIX
A hot and dry temperament is said to be most prone to anger, following the ancient theory of the four elements and their mixtures in the body.
- Book II, section XX
Seneca recommends that hot-tempered people keep from wine and from overeating, take exercise short of fatigue, and enjoy moderate games to keep the mind in balance.
- Book II, section XXXVI
Sextius is said to have found that looking in a mirror cured some angry people by showing them how their faces were changed.
Creative Prompts
- Essay
Choose a time when you were angry and write an account of it using Seneca's distinction between the first shock and the consent of the will, then say where delay might have changed the outcome.
- Dialogue
Write a dialogue between Seneca and Aristotle on whether anger is ever right, using what each says about courage, justice and the good man.
- Classroom
Hold a debate on the resolution that anger is sometimes useful, with one side drawing on Book I's defenders and the other on Seneca's replies.
- Poetry
Write a short poem or a collect for the end of the day that follows the form of Sextius's evening examination and ends with a prayer for a gentle temper.
- Fiction
Write a short story in which a teacher or a captain meets an insult, delays his answer for a night, and finds in the morning that the offender meant none.
Further Reading
- Letters from a Stoic, Seneca
- Meditations, Marcus Aurelius
- Dialogues and Essays, Seneca, tr. John Davie
A modern English translation in the Oxford World's Classics series.
- Seneca: A Philosopher in Politics, Miriam T. Griffin
- Stoicism and Emotion, Margaret Graver
- Reading Seneca: Stoic Philosophy at Rome, Brad Inwood
Verification notes
The text is Aubrey Stewart's 1889 translation, cleaned from the Internet Archive OCR of the Bohn's Classical Library volume, with the translator's footnotes and running page heads removed; small OCR slips and an occasional misplaced quotation mark may remain. Every quotation in this file was matched to the hosted text. The dating and the identity of Novatus are matters of scholarly debate, and the Christian parallels are the library's, not Seneca's.
- The date of composition (given as c. AD 41–49) is debated and should be checked against a current scholarly source.
- The identification of Novatus with Seneca's elder brother, later called Gallio, is traditional and should be checked.
- Seneca's life dates and his exile to Corsica under Claudius follow standard reference works and are not checked against primary sources here.
- The claim that the third book was written after Caligula's death rests on its references to him and is a scholarly inference.
- The reference to Aquinas (Summa Theologiae II-II, q. 158) and to Basil's homily on anger should be checked against the editions used by the library.
- The section numbering follows Stewart's 1889 edition, which differs from some modern chapter divisions.