Work record

Selected Poems (Yeats)

Also known as: Yeats Selected Poems · W. B. Yeats: Selected Poems · The Wild Swans at Coole and The Tower (selection)

1919–1928 · Early 20th Century · Poetry · English

Read this when public violence, old age or a classroom makes you ask what lasts.

Public domainlow medical relevanceRead full textDownload EPUBFive-minute digest

Abstract

Written
1915–1927; published 1919–1928
Setting
1915 to 1927, from the First World War to the aftermath of the Irish civil war; Ireland, chiefly Coole Park and Thoor Ballylee in County Galway, and Dublin
Country
Ireland
Language
English
Genre
Lyric poetry
Form
Sixteen poems from three collections, in stanzas of varied length
Recommended
Grades 11–12 (Dense late poems with Irish history and private symbols; grades 11–12.)

Background. These poems were written in the years of the First World War and the Irish revolution, by a poet in middle age who had already won fame for earlier work and who gave his late work a plainer, harder voice. The poems come from three books, which came out between 1919 and 1928.

Plot. There is no single story. The poems in turn mourn a friend, speak for a pilot, name the executed men of 1916, pray for a child, turn from age to a holy city and look at a classroom, at Athens and at a country at war.

Ideas. Sacrifice and its cost, the longing for beauty that does not decay, grief, the education of the whole person and the fragility of civilisation are the main themes. The poet's own beliefs were not those of the Church, and readers will want to compare.

Text. The complete text is hosted here for each of the sixteen poems, and the quotations in the guide have been checked against it. Teachers can pair this work with the library's study guide, seminar questions and memory-work selection to prepare a discussion, a short essay or a recitation. The full text is hosted on this site, and each quotation in the guide has been checked against the hosted text.

Main characters

  • The poet: The speaker, in several roles
  • Robert Gregory: The pilot mourned and given a voice
  • The men of 1916: Executed rebels
  • The daughter: The baby of the prayer poem

Summary

This selection gathers sixteen poems by W. B. Yeats from three collections published before 1929: The Wild Swans at Coole (1919), Michael Robartes and the Dancer (1920–21) and The Tower (1928). It covers the years in which Yeats, in middle and old age, wrote the poems on which his reputation now rests. The Second Coming and the other poems of the same books that fall outside this selection are not included here, and the poet's own notes are left out. The first group looks back on friends and loyalties. The title poem of The Wild Swans at Coole counts the nineteen autumns since the poet first counted the swans, and finds that his own heart is sore while the birds remain unchanged. In Memory of Major Robert Gregory mourns the son of Yeats's friend Lady Gregory, killed flying in Italy in 1918, and An Irish Airman Foresees His Death gives the pilot's own voice, who fights neither from law nor duty nor love of the crowd. The Fisherman and the short poem on being asked for a war poem ask what a poet owes to the public and to the truth. The second group answers the violence of Ireland. Easter, 1916 honours the men executed after the rising and asks, with real hesitation, what a sacrifice does to the heart that makes it. A Prayer for My Daughter, written when his daughter was a baby, asks for custom, courtesy and a humble, rooted life. Meditations in Time of Civil War and Nineteen Hundred and Nineteen are bleaker poems about a country at war with itself and about the loss of faith in progress. The last group, from The Tower, is the best known. Sailing to Byzantium turns from the young and sensual world to the holy city and asks to be gathered into the artifice of eternity. The Tower weighs old age against imagination. Two Songs from a Play and Colonus' Praise look at Christ and at ancient Athens as turning points of history, and Among School Children, written after a visit to a convent school, ends by asking how we can know the dancer from the dance. A Christian reader will meet great poetry about courage, grief, memory and the longing for what does not decay. The poet himself did not hold the Christian faith; he put his trust in cycles of history and in spirits, and parts of Two Songs from a Play and Nineteen Hundred and Nineteen reflect that system. The selection is best used with a teacher, over several sessions, for older students.

Virtues in this work

  • Fortitude: The poems honour courage in the airman and the rebels and ask what it costs the heart.
  • Justice: Easter, 1916 and the civil war poems ask what justice and mercy require in a country at war with itself.
  • Prudence: A Prayer for My Daughter asks for custom, courtesy and a rooted life as protection against hatred and opinion.
  • Hope: Sailing to Byzantium reaches for what does not decay, and Christian readers can read the longing as pointing toward the resurrection.

Plot or Argument

  • The Wild Swans at Coole and friends (1919)

    Six poems on friends, a lost pilot, the fisherman as an ideal reader and the poet's duty in a war. They move from the swans at the lake to the death of Robert Gregory and his airman's choice.

  • Easter, 1916 and the poems of 1920–21

    The poem names the men executed after the rising and asks whether too long a sacrifice can harden the heart. A Prayer for My Daughter turns from public violence to the home and the virtues that guard it.

  • The Tower: old age and Byzantium

    Sailing to Byzantium and The Tower are two poems on ageing and the soul, one turned to the holy city and the other to the poet's own imagination and pride.

  • The Tower: Ireland at war

    Meditations in Time of Civil War and Nineteen Hundred and Nineteen set the Irish conflict inside a wider ruin of hopes and ask what is left when the old order goes.

  • The Tower: history, Athens and school

    Two Songs from a Play and Colonus' Praise read history through Christ and Athens. Among School Children looks at a classroom, at love and age, and ends on a vision of unity in work and art.

Characters

  • The poet, speaker

    The aging Yeats, speaking as a senator, friend, father and craftsman, often looking back on his own choices.

  • Major Robert Gregory, airman

    Son of Lady Gregory and a painter, scholar and pilot, mourned in one poem and given his own voice in another.

  • The men of Easter 1916, patriots

    Irish rebels executed after the rising, some of whom the poet knew and had mocked.

  • The daughter, child

    Anne Yeats, the baby of A Prayer for My Daughter, over whom the poet prays at the tower during a storm.

  • The fisherman, ideal reader

    A figure of the poet's imagined audience, simple, wise and free of fashion.

Lessons

  • Sacrifice has a cost, and the cost is to be counted

    In Easter, 1916 the poet gives a hard look at a sacrifice that has become a cause. He honours the dead and admits that a long sacrifice can turn a heart to stone. Students can talk about the difference between courage and fanaticism, and why a Christian also asks what the sacrifice is for.

    • What does the poet admire in the men he names?
    • What is the danger of too long a sacrifice?
  • Beauty longs for what does not decay

    Sailing to Byzantium treats old age as a loss of the body and a gain of the soul, and asks to be gathered into a work of art that cannot die. A Christian can honour the longing and also see that the poem puts art where the Church puts the resurrection of the body.

    • What is the speaker leaving behind, and what does he ask for?
    • How does the poem's picture of eternity differ from Christian hope?
  • Education should join the whole person

    In Among School Children the poet visits a classroom and ends with a question about the dancer and the dance, and a labour in which body and soul are not set against each other. Classical students can talk about a learning that forms the whole person and not only the mind.

    • What do the great philosophers in the poem fail to give?
    • What does the closing question suggest about learning?

Context

The poems belong to the years of the Easter Rising in Dublin in 1916, the First World War, the Irish War of Independence, the Anglo-Irish Treaty and the civil war of 1922–23. Yeats lived in Thoor Ballylee, a Norman tower in County Galway, and served as a senator of the new Irish Free State from 1922 to 1928.

Composition

The Wild Swans at Coole was published in 1917 and in a larger form in 1919. Michael Robartes and the Dancer came from the Cuala Press in 1920–21, and The Tower from Macmillan in 1928. The poems here are taken from the public-domain editions of those three books.

Reception

The Tower made Yeats a major voice of the twentieth century; Sailing to Byzantium, Easter, 1916 and Among School Children are standard texts in schools and universities.

Comparisons

  • The Second Coming

    Yeats's best-known short poem is a vision of a world coming apart, drawn from the same years and the same system of symbols as the poems in this selection.

  • The Waste Land

    Eliot's poem answers the same postwar collapse with fragments and allusion; Yeats uses a plain voice and an ordered stanza.

  • Ode to a Nightingale

    Both poems begin with a bird and turn to age and the longing for what does not die; Yeats's Byzantium is the older man's reply.

  • In Memoriam A.H.H.

    Tennyson's long elegy and Yeats's poem on Robert Gregory both turn grief for a young friend into reflection on faith and time.

  • The Iliad

    Easter, 1916 and the Airman poem ask the Homeric question of why men choose to die young, and give a different answer from the old heroes.

Quotes

“The years to come seemed waste of breath, A waste of breath the years behind In balance with this life, this death.”
— W. B. Yeats, Selected Poems (Yeats), An Irish Airman Foresees His Death (Project Gutenberg #32491, #72987, #72985 (Macmillan 1919 and 1928; Cuala Press 1920–21)).Quote card
“An intellectual hatred is the worst, So let her think opinions are accursed.”
— W. B. Yeats, Selected Poems (Yeats), A Prayer for My Daughter (Project Gutenberg #32491, #72987, #72985 (Macmillan 1919 and 1928; Cuala Press 1920–21)).Quote card
“O sages standing in God’s holy fire As in the gold mosaic of a wall, Come from the holy fire, perne in a gyre, And be the singing masters of my soul. Consume my heart away; sick with desire And fastened to a dying animal It knows not what it is; and gather me Into the artifice of eternity.”
— W. B. Yeats, Selected Poems (Yeats), Sailing to Byzantium (Project Gutenberg #32491, #72987, #72985 (Macmillan 1919 and 1928; Cuala Press 1920–21)).Quote card

For Students

A reading companion for classical Christian high school students. See the student guide.

Reading Guide

Watch for

  • The speaker's voice: where he is friend, father, senator, old man or craftsman.
  • Every place where a bird, a tree, a tower or a stone appears, and what each stands for.
  • The change in tone between the 1919 poems and the late poems of The Tower.

Key terms and names

Byzantium
The Eastern Roman capital, now Istanbul, which Yeats made into a symbol of holy art and an ordered civilisation.
Gyre
A spiral or cone. Yeats used the gyre as a symbol of historical cycles; the word appears in Sailing to Byzantium.
Anglo-Irish
The Protestant landed class of Ireland to which Yeats's friends and, by temperament, Yeats himself belonged.
Easter Rising
The armed rebellion in Dublin during Easter week 1916; its leaders were executed in the weeks that followed.
Artifice
A work of art or skill; in the late poems Yeats sets it against natural life and decay.

Seminar Questions

  1. Comprehension Who is Robert Gregory, and how does the airman explain why he fights?
  2. Comprehension What does the speaker of Sailing to Byzantium ask the sages to do?
  3. Interpretation Why does Yeats say a terrible beauty is born, and not simply a terror or a beauty?
  4. Interpretation How does the old speaker of Sailing to Byzantium differ from the young world he leaves?
  5. Interpretation What does the last stanza of Among School Children say about the aim of education?
  6. Big Question Can a person give everything to a cause and keep a living heart?
  7. Big Question Is art able to give a person what faith promises?

Faith Connections

  • Ecclesiastes 12:1-7 (Scripture)

    Remember your Creator in the days of your youth, before the silver cord is loosed. The ageing speakers of the late poems look at the same facts without the answer the preacher gives.

  • 1 Corinthians 15:42-44 (Scripture)

    The body is sown in dishonour and raised in glory. Sailing to Byzantium wants a golden form out of nature, and the Christian hope is the resurrection of the body.

  • Plato and Aristotle in Among School Children (Great Conversation)

    The poem names Plato, Aristotle and Pythagoras as teachers and shows that their systems do not cure the grief of age.

Logic and Rhetoric

Central argument: Beauty, loyalty and sacrifice are real goods, and the heart both needs them and is at risk of being hardened or deceived by them; the late poems search for a unity of life and work that the poet can only reach in imagination.

Rhetorical device: refrain and paradox. The phrase terrible beauty joins two words that normally do not belong together, and the poem uses the pair to hold its hesitation about the rising.

Debate: Resolved: That the beauty of a sacrifice is a reliable measure of whether the sacrifice was good.

Memory Work

All changed, changed utterly: A terrible beauty is born.

Easter, 1916. The refrain of Easter, 1916 is short, famous and a good test of attention to tone.

O body swayed to music, O brightening glance, How can we know the dancer from the dance?

Among School Children. The final lines of Among School Children are a fine passage to learn and to discuss.

Writing Prompts

Essay: Compare the young world in the first stanza of Sailing to Byzantium with the holy city in the next three, and say what the poet wants from each.

Comparison with The Second Coming: Compare the way Yeats sees the failure of the old order in The Second Coming and in Meditations in Time of Civil War, and say what hope each poem allows.

Medical Lens

Several poems treat old age, the failing body and the death of friends. Sailing to Byzantium and The Tower are the main texts on ageing. The poems are not clinical, and they should be read as literature, not as guidance about the end of life.

    Creative Prompts

    • Essay

      Explain what Yeats means by a terrible beauty in Easter, 1916, and say whether the poem praises, mourns or judges the men it names.

    • Classroom

      Read Sailing to Byzantium aloud, then discuss what the speaker leaves behind, what he asks for and how a Christian would answer his prayer.

    • Poetry

      Write a poem of three or four stanzas about a place you have known for many years, in which the speaker counts what has changed and what has not.

    • Dialogue

      Write a conversation between the airman of the Irish Airman poem and a chaplain who asks him why he fights.

    Further Reading

    • W. B. Yeats: A Life, R. F. Foster

      A two-volume life of the poet, published in 1997 and 2003.

    • Yeats's Poetry, Drama, and Prose, James Pethica, ed.

      A Norton Critical Edition of the major works with essays.

    • The Second Coming, W. B. Yeats

      Yeats's best-known short poem, in this library.

    • Four Quartets, T. S. Eliot

      A later poem of time, memory and a different faith; see the companion guide in this library.

    Verification notes

    Full text from Project Gutenberg #32491 (The Wild Swans at Coole, 1919), #72987 (Michael Robartes and the Dancer, Cuala Press, 1920–21) and #72985 (The Tower, Macmillan, 1928). All three books were published before 1929 and are in the public domain in the United States; Yeats died in 1939, so they are also public domain in the many countries that use life plus seventy years. Quotes were matched to the hosted text. The selection omits other poems in these books and the poet's own notes.

    • Which poems appeared in the first Cuala Press issue of Michael Robartes and the Dancer and which were added later.
    • The exact date on which each poem in The Tower was first written.