Work record
On the Nature of the Gods
Marcus Tullius CiceroDe Natura Deorum; On the Nature of the GodsOn the Nature of the Gods by Marcus Tullius Cicero (45 BC)On the Nature of the Gods is a dialogue in three books, written by Cicero in 45 BC.Also known as: De Natura Deorum · On the Nature of the Gods
45 BC · Ancient · Philosophy · Latin
Read this when you want Cicero weighing what the gods are and whether they care.
Abstract
The setting. Cicero reports a conversation at the house of Gaius Cotta during a festival, between an Epicurean, a Stoic and a skeptic of the Academy. The topic is what the gods are and whether they care for the world.
The arguments. Velleius presents the Epicurean view of gods who take no part in human affairs. Balbus presents the Stoic case that a divine reason rules the world, arguing from the order of the heavens and of living things. Cotta replies to each, using the skeptic's weapons.
The result. Cotta presses the problem of why good men suffer and what piety could mean if the gods did not care. Cicero closes by naming the Stoic's account as nearer to truth, though he does not claim certainty.
Why it matters. The dialogue is an ancient survey of views on the gods and preserves ideas from lost Greek works. Cicero appears as a doubter who still honors piety, and later Christian writers read the dialogue and answered it. Its balanced form also makes it a good model for students learning to state an opponent's view fairly before replying. The result is a work that treats belief seriously without forcing a single answer on the reader.
Key figures
- Cicero: The narrator, who reports the discussion.
- Velleius: An Epicurean who argues that the gods take no part in the world.
- Balbus: A Stoic who argues that divine reason rules the world.
- Cotta: An Academic skeptic who answers both.
- Marcus Brutus: The friend to whom the work is dedicated.
Summary
On the Nature of the Gods is a dialogue in three books, written by Cicero in 45 BC. It is set at the home of the orator and pontifex Gaius Cotta, where a small group of friends meet during a Roman festival to debate the question of the divine. Cicero, who is the narrator, listens and records the discussion. The work is dedicated to his friend Marcus Brutus. The first speaker is Velleius, an Epicurean, who sets out the view of Epicurus that the gods are blessed and immortal beings who take no part in the world and have no concern with human affairs. Velleius mocks other schools for their stories of gods who plan, build and care, and he argues that a god who cares for the world would be burdened with labor, which would be beneath his happiness. Cotta, an Academic skeptic, answers him in the first book, taking apart the Epicurean argument and asking what difference such gods make. He says that if the gods do not care for humans, there is no ground for piety. In the second book, Balbus, a Stoic, presents the case for a divine providence. He argues from the order of the heavens, the structure of living things and the fitness of the world to human life that the world is guided by reason. He draws on a long tradition of design arguments, including the image of a mechanical model of the heavens that no one would suppose to have been made by chance. In the third book, Cotta replies to Balbus, using the skeptical arguments of the Academy. He questions whether the order of the world proves that the gods care for men, and he asks why good men suffer and wicked men prosper. At the end, Cicero says that he found Balbus's account closer to the truth, though he does not claim to be certain. The work is a rare ancient survey of Greek views on the gods, and it records ideas from lost works of the Hellenistic schools. It shows Cicero as a skeptic who still values piety and the public worship of Rome. For Christian readers, it is an important example of how an educated pagan thought about providence, and it was read by Lactantius and Augustine.
Virtues in this work
Plot or Argument
- Book I
Velleius presents the Epicurean view of the gods as blessed beings with no care for the world. Cotta then dismantles the argument and asks what piety could mean on such a view.
- Book II
Balbus presents the Stoic case for divine providence, drawing on the order of the heavens and the fitness of living things.
- Book III
Cotta answers Balbus with skeptical objections and asks why the world contains so much suffering. Cicero says that Balbus's view seems closer to truth.
Characters
- Velleius, Epicurean speaker
Sets out a doctrine of gods who do not govern.
- Balbus, Stoic speaker
Argues for providence and a designed world.
- Cotta, Academic skeptic
Tests both cases; the dialogue’s doubtful close is in his key.
- Cicero, Narrator and listener
Presents the conversation and, in his other works, leans toward a Stoic providence without pretending to have settled every question.
Lessons
Argument from design
Balbus argues that the order of the world points to a ruling mind. The work gives students one of the earliest forms of the design argument and its answers.
- What features of the world does Balbus take as signs of design?
- How does Cotta answer the argument?
Piety and belief
Cotta says that without belief in gods who care, piety loses its ground. Students can ask what duty to the divine depends on.
- Why does Cotta think the Epicurean view undermines piety?
- Can piety exist without belief?
Doubt and honest inquiry
Cicero presents the arguments of rival schools and does not claim certainty. The work teaches how to weigh competing claims fairly.
- Why does Cicero include so many voices?
- What does Cicero mean when he calls one view closer to the truth?
Context
Cicero wrote the dialogue in 45 BC, in a period of private grief after the death of his daughter Tullia and after Caesar's victory had ended his public career. He wrote a series of philosophical works in these months.
Composition
The dialogue is set in the 70s BC at Cotta's house. Cicero draws on Greek works by the Epicureans, Stoics and Academics, many of them now lost, and he presents them in Latin.
Reception
The work was read by later Latin writers, including Lactantius and Augustine, who used its arguments and its report of pagan thought in their own writings.
Comparisons
- On Duties (De Officiis)
On Duties is the practical companion: how a man ought to live; this dialogue asks what kind of gods, if any, underwrite that life.
- The Republic and The Laws
The Republic and the Laws treat the divine and the civic together in another key.
- City of God
Augustine answers the Roman argument about the gods and the city at length, and he had read this tradition.
- Letters from a Stoic
Seneca’s letters assume a Stoic providence in a more pastoral voice.
Quotes
Frequently cited
“I do not even know, if we cast off piety towards the Gods, but that faith, and all the associations of human life, and that most excellent of all virtues, justice, may perish with it.”
“But if their doctrine be true, of what avail is piety, sanctity, or religion?”
“Piety, like the other virtues, cannot have any connection with vain show or dissimulation; and without piety, neither sanctity nor religion can be supported; the total subversion of which must be attended with great confusion and disturbance in life.”
For Students
A reading companion for classical Christian high school students. See the student guide.
Reading Guide
Watch for
- How each speaker defines the gods before arguing about them.
- The Stoic's argument from the order of the heavens and living things.
- The way the dialogue ends, and what Cicero says about which view seems closer to truth.
Key terms and names
- Epicurean
- A follower of Epicurus, who held that the gods exist but take no part in the world.
- Stoic
- A follower of the school that held that a divine reason, or logos, orders the world.
- Academic skeptic
- A follower of Plato's later Academy, who held that certainty is hard to reach and argued both sides.
- providence
- The idea that a divine mind cares for and guides the world.
Seminar Questions
- Comprehension What does Velleius say the gods are like, according to Epicurus?
- Comprehension What signs of design does Balbus point to in the world?
- Interpretation Why does Cotta say that the Epicurean view undermines piety?
- Interpretation Why does Cicero let the skeptic have the last word in the third book, and what does he say at the end?
- Big Question Does the order of the world show that someone designed it?
- Big Question Can there be true piety without belief in a god who cares?
Faith Connections
- Psalm 14:1; Romans 1:19–21 (Scripture)
Scripture speaks of a knowledge of God in what is made, and of the folly of a life that will not honor Him. Cicero’s speakers are reaching for that question with pagan tools.
- Augustine, City of God IV–VIII (Church Fathers)
Augustine takes up the Roman debate about the gods and judges it by the truth of the gospel.
Logic and Rhetoric
Central argument: The dialogue sets three schools against each other: the Epicurean says the gods do not care, the Stoic says they do, and the skeptic says we cannot be sure.
Rhetorical device: Dialogue form. Cicero lets each side present its case in a full speech, then answers it, so the reader sees the weak points of each view.
Debate: Resolved: that the order of the world is evidence of a divine mind.
Memory Work
Piety, like the other virtues, cannot have any connection with vain show or dissimulation; and without piety, neither sanctity nor religion can be supported; the total subversion of which must be attended with great confusion and disturbance in life.
Writing Prompts
Essay: Compare how Velleius and Balbus argue about the gods and say which argument is more convincing, and why.
Comparison with On Duties (De Officiis): Compare how Cicero treats belief in the gods in On the Nature of the Gods and the duties of a citizen in On Duties.
Creative Prompts
- Essay
Compare the Epicurean and Stoic accounts of the gods in the dialogue and say which Cicero finds closer to the truth, and why.
- Dialogue
Write a conversation between a Christian student and Balbus about the order of the world.
- Classroom
Have students list the arguments of Velleius, Balbus and Cotta, and then sort them into those that depend on observation and those that depend on definition.
Further Reading
- Cicero: On the Nature of the Gods, Cicero, trans. P. G. Walsh
Oxford World's Classics; with notes and introduction.
- Cicero: The Life and Times of Rome's Greatest Politician, Anthony Everitt
A readable life, with attention to his later philosophical writing.
- City of God, Augustine
Augustine's answer to the pagan gods and to Roman philosophers.
Verification notes
The hosted text is the complete three books from PG #14988. The 1877 note’s ‘Benjamin Franklin’ is a long-standing confusion with Thomas Francklin; it is corrected in our metadata and notes, not in the hosted wording of the 1877 preface.
- Cicero’s own final leanings in this dialogue are still discussed by scholars; the work page does not pretend he recites a creed.