Work record

Mr. Midshipman Hornblower

Also known as: Midshipman Hornblower · Hornblower

1950 · Postwar Contemporary · Novel · English

Read this when a midshipman must learn courage, seamanship and self-command in war.

Copyrightedlow medical relevanceFive-minute digest

Abstract

Written
1950 (first in the hero’s life; other Hornblower books were written earlier)
Setting
The Royal Navy in the wars of the 1790s; Ships, prizes and shores of the British naval war against France
Country
United Kingdom
Language
English
Genre
novel
Form
episodic naval historical fiction
Recommended
Grades 7–12 (Naval war adventure of duty and self-command; some battle violence. Grades 7–12.)

The berth. Young Horatio Hornblower, tall, awkward and gifted, goes to sea as a midshipman in the British navy in the wars of the 1790s. He must find a place in the midshipmen’s berth, learn the craft of a ship of war, and begin to live under a discipline that is harder than any he has known at home, among older officers and among boys as untried as himself.

The trials. In a chain of episodes he faces a duel, foul weather, prize-taking, a small command, and moments when he must act because there is no one else to act. He is often afraid and often ashamed, and he is harder on himself than others are, but he does not quit and he will not take an easy lie.

The beginning of an officer. By the close he has begun to be trusted, not because he is easy in company, but because he will do his duty and will govern himself. The later Hornblower books, not treated at length here, continue the life that this volume begins, from lieutenant toward a later fame he never quite believes he deserves.

Main characters

  • Horatio Hornblower: shy midshipman
  • His officers: the men who command and test him

Summary

Mr. Midshipman Hornblower is the beginning, in the order of the hero’s life, of C. S. Forester’s naval stories of Horatio Hornblower. A tall, awkward, gifted boy goes to sea in the wars of the 1790s and must learn, in a series of trials, what it is to be an officer: to keep his head in a duel and in a storm, to take responsibility for men, to tell the truth about a failure, and to go on when he is afraid. The book is not one long plot but a chain of episodes—on ship, on prize, in a siege, in a small command—that show a character being formed by duty. Forester is careful about ships, wind and gunnery, and he is equally careful about shame, pride and the wish to be worthy. The result is a story of courage that is not loud. Hornblower is often sick, often unsure, and often harder on himself than anyone else is; the reader comes to respect him because he does not quit and because he will not take an easy lie. This library offers a companion guide only, with no text and no quotations. The book is suitable for grades 7 to 12. There is naval violence, as there must be in a tale of war at sea, but there is also a high standard of honor, perseverance and self-command. It stands well beside other books in this library in which a young person is schooled by a hard outdoor craft, such as Captains Courageous and The Log of a Cowboy. A teacher can use it to ask what leadership is, what a person owes to those under him, and how fear and duty can live in the same mind. Parents who want a first Hornblower book will find this the right place to begin in the hero’s life, even though Forester wrote other volumes earlier.

Virtues in this work

  • Fortitude: He goes on through fear, sickness and shame, and the book honors courage that is not loud.
  • Temperance: Self-command, including the government of pride and of despair, is the habit he is learning.
  • Honor: He would rather tell the truth about a failure than keep a false credit.

Plot or Argument

  • The midshipman goes to sea

    Young Horatio Hornblower joins a ship of the British navy in the wars of the 1790s, awkward and untried, and begins to learn the life of the midshipmen’s berth, the discipline of the service, and the cost of a first failure.

  • Trials of nerve and skill

    In a chain of episodes he faces a duel, bad weather, prize-taking and the need to act when there is no one else to act. Each trial shows a little more of the officer he is becoming.

  • A first command of himself

    By the close he has begun to be trusted, not because he is easy in company, but because he will do his duty and will not spare himself. The later Hornblower books continue the life begun here.

Characters

  • Horatio Hornblower, shy

    A shy, gifted midshipman who learns courage and self-command in the naval wars of the 1790s.

  • The captains and lieutenants of his ships, officers under

    The officers under whom he serves, whose standards and tempers help to form him.

  • Fellow midshipmen, other boys of the berth

    The other boys of the berth, among whom he must find a place without losing his honor.

Lessons

  • Duty is a school

    Hornblower is formed by a service that asks him to be larger than his fear. A Christian reader can set this beside the call to be faithful in a charge, even when the charge is hard.

    • What does the service require of a midshipman besides skill?
    • Where does Hornblower judge himself more harshly than others do?
    • Is duty the same as pride?
  • Courage includes confession

    Some of his best moments are not victories but truthful accounts of a failure. The book honors a young man who will not hide behind a lie.

    • When does telling the truth cost him, and why does he do it?
    • How is this different from mere boldness in a fight?
    • What would be lost if he were only lucky, and not honest?
  • Leadership begins in self-command

    Before he can lead men he must govern his own shame, sickness and pride. The later books rest on that beginning.

    • What habits is he forming in these early episodes?
    • How should a reader judge a hero who is often unhappy with himself?
    • What does a person owe to those placed under him?

Context

The stories are set in the Royal Navy of the wars against Revolutionary and Napoleonic France, a world of blockade, prize money, midshipmen’s berths and severe discipline, which Forester studied with care.

Composition

Forester had already written later episodes in Hornblower’s life when he published Mr. Midshipman Hornblower in 1950 as a beginning in the hero’s chronology. This guide treats the 1950 book as the right first volume for a reader following the life in order.

Reception

The Hornblower books have remained standard naval historical fiction and have had a long life in later adaptations. This first volume is still the best entrance to the character.

Comparisons

  • Captains Courageous

    Kipling’s fishing schooner, like Forester’s navy, is a hard school in which a young man learns to take his place and to keep faith with a crew.

  • The Log of a Cowboy: A Narrative of the Old Trail Days

    Adams’s cattle drive, hosted in this library, is another tale of a young man schooled by a long outdoor job and by loyalty to an outfit.

  • Treasure Island

    Stevenson’s sea adventure is quicker and more romantic; Hornblower is slower, closer to the craft of a ship, and more concerned with the making of an officer.

Quotes

For Students

A reading companion for classical Christian high school students. See the student guide.

Reading Guide

Watch for

  • How Hornblower behaves when he is afraid, and what he does with the fear.
  • Where he tells the truth about a failure, and what it costs him.
  • How he treats men placed under him when he first has a small command.
  • What remains unfinished in him at the end, for later books to take up.

Key terms and names

Midshipman
A junior officer in training, neither a common seaman nor yet a lieutenant.
Prize
An enemy ship taken in war, a source of danger, duty and possible reward.
The berth
The crowded quarters of the midshipmen, a school of manners as well as of seamanship.
Self-command
The government of one’s own fear, pride and shame, which this book treats as the beginning of leadership.

Seminar Questions

  1. Comprehension When and in what service does Hornblower begin, and what is a midshipman?
  2. Comprehension Name two early trials he faces, and how each ends.
  3. Interpretation What kind of young man is he, and why do others come to trust him?
  4. Interpretation How does the book show courage in some way other than a successful fight?
  5. Big Question Is a hard service a sufficient school of character, or does it need a higher law?
  6. Big Question What does a person owe to those he is set to lead?

Faith Connections

  • Luke 16:10 (Scripture)

    The word that the one faithful in very little will be faithful also in much is a measure of a midshipman’s small charges, in which a whole character is already being formed.

  • Joshua 1:9 (Scripture)

    The charge to be strong and courageous, and not to be afraid, is a word a young officer might need, though the book itself is not a work of devotion.

  • Rudyard Kipling, Captains Courageous (Great Conversation)

    Kipling’s schooner, in this library, is a companion school of a young man made useful by a crew and by hard work at sea.

Logic and Rhetoric

Central argument: A shy, gifted boy can be made into an officer by a service that demands self-command, truth-telling and responsibility for other men’s lives.

Rhetorical device: episodic naval chronicle. Forester tells the early life as a chain of trials at sea, each complete in itself, so that character is shown in repeated tests rather than in one plot.

Debate: Resolved: That a person unfit for easy company may still be fit to lead, if he will govern himself.

Writing Prompts

Essay: Show how three early episodes form Hornblower’s idea of duty, and say what a Christian reader should praise in his self-command.

Comparison with Captains Courageous: Compare the schooling Hornblower receives in the navy with the schooling Harvey Cheyne receives on the fishing schooner, and say what each book holds up as a mark of a true man.

Medical Lens

The book includes sea-sickness, fear, and the wounds of naval war. It is of slight medical interest except as a picture of a young man under strain.

    Creative Prompts

    • Essay

      Explain how Hornblower’s early trials form his idea of what an officer must be, using three episodes.

    • Dialogue

      Write a dialogue in which a senior officer tells a friend why he is willing to trust this awkward midshipman.

    • Classroom

      On a simple chart of the 1790s navy, note the ranks from midshipman upward and what each is responsible for.

    Further Reading

    • Captains Courageous, Rudyard Kipling

      A young man schooled by a hard crew at sea, in this library.

    • The Log of a Cowboy, Andy Adams

      A long outdoor apprenticeship, hosted in this library.

    • Treasure Island, Robert Louis Stevenson

      A classic sea adventure, in this library.

    Verification notes

    Copyrighted; no text and no quotations are stored. The outline of the hero’s early life, Forester’s dates, and the 1950 publication follow standard reference accounts and publisher descriptions. The Open Library record for ISBN 9780316289122 names Back Bay Books and a date of 1984, which may reflect an earlier related publication rather than the first Back Bay printing; the year is marked for verification.

    • The Open Library record for ISBN 9780316289122 gives the date 1984 for a Back Bay Books edition; that year may be uncertain and was not checked against a physical copy.
    • Forester’s dates (1899–1966) and the 1950 first publication follow standard reference accounts.