Work record

Discourse on Metaphysics

Also known as: Discourse on Metaphysics · Discours de métaphysique

1686 · Renaissance Early Modern · Philosophy · French

Read this when a created world is ordered by God, and substances, freedom, and grace are in view.

Abstract

Written
Written 1686; not published in Leibniz's lifetime
Setting
Late seventeenth-century European philosophy, in correspondence with Arnauld; Hanover and the wider Republic of Letters
Author
Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz; trans. George R. Montgomery
Country
Germany (Holy Roman Empire)
Language
French
Genre
Metaphysical treatise
Form
Thirty-seven numbered articles in French, here in Montgomery's English
Recommended
Grades 11–12 (Short numbered articles; pair with the logical writings. Some Scholastic terms.)

Occasion. Leibniz wrote the Discourse in French in 1686 and sent a summary of its articles to Antoine Arnauld. The work was not printed in his lifetime. It is a relatively complete early statement of the system later associated with the Monadology, here given in thirty-seven numbered articles. Readers meeting Leibniz for the first time will find the articles short enough to outline on a single page, yet full enough to display the whole system.

God and the best world. God is an absolutely perfect being, whose actions are wholly free and wholly wise. He selects this world as the most excellent of those that could have been, and he does nothing without a reason. That theological opening governs the later account of substances.

Substances and harmony. Each created being is, on this account, an independent whole that reflects God and the entire created order. Apparent commerce among creatures is not a real physical influence of one on another, but a pre-established harmony ordained by God from the beginning, as between two clocks set by one workman.

How to read it here. This library presents Montgomery's 1902 Open Court English, taken from the unrevised 1908 reprint, and limited to the Discourse itself. Read it beside the logical writings already gathered here. Grades 11–12 can follow the articles with guidance, and should test Leibniz's perfect deity against the God of Scripture.

Key figures

  • Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz: Author of the Discourse
  • Antoine Arnauld: The theologian to whom Leibniz sent a summary of the articles
  • God: The absolutely perfect being with whom the Discourse begins and ends

Summary

Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz wrote the Discourse on Metaphysics in 1686 as a relatively complete statement of his mature philosophy, some thirty years before the more famous Monadology. He composed it in French, sent a summary of its articles to Antoine Arnauld, and so began one of the great correspondences of early modern philosophy. The work itself was not printed in his lifetime. The hosted English is George R. Montgomery's translation, first published by Open Court in 1902 and reprinted, unrevised, in 1908. This library uses that public-domain text, taken from the proofread 1908 pages, and it includes only the Discourse itself, the thirty-seven articles. It does not use later revised reprints. The Discourse opens with God, who is an absolutely perfect being, and whose actions are wholly free and wholly wise. Among possible universes, God elects this one as the best, and he does nothing without a reason. From that theology Leibniz moves, without a break in method, to substances. Every substance is as a world apart, independent of every other created thing, and is like a complete world or a mirror of God or of the whole universe. Individual substances have complete individual notions, from which every truth about them follows, including what we call future and contingent. The apparent commerce among substances is explained not by a real physical influence of one creature on another, but by a pre-established harmony which God has ordained from the beginning, as between two clocks that keep time together because a workman set them so. The soul is a rational substance that expresses the universe with a peculiar distinctness, and God has provided a city of God among such spirits. Freedom is not chance; it is intelligence acting without constraint, and in a way consistent with the principle of sufficient reason. Students in grades 11–12 can read the Discourse as a short, article-by-article way into Leibniz, and should pair it with the logical writings already in this library. It is a work of natural theology and of metaphysics together, and it should be judged from a classical Christian perspective on those terms: whether the God who always acts for the best is the God of Scripture, and whether a world of windowless substances in pre-established harmony still leaves room for providence, prayer, and moral responsibility.

Virtues in this work

  • Prudence: Leibniz proceeds article by article, and will not let a later claim float free of the account of God with which the Discourse begins.
  • Humility: He submits the articles to Arnauld's judgment, and treats correspondence as a test of the system, not as a mere courtesy.
  • Faith: The close of the work places rational spirits in a City of God, and will not separate metaphysics from the love of God.

Plot or Argument

  • God and perfection

    The Discourse begins with God as an absolutely perfect being, whose acts are wholly free and wholly wise.

  • The best of possible worlds

    Among possible universes God elects this one as the best, and does nothing without a reason.

  • Individual substances

    Each substance has a complete individual notion, and is as a world apart, a mirror of God or of the whole universe.

  • Pre-established harmony

    Apparent influence among creatures is the harmony God ordained from the beginning, as between two clocks set by one workman.

  • The City of God

    Rational spirits form a moral world, a City of God, and the last articles hold metaphysics and piety together.

    Lessons

    • A short system

      The thirty-seven articles are a complete sketch, not a set of isolated remarks. Students should watch how the doctrine of God governs the doctrine of substances.

      • How does the opening account of God control what Leibniz later says about individual substances?
      • Why did Leibniz send a summary of these articles to Arnauld, and what kind of test is a correspondence of that sort?
    • Harmony without influence

      The image of two clocks is the most famous explanation of pre-established harmony. A class should ask what it saves, and what it costs, in an account of action and of prayer.

      • What problem is pre-established harmony meant to solve, if one substance cannot really act upon another?
      • Does the clock image leave room for petitionary prayer and for moral responsibility, or only for a foreordained agreement?
    • Freedom and sufficient reason

      Leibniz will not let freedom be chance, and will not let sufficient reason become a fatalism he would disown. Students should press both sides.

      • How does Leibniz distinguish certainty from absolute necessity in the Discourse?
      • Is a will that always has a reason still free in a sense a Christian moral life can use?

    Context

    In 1686 Leibniz, already a mathematician and diplomat in the service of Hanover, set down this French Discourse as a relatively complete account of his metaphysics. He sent a summary of its articles to Antoine Arnauld, and the ensuing correspondence became one of the chief documents of his thought. The work itself remained unpublished in his lifetime.

    Composition

    The original is French, 1686. The hosted English is George R. Montgomery's translation, Open Court, 1902, used from the unrevised 1908 reprint, Discourse only, not later revised editions.

    Reception

    The Discourse is now often preferred as an entrance to Leibniz, being fuller than the later Monadology and closer to the argument with Arnauld. Christian readers have long asked whether the God who always chooses the best is the God of Scripture, and whether a harmony set from the beginning still honors providence as the Bible speaks of it.

    Comparisons

    • Logical Writings on Binary Arithmetic and Universal Character

      The logical writings already in this library show the formal side of the same mind: complete individual notions, identity, and sufficient reason. The Discourse is the more theological and systematic companion.

    • Discourse on Method

      Descartes's Discourse, also in French and also a compact self-presentation, is a useful contrast: methodical doubt and a real distinction of mind and body against Leibniz's God-governed harmony of substances.

    • Meditations on First Philosophy

      Descartes's Meditations set the problems of God, mind, and body to which Leibniz is offering a different solution, especially on the commerce of substances.

    • Ethics

      Spinoza's Ethics is the other great late-seventeenth-century system: a God or Nature of necessity, against Leibniz's God who freely chooses the best of possible worlds.

    Quotes

    “The conception of God which is the most common and the most full of meaning is expressed well enough in the words: God is an absolutely perfect being. The implications, however, of these words fail to receive sufficient consideration.”
    — Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz, Discourse on Metaphysics, Section I, trans. George R. Montgomery (1902).Quote card
    “In order to distinguish between the activities of God and the activities of created things we must explain the conception of an individual substance. It is quite difficult to distinguish God’s actions from those of his creatures.”
    — Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz, Discourse on Metaphysics, Section III, trans. George R. Montgomery (1902).Quote card
    “Furthermore every substance is like an entire world and like a mirror of God, or indeed of the whole world which it portrays, each one in its own fashion; almost as the same city is variously represented according to the various situations of him who is regarding it.”
    — Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz, Discourse on Metaphysics, Section VIII, trans. George R. Montgomery (1902).Quote card
    “Their opinion is, in my judgment, unknown to the writers of antiquity and is a deduction based upon the too slight acquaintaince which we have with the general harmony of the universe and with the hidden reasons for God’s conduct.”
    — Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz, Discourse on Metaphysics, Section IX, trans. George R. Montgomery (1902).Quote card
    “As I do not wish to judge people in ill part I bring no accusation against our new philosophers who pretend to banish final causes from physics, but I am nevertheless obliged to avow that the consequences of such a banishment appear to me dangerous, especially when joined to that position which I refuted at the beginning of this treatise.”
    — Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz, Discourse on Metaphysics, Section XIV, trans. George R. Montgomery (1902).Quote card
    “Jesus Christ has revealed to men the mystery and the admirable laws of the kingdom of heaven, and the greatness of the supreme happiness which God has prepared for those who love him.”
    — Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz, Discourse on Metaphysics, Section XIII, trans. George R. Montgomery (1902).Quote card
    “It has brought us to know the kingdom of heaven, or that perfect republic of spirits which deserves to be called the city of God. He it is who has discovered to us its wonderful laws.”
    — Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz, Discourse on Metaphysics, Section XXX, trans. George R. Montgomery (1902).Quote card
    “For if the future shall perhaps show that God has not wished our good intention to have its way, it does not follow that he has not wished us to act as we have; on the contrary, since he is the best of all masters, he ever demands only the right intentions, and it is for him to know the hour and the proper place to let good designs succeed.”
    — Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz, Discourse on Metaphysics, Section XXXVI–XXXVII, trans. George R. Montgomery (1902).Quote card

    For Students

    A reading companion for classical Christian high school students. See the student guide.

    Reading Guide

    Watch for

    • The opening definition of God as an absolutely perfect being.
    • The claim that God does nothing without a reason, including in His voluntary acts.
    • Complete individual notions, and the idea of a substance as a world apart.
    • Pre-established harmony, and the image of two clocks.
    • The distinction between certainty and absolute necessity, and the City of God at the close.

    Key terms and names

    Sufficient reason
    The principle that God does nothing, and permits nothing, without a reason, even in His voluntary acts.
    Individual substance
    A complete being whose notion is so full that every predicate true of it can be deduced from that notion.
    Pre-established harmony
    God's ordaining, from the beginning, the agreement of substances, so that apparent influence is not a real action of one creature on another.
    City of God
    The moral community of rational spirits, under God, with which the Discourse closes.
    Possible worlds
    The alternative universes among which, on Leibniz's account, God freely chooses the most perfect.

    Seminar Questions

    1. Comprehension In what year did Leibniz write the Discourse, and why did he send a summary of its articles to Arnauld?
    2. Comprehension What does it mean, in the early articles, to say that God does nothing without a reason?
    3. Interpretation How can a substance be 'as a world apart' and still belong to a universe that looks as if things act on one another?
    4. Interpretation How does Leibniz try to keep both sufficient reason and a real distinction between certainty and absolute necessity?
    5. Big Question Is the God who always chooses the best of possible worlds the God of Scripture, or a different kind of deity?
    6. Big Question Can a classical Christian account of prayer and responsibility accept pre-established harmony as it is stated here?

    Faith Connections

    • Genesis 1:31 (Scripture)

      God saw all that he had made, and it was very good: a biblical measure for Leibniz's claim that this is the best of possible worlds, not a simple endorsement of it.

    • Colossians 1:17 (Scripture)

      In him all things hold together: a standard for the claim that the world's agreement is kept in God, and a warning against reducing providence to a clockmaker's first setting.

    • James 1:17 (Scripture)

      Every good gift is from above, from the Father of lights, with whom there is no variation: a measure for the Discourse's perfect God, and for whether that God still acts in history.

    Logic and Rhetoric

    Central argument: Because God is absolutely perfect and does nothing without a reason, he freely chooses the best of possible worlds and ordains a pre-established harmony among individual substances, each of which is as a world apart and a mirror of the universe; rational spirits form a City of God, and freedom is intelligence without constraint, consistent with sufficient reason.

    Rhetorical device: numbered discourse in articles. The image of two clocks that keep time together because a workman set them so, used to explain apparent influence without a real action of one creature on another.

    Debate: Resolved: that the God of Leibniz's Discourse, who always chooses the best of possible worlds and ordains a pre-established harmony, is consistent with the God of Scripture and with Christian prayer.

    Memory Work

    Jesus Christ has revealed to men the mystery and the admirable laws of the kingdom of heaven, and the greatness of the supreme happiness which God has prepared for those who love him.

    Section XIII, trans. George R. Montgomery (1902). The compact claim that each substance is as a world apart, a complete world and a mirror of God or of the whole universe.

    Writing Prompts

    Essay: Explain individual substance and pre-established harmony from the Discourse, then judge the system from a classical Christian account of providence.

    Comparison with Logical Writings on Binary Arithmetic and Universal Character: What does the Discourse add, in theology and in the doctrine of substances, to the logical writings already in this library? Where do the two records say the same thing in different forms?

    Creative Prompts

    • Classroom

      Make a numbered map of the thirty-seven articles, grouping them under God, substances, harmony, freedom, and the City of God, and mark where a later article depends on an earlier one.

    • Dialogue

      Write a short letter in the voice of Arnauld raising one objection to article XIII or XIV, and a reply in the voice of Leibniz.

    • Essay

      Explain pre-established harmony from the Discourse, then judge it from a classical Christian account of providence and of prayer.

    Further Reading

    • Logical Writings, Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz

      The formal companion already hosted in this library.

    • Discourse on the Method, René Descartes

      A compact earlier French self-presentation against which Leibniz's method and theology can be set.

    • Ethics, Benedict de Spinoza

      The other major late-seventeenth-century system of God, substance, and necessity.

    Verification notes

    Quotes were matched as substrings against the hosted Montgomery 1902/1908 Discourse-only text. The 1968 Open Court reprint revised by Albert R. Chandler was not used.

    No verification flags recorded.