Work record

And Then There Were None

Also known as: And Then There Were None (Christie) · Soldier Island · Agatha Christie: And Then There Were None

1939 · Early 20th Century · Novel · English

Read this when you wonder what happens to a secret guilt that the law never found.

Copyrightedlow medical relevanceFive-minute digest

Abstract

Written
1939
Setting
The late 1930s, in the days before the Second World War; Soldier Island, a small rock off the Devon coast, and a modern house on it
Country
England (United Kingdom)
Language
English
Genre
Detective fiction; closed-circle mystery
Form
Novel in short chapters, with an epilogue
Recommended
Grades 8–12 (Companion guide only; murder mystery, some deaths of children in the backstory. No text stored.)

Background. A leading writer of detective fiction published this book in 1939, near the high point of her career. It has been named the best-selling mystery of all time, and it is remembered for its economy, its ingenuity and its dark moral centre. It was adapted for the stage by the author and has been filmed and televised many times.

Plot. Ten strangers are invited to an island, where a recorded voice accuses them of murder. They die one by one in ways that match a nursery rhyme, while the survivors search for the killer. The solution is explained at the end and is not given here.

Ideas. The book is about guilt and conscience, the difference between law and revenge, and the way fear exposes character. It raises the question whether any person has the right to act as a judge, and it asks the reader to weigh the idea of justice against that of mercy and of confession.

Text. The library holds no text of this copyrighted novel and quotes none of it. The guide supports a class discussion or an essay, and it can be read without spoiling the book for those who have not yet read it. It also suggests a few quiet exercises in close reading.

Main characters

  • Vera Claythorne: A young governess
  • Philip Lombard: A soldier of fortune
  • Dr. Armstrong: A physician
  • Judge Wargrave: A retired judge
  • Emily Brent: A self-righteous spinster

Summary

And Then There Were None, published in Britain in 1939 by Agatha Christie, is often named as the best-selling mystery novel of all time. It is a closed-circle puzzle of great economy and force: ten strangers are brought to an island off the coast of Devon, where they find themselves cut off from the world and accused, one by one, of crimes that the law never punished. It is also a moral story about guilt, justice and the limits of private judgement, and it stands apart from the author's series stories in that no professional detective stands at its centre. The ten guests have been invited to Soldier Island, a small rock near the English coast with a modern house on it, by a host whom none of them has met and who is not there to receive them. They include a retired judge, a doctor, a young governess, a soldier of fortune, an elderly spinster, a former policeman and an old general, with two servants who have been engaged for the visit. After dinner, a recorded voice accuses each person present of causing a death. A nursery rhyme about ten soldier boys hangs on the wall of every bedroom, and ten china soldiers stand on the dining-room table. One by one the guests die in ways that echo the verses of the rhyme, and one by one a figure disappears from the table. As the storm cuts off the island and suspicion grows, those who are left must find out which of them is the killer, and each of them has to face the truth about the death at his own door. The book moves with rising dread, and the final chapters and an epilogue explain how it was done. This guide does not reveal the answer. Christie wrote the novel in 1939 and adapted it for the stage in 1943. A Christian reader will find in it a vivid picture of conscience, the weight of unconfessed sin and the danger of a justice that takes the law into its own hands. It is a gripping read for students, and it raises serious questions about guilt and mercy.

Virtues in this work

  • Justice: The book tests the idea of justice by showing a judge who takes the law into his own hands.
  • Prudence: Those who stay calm and read the evidence carefully are the most likely to survive.
  • Humility: The book shows what happens to those who refuse to admit their own guilt.
  • Fortitude: The guests are tested by fear, and the few who keep their nerve show true courage.

Plot or Argument

  • The invitations

    Ten strangers are invited, for different reasons, to a house on Soldier Island off the Devon coast. None has met the host.

  • The accusation

    After dinner, a recorded voice accuses each of the ten of a death for which the law did not hold them to account. The guests are shocked and deny it.

  • The first deaths

    One guest dies at once, and the first china soldier disappears from the table. The guests discover that the boat has not come and that they cannot leave.

  • Suspicion and fear

    As more guests die in ways that match the rhyme, the survivors search the island and distrust one another. They try to work out who among them might be the killer.

  • The solution

    The last chapters and an epilogue show who was responsible and how the plan was carried out. The guide does not reveal this.

Characters

  • Vera Claythorne, governess

    A young woman who has been engaged as a secretary and who has a history of her own.

  • Philip Lombard, soldier of fortune

    A resourceful adventurer who carries a revolver and has no illusions about himself.

  • Dr. Edward Armstrong, physician

    A respected London doctor who tries to keep calm in the crisis.

  • Judge Wargrave, retired judge

    An elderly man with a long career on the bench and a precise way of reasoning.

  • Emily Brent, spinster

    A rigid, devout and self-righteous woman who thinks little of the guilt of others.

  • General Macarthur, retired soldier

    An old man of fixed habits who is haunted by his past.

Lessons

  • Hidden sin has weight

    Each guest has carried a hidden guilt, and the book shows how it works in them. A Christian can see in this the old teaching that the conscience bears witness and that confession is a mercy.

    • How does each guest respond when accused?
    • What does the book suggest about the way an unconfessed sin works?
  • Justice is not the same as revenge

    The plot depends on someone who believes he is a righteous judge of those whom the law has missed. The book allows the reader to feel the force of that idea and to see where it goes wrong.

    • What is the difference between law and private judgement?
    • Where does the judge's idea of justice go wrong?
  • Fear tests character

    The guests are shown under pressure, and each reveals a trait that has been hidden. The book is a short course in how fear exposes habit and virtue.

    • Who stays calm and why?
    • How do fear and suspicion damage trust?
  • Fair play in a mystery

    The book plays fairly, giving the reader every clue. Students can learn to read closely, to note details and to test a theory against the evidence.

    • Which clues did you notice early?
    • How does Christie manage the reader's attention?

Context

The novel was published in November 1939, soon after the outbreak of the Second World War, and it comes from the high point of what is called the Golden Age of detective fiction between the wars. It uses the conventions of the closed-circle mystery, in which a small group is isolated and each member is a suspect.

Composition

Christie wrote the book in 1939 and first published it in the United Kingdom through the Collins Crime Club in that year, and in the United States in 1940 through Dodd, Mead. She adapted it for the stage in 1943, changing the ending. It has since been filmed and televised many times.

Reception

It was praised on publication for its ingenuity and has since sold more than a hundred million copies by the publisher's reckoning. It is regularly named as Christie's masterpiece and as one of the greatest mysteries.

Comparisons

  • Murder on the Orient Express

    Another closed-circle mystery by Christie, in which the question of justice outside the law is again at the heart of the plot.

  • The Murder of Roger Ackroyd

    Christie's earlier novel, in the library with its full text, is the other great puzzle from her best period.

  • The Mysterious Affair at Styles

    Christie's first novel, in this library, shows how she began with a small cast and a house.

  • Crime and Punishment

    Dostoevsky's novel treats guilt and conscience at depth, and gives a Christian answer to the question of what to do with a hidden crime.

  • Macbeth

    Shakespeare's play shows how guilt works in the mind of a murderer, with the same sense that blood cannot be hidden.

  • The Innocence of Father Brown

    Chesterton's priest-detective stories often turn on the moral life of the criminal, a contrast with Christie's colder approach.

Quotes

For Students

A reading companion for classical Christian high school students. See the student guide.

Reading Guide

Watch for

  • The accusation in the first evening and each guest's reaction.
  • The china soldiers on the table and the verses in the rooms.
  • Small details of time, place and speech that matter later.
  • How the mood of the guests changes as the numbers fall.

Key terms and names

Closed-circle mystery
A story in which a limited group is isolated and one of them is the culprit.
Golden Age
The period between the world wars when the puzzle-style detective novel flourished.
Conscience
The inner sense of right and wrong that accuses and excuses.
Vigilante
A person who punishes others without legal authority.
Red herring
A false clue that leads the reader to the wrong conclusion.

Seminar Questions

  1. Comprehension Who are the ten guests, and what are they accused of?
  2. Comprehension What is the pattern that the deaths follow?
  3. Interpretation How does Christie keep the reader uncertain about who is guilty?
  4. Interpretation What does each guest's reaction to the accusation show about his character?
  5. Interpretation Why might the book have no detective?
  6. Big Question Is it ever just to punish those whom the law has missed?
  7. Big Question What does a Christian say about hidden guilt that has not been confessed?

Faith Connections

  • Numbers 32:23 (Scripture)

    Be sure your sin will find you out. The book dramatises the idea that hidden guilt does not stay hidden.

  • Romans 12:19 (Scripture)

    Vengeance is mine, I will repay, says the Lord. The idea of a human judge who takes vengeance into his own hands is at the centre of the plot.

  • Psalm 32:3-5 (Scripture)

    When I kept silent, my bones wasted away; I acknowledged my sin to you. The psalm shows the relief of confession that none of the guests can find.

Logic and Rhetoric

Central argument: Guilt does not disappear because the law has not found it, but no private person has the right to take the place of the judge, and the attempt to do so turns justice into a crime.

Rhetorical device: closed-circle puzzle. By shutting ten people on an island and letting the numbers fall, Christie turns an argument about guilt and justice into a story that the reader can feel.

Debate: Resolved: That a private person may sometimes act as a judge when the law has failed.

Writing Prompts

Essay: Explain how Christie uses fear and suspicion to reveal the characters of the guests, and say what the book suggests about hidden guilt.

Comparison with Murder on the Orient Express: Compare how Christie treats justice outside the law in this novel and in Murder on the Orient Express, and say what each book asks of the reader.

Medical Lens

The deaths on the island involve poison and sedatives, and one of the guests is a physician who examines the dead. The book is a puzzle, not a medical text, and its details should not be taken as clinical.

    Creative Prompts

    • Essay

      Explain how Christie makes the reader suspect each guest in turn without revealing the answer.

    • Classroom

      Make a chart of the ten guests with a column for each of their secrets, and talk about which sins the law can reach and which it cannot.

    • Fiction

      Write the opening of a closed-circle mystery set in a place of your own choosing, with a small group of people and a threat.

    • Dialogue

      Write a conversation between two of the guests who disagree about what justice requires.

    Further Reading

    • The Murder of Roger Ackroyd, Agatha Christie

      Christie's 1926 novel, in this library with its full text.

    • Murder on the Orient Express, Agatha Christie

      Christie's 1934 novel, in this library.

    • Agatha Christie: A Biography, Janet Morgan

      The authorised life of Christie, published in 1984.

    • An Autobiography, Agatha Christie

      Christie's own account of her life, published in 1977.

    • A Talent to Deceive, Robert Barnard

      An appreciation of Christie's methods, published in 1980.

    Verification notes

    Copyrighted; no text and no quotations are stored. The 1939 publication by the Collins Crime Club, the 1940 US publication by Dodd, Mead, the 1943 stage version, the ten guests and their roles, the setting on Soldier Island, the nursery rhyme and the recorded accusation follow standard reference accounts. The plot is given in outline, and the solution is deliberately not revealed. The sales figure is the publisher's claim.

    • The most recent sales figure, which varies by source.
    • The most recent printing details of the further reading titles.