Work record
Out of the Silent Planet
C. S. LewisC. S. Lewis; CS Lewis; C.S. Lewis; C S Lewis; CSLewis; Clive Staples Lewis; Out of the Silent Planet (Space Trilogy, Book One); The Space Trilogy, Book One; Ransom and Malacandra; MalacandraOut of the Silent Planet by C. S. Lewis (1938)Out of the Silent Planet, published in 1938, is the first book of C. S. Lewis's Space Trilogy and his first novel.Also known as: Out of the Silent Planet (Space Trilogy, Book One) · The Space Trilogy, Book One · Ransom and Malacandra · Malacandra
1938 · Early 20th Century · Novel · English
Read this when a bold scientific plan starts treating other people as raw material.
Abstract
Background. A well-known Oxford scholar wrote this novel as the first of three books that answer the scientific romances of his time. It is also an adventure story, with a hero who is a shy language scholar and a setting that is vivid, gentle and strange, and it can be read with pleasure by teenagers who have never opened a book of theology.
Plot. A scholar on a walking holiday is kidnapped and taken by spaceship to Mars. He escapes his captors and lives among peaceful creatures, learns their language, and is brought before the planet's ruler, who judges the human visitors and sends them home. A short epilogue in which the author appears as a character closes the story.
Ideas. The book is about the corruption of knowledge by pride and greed, the beauty of an unfallen world and the claim that moral order is part of creation. It also argues that language and friendship are better ways to know another people than conquest, and it prepares the reader for the next two books of the trilogy.
Text. The library holds no text of this copyrighted book and quotes none of it. The guide is for students who read their own copy and for teachers who plan a seminar on science, ethics and the Christian imagination, with the questions and comparisons listed in the study guide.
Main characters
- Ransom: A Cambridge philologist
- Weston: A physicist and believer in progress
- Devine: A businessman
- Hyoi: A friendly hross
- Oyarsa: Ruler of Malacandra
Summary
Out of the Silent Planet, published in 1938, is the first book of C. S. Lewis's Space Trilogy and his first novel. It is a story of interplanetary travel that answers the scientific romances of H. G. Wells and Olaf Stapledon, and it turns the usual story upside down: the hero finds not a hostile world to conquer but a world still obedient to God, and the greater danger is the human beings who have brought him there. The hero is Dr. Elwin Ransom, a philologist at Cambridge, who is walking in the English countryside when he is kidnapped by two men he half knows. They are the physicist Edward Weston and the businessman Dick Devine, and they have built a spaceship. They carry Ransom to Malacandra, as the inhabitants call Mars, intending to hand him over to creatures who they think demand a human sacrifice. Ransom escapes into a strange, beautiful world of high pale mountains, blue lakes and long valleys. There he meets three kinds of reasoning beings who live in peace: the poetic, otter-like hrossa, the tall and scholarly séroni, and the miners and craftsmen called pfifltriggi. He learns their language, to which his training as a philologist is well suited, and he comes to love the hrossa, whose poetry and songs are the best he has heard. In time he is summoned to meet Oyarsa, the ruling spirit of the planet, and he discovers that Earth is known to them as the silent planet, shut off from the other worlds by its ruler's rebellion. Weston and Devine arrive and are examined too. Weston's speech to Oyarsa, in which he defends the conquest of the universe in the name of life and progress, is the central episode of the book. Oyarsa answers it, and sends the three men home. The book ends with a short note in which Lewis explains that the story rests on the real experiences of Ransom. A Christian reader will see a fable about unfallen creation, the corruption of knowledge by pride and greed, and the justice of a moral order that does not depend on human power. It is the best entry into the trilogy.
Virtues in this work
- Prudence: Ransom's careful learning of the language and the customs of Malacandra is a model of wise attention.
- Justice: Oyarsa judges the human visitors by a moral order that does not depend on power.
- Humility: The book sets Ransom's humble listening against Weston's pride in the human race.
- Friendship: Ransom's friendship with the hrossa shows what real attention to another people can become.
Plot or Argument
- The kidnapping
Ransom, on a walking tour, is drugged and taken aboard a spaceship by Weston and Devine, who treat him as a payment for the beings of another world.
- The journey and landing
The voyage through space is quiet, even beautiful, and changes Ransom's idea that space is a lifeless void. They land on Malacandra, and Ransom runs from his captors.
- Life among the hrossa
Ransom learns the language of the hrossa and finds them wise, musical and without greed. He also meets the other two species and learns how the planet is ordered.
- Oyarsa
Ransom is called before the ruler of the planet, who explains the history of the solar system and what Earth is. Weston and Devine are brought in and made to give an account.
- Return
Oyarsa sends the men back to Earth, and the book closes with a note that explains how Lewis came to write down Ransom's story.
Characters
- Elwin Ransom, protagonist
A Cambridge philologist who is by temperament scholarly and shy and who becomes, through his adventure, a witness to the truth about the heavens.
- Edward Weston, antagonist
A physicist who believes that humanity's future justifies any means, and who is later shown to be spiritually corrupt.
- Dick Devine, antagonist
A businessman who joins the voyage for gold and who stands for greed.
- Hyoi and the hrossa, friends
Poetic, loyal and brave creatures who befriend Ransom and teach him their language.
- Oyarsa, ruler
The spirit who governs Malacandra under God, called Maleldil, and who judges the human visitors.
Lessons
Knowledge without wisdom is dangerous
Weston has real learning and no humility; he thinks the future of the human race justifies cruelty toward other creatures. The book is an early and clear criticism of the scientism that treats progress as the highest good.
- What exactly does Weston think he is serving?
- How does Lewis show the weakness of that view?
The heavens are not empty
Ransom expects a cold void in space and finds, instead, a place full of light and life. Lewis was reviving the medieval picture of the heavens as full of meaning, against the modern picture of space as dead.
- What does Ransom learn to call space?
- Why is the older picture closer to the Christian view of creation?
Language shapes understanding
Ransom the philologist learns to love Malacandra through its language. The book is a quiet argument that learning a tongue is a way to learn to love a people, and that translation is a form of respect.
- How does Ransom's learning of the language change him?
- What does Weston's refusal to learn it reveal?
Moral order does not need our power
Oyarsa judges Weston without any need for armies. The book shows that moral order is part of creation and not an invention of the strong.
- What is the source of Oyarsa's authority?
- How is this different from Weston's idea of authority?
Context
The book appeared in 1938, in the years when Wells, Stapledon and the biologist J. B. S. Haldane were presenting space travel and human evolution as a new religion of progress. Lewis, who had read their books closely, set out to write the same kind of story from a different premise.
Composition
Lewis later said that he and his friend J. R. R. Tolkien had agreed to write the kind of stories they wanted to read, Tolkien one on time and Lewis one on space. The book was published by John Lane The Bodley Head in 1938 and followed by Perelandra in 1943 and That Hideous Strength in 1945.
Reception
It was well received on publication and has remained a favourite of readers who come to Lewis through Narnia. Critics often read it with its sequels as a single argument against scientism and for a Christian cosmology.
Comparisons
- The First Men in the Moon
Wells's novel of a voyage to the Moon is the kind of scientific romance that Lewis answers, with a different view of other worlds and of science.
- The War of the Worlds
Wells imagines a hostile invasion from space; Lewis imagines human invaders in a world that is not hostile, so that the threat is turned round.
- That Hideous Strength
The third book of the trilogy shows the same scientism at work on Earth in an English university town.
- The Abolition of Man
Lewis's lectures state in plain argument what the trilogy shows in story, about the danger of power that has rejected moral law.
- Paradise Lost
Milton's epic of cosmic rebellion gave Lewis his idea of a universe that is ordered, populated and morally charged, and is a source behind the planet's spiritual rulers.
Quotes
For Students
A reading companion for classical Christian high school students. See the student guide.
Reading Guide
Watch for
- How Ransom's feelings about space change from fear to wonder.
- Each difference between the three species of Malacandra and what each contributes.
- How Weston and Devine speak when they are among the hrossa and what they hope to take.
- The stages of Ransom's learning of the language.
Key terms and names
- Philologist
- A scholar of languages and their history; Ransom's profession is key to his role.
- Malacandra
- The name the inhabitants give to Mars in this book.
- Hnau
- The word in the Malacandran language for any rational, speaking creature.
- Oyarsa
- The spirit who rules a planet under God in the trilogy.
- Scientism
- The belief that natural science is the only source of truth and the only guide to action.
Seminar Questions
- Comprehension Who kidnaps Ransom, and what do they want from the beings of Malacandra?
- Comprehension What are the three kinds of reasoning creatures on Malacandra?
- Interpretation Why does Lewis make a philologist the hero of a space adventure?
- Interpretation What does Weston mean by his claim about the future of life, and how does the book answer it?
- Interpretation Why does the book call Earth the silent planet?
- Big Question Can science be pursued without moral limits?
- Big Question How should a Christian answer the claim that humanity's survival justifies any act?
Faith Connections
- Psalm 19:1-4 (Scripture)
The heavens declare the glory of God. Lewis's picture of space as living and full of meaning is a reply to the view of the heavens as dead.
- Genesis 1:26-28 (Scripture)
Humanity's dominion over creation is a charge to care for it. Weston treats it as a licence to use.
- Romans 1:18-23 (Scripture)
Knowledge that refuses to honour God becomes futile. Weston's speech is a modern example.
- Medieval cosmology and Dante (Great Conversation)
Lewis took the medieval picture of the heavens, as found in Dante and in Ptolemy, as a model for his space story.
Logic and Rhetoric
Central argument: The universe is ordered and morally charged, and a science that serves human power alone is a form of rebellion that leads to cruelty and finally to ruin.
Rhetorical device: inversion of a genre. The space romance usually shows aliens as threat and humans as heroes; Lewis makes the human visitors the threat and the aliens the wiser party.
Debate: Resolved: That the pursuit of scientific progress justifies the sacrifice of the weak.
Writing Prompts
Essay: Explain how Lewis uses the character of Weston to criticise a whole way of thinking, and say whether the criticism is fair.
Comparison with The First Men in the Moon: Compare Lewis's picture of other worlds with Wells's, and say what each author thinks is the proper attitude of human beings toward the unknown.
Creative Prompts
- Fiction
Write a short scene in which a visitor to a new country learns a few words of the language and finds that they change how he sees the people.
- Essay
Analyse Weston's speech to Oyarsa and say which of his arguments a modern reader might still hear and where Lewis thinks they go wrong.
- Classroom
Compare the picture of space in this book with the picture of space in a modern science fiction film, and talk about what each suggests about meaning.
- Dialogue
Write a conversation between Ransom and a hross on the question of what it means to be a good neighbour.
Further Reading
- Perelandra, C. S. Lewis
The second book of the trilogy; see the guide in this library.
- That Hideous Strength, C. S. Lewis
The third book of the trilogy, in this library.
- Planet Narnia, Michael Ward
A study of the planetary imagery behind Lewis's fiction, published in 2008.
- C. S. Lewis: A Biography, A. N. Wilson
A critical life, published in 1990; readers should compare it with others.
Verification notes
Copyrighted; no text and no quotations are stored. Publication in 1938 by John Lane The Bodley Head, the plot outline, the three species of Malacandra, the role of Oyarsa and the framing note follow standard reference accounts and the book's front and back matter. Lewis's reply to Wells and Stapledon and the agreement with Tolkien are taken from Lewis's own letters and essays as commonly cited.
- The exact phrasing of the framing note and whether to describe it more fully.
- The details of how the agreement with Tolkien is dated in Lewis's letters.