Work record
Perelandra
C. S. LewisC. S. Lewis; CS Lewis; C.S. Lewis; C S Lewis; CSLewis; Clive Staples Lewis; Perelandra (Space Trilogy, Book Two); Voyage to Venus; The Space Trilogy, Book TwoPerelandra by C. S. Lewis (1943)Perelandra, published in 1943, is the second book of C. S. Lewis's Space Trilogy and the most theological of the three.Also known as: Perelandra (Space Trilogy, Book Two) · Voyage to Venus · The Space Trilogy, Book Two
1943 · Early 20th Century · Novel · English
Read this when you must resist a clever argument that sounds almost like wisdom.
Abstract
Background. A well-known Christian author wrote this second book of his space trilogy during the Second World War. It is the most theological of the three, and it asks what would happen if the first temptation took place on another world and was refused. It follows the first book and is read best after it, though the story can be followed alone.
Plot. A scholar is sent to the planet Venus, where he meets the first woman of that world and is joined by a tempter who works through clever arguments. He must resist him by words and finally by deeds, and the book ends in a scene of joyful celebration among the rulers of the worlds.
Ideas. The book is about temptation, obedience, the work of the devil and the costly action of the faithful. It treats obedience as trust, and it argues that evil is best resisted by a clear mind and a courageous body. It sets Milton's picture of the Fall beside a world where the choice is still open.
Text. The library holds no text of this copyrighted book and quotes none of it. The guide supports a seminar, an essay or a comparison with Milton and Genesis for students who read their own copy, and it lists questions for each stage of the debate.
Main characters
- Ransom: Philologist and hero
- The Green Lady: The first woman of Perelandra
- Weston: A possessed physicist
- The King: The Lady's husband
Summary
Perelandra, published in 1943, is the second book of C. S. Lewis's Space Trilogy and the most theological of the three. Where the first book showed a world that had never fallen, this one imagines a world at the moment of its first great test, and asks what a Christian man should do when the tempter appears in a fresh and innocent creation. The hero, Elwin Ransom, the philologist of the first book, is called by the spiritual rulers of the heavens to Perelandra, which is Venus. A frame story shows the narrator visiting Ransom's cottage before he leaves. Ransom is carried by supernatural means to a world of golden skies and a single ocean on which float islands of vegetation. There he meets its first woman, the Green Lady, who is as yet without sin, and who lives with a trusting and curious joy under the one command that is given to her. The peace is broken when a ship arrives carrying Weston, the physicist of the first book. He has been taken over by a spirit of evil, and he sets out to persuade the Green Lady to disobey. Ransom discovers that he has been sent to resist the tempter, first by argument and then by action, and that no clever argument alone is going to be enough. The long arguments between Ransom and the tempter give the book its drama. Ransom's own struggle, which ends in a physical contest and a long and costly pursuit, is told with a strength that has made the book a favourite. Lewis does not retell the book of Genesis, and he does not say that his story is true. He asks what would happen if the temptation were refused. A Christian reader will find an extended meditation on obedience, desire, the nature of evil and the role of the human person in God's plan. It is a book for readers who can follow a debate, and who want an unusual picture of what faith demands.
Virtues in this work
- Fortitude: Ransom must endure fear and pain to act, though he would rather not.
- Prudence: The book shows the wisdom of noticing how a clever argument leads step by step to a wrong end.
- Faith: The Lady's trust in the command is shown as the right response of a creature to a good creator.
- Piety: The book's closing scenes show worship and gratitude as the right ending of a creature's story.
Plot or Argument
- The summons
Ransom is called to Venus by the spiritual powers of the heavens, and is sent in a coffin-like vessel to Perelandra.
- The Green Lady
Ransom meets the first woman of Perelandra, who has not yet been tempted, and learns the single command laid on her and the joy with which she lives under it.
- The tempter arrives
Weston lands and is revealed to be the instrument of an evil spirit; he begins a long campaign of argument to turn the Lady against the command.
- Ransom's resistance
Ransom answers the tempter with argument, discovers that argument is not enough, and is led to do what he fears. The struggle becomes physical and wears on.
- The resolution
Ransom is wounded in the heel. The rulers of the worlds appear, and the King and Queen of Perelandra are brought together in a closing scene of celebration.
Characters
- Elwin Ransom, protagonist
The philologist of the first book, who is now called to resist evil and who must learn what courage demands.
- The Green Lady, the first woman
An innocent, curious and trusting woman who lives under a single command and is tested by the tempter.
- Weston, the Un-man, antagonist
The physicist of the first book, now possessed by an evil spirit that argues with a persistent and poisonous cleverness.
- The King, the first man
The Lady's husband, who is absent for most of the story and who returns in the closing scenes.
- The Oyéresu, angelic rulers
The spiritual rulers of Mars and Venus, who appear in the last pages.
Lessons
Temptation works by argument
The tempter does not begin with a crude lie but with a series of reasonable-sounding questions about whether the command is truly meant. Students can learn to notice how a clever argument leads step by step away from the truth.
- What is the first thing the tempter asks the Lady?
- How does Ransom first try to answer him?
Obedience is not slavery
The Lady's joy under the single command shows obedience as a form of trust. A reader can talk about the difference between a rule that confines and a rule that keeps a person in a good relationship.
- How does the Lady describe her own freedom?
- What does the book suggest the command protects?
Evil must sometimes be resisted with the body
Ransom discovers that argument is not enough and that he must act. Lewis is not glorifying violence but showing that a person can be called to a costly physical act in defence of the good.
- Why does Ransom resist the idea that he must act?
- What does he come to see about his calling?
A fall that did not happen
The book asks what would have happened if Eve had refused. It is not a claim that it did happen differently; it is a way to see the Fall by contrast with a world that stands.
- How does the book help the reader see Genesis more sharply?
- What does the contrast teach about grace?
Context
Perelandra was published in 1943, in the middle of the Second World War, and it draws on the same Christian imagination as Lewis's radio talks of those years. It belongs to a long English tradition of poems and stories about the first temptation, of which Milton's Paradise Lost is the greatest.
Composition
Lewis wrote the book in 1942 and 1943 and the Bodley Head published it in 1943. It follows Out of the Silent Planet and is followed by That Hideous Strength, which is set on Earth.
Reception
Perelandra has often been ranked as the finest of the three books by readers who value Lewis's theology, while those who prefer plain adventure sometimes find the long debates heavy. It has been much discussed alongside Milton.
Comparisons
- Paradise Lost
Milton's epic of the Fall is the chief literary ancestor of the book, which Lewis acknowledged and rewrote as a story of a temptation that fails.
- Out of the Silent Planet
The first book of the trilogy sets up Ransom, Weston and the rulers of the planets.
- That Hideous Strength
The third book follows the same enemy on Earth, in a modern institute and an English village.
- The Divine Comedy
Dante's picture of a universe full of spiritual powers and moral order stands behind Lewis's cosmology.
- The Screwtape Letters
The tempter in Perelandra uses the same methods that Screwtape teaches, but face to face.
Quotes
For Students
A reading companion for classical Christian high school students. See the student guide.
Reading Guide
Watch for
- The tempter's first moves and what he never says plainly.
- How the Lady's replies change as the arguments go on.
- Ransom's inner struggle about whether to act.
- The imagery of water, fruit, light and land in the setting.
Key terms and names
- Perelandra
- The name its inhabitants give to Venus in this book.
- Fixed Land
- The one place on Perelandra on which the Lady has been told not to stay; the object of the single command.
- Temptation
- A persuasion to do what one has been told not to do, often by reasoning.
- Fall
- The disobedience of the first humans, with its effects on the whole human race.
- Un-man
- The name Ransom gives to the possessed form of Weston.
Seminar Questions
- Comprehension What is the single command given to the Green Lady?
- Comprehension Who is the tempter, and what has become of him since the first book?
- Interpretation Why does the tempter begin with questions and not with commands?
- Interpretation What does Ransom learn about the limits of argument?
- Interpretation How does the book show obedience as a form of trust?
- Big Question Can a good rule be understood by one who has not yet obeyed it?
- Big Question What does a world look like that has not yet fallen?
Faith Connections
- Genesis 3:1-6 (Scripture)
The serpent's first question is the pattern for the tempter's method, and the whole book is a retelling of the choice on a different world.
- Ephesians 6:10-18 (Scripture)
Put on the whole armour of God: Ransom's struggle shows what it means to stand against the schemes of the devil.
- Romans 5:12-19 (Scripture)
Through one man sin came into the world; Lewis's story asks what the world would be like if the first choice had gone the other way.
- Augustine, City of God, Book XIV (Church Fathers)
Augustine's account of the first sin as a turning from God to the self is the background of the book's picture of temptation.
Logic and Rhetoric
Central argument: Evil comes through reasonable-sounding arguments against a trusting obedience, and the answer to it is a costly and embodied act of resistance and not only a better argument.
Rhetorical device: extended dialogue. The long debates between Ransom and the tempter let the reader hear each argument in full and test it before the story answers.
Debate: Resolved: That a good argument is always enough to answer a temptation.
Writing Prompts
Essay: Explain how Lewis uses the setting of Perelandra to make the first temptation fresh, and say what the reader sees that Genesis does not state.
Comparison with Paradise Lost: Compare how Milton and Lewis show the work of the tempter, and say what each suggests about how a person should answer.
Medical Lens
Ransom endures a long ordeal of fear, pain and exhaustion during his struggle with the tempter. The book can open a discussion of how the body takes part in spiritual struggle, though it is not clinical.
Creative Prompts
- Essay
Explain how the tempter's argument proceeds step by step, and say which step a reader would most easily accept.
- Classroom
Take a modern temptation, such as an easy lie or a shortcut, and write a version of the tempter's questions that would lead toward it, then write the answer.
- Fiction
Write a scene in which a character is asked to agree to something that is small but wrong, and shows how the argument is made.
- Dialogue
Write a conversation between the Lady and Ransom in which she asks him why a rule should be obeyed that she does not understand.
Further Reading
- Out of the Silent Planet, C. S. Lewis
The first book of the trilogy; see the guide in this library.
- A Preface to Paradise Lost, C. S. Lewis
Lewis's 1942 lectures on Milton's epic, a key to the book.
- Paradise Lost, John Milton
The epic that stands behind the book, in this library.
- Planet Narnia, Michael Ward
A study of the planetary imagery in Lewis's fiction, published in 2008.
Verification notes
Copyrighted; no text and no quotations are stored. Publication in 1943 by The Bodley Head, the plot outline, the role of the Green Lady, the possession of Weston, the physical struggle and the closing scene follow standard reference accounts and publisher summaries. The detail of the opening frame and the number of pages are not given.
- The precise sequence of the closing chapters, which should be checked against a print copy.
- Whether to name the Lady and the King by the names given in the third book.