Work record

The Silmarillion

Also known as: Silmarillion · Tolkien, The Silmarillion · The Tale of the Silmarils · Quenta Silmarillion

1977 · Postwar Contemporary · Epic · English

Read this when you want the old legends behind Middle-earth and their hard beauty.

Copyrightedlow medical relevanceFive-minute digest

Abstract

Written
1914–1973; published 1977
Setting
The creation of the world and the First Age, long before the events of The Lord of the Rings; Middle-earth, especially Beleriand, the island of Númenor and the blessed land in the West
Country
England (United Kingdom)
Language
English
Genre
Mythic epic; legendary history
Form
Five linked books of legend
Recommended
Grades 9–12 (Companion guide only; grave scriptural style, tragic episodes and war. No text stored.)

Background. A famous Oxford scholar of old languages worked for sixty years on these legends, and his son shaped his manuscripts into a book four years after his death. It lies behind The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings, and it is written in the grave manner of a chronicle and not of a novel.

Plot. The book tells of the creation of the world through music, the fall of the proud power Melkor, the making and theft of three jewels, the long war of Elves and Men against the Enemy, and the fall of an island kingdom. It ends by linking to the Third Age, the time of The Lord of the Rings.

Ideas. The legends are about creation, pride and the possession of beauty, oaths and their consequences, death and the desire for deathlessness, and hope against hope. They are the work of a Catholic imagination, but they are not retellings of the Bible. They include tragic episodes, so parents and teachers may wish to preview them.

Text. The library holds no text of this copyrighted book and quotes none of it. The guide is a companion for students and teachers who read their own copy, and it suggests a gradual approach, a part at a time.

Main characters

  • Eru Ilúvatar: The one God
  • Melkor (Morgoth): The fallen power
  • Fëanor: Maker of the Silmarils
  • Beren and Lúthien: Mortal and immortal lovers
  • Túrin: A tragic warrior
  • Eärendil: The mariner

Summary

The Silmarillion, published in 1977, four years after J. R. R. Tolkien's death, is the history of the First Age of Middle-earth and of the creation of the world before it. It was edited from Tolkien's unfinished manuscripts by his son Christopher, with the help of the writer Guy Gavriel Kay, and it stands behind The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings as the deep story from which they come. The style is not that of a novel but of a chronicle or of ancient scripture, grave, compressed and often sorrowful. The book has five parts. The Ainulindalë tells how the one God, Eru Ilúvatar, creates the angelic Ainur and sets them to sing, and how one of them, Melkor, introduces a discord of pride into the music. The Valaquenta describes the powers who shape the world. The longest part, the Quenta Silmarillion, tells the story of the Elves and their war with Melkor, who is later called Morgoth. It begins with the awakening of the Elves and the making of the three Silmarils, jewels of great beauty by the craftsman Fëanor, which Morgoth steals. Fëanor and his followers swear an oath to recover them and leave the blessed land in rebellion, and a long war follows in which many Elves and Men fall. Among its tales are the love of Beren and Lúthien, the tragic life of Túrin, and the voyage of Eärendil, whose prayer brings the Valar into the final war against Morgoth. The last two parts tell the Akallabêth, the fall of the island kingdom of Númenor, and a short account of the Rings of Power and the Third Age, which links the book to The Lord of the Rings. Throughout, the same pattern is repeated: beauty is made, pride and the desire to own it lead to ruin, and a few faithful characters hold on to hope against the odds. Tolkien said that the central theme of his stories was death and the desire for deathlessness. A Christian reader will find in the book a monotheistic creation story, a fall, a long history of sorrow and a repeated hope of redemption. It is not a retelling of the Bible, and it should be read as a work of imagination in its own right. It contains tragic episodes that parents and teachers may want to preview.

Virtues in this work

  • Fortitude: Beren, Lúthien and Eärendil show courage against hopeless odds.
  • Hope: The tales hold on to hope in a world of loss, and show a hope that does not rest on success.
  • Humility: The book shows the ruin of those who grasp at what is not theirs, and the worth of those who accept their place.
  • Justice: The oath of Fëanor and its consequences show a perverse justice that destroys those who seek it.

Plot or Argument

  • Ainulindalë and Valaquenta

    Eru Ilúvatar makes the Ainur and the music of creation, and Melkor sings a discord. The Valar and their servants are named, and the world is shaped.

  • The Silmarils and the oath

    Fëanor makes three jewels that hold the light of the Two Trees. Melkor steals them, and Fëanor and his people swear an oath and rebel against the Valar to recover them.

  • The wars of Beleriand

    Elves and Men fight Morgoth for centuries. The love of Beren and Lúthien, the life of Túrin and the fall of the hidden city of Gondolin belong to this time.

  • Eärendil and the end of the First Age

    Eärendil sails to the West to ask for help, and the Valar come to war and overthrow Morgoth. The First Age ends in the ruin of much of the land.

  • Akallabêth and the Rings of Power

    The kings of Númenor grow proud and attempt to take what was forbidden, and their island is destroyed. A short last section tells of the Rings of Power and links the book to the later story.

Characters

  • Eru Ilúvatar, the one God

    The creator of all things, who gives the Ainur the theme of the great music and who brings good out of evil.

  • Melkor (Morgoth), the dark power

    The greatest of the Ainur, who falls through pride and becomes the Enemy of the world.

  • Fëanor, craftsman and rebel

    The most gifted of the Elves, whose creation of the Silmarils and whose oath begin the long sorrow.

  • Beren and Lúthien, lovers

    A mortal man and an immortal Elf-maid whose love and courage win a Silmaril from Morgoth's crown.

  • Túrin Turambar, tragic hero

    A great warrior whose life is marked by pride, ill luck and ruin.

  • Eärendil, mariner

    The half-elven sailor who goes to ask the Valar for help and whose star is a sign of hope.

Lessons

  • Creation is good, and evil is a spoiling

    The first chapter shows a world made good by a single creator, in which evil enters through a proud will that wants to make its own. Students can compare it with the Christian view of evil as a corruption of the good and not an equal power.

    • How does Melkor's discord differ from the theme that Ilúvatar gave?
    • How does the book show that evil depends on good?
  • Pride and the possession of beauty

    The Silmarils are lovely and are made out of love, and yet the wish to own them leads Fëanor and many others to ruin. The book gives a clear picture of the way that a good thing can become an idol.

    • Why does Fëanor refuse to give up the Silmarils?
    • What does the oath do to those who swear it?
  • Hope against hope

    The tales of Beren and Lúthien and of Eärendil show courage and faith in times that seem hopeless. They are among the best pictures in modern fiction of what the old writers called theological hope.

    • What does each of them risk?
    • Why does Tolkien give so much of the story to loss before the hope appears?
  • Mortality and the desire for deathlessness

    The book repeatedly contrasts Elves who live as long as the world and Men who die, and it shows the dangers of the wish to avoid death. Students can talk about how a Christian understands the gift of death and the hope of resurrection.

    • What does each race envy in the other?
    • How does Númenor show the folly of grasping at deathlessness?

Context

Tolkien began the stories of the First Age during the First World War, while he was recovering from illness after the Battle of the Somme, and he worked on them for the rest of his life. His work was shaped by his Catholic faith, by his study of Old English, Old Norse and Finnish poetry and by his experience of war.

Composition

Tolkien offered a version of the legends to his publisher after The Hobbit, and they asked him instead for a sequel, which became The Lord of the Rings. He went on revising the old tales until his death in 1973. Christopher Tolkien, with Guy Gavriel Kay, shaped the manuscripts into a single book in 1977, and later published the earlier drafts in many volumes.

Reception

The book was a best-seller on publication and has been admired for its depth and criticised by some readers for its remote style. It is often read as a companion to The Lord of the Rings, and its relationship to the author's other writings is still under study.

Comparisons

  • The Lord of the Rings

    The later epic grows out of the same world and its legends, and the Third Age section of The Silmarillion tells how it begins.

  • The Hobbit

    The earlier children's story is the first published tale of Middle-earth and has many allusions to the history behind it.

  • On Fairy-Stories

    Tolkien's essay on fairy-stories sets out his idea of sub-creation and of the consolation of the happy ending, which governs the legends.

  • Paradise Lost

    Milton's account of a proud angel who falls is a close parallel to the story of Melkor, though Tolkien's world is pre-Christian.

  • Kalevala

    The Finnish epic was an important source for Tolkien, especially for the story of Túrin.

  • Beowulf

    Tolkien was a great scholar of the poem, and its grave and elegiac mood is the mood of the legends.

Quotes

For Students

A reading companion for classical Christian high school students. See the student guide.

Reading Guide

Watch for

  • The theme of music in the first chapter and how it returns later.
  • Each time a character takes an oath or makes a promise and what follows.
  • The way beauty and loss are joined in the great tales.
  • The links forward to The Lord of the Rings.

Key terms and names

Ainur
The angelic beings whom Ilúvatar made at the beginning, some of whom entered the world as the Valar.
Silmaril
One of three jewels made by Fëanor, which hold the light of the Two Trees.
Valar
The powers who shape and guard the world under Ilúvatar.
Beleriand
The land in the north-west of Middle-earth where the wars of the First Age were fought.
Sub-creation
Tolkien's word for the human act of making a story or a world within the world that God made.

Seminar Questions

  1. Comprehension What is the discord in the Music of the Ainur, and who makes it?
  2. Comprehension What are the Silmarils, and what oath is sworn about them?
  3. Interpretation Why does Tolkien tell the story as a chronicle and not as a novel?
  4. Interpretation What does the story of Beren and Lúthien show about love?
  5. Interpretation How does the book show the cost of pride?
  6. Big Question Can a story that is not the Bible still teach Christian truth?
  7. Big Question Is the desire to avoid death good or dangerous?

Faith Connections

  • Genesis 1 (Scripture)

    The creation of the world by the word of God is the model for the chapter on the music of the Ainur.

  • Isaiah 14:12-15 (Scripture)

    How you are fallen from heaven; the fall of the proud morning star is a pattern behind the story of Melkor.

  • Romans 8:19-21 (Scripture)

    Creation waits with longing for its liberation, which is the longing in the whole history of Middle-earth.

  • Augustine, City of God (Great Conversation)

    The idea of evil as a privation and of history as the struggle between two loves is shared by Tolkien.

Logic and Rhetoric

Central argument: A world made good by a single creator is marred by the pride of created wills, and its history is a long sorrow in which beauty and hope persist through the faith and courage of the few.

Rhetorical device: chronicle style. The compressed, solemn manner of the narrative makes the events feel like ancient history, and gives the loss and the hope a weight that a novel could not bear.

Debate: Resolved: That the stories of the First Age are best read as a Christian work.

Writing Prompts

Essay: Choose one of the great tales and say how it shows the pattern of beauty, pride, loss and hope.

Comparison with Paradise Lost: Compare the fall of Melkor with the fall of Milton's Satan, and say what each author sees as the root of evil.

Medical Lens

The book is full of war, loss and the grief of the long-lived. It deals with death as a central question for Elves and Men, but it is not clinical. It can serve as a literary reflection on mortality and on the lasting effects of war.

    Creative Prompts

    • Essay

      Explain how Tolkien shows the nature of evil in the first chapter of the book, and say how it differs from the evil of a villain in an adventure.

    • Classroom

      Draw a map or a timeline of the First Age, and mark where the main tales occur.

    • Poetry

      Write a short poem in the manner of an old lament for a person or a place that has been lost.

    • Fiction

      Write a short story in which a gifted craftsman is tempted to keep a thing that he has made.

    Further Reading

    • The Lord of the Rings, J. R. R. Tolkien

      Tolkien's great epic, in this library.

    • Unfinished Tales, J. R. R. Tolkien, ed. Christopher Tolkien

      Further stories of the First and Second Ages, published in 1980.

    • J. R. R. Tolkien: A Biography, Humphrey Carpenter

      The standard life, published in 1977.

    • The Road to Middle-earth, Tom Shippey

      A study of Tolkien's sources and language, first published in 1982.

    Verification notes

    Copyrighted; no text and no quotations are stored. Publication in 1977, the editorial work of Christopher Tolkien with Guy Gavriel Kay, the five-part structure, the main stories and characters, Tolkien's offer to his publisher, and his work on the legends since the First World War follow standard reference accounts. The plot is given in outline. The remark on death and deathlessness paraphrases Tolkien's letters as commonly cited.

    • The exact years of the first drafts of the main tales.
    • The page references for any discussion of particular tales.