Work record

Fra Lippo Lippi

1855 · 19th Century · Poetry · English

Read this when someone asks whether religious art should paint the soul or the body.

Abstract

Written
1855
Setting
A spring night in Florence, c. 1450; An alley near the Carmelite convent in Florence
Country
Italy (Florence)
Language
English
Genre
Dramatic monologue; blank verse
Form
392 lines of unrhymed iambic pentameter, with snatches of song
Recommended
Grades 10–12 (A lively monologue with night-time mischief; best read with some Italian art history.)

Background. Browning published the poem in Men and Women in 1855. It draws on Vasari's life of the friar and painter Fra Filippo Lippi, who lived in Florence in the fifteenth century.

Content. The night watch seizes Lippo in an alley after midnight, and he talks his way free by naming his patron Cosimo de' Medici. He tells of his childhood hunger, his entry into the Carmelite convent, his gift for drawing and his quarrel with the Prior, who wants him to paint souls alone. He argues that art teaches us to see and that the world means intensely and means good. He plans a great altarpiece and goes home as dawn comes.

Form. A dramatic monologue in unrhymed iambic pentameter, with snatches of song and a lively conversational voice. It uses humor, argument and confession by turns.

Themes. Body and soul in art, the goodness of creation, monastic vows and appetite, patrons and the church, and the value of art as a teacher to ordinary people who pass great things without seeing them.

Significance. The poem is one of the most famous English defenses of realism in art, and it remains a lively way to teach the history of Renaissance painting and the relation of faith and beauty.

Summary

Fra Lippo Lippi is a dramatic monologue of 392 lines of blank verse by Robert Browning, first published in 1855 in Men and Women. The speaker is Fra Filippo Lippi (c. 1406-1469), a Carmelite friar and painter of Florence, who is caught by the night watch after midnight at the end of an alley where the doors of sportive ladies stand ajar. Lippo talks his way out by naming his patron, Cosimo de' Medici, and bribes the watch with a coin. He then tells the guards his life story. He was left an orphan and starved in the street until, at eight, the Carmelites took him in and made him a monk, which meant a full belly more than a calling. They tried to teach him Latin, but all he could construe was amo, I love. He found that he could draw, and he covered his school books with faces. The Prior at first lets him daub, and the monks praise his wall of drawn faces, but the Prior and the learned soon stop it and tell Lippo that his business is to paint the souls of men and not to catch men with show. Lippo protests that beauty and soul go together and that to paint the body well is to honor what God made. He says we are made so that we love first when we see things painted, and that art teaches us to see. He mocks the scheme that would make his pictures do nothing but prompt prayer, and he tells of a fresco whose painted tormentors were scratched and prodded by pious viewers, and a brother's remark that the painting serves its purpose. He recalls the young pupil Hulking Tom, who will take his practice further. The poem ends with Lippo describing the great altarpiece he will paint, with himself half hidden in a corner of heaven and saved by an angel's kindly word, and the dawn comes up and the watch lets him go. It is a lively defense of realism in art and of the goodness of creation, and it has its own tension of piety and appetite. Christian readers can ask how art should honor both the body and the soul.

Virtues in this work

  • Honor: Lippo is honest about his faults, though he excuses them.
  • Temperance: The poem asks how appetite and beauty may be held in right order.

Plot or Argument

  • Lines 1-38: caught at night

    The night watch seizes Lippo in an alley after midnight; he names Cosimo de' Medici and bribes them with a coin.

  • Lines 39-80: the escapade

    Lippo explains that after three weeks of painting saints he heard singers in the street, climbed down from his window and joined them.

  • Lines 81-110: the orphan monk

    He tells of his childhood hunger and how the Carmelites took him at eight and tried to teach him Latin.

  • Lines 111-180: drawing and the Prior

    He draws on his books and walls; the Prior sets him to paint, the monks praise his faces, and then the Prior and the learned forbid such show.

  • Lines 181-264: soul and body

    Lippo argues that body and soul belong together, and complains that the old schooling still looks over his shoulder.

  • Lines 265-299: the pupil and the world

    He says that he sees God in the creation of man, tells of the pupil Hulking Tom and his own view that God made it all to be wondered at.

  • Lines 300-343: art teaches us to see

    Lippo argues that painting makes people love what they have not noticed, while the Prior objects that it does not prompt prayer.

  • Lines 344-392: the altarpiece and the dawn

    He plans to paint a great altarpiece with himself in a corner, in which an angel pleads for him; the day dawns and he goes home.

Characters

  • Fra Lippo Lippi, The friar-painter

    A Carmelite monk of Florence who loves the world and its beauty and paints what he sees.

  • The watch, The guards

    The night watchmen who catch him and whom he bribes and charms.

  • The Prior, The monastery's head

    The Carmelite superior who tells Lippo to paint souls, not bodies.

  • Cosimo de' Medici, The patron

    The wealthy Florentine whose name saves Lippo from the watch.

  • Hulking Tom, The pupil

    A young painter, called Guidi, who is learning from Lippo's practice.

Lessons

  • Beauty may glorify the Creator

    Lippo argues that painting the body and the world is a way of being thankful to God, who made them. The Prior calls this worldly.

    • What is Lippo's case for painting the body?
    • How does the Prior answer him?
  • Art teaches us to see

    Lippo says we first love things when we see them painted, and that art lends our minds out to one another. The poem makes a modest case for beauty as a teacher.

    • What does Lippo say painting does for the viewer?
    • Is his claim true of any art you know?
  • The monk's weakness is part of the picture

    Lippo's night escapade and his plea for mercy complicate the poem's religion with humor. The poem does not hide his faults.

    • How does Lippo excuse himself?
    • What does the poem seem to think of him?

Context

Fra Filippo Lippi was a Carmelite friar and a leading painter of fifteenth-century Florence. Giorgio Vasari's Lives of the Artists, which Browning read, tells of his youth in the Carmelite convent, his patron Cosimo de' Medici and his love affairs.

Composition

The poem refers to Giotto, to the young painter whom Browning's Lippo calls Hulking Tom (an echo of the nickname of Masaccio, whose real name was Tommaso), and, in the closing vision, to the Latin phrase Iste perfecit opus, this man made the work, which echoes an inscription on Lippi's real Coronation of the Virgin.

Reception

Browning's poem was first published in 1855 in Men and Women. It became one of the most admired Victorian poems on the aims of art, and a key text for the view that realism may serve faith.

Comparisons

  • Andrea del Sarto (Called "The Faultless Painter")

    Another Browning monologue on a Florentine painter, which treats the failure of skill without soul where Lippo defends the body and the world.

  • My Last Duchess

    Browning's other famous Italian monologue also lets a speaker reveal himself, with a ruthless Duke in place of a merry monk.

  • God's Grandeur

    Hopkins's poem sees the world charged with the grandeur of God, as Lippo says the world means intensely and means good.

  • The Canterbury Tales

    Chaucer's merry friar and other clerics are comic cousins to Lippo's mix of piety and appetite.

Quotes

“I am poor brother Lippo, by your leave!”
— Robert Browning, Fra Lippo Lippi, Line 1 (The Complete Poetic and Dramatic Works of Robert Browning, Cambridge Edition, ed. Horace E. Scudder (Gutenberg #50954)).Quote card
“Flower o' the broom, Take away love, and our earth is a tomb!”
— Robert Browning, Fra Lippo Lippi, Lines 53-54 (The Complete Poetic and Dramatic Works of Robert Browning, Cambridge Edition, ed. Horace E. Scudder (Gutenberg #50954)).Quote card
“Your business is to paint the souls of men--”
— Robert Browning, Fra Lippo Lippi, Line 183 (The Complete Poetic and Dramatic Works of Robert Browning, Cambridge Edition, ed. Horace E. Scudder (Gutenberg #50954)).Quote card
“You should not take a fellow eight years old And make him swear to never kiss the girls.”
— Robert Browning, Fra Lippo Lippi, Lines 224-225 (The Complete Poetic and Dramatic Works of Robert Browning, Cambridge Edition, ed. Horace E. Scudder (Gutenberg #50954)).Quote card
“Art was given for that; God uses us to help each other so, Lending our minds out.”
— Robert Browning, Fra Lippo Lippi, Lines 304-306 (The Complete Poetic and Dramatic Works of Robert Browning, Cambridge Edition, ed. Horace E. Scudder (Gutenberg #50954)).Quote card
“Iste perfecit opus!”
— Robert Browning, Fra Lippo Lippi, Line 377 (The Complete Poetic and Dramatic Works of Robert Browning, Cambridge Edition, ed. Horace E. Scudder (Gutenberg #50954)).Quote card
“I always see the garden and God there A-making man's wife:”
— Robert Browning, Fra Lippo Lippi, Lines 266-267 (The Complete Poetic and Dramatic Works of Robert Browning, Cambridge Edition, ed. Horace E. Scudder (Gutenberg #50954)).Quote card

For Students

A reading companion for classical Christian high school students. See the student guide.

Reading Guide

Watch for

  • How Lippo moves from excuse to argument to confession.
  • The conflict between the Prior's view of art and Lippo's own.
  • The closing picture of Lippo in a corner of his own painted heaven.

Key terms and names

Dramatic monologue
A poem in which a single speaker addresses a listener and reveals his character.
Carmelite
A member of the Order of Our Lady of Mount Carmel, a religious order of friars.
Prior
The head of a monastery or priory.
Iste perfecit opus
Latin for "this man made the work"; an inscription on the painting.

Seminar Questions

  1. Comprehension How does Lippo come to be a monk, and what does he say about his childhood?
  2. Comprehension What does the Prior tell him to paint, and what does he want to paint?
  3. Interpretation What does Lippo mean when he says that the world means intensely?
  4. Interpretation How does the poem make Lippo both comic and serious?
  5. Big Question Should art serve prayer or truth?
  6. Big Question Does the love of beauty draw us toward God or away from Him?

Faith Connections

  • Genesis 1:31 (Scripture)

    God saw everything that he had made, and it was very good; Lippo's defense of the world rests on this.

  • Psalm 19:1 (Scripture)

    The heavens declare the glory of God; Lippo argues that painting the made world gives thanks for it.

  • Gregory the Great, Letter to Serenus (Church Fathers)

    Pope Gregory wrote that pictures are the books of those who cannot read, a defense of religious images that is close to Lippo's own view that art teaches.

Logic and Rhetoric

Central argument: Lippo argues from creation to art: the world is good and means something, so painting it truthfully honors its maker, and the Prior's demand to paint only the soul is mistaken.

Rhetorical device: Rhetorical self-defense. Lippo explains himself to the watch with wit, confession and argument, and the reader sees that his case is both sincere and self-serving.

Debate: Resolved: Religious art should paint the body as well as the soul.

Memory Work

This world's no blot for us, Nor blank; it means intensely, and means good: To find its meaning is my meat and drink.

Lines 313-315. A famous statement of the goodness of the created world.

For, don't you mark? we're made so that we love First when we see them painted, things we have passed Perhaps a hundred times nor cared to see;

Lines 300-302. Lippo's central argument for the value of painting.

Writing Prompts

Essay: Write an essay on how Browning uses the monologue of Fra Lippo Lippi to explore the relation of body, soul and art.

Comparison with Andrea del Sarto (Called "The Faultless Painter"): Compare the two painters' views of art, ambition and what makes a work great.

Medical Lens

The poem concerns art and the monastic life and includes no medical material.

    Creative Prompts

    • Essay

      Write an essay on the argument between Lippo and the Prior about painting the soul and the body.

    • Poetry

      Write a blank-verse monologue for a craftsman caught out late at night who tries to talk his way free.

    • Adaptation

      Study a painting by Filippo Lippi and describe how it joins body and soul.

    • Classroom

      Debate whether religious art should aim at piety or at truth.

    Further Reading

    • Lives of the Artists (Life of Fra Filippo Lippi), Giorgio Vasari

      Browning's source for the friar's life and temper.

    • Men and Women, Robert Browning

      The 1855 volume in which the poem first appeared.

    • Letter to Serenus of Marseille, Gregory the Great

      A letter defending pictures as the books of those who cannot read.

    Verification notes

    The text follows the Cambridge Edition, ed. Horace E. Scudder, Project Gutenberg #50954, with the editor's headnote omitted; line numbers count the 392 non-blank lines of the hosted text. The date range for Fra Filippo Lippi, the Vasari source and the Hulking Tom connection to Masaccio follow standard accounts and the Coronation of the Virgin inscription have not been matched to a page here, nor has the Gregory the Great letter. Quotes were checked against the hosted text.

    No verification flags recorded.