Work record
The Coming Slavery
Herbert SpencerThe Man Versus the State; The Man vs. the State; The Coming Slavery (Contemporary Review, 1884); Spencer on the New ToryismThe Coming Slavery by Herbert Spencer (1884)The Coming Slavery is the second essay in the book that Herbert Spencer published in 1884 as The Man Versus the State, and it appeared in the Contemporary Review in April of that year.Also known as: The Man Versus the State · The Man vs. the State · The Coming Slavery (Contemporary Review, 1884) · Spencer on the New Toryism
1884 · 19th Century · Essays · English
Read this when a plan to help the poor by public law needs a hard critic.
Abstract
Background. An English philosopher, once close to the Liberal party, writes in 1884, when Parliament is passing laws on housing, health and trades and a socialist movement has begun, and fears that his own party has given up the cause of individual liberty.
Argument. Spencer says pity forgets the faults of the poor, that each regulation prepares another, and that all socialism involves slavery because the individual would work under the orders of officials. He ends by saying that no change of institutions can make good conduct from bad.
Ideas. The essay warns that good aims can carry a State farther than anyone meant. Its claims about the poor, and its use of a law of nature under which the weak must fail, are at odds with Christian charity, and the guide's teacher's note asks students to hold both thoughts.
Text. The text is the essay as printed in the Popular Science Monthly of 1884, and each quotation in the guide was matched to the hosted text. Teachers can pair it with Rerum Novarum and with the library's study guide, seminar questions and memory work.
Key figures
- Spencer: The English philosopher who writes in the first person
- The practical politician: Spencer's name for the legislator who sees only the first effect of a law
- Thomas Spencer: His uncle, a clergyman whose parish is his example
- The Democratic Federation: A socialist body of the day whose proposals he quotes
Summary
The Coming Slavery is the second essay in the book that Herbert Spencer published in 1884 as The Man Versus the State, and it appeared in the Contemporary Review in April of that year. Spencer was alarmed that the Liberal party, which had once stood for the freedom of the individual, was passing law after law to regulate housing, hours, health and trades, and that Conservatives were doing the same. His essay claims that these steps, each defended by a reasonable aim, are a path to a new form of slavery, in which the individual works under the orders of officials for the sake of the whole. He begins with the poor. He says that pity pictures the poor as all deserving, though many are idle and bring misery on themselves, and he argues that relief that is cut off from conduct has made things worse, citing the old poor-law, the new poor-law of 1834 and the work of his uncle, a clergyman who took a stern line with the paupers of his parish. He then compares the housing and other public aids of his own day to the make-wage system of the old poor-law, and introduces the idea of political momentum: the practical politician forgets that a measure, once begun, gathers force. He lists the causes that carry the process along, among them precedent, the failure of one law needing another, the wish of many for a place in the public service, the votes of those who expect gifts, and the work of the schemers. Then he states his charge. All socialism, he writes, involves slavery, because a slave is one who labours under another's direction for another's benefit, and a community that owned all the means of life would stand in that relation to each of its members. He adds that officials would not be better than other men, and that a socialist state would end in despotism. The essay is a strong argument, but it is also a hard one. Spencer's contrast of the deserving and undeserving poor and his appeal to a natural law under which the weak must fail sit uneasily with Christian charity, and the teacher's note in this guide asks students to read his warning about the State with care and to test his remedy against the Gospel.
Virtues in this work
- Prudence: Spencer asks legislators to foresee the course of a measure and not only its first result.
- Charity: The essay is a hard test of charity: it asks how to help the poor without harm, and the teacher's note sets his remedy against the Gospel.
- Humility: The closing sentence reminds the reader that no scheme can improve society without an improvement in character.
Plot or Argument
- Pity and the undeserving poor
Spencer says that pity pictures the suffering poor as all deserving, and he argues that those who suffer by their own misconduct should not be shielded from the results.
- A lesson from the poor-law
He tells the story of his uncle's parish and the new poor-law of 1834, claiming that the withdrawal of easy relief improved the lives of the poor.
- Political momentum
The practical politician thinks only of the first result of a law. Spencer compares him to the engine-driver who cannot stop a train and argues that every measure gathers force.
- The drift to regulation
He lists the causes that carry the process on, from precedent and failed laws to the hopes of voters, the desire for public posts and the work of schemers, and he claims that all point to state ownership.
- All socialism involves slavery
A slave works under the direction of another for the other's benefit. Spencer says that a community which owned all the means of life would stand in that relation to each of its members.
- The rulers would be men
He replies to the claim that the people would keep the rulers in check by saying that officials will serve their own interests, that the machinery will not work as it was planned, and that the result will be despotism.
- No political alchemy
He ends by saying that the welfare of a society depends on the character of its people, and that no change in the form of its institutions can make good conduct out of bad.
Lessons
The State and the freedom of the person
Spencer asks the reader to count the cost to liberty whenever a new law is proposed, and he warns that small steps can sum to a large loss. Students may admire his watchfulness while asking whether his own proposal answers every need.
- What does Spencer mean by saying that all socialism involves slavery?
- Which of his examples of regulation does he seem to treat fairly, and which not?
Political momentum
The comparison of a law to a train gathering speed is a lasting image. It teaches the student to ask where a measure leads, and not only what it does, and it fits the older virtue of prudence.
- Why does Spencer say the practical politician forgets momentum?
- Can you think of a law or custom that grew far beyond its first purpose?
A teacher's note: Spencer and Christian charity
Parts of this essay conflict with the Christian teaching on charity, and teachers should say so plainly before it is read. Spencer divides the poor into the deserving and the undeserving, argues that the pain of the idle should be left to run its course, and defends this by a natural law under which creatures too weak to keep themselves alive must die, which is the thought behind what later writers called social Darwinism. The Gospel gives another account. Every person bears the image of God, the Samaritan helps a stranger without asking whether he deserves it, and the Lord says that what is done for the least of his brothers is done for him. Spencer is right that help which rewards idleness can do harm, and Paul's rule that the one who will not work should not eat is a real part of Scripture, but Paul says it of those who refuse to work, and he tells the church elsewhere to remember the poor. Students are asked to take Spencer's warning about State power seriously, and to ask whether his remedy is Christian.
- What does Spencer mean by calling some of the poor undeserving, and how does the parable of the Good Samaritan answer him?
- Where does Paul's rule that the one who will not work should not eat apply, and where does Spencer stretch it?
Character before structure
The last sentence says that no change in the form of society can make good conduct out of bad instincts. Students can ask where Spencer's point is sound, since laws cannot make people good, and where it neglects the Christian teaching that grace changes the heart.
- Why does Spencer say that political alchemy is impossible?
- What does the Christian account of virtue add to his view of character?
Context
Spencer wrote in Britain in 1884, when the Third Reform Act was about to extend the vote to rural working men, when Parliament was passing laws on housing, factories, sanitation and education, and when the socialist Democratic Federation of H. M. Hyndman had begun to organise. He feared that the Liberal party, to which he had been close, was giving up its tradition of limiting State power.
Composition
The essay was one of four published in the Contemporary Review between February and July 1884 and then collected, with a preface and postscript, as The Man Versus the State. The text hosted here is the one printed in the Popular Science Monthly of New York, transcribed and proofread on Wikisource.
Reception
The book was widely read in Britain and America, and it was welcomed by opponents of State growth and attacked by reformers. Spencer's own reputation declined after his death, and the phrase social Darwinism is now commonly used, often with criticism, of the views he and others drew from evolution.
Comparisons
Read these together
- Arguments Against Socialism: A Reading Path
Fifteen works that argue, from different sides, against common ownership and the planned economy—from Bastiat's parables to Orwell's farm—with the questions each one answers.
- On Liberty
Mill argues from the harm principle for the limits of State power over the individual; Spencer's attack on regulation covers the same ground from a harder, more economic side.
- The Road to Serfdom
Hayek's 1944 argument that planning leads to loss of liberty has a clear ancestor in Spencer's claim that each step of regulation prepares the next.
- That Which Is Seen, and That Which Is Not Seen
Bastiat's rule that the unseen costs of public spending must be counted fits Spencer's argument about the political momentum that a measure gathers.
- Rerum Novarum
Leo XIII rejects the plan of common ownership but also teaches the duty of justice and charity to the poor, which is the Christian answer Spencer's essay needs.
- A Modest Proposal
Swift's satire on the treatment of the Irish poor shows how an argument about the poor can drift from pity to calculation, a risk this essay also runs.
- In Darkest England and the Way Out
General Booth's plan of 1890 to help the poor by a Christian army of relief is a Christian answer to the same problem Spencer addresses.
Quotes
Frequently cited
“they are thought of as the miseries of the deserving poor, instead of being thought of, as in large measure they should be, as the miseries of the undeserving poor.”
Frequently cited
“The theory on which he daily proceeds is that the change caused by his measure will stop where he intends it to stop.”
Frequently cited
“All socialism involves slavery.”
Frequently cited
“Well, the command “if any would not work neither should he eat” is simply a Christian enunciation of that universal law of Nature under which life has reached its present height”
Frequently cited
“There is no political alchemy by which you can get golden conduct out of leaden instincts.”
“To separate pain from ill-doing is to fight against the constitution of things, and will be followed by far more pain.”
“each member of the community as an individual would be a slave to the community as a whole”
“It is assumed that officialism will work as it is intended to work, which it never does.”
For Students
A reading companion for classical Christian high school students. See the student guide.
Reading Guide
Watch for
- The way Spencer first describes the poor, and the words he uses for those he calls undeserving.
- The comparison of a law to a gathering momentum, and where he uses it again.
- Each cause he lists for the growth of regulation, and the example he gives for it.
- The point at which he claims that a socialist state must end in despotism.
Key terms and names
- Poor-law
- The English system of relief for the poor paid for from local rates, reformed in 1834 to make relief harder to obtain.
- Make-wages
- An old practice by which the parish added to a labourer's low wages so that he could live, which Spencer says lowered wages.
- Practical politician
- Spencer's name for the man who thinks only of the first result of a law.
- Socialism
- The doctrine that the community should own the means of production; here, Spencer's name for any scheme of common control.
- Social Darwinism
- A later name for the use of evolution and survival of the fittest to justify a hard view of the poor and the weak.
- Status and contract
- Spencer's pair of terms for a society in which each is bound to a place and one in which each makes free agreements.
Seminar Questions
- Comprehension What does Spencer say that pity tends to forget when it thinks of the poor?
- Comprehension What does he mean by political momentum, and what example does he give?
- Interpretation Why does Spencer say that all socialism involves slavery, and how does he define a slave?
- Interpretation Which of his arguments about State power seem strongest, and which depend on his view of the poor?
- Interpretation How does he use the rule that the one who will not work should not eat, and does he apply it as Paul does?
- Big Question Can a person hold a warning about the power of the State and also hold the Christian duty of charity to the poor? What would each require of the other?
- Big Question What makes a reader treat a hard teacher fairly: how do we learn from an argument that is partly right and partly wrong?
Faith Connections
- Luke 10:25-37 (Scripture)
The parable of the Good Samaritan answers the question of who is a neighbour and shows help given to a stranger without any test of desert, the opposite of Spencer's separation of the deserving from the undeserving.
- 2 Thessalonians 3:10-12 (Scripture)
Paul's rule that if any would not work, neither should he eat is the verse Spencer quotes; read in context, it is addressed to those who refuse work, and Paul asks the church not to grow weary in well doing.
- Matthew 25:31-46 (Scripture)
The Lord says that what is done for the least of his brothers is done for him, which gives the poor a claim on Christian charity that Spencer's natural law does not.
- Leo XIII, Rerum Novarum (1891) (Great Conversation)
The Pope rejects socialism and defends private property but also calls on States and owners to act justly toward the poor, a Christian answer to both sides of Spencer's debate.
Logic and Rhetoric
Central argument: A series of laws, each defended by a good purpose, is carrying England toward a State that owns and controls all of life, and such a State would make each person a slave of the community; the change should be resisted, and the good of society depends on the character of its people, not on the form of its institutions.
Rhetorical device: analogy. Spencer compares the practical politician to the railway engine-driver in Spain who cannot stop a train, to show that a law gathers force once it is begun.
Debate: Resolved: That a long series of reasonable laws can lead a free people into servitude.
Memory Work
All socialism involves slavery.
There is no political alchemy by which you can get golden conduct out of leaden instincts.
Writing Prompts
Essay: Using at least three passages, explain Spencer's argument that a long series of laws can lead to servitude, and say where a Christian student would agree with him and where not.
Comparison with Rerum Novarum: Compare the way Spencer and Leo XIII reply to the plan of common ownership and say how each treats the duty to the poor.
Medical Lens
Spencer objects to State regulation of housing, sanitation and food supply in the 1880s and to the laws on the inspection of dwellings, trades and food. The essay is therefore a useful primary source for the argument over public health measures, though it argues against them and is not a medical text.
- Section on public regulation of housing and trades
Spencer lists the Acts that regulate lodging houses, workshops and food and calls them steps toward regulation of the whole of life.
Creative Prompts
- Essay
Write an essay that sets Spencer's warning about State power beside the Christian duty to care for the poor, and says which parts of his argument a Christian can accept and which he must reject.
- Dialogue
Write a conversation between Spencer and a Victorian clergyman who works among the poor. Let each give his best reason and let the clergyman use the parable of the Good Samaritan.
- Classroom
Hold a debate on the resolution that the State should relieve the poor. Assign the roles of Spencer, Leo XIII, General Booth and a Victorian reformer, and ask each to quote from a hosted text.
Further Reading
- Rerum Novarum, Pope Leo XIII
The Pope's 1891 letter on the condition of the working classes; hosted in this library.
- The Road to Serfdom, Friedrich A. Hayek
- On Liberty, John Stuart Mill
- Herbert Spencer and the Invention of Modern Life, Mark Francis
- Social Darwinism in American Thought, Richard Hofstadter
Verification notes
The text is the essay as printed in the Popular Science Monthly of April 1884, taken from the proofread Wikisource transcription, with the author's source notes gathered at the end and the spelling of the New York printing. The collected book, The Man Versus the State (London, 1884), has small differences of wording and spelling, and its other essays are not included. Every quotation in this file was matched to the hosted text. Spencer's biographical details follow standard reference works. The teacher's note on Christian charity states this guide's judgement and not Spencer's, and the label social Darwinism is a later and disputed one.
- The first publication of the essay in the Contemporary Review in April 1884 is taken from the preface of the book and should be checked against a bibliography.
- Details of Spencer's career at The Economist and the dates of his major works follow standard reference works.
- The claim that the book was widely read and attacked from several sides is drawn from general histories and should be checked.