Read these together

← All companion pairings

Arguments Against Socialism: A Reading Path

Fifteen works that argue, from different sides, against common ownership and the planned economy—from Bastiat's parables to Orwell's farm—with the questions each one answers.

Read these together

Main question: What have serious writers said against the plan of putting the means of production in the hands of the State, and where do their arguments differ or come into conflict with Christian teaching?

This path is a gathering of arguments, not a verdict. The writers disagree among themselves: Bastiat and Spencer argue from liberty, Böhm-Bawerk and Mises from economic reasoning, Leo XIII and Belloc from the rights of the family and of property, and Orwell and Solzhenitsyn from what happened to people. To judge them fairly, a student should also read the case they answer, beginning with The Communist Manifesto.

A suggested order

  1. The first questions. Start with Bastiat: That Which Is Seen, and That Which Is Not Seen (the broken window) and The Law. Both ask who pays, and what the law is for.
  2. A story. Read Eugen Richter's satire, Pictures of the Socialistic Future, a Berlin diary written in 1891, or Animal Farm. Ask how fair a story can be as an argument.
  3. The economic case. Böhm-Bawerk on Marx answers the theory of value; then Mises on economic calculation and Socialism ask how a planner could know what things cost; Hazlitt applies Bastiat's rule to many policies.
  4. The case from liberty and from the person. Tocqueville's Democracy in America warns of a gentle and all-embracing State. Spencer's The Coming Slavery states the case for freedom in its hardest form, and needs the teacher's note. Hayek's Road to Serfdom gives the argument of 1944.
  5. The Christian witness. Rerum Novarum rejects socialism and also calls on owners and the State to do justice to the worker. Belloc's Servile State proposes a society of many owners as the alternative.
  6. What happened. Nineteen Eighty-Four and The Gulag Archipelago show the cost to people of a State that claimed everything.

Context labels

Work Genre Date In the library
Bastiat, What Is Seen and What Is Not Seen Essay 1850 Full text (Stirling translation)
Bastiat, The Law Essay 1850 Full text
Richter, Pictures of the Socialistic Future Satirical novel 1891 Full text (Henry Wright translation)
Böhm-Bawerk, Karl Marx and the Close of His System Economic criticism 1896 Full text
Leo XIII, Rerum Novarum Encyclical 1891 Full text
Spencer, The Coming Slavery Essay 1884 Full text
Belloc, The Servile State Political argument 1912 Full text
Mises, Hayek, Hazlitt, Orwell, Solzhenitsyn Economics, politics, fiction, history 1920–1973 Study guides (the works are under copyright)
Tocqueville, Democracy in America Political thought 1835–1840 Full text

Discussion prompts

  1. Which of these writers argues from the cost, which from freedom, and which from the rights of the family? Which argument seems strongest, and why?
  2. Bastiat says every public benefit has an unseen cost. What does Leo XIII say is owed to the worker that a calculation of cost does not count?
  3. Richter and Orwell write fiction; Mises and Böhm-Bawerk write argument. What can a story do that an argument cannot, and what can it not do?
  4. Belloc says there are only three courses. Do you agree?

Grade range and advisories

Grades 9–12. Orwell and Solzhenitsyn describe imprisonment, hunger and killing and need preview. Richter's satire includes the shooting of fugitives and a mother's breakdown. Tocqueville and Hayek are for the upper grades.

Honest limits

Teachers should name three cautions. Spencer's essay defends a hard line on the poor and uses a natural law of survival that conflicts with Christian charity; read it with the teacher's note. Belloc also wrote works hostile to the Jews, which the library does not host, and his prophecy of a servile Britain was wrong in its main form. Richter's book is a satire by an opponent, a caricature of what the Social Democrats proposed. A path of arguments against one view should be followed by honest reading of the view itself.

Works in this pairing

Animal Farm

1945 · Early 20th Century · Novella

Animal Farm is a short beast fable about a revolution that turns into a tyranny. On Manor Farm near Willingdon in England, the old prize boar Major gathers the animals one night and describes a dream of a world without Man, who takes their milk, eggs and labour and sends them to the knacker when they are old.

Democracy in America

1835 / 1840 · 19th Century · Political Theory

Democracy in America is Tocqueville's great comparative study of democratic society. The first volume examines American political institutions: township government, federalism, courts, associations, parties, newspapers, religion, and the habits that sustain self-government.

Economic Calculation in the Socialist Commonwealth

1920 · Early 20th Century · Political Theory

Economic Calculation in the Socialist Commonwealth is a long article by the Austrian economist Ludwig von Mises, published in German in 1920 in the Archiv für Sozialwissenschaft und Sozialpolitik. It argues that a fully socialist economy, in which the state owns all the means of production, cannot calculate rationally, and it began one of the most important controversies in twentieth-century economics.

Economics in One Lesson

1946 · Postwar Contemporary · Essays

Economics in One Lesson is a short primer that sets out to explain the economic fallacies most common in public debate and to show that nearly all of them come from a single mistake. Henry Hazlitt, then an editorial writer for The New York Times, published it in 1946, and a revised edition with a new concluding chapter appeared in 1979.

Karl Marx and the Close of His System

1896 · 19th Century · Political Theory

Karl Marx and the Close of His System is the Austrian economist Eugen von Böhm-Bawerk's critique of the theory of value at the heart of Marx's Capital. It first appeared in German in 1896 as Zum Abschluss des Marxschen Systems, a contribution to a volume of essays honouring the economist Karl Knies, two years after Friedrich Engels published the third volume of Capital from Marx's manuscripts.

Pictures of the Socialistic Future

1891 · 19th Century · Satire

Pictures of the Socialistic Future is a short satirical novel by the German liberal Eugen Richter, first published in 1891 and offered by its author as a picture freely adapted from the writings of the Social Democratic leader August Bebel. It is told as the diary of a Berlin tradesman, a loyal party man who has worked for years for the cause and who sits down on the first day of the new order to write an account for his children.

Rerum Novarum

1891 · 19th Century · Essays

Rerum Novarum, issued by Pope Leo XIII on 15 May 1891 and addressed to the bishops of the Catholic world, takes its Latin title from its opening words about the spirit of revolutionary change. Its English title is On the Condition of the Working Classes.

Socialism: An Economic and Sociological Analysis

1922 · Early 20th Century · Political Theory

Socialism: An Economic and Sociological Analysis is Ludwig von Mises's comprehensive critique of socialist thought, published in German in 1922 as Die Gemeinwirtschaft and revised in 1932. J. Kahane's English translation appeared in London in 1936; Yale University Press reissued it in 1951 with an epilogue, and the Liberty Fund edition of 1981 added a foreword by F. A. Hayek.

The Coming Slavery

1884 · 19th Century · Essays

The Coming Slavery is the second essay in the book that Herbert Spencer published in 1884 as The Man Versus the State, and it appeared in the Contemporary Review in April of that year. Spencer was alarmed that the Liberal party, which had once stood for the freedom of the individual, was passing law after law to regulate housing, hours, health and trades, and that Conservatives were doing the same.

The Gulag Archipelago

1973 · Postwar Contemporary · History

The Gulag Archipelago, 1918–1956: An Experiment in Literary Investigation is Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn's history of the Soviet system of prisons, labour camps and exile, which he likened to an archipelago of islands scattered across the country, visible only to those taken there. Written in secret between 1958 and 1968, it draws on Solzhenitsyn's own eight years as a prisoner and on the testimony of some two hundred and twenty-seven other former prisoners, together with published Soviet sources.

The Law

1850 · 19th Century · Essays

The Law (La Loi) is a pamphlet of about sixteen thousand words that Frédéric Bastiat published in Paris in 1850, during the Second Republic, when he sat in the Legislative Assembly and was dying of a disease of the throat and lungs. It is his most direct statement of the purpose and limits of law.

The Road to Serfdom

1944 · Early 20th Century · Political Theory

The Road to Serfdom is a short book by the Austrian-born economist F. A. Hayek, written in London during the Second World War and published by Routledge in March 1944 and by the University of Chicago Press that September. Hayek dedicated it to the socialists of all parties.

The Servile State

1912 · Early 20th Century · Political Theory

The Servile State is a short book by Hilaire Belloc, published in London in 1912, that argues that the industrial societies of Europe are moving toward a new form of slavery. His thesis is that a society of free citizens must be a society of many owners.