Read these together
Arguments Against Socialism: A Reading Path
Fifteen works that argue, from different sides, against common ownership and the planned economy—from Bastiat's parables to Orwell's farm—with the questions each one answers.
Read these together
Main question: What have serious writers said against the plan of putting the means of production in the hands of the State, and where do their arguments differ or come into conflict with Christian teaching?
This path is a gathering of arguments, not a verdict. The writers disagree among themselves: Bastiat and Spencer argue from liberty, Böhm-Bawerk and Mises from economic reasoning, Leo XIII and Belloc from the rights of the family and of property, and Orwell and Solzhenitsyn from what happened to people. To judge them fairly, a student should also read the case they answer, beginning with The Communist Manifesto.
A suggested order
- The first questions. Start with Bastiat: That Which Is Seen, and That Which Is Not Seen (the broken window) and The Law. Both ask who pays, and what the law is for.
- A story. Read Eugen Richter's satire, Pictures of the Socialistic Future, a Berlin diary written in 1891, or Animal Farm. Ask how fair a story can be as an argument.
- The economic case. Böhm-Bawerk on Marx answers the theory of value; then Mises on economic calculation and Socialism ask how a planner could know what things cost; Hazlitt applies Bastiat's rule to many policies.
- The case from liberty and from the person. Tocqueville's Democracy in America warns of a gentle and all-embracing State. Spencer's The Coming Slavery states the case for freedom in its hardest form, and needs the teacher's note. Hayek's Road to Serfdom gives the argument of 1944.
- The Christian witness. Rerum Novarum rejects socialism and also calls on owners and the State to do justice to the worker. Belloc's Servile State proposes a society of many owners as the alternative.
- What happened. Nineteen Eighty-Four and The Gulag Archipelago show the cost to people of a State that claimed everything.
Context labels
| Work | Genre | Date | In the library |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bastiat, What Is Seen and What Is Not Seen | Essay | 1850 | Full text (Stirling translation) |
| Bastiat, The Law | Essay | 1850 | Full text |
| Richter, Pictures of the Socialistic Future | Satirical novel | 1891 | Full text (Henry Wright translation) |
| Böhm-Bawerk, Karl Marx and the Close of His System | Economic criticism | 1896 | Full text |
| Leo XIII, Rerum Novarum | Encyclical | 1891 | Full text |
| Spencer, The Coming Slavery | Essay | 1884 | Full text |
| Belloc, The Servile State | Political argument | 1912 | Full text |
| Mises, Hayek, Hazlitt, Orwell, Solzhenitsyn | Economics, politics, fiction, history | 1920–1973 | Study guides (the works are under copyright) |
| Tocqueville, Democracy in America | Political thought | 1835–1840 | Full text |
Discussion prompts
- Which of these writers argues from the cost, which from freedom, and which from the rights of the family? Which argument seems strongest, and why?
- Bastiat says every public benefit has an unseen cost. What does Leo XIII say is owed to the worker that a calculation of cost does not count?
- Richter and Orwell write fiction; Mises and Böhm-Bawerk write argument. What can a story do that an argument cannot, and what can it not do?
- Belloc says there are only three courses. Do you agree?
Grade range and advisories
Grades 9–12. Orwell and Solzhenitsyn describe imprisonment, hunger and killing and need preview. Richter's satire includes the shooting of fugitives and a mother's breakdown. Tocqueville and Hayek are for the upper grades.
Honest limits
Teachers should name three cautions. Spencer's essay defends a hard line on the poor and uses a natural law of survival that conflicts with Christian charity; read it with the teacher's note. Belloc also wrote works hostile to the Jews, which the library does not host, and his prophecy of a servile Britain was wrong in its main form. Richter's book is a satire by an opponent, a caricature of what the Social Democrats proposed. A path of arguments against one view should be followed by honest reading of the view itself.