Work record
The Servile State
Hilaire BellocServile State; The Servile State (1912); Belloc on Distributism; Hilaire Belloc's Servile StateThe Servile State by Hilaire Belloc (1912)The Servile State is a short book by Hilaire Belloc, published in London in 1912, that argues that the industrial societies of Europe are moving toward a new form of slavery.Also known as: Servile State · The Servile State (1912) · Belloc on Distributism · Hilaire Belloc's Servile State
1912 · Early 20th Century · Political Theory · English
Read this when you want to ask who owns the means of life and what follows.
Abstract
Background. An English Catholic writer and former member of Parliament, writing in 1912 just after the National Insurance Act, argues that the industrial societies of Europe are drifting toward a new kind of slavery.
Argument. A society of a few owners and many propertyless people is unstable, and must put property in the hands of many, or of the officials, or must bind the propertyless by law to labour for the owners. Belloc says Socialism and reform will lead to the third, and cites the Insurance Act.
Ideas. The book joins history and argument, and asks whether freedom needs property. It is a work of Catholic polemic, its history is disputed, and its prophecy did not come true in the form he gave. Students are asked to weigh the argument on its merits, and to read the author's other writings with great care.
Text. The text is the 1912 edition as given by Project Gutenberg, and each quotation in the guide was matched to the hosted text. Teachers can pair it with Rerum Novarum and with the library's study guide, seminar questions and memory work for a seminar of several class periods.
Key figures
- Belloc: The Anglo-French writer who speaks in the first person
- The capitalist: The owner of the means of production in Belloc's account
- The proletarian: The free citizen who owns nothing by which to live
- The peasant owner: The medieval figure of the free small owner whom Belloc praises
Summary
The Servile State is a short book by Hilaire Belloc, published in London in 1912, that argues that the industrial societies of Europe are moving toward a new form of slavery. His thesis is that a society of free citizens must be a society of many owners. Where most people own none of the land or the tools by which wealth is made, as in the England of his day, the owners and the owned stand in an unstable relation, and the state must settle it in one of three ways. It can put property back into many hands, a Distributive State of small owners. It can put property in the hands of the political officers of the community, which Belloc calls Collectivism or Socialism. Or it can let a society keep the owners and the propertyless and compel the second by law to work for the first, which is the Servile State. He begins with definitions, then tells a history. The ancient world rested on slavery. The Christian Church, by the force of its teaching on the human person, wore the institution away over the Middle Ages, and the serf became a peasant owner. The society of small owners was nearly complete in the late Middle Ages, and Belloc says that it was destroyed in England by the seizure of the monastic lands under Henry VIII, which put the land into a few hands and made the capitalist State. Capitalism, he argues, cannot last because its owners and workers cannot be at peace, and the easiest apparent cure is Socialism. But the socialist and the reforming capitalist alike, as he sees it, will end by making the workers a class bound by law, and he finds the first signs in the Insurance Act of 1911 and other laws that treat the wage earner as a separate order. The book is a work of argument and of Catholic history, not of neutral scholarship, and its history of the Reformation is disputed. Its prediction of a servile Britain did not come to pass in the form he gave. It remains a clear statement of a question many thinkers have asked: who owns, and what does ownership do for freedom.
Virtues in this work
- Justice: Belloc asks what is owed to each family in the use of the goods of the earth and who may be bound to labour for another.
- Prudence: The book asks the reader to see where the laws of the day lead before they have led there.
- Fortitude: Belloc admires the peasant and the free society that hold to their own against the tide of the age.
Plot or Argument
- Introduction and plan
Belloc states his thesis that industrial society tends toward the re-establishment of slavery, and sets out the three possible solutions: Collectivism, a distribution of property, or servitude.
- Definitions (Section One)
He defines wealth, capital, property and the proletariat, then defines the capitalist state and the servile state. The servile state is one in which so many are bound by law to labour for others that the whole community bears the mark.
- Slavery in the old world and its dissolution (Sections Two and Three)
The ancient world took slavery for granted, and Belloc says the Church's teaching slowly wore it down, so that the slave became a serf and then a peasant who owned his land.
- How the Distributive State failed (Section Four)
In England, he says, the confiscation of the monastic lands and the rise of a landed oligarchy ended the state of many owners and made the country capitalist before the age of machines.
- The capitalist state is unstable (Section Five)
A society of a few owners and a free propertyless majority cannot rest, because the two groups have opposed interests and the workers are insecure.
- The stable solutions (Section Six)
Property must be put into the hands of many or of none, and Belloc says there is no third course. A third resolution, servitude, is the one the system tends to choose.
- Socialism and reform (Sections Seven and Eight)
Socialism appears the easiest cure, but its means of carrying it out will give officials control of labour. Reformers who accept the capitalist system and seek to relieve it make for the same end.
- The Servile State has begun (Section Nine and Conclusion)
He cites the Insurance Act of 1911 and other laws, which treat wage earners as a separate class, as the first signs, and ends by hoping that free societies, especially France and Ireland, may check the tendency.
Lessons
Ownership and freedom
Belloc asks whether a man can be free if he owns nothing by which to live. Students can weigh his claim that widely spread property is the safeguard of liberty, and compare it with the Christian teaching that property is a trust for the good of the household and the neighbour.
- Why does Belloc say a free society needs many owners?
- What does the Church teach about property, and does it support Belloc's reading?
Three solutions, and a false third
The book states its case as a choice among three courses and warns against a middle path that does not exist. A careful reader tests the dilemma: are there really only three, or has Belloc simplified the case?
- Name the three solutions Belloc gives. Do you think they are the only ones?
- Which of the three would Belloc's critics say is missing?
History as an argument
Belloc tells the story of Christian Europe from antiquity to the Reformation to support his thesis. Students learn to see how a historian's account serves an argument and to ask where the evidence is thin, as with his claims about the monastic lands and the free peasantry.
- How does the story of the serf and the peasant support his thesis?
- What would a historian who disagreed with his account of the sixteenth century reply?
A teacher's note on Belloc
Belloc was a brilliant and combative writer, and teachers should tell students that he was also the author of later works that are hostile to the Jews, including The Jews of 1922. Those writings are not part of this book, which does not turn on them, but they are part of his record and are no more to be excused than imitated. His prophecy of a servile Britain was also wrong in its main form: the welfare measures he feared were widely accepted, and the English wage earner did not become a bondman. Students should read him as a clear and forceful voice in a continuing argument, and weigh the argument by the text.
- What does it mean to learn from an author whose other writings we reject?
- Was Belloc's prediction wrong in every respect, or does some part of his question still stand?
Context
Belloc wrote in Edwardian England, when the Liberal government of Asquith and Lloyd George was passing the first national insurance law, the Labour party had entered Parliament and Fabian socialists were proposing State planning. The book answers both the socialists and the reforming capitalists.
Composition
He published the book in 1912, in the year after the National Insurance Act, and used the Act as his chief example. He had left the House of Commons in 1910 and was writing for the press, and he was already arguing with Chesterton and others for the ideas that later became distributism.
Reception
The book was influential among Catholic writers and among the circle of Chesterton and Belloc, and it was later cited by opponents of the growth of the welfare State. Historians dispute its account of the sixteenth century, and the servile order it predicted did not arrive in the form he feared.
Comparisons
Read these together
- Arguments Against Socialism: A Reading Path
Fifteen works that argue, from different sides, against common ownership and the planned economy—from Bastiat's parables to Orwell's farm—with the questions each one answers.
- Rerum Novarum
Leo XIII defends private property and the rights of workers in 1891, and distributists like Belloc took the encyclical as the root of their argument for a society of small owners.
- The Road to Serfdom
Hayek argues in 1944 that planning leads to servitude, an argument which Belloc's 1912 book anticipates in a different key, with property as the safeguard.
- The Communist Manifesto
The Manifesto answers the same unrest of owners and wage earners with common ownership, the Collectivist solution that Belloc rejects.
- Utopia
More's Utopia, written at the end of the age Belloc praises, imagines an island without private property, and also describes the enclosures that turned peasants from the land.
- Socialism: An Economic and Sociological Analysis
Mises criticises socialism on the ground of economic calculation, while Belloc criticises it on the ground of freedom; the two arguments reach a common conclusion by different roads.
- Orthodoxy
Belloc's friend Chesterton gave the idea of a society of small owners its popular voice, and Orthodoxy shows the temper of the circle in which it grew.
Quotes
Frequently cited
“Property, or the re-establishment of a Distributive State in which the mass of citizens should severally own the means of production.”
Frequently cited
“constrained by positive law to labour for the advantage of other families and individuals as to stamp the whole community with the mark of such labour we call The Servile State”
Frequently cited
“It was not machinery that lost us our freedom; it was the loss of a free mind.”
Frequently cited
“by putting property into the hands of many, or by putting it into the hands of none. There is no third course.”
“Collectivism, or the placing of the means of production in the hands of the political officers of the community.”
“Slavery, or a Servile State in which those who do not own the means of production shall be legally compelled to work for those who do”
“which examples prove that the Servile State is actually upon us”
For Students
A reading companion for classical Christian high school students. See the student guide.
Reading Guide
Watch for
- Belloc's three words for the three solutions and the order in which he presents them.
- The definition of the Servile State in Section One and the three negative limits he places on it.
- Each stage of his history, from slavery to the serf to the peasant owner to the capitalist.
- The examples from English law in Section Nine and the way he reads them.
Key terms and names
- Servile State
- Belloc's name for a society in which so many are bound by law to labour for others that the whole community bears the mark of it.
- Distributive State
- A society in which property, especially land and tools, is spread among the mass of citizens.
- Capitalist State
- A society of political freedom in which the means of production are owned by a few and most are propertyless.
- Collectivism
- The plan of putting the means of production in the hands of the political officers of the community.
- Proletariat
- In Belloc's use, the class of citizens who own no capital and live by wages.
- Status and contract
- The contrast between a place fixed by law and a place fixed by free agreement.
Seminar Questions
- Comprehension What are the three solutions that Belloc says a capitalist society may choose, and which does he predict?
- Comprehension How does Belloc define the Servile State, and what does he say it is not?
- Interpretation Why does Belloc say the Church had a part in ending slavery, and how does this support his thesis?
- Interpretation How does he use the Insurance Act of 1911 to support his claim, and how might a defender of the Act reply?
- Interpretation Why does Belloc say that Socialism and capitalist reform lead to the same end?
- Big Question What makes a person free: law, property, character, or all of these? How does Christian teaching on the person and on property bear on the question?
- Big Question If a historian's account serves an argument, how should a reader use the book, and how does a student treat an author whose later views he must reject?
Faith Connections
- 1 Kings 21:1-19 (Scripture)
The story of Naboth's vineyard shows a king seizing a man's inheritance and the prophet's rebuke, which bears on Belloc's claim that property in the hands of the family is a safeguard against power.
- Philemon 15-17 (Scripture)
Paul asks Philemon to receive his runaway slave no longer as a slave but as a beloved brother, an early example of how the Christian teaching on the person works against slavery.
- Leo XIII, Rerum Novarum (1891) (Great Conversation)
The encyclical defends the right of the family to hold property and calls on the State to spread it widely; Belloc's book is a development of that teaching.
Logic and Rhetoric
Central argument: A capitalist society, in which most citizens are propertyless, is unstable and must resolve into one of three forms: a society of many owners, a collectivism run by officials, or a society in which the propertyless are bound by law to labour for the owners; the first has failed, the second will tend to the third, and the reforms of his time are already moving toward servitude.
Rhetorical device: dilemma. Belloc says that property must be put into the hands of many or of none, and that there is no third course.
Debate: Resolved: That a free society requires the widespread ownership of property.
Memory Work
It was not machinery that lost us our freedom; it was the loss of a free mind.
by putting property into the hands of many, or by putting it into the hands of none. There is no third course.
Writing Prompts
Essay: Using at least three passages, explain Belloc's argument that Socialism and capitalist reform both lead to the Servile State, and say whether his dilemma is a fair one.
Comparison with Rerum Novarum: Compare what Leo XIII says on property with what Belloc builds on it, and say where the book goes beyond the encyclical.
Medical Lens
The book contains no medical subject matter beyond its discussion of insurance against sickness in the Act of 1911, which Belloc treats as a political measure.
Creative Prompts
- Essay
Write an essay that tests Belloc's claim that there are only three solutions to the problem of capitalism, and say whether a fourth course exists.
- Dialogue
Write a conversation between Belloc and a Fabian socialist in 1912. Let the Fabian defend the Insurance Act as a gain for the worker and Belloc reply that it makes him a separate class.
- Classroom
Hold a debate on the resolution that widely spread property is the best safeguard of a free society. Ask the affirmative to use Belloc and the negative to find the limits of the claim.
- Essay
Compare Belloc's account of the Church and the end of slavery in the Middle Ages with a reliable history, and say where his account holds and where it needs correction.
Further Reading
- Rerum Novarum, Pope Leo XIII
Hosted in this library.
- The Road to Serfdom, Friedrich A. Hayek
- What's Wrong with the World, G. K. Chesterton
Chesterton's book of 1910 on the family and small property.
- Hilaire Belloc, A. N. Wilson
- An Essay on the Restoration of Property, Hilaire Belloc
Belloc's later short statement of the distributist case (1936).
Verification notes
The text is the 1912 edition as produced by Project Gutenberg from page images, with the synopsis, the nine sections, the appendix, the conclusion and the author's notes; Belloc's italics marked with slashes in the Gutenberg file were removed. Every quotation in this file was matched to the hosted text. The details of Belloc's life follow standard reference works. The summary of his argument reports his claims, and several of them, including his account of the monastic lands and the free peasantry, are matters of dispute among historians. The teacher's note describes Belloc's later writings from standard biographies and does not quote them.
- Belloc's birth place, the dates of his seat in the Commons (1906–1910) and of his naturalisation (1902) follow standard reference works.
- The date and title of his later work on the Jews (1922) should be checked against a bibliography.
- The claim that the book was influential in Catholic and distributist circles is taken from general accounts.
- The description of the National Insurance Act of 1911 follows Belloc's own account, which is a polemic.