Work record

The Private Memoirs and Confessions of a Justified Sinner

Name: The Private Memoirs and Confessions of a Justified Sinner
Author: James Hogg

James Hogg

1824 · 19th Century · Novel · English

Public domainmedium medical relevanceRead full text Download EPUB Five-minute digest

Abstract

Written: Published anonymously, 1824
Setting: About 1687-1712, with a frame set in 1823; Dalcastle, Edinburgh and the Scottish Borders
Author: James Hogg
Country: Kingdom of Great Britain
Language: English
Genre: Gothic novel / religious satire
Form: Prose in three parts: an editor's account, a first-person memoir and a closing frame
Recommended: Grades 11–12 (Scots dialogue, nested narrators, murder and suicide; preview for grades 11-12.)

Background. Hogg, a Borders shepherd turned author, published the book without his name and even wrote himself into its frame as a gruff local who refuses to help dig up a grave. It grew out of Scottish memories of fierce doctrinal quarrels.

Content. A worldly laird's wife leaves him for the guidance of a fanatical minister. Her younger son, raised by that preacher, becomes convinced that heaven has chosen him beyond any possibility of loss. A stranger who can take on any face encourages him to strike down those he calls God's foes, beginning with a clergyman and his own elder sibling. A housekeeper pieces the crime together, while the murderer's own record shows him haunted, confused and finally desperate.

Form. One story told twice, first by a sceptical modern compiler and then by the killer himself, with a coda about a recovered manuscript.

Themes. Pride dressed as holiness, the devil's flattery, the divided self, and the abuse of doctrine to excuse sin.

Reception. Neglected for a century, it was championed by modern critics and is now ranked among the finest Scottish novels. Much of the action moves between the Tolbooth wynds of the capital and the hill farms of the Borders, landscapes the shepherd-author knew intimately, with supernatural touches drawn from local legend.

For students. For grades 11-12 with preview; read with Romans 6 and James 2.

Main characters

Robert Wringhim Colwan: Self-styled elect murderer
Gil-Martin: His mysterious double and tempter
George Colwan: His murdered half-brother
Mrs Logan: Housekeeper seeking justice
The editor: Presenter of the documents

Summary

The Private Memoirs and Confessions of a Justified Sinner, published anonymously by James Hogg in 1824, is a Scottish novel told in three parts. First an unnamed editor, writing more than a century after the events, tells the story as tradition and documents preserve it. In about 1687 the jovial laird of Dalcastle marries a severe and pious young woman who soon separates from him and lives under the spiritual direction of the Reverend Robert Wringhim, an extreme Calvinist preacher. She bears two sons: George, raised by the laird as his heir, and Robert, who is disowned by the laird, adopted by Wringhim and raised to believe he is one of the elect. Robert grows up hating George, pursues him through Edinburgh, and at last George is found murdered. Robert inherits the estate, but evidence gathered by the laird's housekeeper Mrs Logan points to him, and he vanishes. The second part is Robert's own memoir. On the day Wringhim tells him that he is justified, that is, assured of salvation so that no future act can endanger his soul, Robert meets a mysterious stranger who resembles him and who later says he may be called Gil-Martin. The stranger flatters Robert's sense of election and persuades him that the elect may destroy God's enemies. Under his influence Robert murders a preacher, then his brother, and loses track of days, accused of crimes he cannot remember. Hounded by Gil-Martin, whom the reader increasingly recognises as the devil, Robert flees across the country in terror and ends his memoir before taking his own life. In the final part the editor reports the opening of a suicide's grave in 1823, described in a letter by one James Hogg, and the discovery of the manuscript. The novel leaves open whether Gil-Martin is a real devil or a projection of Robert's mind. It is a powerful satire of antinomianism, the belief that the saved are free from the moral law, and a profound study of spiritual pride, though it is not an attack on Christian faith as such: the sincere believers in the book, and the plain decency of Mrs Logan and the laird's household, stand against Robert's self-righteous madness.

Virtues in this work

Humility: Robert's ruin shows its opposite, spiritual pride.
Justice: Mrs Logan patiently pursues the truth about George's murder.

Plot or Argument

The editor's narrative
The laird of Dalcastle's unhappy marriage, the two sons, Robert's persecution of George and George's murder.
Mrs Logan's inquiry
The laird's housekeeper and Arabella Calvert uncover evidence pointing to Robert, who disappears.
Robert's memoir: justification
Declared justified by Wringhim, Robert meets the stranger Gil-Martin, who encourages him to kill God's supposed enemies.
Robert's memoir: the crimes
Robert murders a minister and his brother and finds himself accused of deeds he cannot remember.
Robert's memoir: flight
Pursued by Gil-Martin, he flees in terror and ends his account.
The grave
The editor tells of the 1823 opening of a suicide's grave and the recovery of the manuscript.

Characters

Robert Wringhim Colwan, narrator of the memoir
A young man convinced of his election who becomes a murderer.
Gil-Martin, tempter
A shape-shifting stranger who flatters and drives Robert; probably the devil.
George Colwan, brother
The laird's cheerful heir, murdered by Robert.
Rev. Robert Wringhim, minister
An extreme Calvinist preacher who raises Robert.
Lady Dalcastle, mother
Robert's severe, religious mother.
Mrs Logan, investigator
The laird's housekeeper who seeks the truth about George's death.
The editor, narrator
A rational modern who presents the documents.

Lessons

The danger of spiritual pride
Robert believes his salvation makes him above the moral law. The novel shows pride disguised as piety.
- What does Wringhim tell Robert about being justified?
- How does Gil-Martin use that belief?
- How does Romans 6:1-2 answer Robert?
Related across the library
- Mere Christianity, Lesson: Pride as the great sin
  Pride as the great sin. Lewis sets pride above sensual sins as the root of the others, because it is essentially competitive and sets the self against God and neighbour. He adds that the humble person will not be thinking about humility at all, but will simply be less occupied with himself.
- On the Making of Man, Wm. B. Eerdmans Publishing Company Grand Rapids, Michigan
  is that God is really incomprehensible and that here we can never know His name This should have led to a statement of the claims of the Sacraments as placing us in heart and spirit but not in mind in communion with this incomprehensible God But this would have been useless with such opponents as the Eunomians Accuracy of doctrine and clearness of statement was to them salvation mysteries were worse than nothing Only in the intervals of the logical battle and for the sake of the faithful does Gregory recur to th...
- Tales from Shakespeare, Full Text
  and Bassanio awaited in dreadful suspense the event of the trial When Portia parted with her husband she spoke cheeringly to him and bade him bring his dear friend along with him when he returned yet she feared it would go hard with Antonio and when she was left alone she began to think and consider within herself if she could by any means be instrumental in saving the life of her dear Bassanio's friend and notwithstanding when she wished to honour her Bassanio she had said to him with such a meek and wifelike g...
- Moby-Dick, Source
  The Needle CHAPTER The Log and Line CHAPTER The Life-Buoy CHAPTER The Deck CHAPTER The Pequod Meets The Rachel CHAPTER The Cabin CHAPTER The Hat CHAPTER The Pequod Meets The Delight CHAPTER The Symphony CHAPTER The Chase First Day CHAPTER The Chase Second Day CHAPTER The Chase Third Day Epilogue Original Transcriber s Notes This text is a combination of etexts one from the now-defunct ERIS project at Virginia Tech and one from Project Gutenberg s archives The proofreaders of this version are indebted to The Univ...
- Narrative of the Life and What to the Slave Is the Fourth of July?, Chapter X
  and he proved himself an instrument in the hands of the church in converting many souls His house was the preachers home They used to take great pleasure in coming there to put up for while he starved us he stuffed them We have had three or four preachers there at a time The names of those who used to come most frequently while I lived there were Mr Storks Mr Ewery Mr Humphry and Mr Hickey I have also seen Mr George Cookman at our house We slaves loved Mr Cookman We believed him to be a good man We thought him i...
The tempter's method
Gil-Martin flatters, imitates and argues from Scripture. Temptation often comes looking like ourselves.
- Why does Gil-Martin resemble Robert?
- Compare Matthew 4 and the devil's use of Scripture.
- Where might Robert have resisted?
Related across the library
- Beyond Good and Evil, Lesson: Suffering is to be interpreted, not only abolished
  Suffering is to be interpreted, not only abolished. Nietzsche attacks the goal of eliminating all suffering and claims that great suffering has disciplined human greatness. The provocation forces clinicians and ethicists to distinguish suffering that degrades from difficulty that can be integrated.
- The Argonautica, Lesson: A leader who needs others
  A leader who needs others. Jason is chosen captain only after Heracles refuses the post, and he often despairs. He succeeds by persuasion, by counsel from Phineus and Argus, and above all by Medea's help, which makes the poem a study of a different kind of heroism from Achilles' self-sufficient strength.
- Beyond Good and Evil, Lesson: The 'I' that thinks is an inference from grammar
  The 'I' that thinks is an inference from grammar. Section 17 argues that thoughts arrive when they will, and that positing an 'I' as their cause reads grammar into reality. Nietzsche replaces the sovereign subject with a society of drives competing for command.
- Grace Abounding to the Chief of Sinners, §§142-228
  The long period of despair under the example of Esau, with physical sensations he attributes to guilt.
- The Devils, Lesson: Faith and unbelief
  Faith and unbelief. Shatov and Kirillov embody the struggle with God.
Who is telling the truth?
The editor and Robert give conflicting accounts. Readers must weigh evidence.
- How do the two narratives differ?
- Is Gil-Martin real or in Robert's mind?
- Why might Hogg leave the question open?
Related across the library
- Hamlet, Lesson: Repentance that will not let go
  Repentance that will not let go. Claudius wants forgiveness but will not give up his crown, his queen or his ambition. Shakespeare shows that true repentance requires surrender of the fruits of sin.
- The Trial of Joan of Arc, Medical lens
  Joan's voices are a classic case for the ethics of retrospective diagnosis. Epilepsy, migraine, schizophrenia, trauma, and dissociation have all been proposed in modern discussions, but the trial record is not a clinical interview and is shaped by coercion, translation, theology, and politics. Present diagnostic language as hypothesis about reception, not fact about Joan.
- Othello, Lesson: The outsider and the city
  The outsider and the city. Venice honours Othello as the general it needs, but Iago, Roderigo and Brabantio speak of him in animal and devilish images. Othello wins Desdemona by telling his history, and he ends by narrating it again, comparing himself to the Turk he once struck down. His dignity and his isolation are both part of the tragedy.
- Beyond Good and Evil, Lesson: The 'I' that thinks is an inference from grammar
  The 'I' that thinks is an inference from grammar. Section 17 argues that thoughts arrive when they will, and that positing an 'I' as their cause reads grammar into reality. Nietzsche replaces the sovereign subject with a society of drives competing for command.
- The Trial of Joan of Arc, Summary
  The trial records of Joan of Arc are not a saint's life in the ordinary devotional sense. They are hostile legal documents that accidentally preserve one of the most vivid medieval voices. In 1431, after capture by Burgundian forces and transfer to English custody, Joan was examined at Rouen by an ecclesiastical court led by Pierre Cauchon. The judges pressed her on clothing, obedience, signs, visions, sacraments, and political claims. She answered as a teenager under lethal pressure: evasive when necessary, bol...

Context

Set in Scotland from about 1687 to 1712, after the Revolution settlement of 1690 restored Presbyterianism; it reflects old quarrels between strict Covenanting Calvinists and moderate or Episcopalian Scots. Hogg wrote in the age of Scott and the Edinburgh Enlightenment.

Composition

Published anonymously in London by Longman in 1824; Hogg inserts a letter by himself, originally printed in Blackwood's Magazine in 1823, about the opening of a suicide's grave.

Reception

Little noticed in Hogg's lifetime and later reissued in bowdlerised form, it was rediscovered in the twentieth century, notably by André Gide, and is now regarded as a Scottish masterpiece.

Guilt Sin Faith / Religion Madness / Mind Crime / Punishment The Supernatural Family Identity Self

Comparisons

Paradise Lost
Milton's Satan also seduces by flattery and argument.
Dracula
Another Gothic novel told through documents.
Frankenstein
A Gothic tale of a divided self and nested narrators.
Tam o’ Shanter
Burns's comic Scottish encounter with the devil.

Quotes

Frequently cited

“How delightful to think that a justified person can do no wrong!”

— James Hogg, The Private Memoirs and Confessions of a Justified Sinner, Editor's narrative (Gutenberg #2276: The Private Memoirs and Confessions of a Justified Sinner).Quote card

The Philosophy of History, Summary
The Philosophy of History (Vorlesungen über die Philosophie der Geschichte) is the posthumous edition of the lectures on the philosophy of world history that G. W. F. Hegel gave five times at the University of Berlin between the winter of 1822-23 and that of 1830-31. Hegel never wrote it as a book. After his death, his student Eduard Gans assembled the text from Hegel's own manuscripts and students' notebooks and published it in 1837 in the collected works; Hegel's son Karl revised it in 1840, and J. Sibree's En...
Pragmatism: A New Name for Some Old Ways of Thinking, Full Text
Philosophical Review vol xv pp and in Mind vol xv p and in the Journal of Philosophy vol iv p Probably the best statements to begin with however are F C S Schiller's in his Studies in Humanism especially the essays numbered i v vi vii xviii and xix His previous essays and in general the polemic literature of the subject are fully referred to in his footnotes Furthermore see G Milhaud le Rationnel and the fine articles by Le Roy in the Revue de Metaphysique vols and Also articles by Blondel and de Sailly in the A...
The History of the Church, Books 5–6, martyr narratives
Accounts of imprisoned and tortured Christians make bodily suffering central to communal memory.
Seven Pillars of Wisdom, Book VI (Deraa, November 1917)
Lawrence's account of his capture, flogging and sexual assault and of the lasting damage to his sense of self. Handle with care: the account is contested as fact and should be cited as his testimony.
Seven Pillars of Wisdom, Summary
Seven Pillars of Wisdom is Lawrence's account of his two years with the Arab Revolt against the Ottoman Empire, from his first visit to the Hejaz in October 1916 to the entry into Damascus in October 1918. It opens with an introductory chapter that admits the book's political bad conscience: Lawrence knew that Britain and France had already divided the Arab lands in the Sykes–Picot agreement while he encouraged the Arabs to fight for independence. The narrative proper begins in Jidda and Rabegh, where Lawrence j...

“I was born an outcast in the world, in which I was destined to act so conspicuous a part.”

— James Hogg, The Private Memoirs and Confessions of a Justified Sinner, Opening of the memoir (Gutenberg #2276: The Private Memoirs and Confessions of a Justified Sinner).Quote card

The Nature of the Physical World, Chapter XIII (Reality)
Eddington proposes that the stuff of the world is of a mental character, known directly only in consciousness.
Middlemarch, Book II, Chapter XXI
We are all of us born in moral stupidity, taking the world as an udder to feed our supreme selves As Dorothea begins to see that Casaubon has an equivalent center of self, with his own anxieties.
The Commonwealth of Oceana, Full Text
who had once acted as governor to the princess and won her affection was James Harrington s uncle and she now cordially welcomed the young student of life for his uncle s sake and for his own pleasantness of outward wit and inward gravity of thought Harrington was taken with him by the exiled and plundered Prince Elector when he paid a visit to the Court of Denmark and he was intrusted afterward with the chief care of the prince s affairs in England From Holland James Harrington passed through Flanders into Fran...
This Side of Paradise, Full Text
Honestly there are only two costumes in the world that I really enjoy being in Combing her hair at the dressing-table One s a hoop skirt with pantaloons the other s a one-piece bathing-suit I m quite charming in both of them CECELIA Glad you re coming out ROSALIND Yes aren t you CECELIA Cynically You re glad so you can get married and live on Long Island with the fast younger married set You want life to be a chain of flirtation with a man for every link ROSALIND Want it to be one You mean I ve found it one CECE...
The Road to Serfdom, Summary
The Road to Serfdom is a short book by the Austrian-born economist F. A. Hayek, written in London during the Second World War and published by Routledge in March 1944 and by the University of Chicago Press that September. Hayek dedicated it to the socialists of all parties. His claim was that many in Britain and America who sincerely wanted freedom and prosperity were embracing central economic planning, and that comprehensive planning would, step by step and against the intentions of its supporters, lead to the...

“you may call me Gil-Martin. It is not my Christian name; but it is a name which may serve your turn.”

— James Hogg, The Private Memoirs and Confessions of a Justified Sinner, Robert's memoir (Gutenberg #2276: The Private Memoirs and Confessions of a Justified Sinner).Quote card

The Bible, Proverbs 17:22
A merry heart doeth good like a medicine: but a broken spirit drieth the bones A wisdom saying linking mood and bodily health.
Twenty Years at Hull-House, Full Text
Hull-House South Halsted Street opposite Hull-House Consulting the Hull-House Bulletin Board from a Photograph by Lewis W Hine A Boy's Club Member An Italian Woman with Grandchild Portrait Jane Addams from a Charcoal Drawing by Alice Kellogg Tyler of Main Entrance to Hull-House Head of Slavic Woman Head of Italian Woman A Doorway in Hull-House Court Woman and Child in Hull-House Reception Room In a Tenement House Sick Mother and Children A Row of Nursery Babies A Neighborhood Alley Hull-House on Halsted Street A...
The Expression of the Emotions in Man and Animals, Introduction
garantir du mal que l me aper oit et le c t qui est abaiss et qui para t enfl nous fait trouver dans cet tat par les esprits qui viennent du cerveau en abondance comme polir couvrir l me et la d fendre du mal qu elle craint la bouche fort ouverte fait voir le saisissement du c ur par le sang qui se retire vers lui ce qui l oblige voulant respirer faire un effort qui est cause que la bouche s ouvre extr mement et qui lorsqu il passe par les organes de la voix forme un son qui n est point articul que si les muscle...
The Last Days of Socrates, Meno. Introduction.
is the power of getting good with justice But justice is a part of virtue and therefore virtue is the getting of good with a part of virtue The definition repeats the word defined Meno complains that the conversation of Socrates has the effect of a torpedo s shock upon him When he talks with other persons he has plenty to say about virtue in the presence of Socrates his thoughts desert him Socrates replies that he is only the cause of perplexity in others because he is himself perplexed He proposes to continue t...
The Tenant of Wildfell Hall, Full Text
own amusement and loved the rascals she created But already in when we first hear of the Gondals and Solala Vernon the material for quite other books was in poor Anne s mind She was then teaching in the family at Thorpe Green where Branwell joined her as tutor in and where owing to events that are still a mystery she seems to have passed through an ordeal that left her shattered in health and nerve with nothing gained but those melancholy and repulsive memories that she was afterwards to embody in Wildfell Hall...

For Students

A reading companion for classical Christian high school students. See the student guide.

Reading Guide

Watch for

The two narrators and where they disagree.
The day Robert is declared justified.
Gil-Martin's resemblance to whomever he speaks with.
Mrs Logan's investigation of the murder.
The final letter about the opened grave.

Key terms and names

Justification: In Protestant theology, God's declaring a sinner righteous through faith in Christ.
Antinomianism: The error that the saved are free from the moral law.
Election: God's choosing of those who will be saved.
Reprobate: In Calvinist language, one not chosen for salvation.
Doppelgänger: A ghostly double of a living person.
Laird: A Scottish landowner, often of an estate.

Seminar Questions

Comprehension What does Robert believe after Wringhim declares him justified?
Comprehension Who investigates George's death?
Interpretation Why does Gil-Martin take Robert's appearance?
Interpretation How does Hogg use two narrators to create doubt?
Interpretation Is the book an attack on Calvinism or on its abuse?
Big Question Can assurance of salvation be twisted into licence to sin?

Faith Connections

Romans 6:1-2 (Scripture)
Shall we continue in sin, that grace may abound? God forbid.
2 Corinthians 11:14 (Scripture)
Satan himself is transformed into an angel of light.
James 2:17 (Scripture)
Faith without works is dead: Robert's faith bears only evil fruit.
Antinomian controversy (Great Conversation)
The church has long rejected the idea that grace frees believers from the moral law.

Logic and Rhetoric

Central argument: A boy taught that he is beyond condemnation meets a tempter who flatters that belief; spiritual pride leads him from contempt to murder and despair; so the novel exposes the destructive lie that the elect can do no wrong.

Rhetorical device: unreliable narrator. Robert's memoir and the editor's account undercut each other, leaving the reader to judge.

Debate: Resolved: that Gil-Martin is a real devil, not a delusion.

Memory Work

How delightful to think that a justified person can do no wrong!
Editor's narrative. The doctrine in a sentence, spoken with fatal approval.

Writing Prompts

Essay: How does Hogg show that spiritual pride, not faith, destroys Robert?

Comparison with Paradise Lost: Compare Gil-Martin's temptation of Robert with Satan's temptation of Eve.

Medical Lens

Robert's memory gaps, double and paranoia have been read as a study of dissociation or psychosis long before such terms existed; the novel keeps a supernatural explanation open.

Madness Psychosis Dementia Memory Suicide Psychology Unconscious

Robert's memoir, middle
Robert loses track of days and is accused of acts he cannot remember committing.
Dementia Memory Madness Psychosis
Robert's memoir, end
Pursued by fiends, Robert resolves to end his life.
Suicide

Creative Prompts

Essay
Is Gil-Martin the devil or Robert's own mind? Argue from both narratives.
Dialogue
Write a conversation in which Mrs Logan answers Robert's claim that the elect can do no wrong.
Classroom
Chart the two narratives side by side and mark where they agree and contradict.