Work record

A Red, Red Rose

Robert Burns

1794 (published 1796) · 18th Century · Poetry · English

Public domainGreat Poems & Speeches · Poem Read full text Download EPUB Five-minute digest

Abstract

Written: Sent for publication in 1794; printed 1796
Setting: Late eighteenth century; Scotland, on the eve of a journey
Author: Robert Burns
Country: Kingdom of Great Britain (Scotland, United Kingdom)
Language: Scots and English
Genre: Song (love lyric)
Form: Four ballad stanzas
Recommended: Grades 6–12 (Short love song; clean.)

Background. Working as a collector and reviser of national songs, Burns shaped this lyric from scraps of older popular verse and passed it to two music editors, Urbani and Johnson, in the last years of his life.

Content. A young man compares the woman he loves to a newly opened summer flower and to a tune well played. He swears that his devotion equals her beauty and will last until oceans evaporate and stone liquefies in the heat, for as long as the hourglass of life keeps running. He bids her a temporary goodbye and pledges to return across any distance.

Form. Ballad quatrains, plain diction and repeated lines make it singable; its hyperboles are deliberately vast.

Themes. The poem is less a description of feeling than a solemn pledge. Its comparisons move from a single summer flower to the whole age of the earth, enlarging the promise with each stanza, and its farewell turns separation into a test of constancy. Burns shows how plain words and traditional images, well ordered, can carry great emotional weight.

For students. A clean, short text for teaching simile, hyperbole and meter, and for discussing love as faithful promise rather than passing feeling.

Main characters

The speaker: A departing lover
The bonie lass: His beloved

Summary

A Red, Red Rose, also called My Luve Is Like a Red, Red Rose, is a song of four short stanzas that Burns sent for publication in 1794; it appeared in Pietro Urbani's collection and in The Scots Musical Museum in 1796. Like many of Burns's songs, it was built from fragments of older folk lyrics, which he reshaped into a single, perfect lyric. The speaker, a young man about to leave his love, begins with two similes: his love is like a red, red rose newly sprung in June, and like a melody sweetly played in tune. He tells her that as fair as she is, so deep in love is he, and that he will love her still till all the seas go dry. The third stanza expands the promise with images of geological time: till the seas go dry and the rocks melt with the sun, and while the sands of life shall run. The last stanza is a farewell: fare thee well, my only love, for a while; he will come again, even if it were ten thousand miles. The poem's power lies in its simplicity. Its images are the most familiar in love poetry, a rose, a tune, the sea, the sun, the sand, but Burns arranges them with such music and sincerity that they seem new. It is a poem of promise as much as of feeling: the speaker binds himself to faithfulness across time and distance. Students can study it as a model of the ballad stanza, of simile and hyperbole, and of the way folk tradition and individual art meet. It is clean and short, and it is one of the best poems for teaching younger students how sound and image work together in a lyric.

Virtues in this work

Faith: The speaker binds himself by a vow of lasting faithfulness across time and distance.
Charity: The poem celebrates devoted love for another person.

Plot or Argument

Stanza 1: two similes
His love is like a fresh June rose and like a sweet melody.
Stanza 2: the vow
As fair as she is, so deep is his love, and it will last till the seas run dry.
Stanza 3: the long promise
Till rocks melt in the sun and while the sands of life run.
Stanza 4: farewell
He must leave for a while but will return, though it be ten thousand miles.

Characters

The speaker, lover
A young man promising lasting love before a journey.
The bonie lass, beloved
The woman he addresses.

Lessons

Faithful promises
The poem is a vow: love that will outlast seas and rocks. Faithfulness is the substance of love.
- What does the speaker promise?
- Why does he use images of vast time?
- Is this a realistic promise?
Related across the library
- Sonnet 116, Lines 11-12
  Love alters not with his brief hours and weeks, But bears it out even to the edge of doom. Love endures to the Last Judgment, outlasting the short measures of Time.
- The Aeneid, Book Vii
  reign princes us d Were the king s office but the king refus d Deaf to their cries nor would the gates unbar Of sacred peace or loose th imprison d war But hid his head and safe from loud alarms Abhorr d the wicked ministry of arms Then heav n s imperious queen shot down from high At her approach the brazen hinges fly The gates are forc d and ev ry falling bar And like a tempest issues out the war The peaceful cities of th Ausonian shore Lull d in their ease and undisturb d before Are all on fire and some with s...
- A Hero of Our Time, Lesson: Fate and freedom
  Fate and freedom. The Fatalist asks whether our deaths are written in advance.
- The American, Full Text
  the American frowned Ah too red too red he rejoined Her complexion pointing to the Murillo is more delicate Delicate Oh it shall be delicate monsieur delicate as S vres biscuit I am going to tone that down I know all the secrets of my art And where will you allow us to send it to you Your address My address Oh yes And the gentleman drew a card from his pocket-book and wrote something upon it Then hesitating a moment he said If I don t like it when it it s finished you know I shall not be obliged to take it The y...
- The Torrents of Spring, Lesson: First love
  First love. Turgenev describes young love as a sudden revolution in life.
Simile and hyperbole
Burns uses the simplest images and exaggerations. Clarity can be more powerful than novelty.
- Find the two similes in stanza 1.
- What is hyperbolic about stanza 3?
- Why do these familiar images still work?
Related across the library
- Our National Parks, Chapter II
  Nothing can be done well at a speed of forty miles a day. Criticizing the hurried coach tours of Yellowstone.
- The Blue Fairy Book, Beauty and the Beast
  Once upon a time, in a very far-off country, there lived a merchant who had been so fortunate in all his undertakings that he was enormously rich. Opening of Beauty and the Beast.
- Across Five Aprils, Lesson: Growing up in hard times
  Growing up in hard times. Jethro takes on a man's work at ten and eleven, ploughing, driving to town and making moral choices alone. The book shows responsibility shaping character, and Shad's lessons show that learning helps a boy understand his times rather than merely suffer them.
- Kim, Lesson: Who is Kim?
  Who is Kim?. Kim belongs to many worlds, Irish, Indian, Hindu, Muslim and Buddhist, and keeps asking who he is. The novel invites reflection on identity formed by place and relationship as much as birth.
- The Nuremberg Code (Permissible Medical Experiments), Medical lens
  The foundational statement of research ethics, written in response to Nazi medical crimes.
Folk song and poet
Burns built the song from older fragments. Tradition and individual craft work together.
- What might Burns have added to the old fragments?
- Is a reworked song still the poet's own?
Related across the library
- John Anderson, My Jo, Lesson: Redeeming a song
  Redeeming a song. Burns took a coarse old song and rewrote it as a tender one, keeping the tune.
- New York Times Co. v. Sullivan, Medical lens
  The opinions address libel, the press and the First Amendment; medical matters do not arise.
- Edward the Second, Lesson: Duty and favour
  Duty and favour. Edward's devotion to Gaveston weakens the realm.
- Tamburlaine the Great, Parts I and II, Full Text
  Fletcher's WOMAN'S PRIZE WHICH this may PROVE Footnote knew So the vo The to knowe Footnote lords So the to The vo Lord Footnote injury This verb frequently occurs in our early writers Then haue you INIURIED manie Lyly's ALEXANDER AND CAMPASPE sig D ed It would seem to have fallen into disuse soon after the commencement of the th century in Heywood's WOMAN KILLED WITH KINDNESS we find You INJURY that good man and wrong me too Sig F but in ed injury is altered to iniure Footnote ALL So the to mitted in the vo Foo...
- Scots Wha Hae (Robert Bruce’s March to Bannockburn), Lesson: History and song
  History and song. Burns wrote this nearly five centuries after the battle. Songs shape how nations remember their past.

Context

Burns gathered and rewrote fragments of folk songs for Scottish song collections in the 1790s; this lyric draws on several earlier popular verses.

Composition

Given to Pietro Urbani for his Scots Songs and printed in The Scots Musical Museum (vol. 5, 1796).

Reception

It is one of the most famous love lyrics in English and has been set to music many times.

Love Desire Memory / Time Travel Journey

Comparisons

John Anderson, My Jo
A song of love fulfilled in old age, to set beside this song of young promise.
Sonnet 116
Shakespeare's definition of love that does not alter with time.

Quotes

Frequently cited

“O my Luve’s like a red, red rose, That’s newly sprung in June:”

— Robert Burns, A Red, Red Rose, Stanza 1 (Gutenberg #1279: Poems and Songs of Robert Burns (chronological arrangement)).Quote card

Kim, Chapter XV
“I am Kim. I am Kim. And what is Kim?” Recovering after the mission, Kim feels detached from the world and asks who he is, a question that runs through the book.
John Anderson, My Jo, Source
John Anderson My Jo John Anderson My Jo John Anderson my jo John When we were first acquent Your locks were like the raven Your bonie brow was brent But now your brow is beld John Your locks are like the snaw But blessings on your frosty pow John Anderson my jo John Anderson my jo John We clamb the hill thegither And mony a cantie day John We ve had wi ane anither Now we maun totter down John And hand in hand we ll go And sleep thegither at the foot John Anderson my jo
Kim, Full Text
to Benares said the lama Assuredly Else why should we come Enter or we are left cried Kim See shrilled the Amritzar girl He has never entered a train Oh see Nay help said the cultivator putting out a large brown hand and hauling him in Thus is it done father But but I sit on the floor It is against the Rule to sit on a bench said the lama Moreover it cramps me I say began the money-lender pursing his lips that there is not one rule of right living which these te-rains do not cause us to break We sit for example...
King John, Act IV, Scene II
How oft the sight of means to do ill deeds Make deeds ill done Believing Arthur dead, John blames Hubert for having been at hand and willing, a self-excusing account of temptation.
John Anderson, My Jo, Stanza 1
But blessings on your frosty pow, John Anderson, my jo. She blesses her husband's white head.

Frequently cited

“And I will luve thee still, my dear, Till a’ the seas gang dry.”

— Robert Burns, A Red, Red Rose, Stanza 2 (Gutenberg #1279: Poems and Songs of Robert Burns (chronological arrangement)).Quote card

The Sun Also Rises, CHAPTER 6
were in love with her She s a drunk I said She s in love with Mike Campbell and she s going to marry him He s going to be rich as hell some day I don t believe she ll ever marry him Why not I don t know I just don t believe it Have you known her a long time Yes I said She was a V A D in a hospital I was in during the war She must have been just a kid then She s thirty-four now When did she marry Ashley During the war Her own true love had just kicked off with the dysentery You talk sort of bitter Sorry I didn t...
Inaugural Address (John Quincy Adams), Inaugural address
It has promoted the lasting welfare of that country so dear to us all; it has to an extent far beyond the ordinary lot of humanity secured the freedom and happiness of this people Adams's verdict on what the Constitution has achieved for the country.
The Scarlet Pimpernel, Ch. I
A surging, seething, murmuring crowd of beings that are human only in name, for to the eye and ear they seem naught but savage creatures, animated by vile passions and by the lust of vengeance and of hate. The opening sentence, describing the Paris crowd at the West Barricade in September 1792.
Ivanhoe, Full Text
thee Guide thee I can and it may be even in some sort defend thee since to protect a Jew against a Saracen can scarce be accounted unworthy of a Christian Therefore Jew I will see thee safe under some fitting escort We are now not far from the town of Sheffield where thou mayest easily find many of thy tribe with whom to take refuge The blessing of Jacob be upon thee good youth said the Jew in Sheffield I can harbour with my kinsman Zareth and find some means of travelling forth with safety Be it so said the Pal...
Sonnet 116, Lines 11-12
Love alters not with his brief hours and weeks, But bears it out even to the edge of doom. Love endures to the Last Judgment, outlasting the short measures of Time.

“And I will come again, my Luve, Tho’ ’twere ten thousand mile!”

— Robert Burns, A Red, Red Rose, Stanza 4 (Gutenberg #1279: Poems and Songs of Robert Burns (chronological arrangement)).Quote card

The Journal of John Woolman, Journal, Chapter VIII
Love was the first Motion, and thence a Concern arose to spend some Time with the _Indians_, that I might feel and understand their Life, and the Spirit they live in Resting in his tent on a rainy day on the road to Wehaloosing in 1763, he considers why he undertook the journey.
Tanglewood Tales, Medical lens
Medicine is incidental but present in small, period-revealing touches. The introduction's chatty report on the Tanglewood children, who have come easily through scarlet fever, whooping cough and possibly measles, records the ordinary childhood epidemics of a New England family in the 1850s. Chiron is remembered as the teacher of Aesculapius and of the art of curing diseases. Poisons and drugs drive several plots: Medea's fatal drop in Theseus's goblet, Circe's enchanted wine, the snow-white flower that protects...
Utilitarianism, Chapter V
Thus, to save a life, it may not only be allowable, but a duty, to steal, or take by force, the necessary food or medicine, or to kidnap, and compel to officiate, the only qualified medical practitioner Mill's example of a case in which another social duty overrides an ordinary maxim of justice.
Kim, Medical lens
Lurgan Sahib's attempt to make Kim see a broken jar made whole is an early literary depiction of suggestion or hypnosis, which Kim resists by reciting the multiplication table.
Timon of Athens, Full Text
THE LIFE OF TIMON OF ATHENS by William Shakespeare Contents ACT I Scene I Athens A hall in Timon s house Scene II The Same A room of state in Timon s house ACT II Scene I Athens A room in a senator s house Scene II The same A hall in Timon s house ACT III Scene I Athens A room in Lucullus house Scene II A public place Scene III The same A room in Sempronius house Scene IV A hall in Timon s house Scene V The same The senate house Scene VI A room of state in Timon s house ACT IV Scene I Without the walls of Athens...

For Students

A reading companion for classical Christian high school students. See the student guide.

Reading Guide

Watch for

The two similes in the first stanza.
The repetition of till a' the seas gang dry.
The images of time in stanza 3.
The farewell and promise in stanza 4.

Key terms and names

Simile: A comparison using like or as, such as my luve's like a red, red rose.
Hyperbole: Deliberate exaggeration for effect, such as till the rocks melt wi' the sun.
Ballad stanza: Four lines alternating four and three stresses, rhymed abcb.
Luve: Scots spelling of love, used for the beloved herself.

Seminar Questions

Comprehension What two things does the speaker compare his love to?
Comprehension Why is he saying farewell?
Interpretation What do the images of seas, rocks and sands suggest about his love?
Interpretation Is the poem more about feeling or about promise?
Interpretation Why does Burns repeat lines between stanzas 2 and 3?
Big Question What makes a promise of love trustworthy?

Faith Connections

Song of Songs 8:6-7 (Scripture)
Love is strong as death; many waters cannot quench it: Scripture's own poetry of lasting love.
1 Corinthians 13:7-8 (Scripture)
Love bears all things, endures all things, and never fails.

Logic and Rhetoric

Central argument: His love is fresh and beautiful; his devotion matches her beauty; so he vows to love her until the end of time and to return however far he must go.

Rhetorical device: simile and hyperbole. My luve's like a red, red rose; I will luve thee still till a' the seas gang dry.

Debate: Resolved: that simple images make better love poetry than original ones.

Memory Work

O my Luve’s like a red, red rose, That’s newly sprung in June:
Stanza 1. A famous opening every student should know.

And I will luve thee still, my dear, Till a’ the seas gang dry.
Stanza 2. The heart of the vow.

Writing Prompts

Essay: Show how the poem moves from feeling to promise.

Comparison with Sonnet 116: Compare Burns's vow with Shakespeare's definition of love that bears it out even to the edge of doom.

Creative Prompts

Classroom
Mark the meter of the first stanza and sing it to the traditional tune.
Poetry
Write a four-stanza promise poem using only simple images from nature.
Essay
Why does a poem made of familiar images remain one of the greatest love lyrics?