Work record

An Essay on the Principle of Population (1798)

Also known as: Essay on Population · Essay on the Principle of Population · Malthus on Population · First Essay on Population · The Principle of Population

1798 · 18th Century · Political Theory · English

Read this when you want to see where the debate over population and food began.

Public domainlow medical relevanceRead full textDownload EPUBFive-minute digest

Abstract

Written
1798 (first edition, anonymous)
Setting
England in the years after the French Revolution, with grain prices high and the Poor Laws under debate; England
Country
England
Language
English
Genre
Political and economic argument
Form
A short treatise in nineteen chapters, each opened by a summary of its contents
Recommended
Grades 10–12 (Short first edition of 19 chapters; older prose, a little arithmetic, a lot of argument.)

Background. An English country clergyman, a Cambridge fellow in his early thirties, publishes an unsigned reply to the hopeful writers of the Revolution, prompted by a conversation with a friend about one of Godwin's essays on the use of wealth.

Argument. Numbers rise in a doubling pattern while food rises step by step, so want, disease and war keep people near the level of the harvest. Malthus applies the law to savages, shepherds, Europe, the colonies and Asia, to the Poor Laws, and to the visions of Godwin and Condorcet.

Ideas. The book weighs hope against limits. It asks whether society can be made perfect, whether relief helps or multiplies the poor, and whether hardship is a call to effort, and it joins an unflinching eye for facts to a clergyman's view of providence. Later readers have found it forceful, severe and open to challenge, and Malthus himself revised its argument in later editions.

Text. The hosted text is the 1798 first edition from Project Gutenberg, with the preface and all nineteen chapters, and each quotation in the guide was matched to it. Teachers can pair it with The Wealth of Nations and with Darwin, who credited the doctrine of Malthus, and with the guide's seminar questions, memory work and writing prompts, taking a chapter or two at a time.

Key figures

  • William Godwin: The radical whose society of equality is the chief opponent
  • The Marquis de Condorcet: The French thinker of unlimited progress
  • Adam Smith: The economist whose wages-fund view is questioned
  • The labouring poor: The English working people whose relief is at stake

Summary

Malthus wrote An Essay on the Principle of Population in 1798, in a reply to optimistic writers of the French Revolution era, above all William Godwin and the Marquis de Condorcet, who thought that human society could be made perfect or nearly so. The book began, as the preface says, in a conversation with a friend about Godwin's essay on avarice and profusion. His case rests on two postulates: that food is necessary to human life and that the passion between the sexes is necessary and will remain nearly what it is. From these he concludes that the power of population is greater than the power of the earth to produce food. Population, when unchecked, doubles in a geometrical ratio, while food grows by an arithmetical one, so that some check must always hold numbers down to the level of the means of living. He sorts those checks into the preventive, which come from foresight and delay of marriage, and the positive, which come from want, disease and war, and says they come down to misery and vice. He tests the argument against hunters and shepherds, the nations of ancient Europe, Hume's estimates, the colonies of North America, and the famines of China and India. He then turns it on the hopes of the age. The Poor Laws, he says, create more poor, and the first palliative he proposes is their total abolition. Godwin's society of equality, he argues, would fall back into scarcity and selfishness within a generation, and Condorcet's dreams of endless life prove nothing, since a partial gain does not show that a gain has no limit. A later chapter questions Adam Smith's view that every increase of national wealth raises the wages fund. The last two chapters change tone. Malthus argues that the pressure of want drives men to labour and thought and that the world may be a trial in which mind is formed, so that evil exists to rouse activity and not to breed despair. The book was widely read, revised in five later editions, and became the starting point for debates in economics and in the study of living things.

Virtues in this work

  • Prudence: Malthus asks that hopes for society be tested against facts, and he commends foresight in marriage and in the use of means.
  • Justice: His long argument over relief for the poor turns on what the poor are owed and what the whole community can sustain.
  • Temperance: The preventive check is the self-command of those who delay marriage and spending until they can bear the cost.
  • Hope: The final chapters answer despair with a hope that hardship rouses effort and the growth of mind.

Plot or Argument

  • The question and the postulates (Preface, Chapters I–II)

    Malthus asks whether society can improve without limit. He grants food and the passion between the sexes as fixed, states the two ratios, and says a check must keep numbers level with food.

  • Savage, shepherd and civilized states (Chapters III–IV)

    He tests the law against hunters, the shepherd tribes that entered Europe, and modern nations. He names the preventive check, which is prudence about marriage, and the positive check, which is want and disease.

  • The Poor Laws (Chapter V)

    He argues that the English Poor Laws raise the number of the poor without raising the food supply, and names their total abolition as the first palliative he would propose. The chapter is the most disputed in the book.

  • Colonies, famines and epidemics (Chapters VI–VII)

    New countries show how fast numbers can grow when food is plentiful, while China, India and the fevers of crowded places show the other face of the law.

  • Condorcet and the prolongation of life (Chapters VIII–IX)

    Condorcet's sketch of progress is answered by the point that a partial improvement does not prove that an improvement is unlimited, as the breeding of animals shows.

  • Godwin's equality (Chapters X–XV)

    Malthus pictures Godwin's equal society and says it would break down in thirty years, then answers Godwin on love, long life, reason and the passions, coercion and labour.

  • Wealth, labour and the economists (Chapters XVI–XVII)

    He doubts that a rise in national wealth always raises the funds for labour, and he questions Adam Smith, the French economists and Richard Price on what wealth is.

  • Evil, mind and providence (Chapters XVIII–XIX)

    The last chapters read the pressure of want as a means by which mind is formed and as a call to effort, and they offer a hopeful view of providence in a world of trial.

Characters

  • William Godwin, the main opponent

    The English radical writer of Political Justice (1793) and The Enquirer, whose hopeful vision of a society of equality Malthus sets out to answer.

  • The Marquis de Condorcet, the second opponent

    The French mathematician and philosopher whose sketch of the progress of the human mind (1795) forecast an unlimited improvement of man.

  • Adam Smith, the economist challenged

    The Scottish author of The Wealth of Nations, whose view that rising wealth raises the funds for labour Malthus qualifies in Chapter XVI.

  • David Hume, an authority tested

    The Scottish philosopher, whose proposed signs of the population of the ancients Malthus examines in Chapter IV.

  • The labouring poor, the subject of the argument

    The common people of England, whose wages and relief under the Poor Laws are the chief practical concern of the book.

Lessons

  • Test a hope against numbers

    Malthus asks that a plan of social improvement be tried against the facts of food, land and family before it is praised. A Christian student can see in the demand a kind of prudence, which counts the cost of a hope without giving it up.

    • What facts does Malthus use to test Godwin's society of equality?
    • When is it wise to ask whether a good plan can be carried out?
  • Read a forecast by what happened

    The two ratios are a mathematical sketch, and Malthus did not foresee the rise of farm yields, trade, falling birth rates and the new sciences of the next two centuries. The student should learn to admire his clarity, to note what his forecast missed, and to ask why.

    • Which parts of the argument still hold, and which did later events overturn?
    • What did Malthus leave out of his two postulates?
  • Charity, the poor and the cost of relief

    His chapter on the Poor Laws raises the question of how best to help the poor, which Christians have answered in many ways, with works of mercy, with the work of the church and with public law. The chapter should be weighed against the Gospel's care for the poor and against the later reforms.

    • What does Malthus think the Poor Laws do to the number of the poor?
    • How do Matthew 25 and 2 Thessalonians 3:10 each bear on the question of relief?
  • Hope and providence

    The closing chapters read hardship as a spur to effort and to the growth of mind, in the manner of an eighteenth-century clergyman. Students can ask whether the claim is consoling, whether it is true to Scripture, and how it differs from the despair of which Malthus is often accused.

    • Why does Malthus say that evil exists to create activity and not despair?
    • Where does his view of providence agree with Scripture, and where would a Christian reader press him?

Context

The Essay appeared in London in June 1798, nine years after the start of the French Revolution and at a time of high grain prices and wartime strain in England. Radical writers such as Godwin and Condorcet had argued that human institutions, not human nature, were the cause of poverty and vice, and Malthus, a country clergyman, wrote to answer them. The English Poor Laws, with their local relief and the allowances then in use, were under debate.

Composition

He wrote quickly, as the preface says, after a conversation with a friend, and published without his name. In the second edition of 1803, rewritten with far more evidence from travel and from the records of many countries, he added moral restraint as a check, and the later editions kept the title but changed the argument. The 1798 text is the short, sharp first form of the argument.

Reception

The Essay was read and answered at once, by Godwin, by William Hazlitt and by Robert Southey, among others, and it shaped the English economists Ricardo and Mill. It was cited in the debate that led to the Poor Law Amendment Act of 1834, and Charles Darwin and Alfred Russel Wallace both named it as a source of the idea of natural selection. Critics have since challenged its forecasts and its remedies, and its place in the history of economics and biology remains secure.

Comparisons

  • The Wealth of Nations

    Malthus questions Smith's view in Chapter XVI that a growing national wealth always raises the funds for labour, and the two books together frame the economics of the age.

  • On the Origin of Species

    Darwin says in his own book that the struggle for existence is the doctrine of Malthus applied to the whole animal and vegetable kingdoms.

  • On the Principles of Political Economy and Taxation

    Ricardo, Malthus's friend and critic, built a theory of rent and wages on the pressure of numbers on land that Malthus described.

  • Principles of Political Economy

    Mill took up the population question and argued for prudence in marriage as the remedy, in a form closer to Malthus's second edition.

  • Essays, Moral and Political (selection)

    Hume's essay on the populousness of ancient nations is one of the writings Malthus tests in his fourth chapter.

  • A Modest Proposal

    Swift's satire of 1729 treats Irish poverty and the number of the poor with savage irony, while Malthus treats them in plain argument.

  • The Burke-Paine Debate on the French Revolution

    The Revolution debate of the 1790s, between Burke and Paine, is the setting in which Godwin's hopes and Malthus's reply were written.

  • Utopia

    More's island is an early picture of a society made perfect by good laws, which Malthus tests in a modern form against the facts of food and numbers.

Quotes

“The passion between the sexes has appeared in every age to be so nearly the same that it may always be considered, in algebraic language, as a given quantity.”
— Thomas Robert Malthus, An Essay on the Principle of Population (1798), Chapter VII (Project Gutenberg #4239 (T. R. Malthus, An Essay on the Principle of Population, London: J. Johnson, 1798, first edition)).Quote card
“Among plants and animals its effects are waste of seed, sickness, and premature death. Among mankind, misery and vice.”
— Thomas Robert Malthus, An Essay on the Principle of Population (1798), Chapter I (Project Gutenberg #4239 (T. R. Malthus, An Essay on the Principle of Population, London: J. Johnson, 1798, first edition)).Quote card
“A theory that will not admit of application cannot possibly be just.”
— Thomas Robert Malthus, An Essay on the Principle of Population (1798), Chapter X (Project Gutenberg #4239 (T. R. Malthus, An Essay on the Principle of Population, London: J. Johnson, 1798, first edition)).Quote card
“Man cannot live in the midst of plenty. All cannot share alike the bounties of nature.”
— Thomas Robert Malthus, An Essay on the Principle of Population (1798), Chapter X (Project Gutenberg #4239 (T. R. Malthus, An Essay on the Principle of Population, London: J. Johnson, 1798, first edition)).Quote card

For Students

A reading companion for classical Christian high school students. See the student guide.

Reading Guide

Watch for

  • The two postulates in Chapter I and the two ratios in Chapter II, and how every later chapter returns to them.
  • Where Malthus tests his law against facts, such as colonies, famines and the records of Europe, and where he argues from reason alone.
  • How the tone changes in the last two chapters, where the argument becomes a view of providence and the growth of mind.

Key terms and names

Geometrical ratio
Growth by repeated multiplication, such as 1, 2, 4, 8, 16, which Malthus says is the pace of unchecked population.
Arithmetical ratio
Growth by repeated addition, such as 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, which Malthus says is the best pace of food.
Preventive check
A check on numbers that comes from foresight, mainly the delay of marriage until a family can be supported.
Positive check
A check that comes from want, disease, war and hard living, which cut short lives already begun.
Perfectibility
The belief of Godwin and Condorcet that human nature and society can be improved without limit.
Poor Laws
English laws, going back to the reign of Elizabeth, that made each parish provide relief for its poor.

Seminar Questions

  1. Comprehension What are Malthus's two postulates, and what does he conclude from them in Chapter II?
  2. Comprehension What are the preventive and the positive checks, and how does Malthus say each acts on numbers?
  3. Interpretation Why does Malthus say that Godwin's society of equality would fall back into scarcity within thirty years?
  4. Interpretation What does the example of the North American colonies show, and why is it important for his argument?
  5. Interpretation How do Chapters XVIII and XIX change the tone of the book, and do they soften its argument?
  6. Big Question How should a Christian weigh the duty to help the poor against the argument that relief can increase the number of the poor?
  7. Big Question Can a hopeful view of human progress survive a careful look at its limits? What would Malthus say, and what would his critics say?

Faith Connections

  • Matthew 25:34–40 (Scripture)

    The Lord's words to the righteous, that whatever was done for the least of his brethren was done for him, set the call to mercy that every account of relief must face.

  • 2 Thessalonians 3:10 (Scripture)

    Paul's rule that if any would not work, neither should he eat, is the text Malthus's readers sometimes set beside his argument about industry and relief.

  • Romans 8:18–25 (Scripture)

    Paul speaks of the sufferings of this present time and of hope in the creation, which may be set beside Malthus's closing view of a world of trial.

Logic and Rhetoric

Central argument: Because food is needed and the passion between the sexes is constant, population, when unchecked, grows faster than the food to feed it, so that misery and vice must hold it down, and any plan of social perfection that ignores this law will fail.

Rhetorical device: argument from first principles. Malthus opens with two postulates he says no one will deny, derives a law from them, and then answers each opponent by showing where his plan breaks that law.

Debate: Resolved: That a plan to improve society must first be tested against the limits of food and land.

Memory Work

Population, when unchecked, increases in a geometrical ratio. Subsistence increases only in an arithmetical ratio.

Chapter I. The two sentences that state the law of the Essay, short enough to recite as its summary.

Evil exists in the world not to create despair but activity.

Chapter XIX. The closing turn from fear to effort, which every reader should keep beside the harder chapters.

Writing Prompts

Essay: Using at least three chapters of the Essay, explain Malthus's two ratios and his answer to Godwin, and say which parts of the argument you think later events have borne out or overturned.

Comparison with The Wealth of Nations: Compare what Malthus and Adam Smith each say about the link between national wealth and the condition of the labouring poor, and explain where Malthus says Smith may be mistaken.

Medical Lens

The Essay is a work of economics and moral philosophy, but its argument leans on famine, epidemic disease and the health of towns and trades as the positive checks on numbers. Malthus draws on mortality records and on the sickly seasons of crowded places, and he treats the unwholesomeness of towns as a form of misery.

Creative Prompts

  • Essay

    Write an essay that sets Malthus's two ratios beside the history of farming and trade since 1798, and say what his argument explains and what it leaves out.

  • Dialogue

    Write a conversation between Malthus and Godwin on a summer evening, in which each tries to answer the other's strongest point about the future of society.

  • Classroom

    Hold a debate on the resolution that a plan to help the poor must be tested against the supply of food and work. Ask one side to use Malthus's chapters and the other to use the Gospel's calls to mercy.

  • Adaptation

    Retell the argument of the first two chapters as a short fable about an island, with a growing number of mouths and a fixed harvest, and a close in which the islanders choose a remedy.

Further Reading

  • An Essay on the Principle of Population (second edition, 1803), Thomas Robert Malthus

    The much longer revised edition, which adds moral restraint and many more facts; not hosted in this library.

  • The Wealth of Nations, Adam Smith

    Smith's treatise, which Malthus questions in Chapter XVI; hosted in this library.

  • On the Origin of Species, Charles Darwin

    Darwin names the doctrine of Malthus as the source of his idea of the struggle for existence; hosted in this library.

  • Malthus: The Life and Legacies of an Untimely Prophet, Robert J. Mayhew

    A recent biography and study of Malthus and his reception.

  • Malthus, Donald Winch

    A short, clear account of his life and writings, in the Past Masters series.

Verification notes

The text is the 1798 first edition from Project Gutenberg #4239, complete with its preface and nineteen chapters, and every quotation in the guide was matched to the hosted text. The chapter summaries printed at the head of each chapter in the original are kept as the first paragraph of each chapter. The much longer second edition of 1803, which many scholars treat as a different book, is not included.

  • Malthus's birth place, college and fellowship dates, and the date of his post at Haileybury follow the Oxford Dictionary of National Biography and standard reference works, and were not checked against primary sources here.
  • That the first Essay was published anonymously in June 1798 and that the 1803 edition added moral restraint follow standard accounts, such as Donald Winch's Malthus and the Cambridge Companion to Malthus.
  • The statements that Darwin and Wallace both named Malthus as a source follow Darwin's Autobiography and Wallace's My Life, and Darwin's statement in the Origin is quoted from the hosted text.
  • The links to the Poor Law Amendment Act of 1834 and the replies of Godwin, Hazlitt and Southey follow standard histories and should be checked before being quoted in class.
  • The Project Gutenberg text of #4239 should be checked against a scan of the 1798 Johnson edition, for example the Internet Archive or Google Books copy, before it is cited in a footnote.